opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/287/2004

Genf · 2004-04-26 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (3 Absätze)

E. 05 ' '(

E. 6 F7/16

7/+8570110 ' 4(    '4' (#(>(  G',   @#   #(  #('(>  '@  #'  " #  (' ) C)  /+ ' 0110,  '  4(&%' (' ''D # '#(  '' &' J' # '' '(  # '#(# ,  &%' @@ '  .  '4' (, %'  # '& ('& #%   %4'  (#(A # '4 '   '')   (? @' 4' &  %@@' @(#( #  ';'63 < $ G=    &' '  B # '  4' .  '#((  '#(#   &  (&  J  #  - ,  -K   D #4' .  &'@'( # ')

%' #  #',   #' ' # ' #   # %$ G # /2 #(D /552  (  # %- LM'-, # -  , # G-N'O'- M-4D#  # D# -N'O'- @- ) %$ G '  ' #  ''4 " ' '  ' ( #  '? 3  ' #  ' # -&   ''      #   ()  ' ('  @' #'( A (# A  4 " # #' @' #  #    &  (( ' 4(  #   ' ('(  G')

 !

/)  '  E?' ' H#''' # 00 4D /5+/;'63 < =  ((#'@'(   'D   #  '  ((' ' (#3  / I 011F;) / )

=) @( A E) F ) F # #'' ' ' ' #  ' # /+ 4D 0110 #'@'  ,   ' #'  4 E (  4'? #  ' (' (  #  #4  '' #   ((' #E@@'  'D   #  ')  ( # 'D # (  #3  (D'  - # ( ' '?) 0)  ' @(#(    ' ?(( # #' #  ' #

E. 8  D 0111;'63 <  =   (  4'?  / H4' 011F,  P # D #'@' ' #  #' #  ')   #%3 #  @' (?'   #'' '  4'? H&% F/ #(D 0110,  (?#  ''  &  H? #  ' %  A #  '#( '  #'@' ' # #'  # %( # @'  (' A  #  #('  #  #('' ' '?'; $ /0C  +8C, '#) /, /0/  F28, '#) /D Q @) (? #'' ' ' ', ) 20 ) /  =)  ( ' '?   (& "'(A  '3 #

6 +7/16

7/+8570110 #'' ' #  ' @(#(  %64''  4'4  # 01 #(D /5+8;'63 <  G=  # 3? %64''  4'4  # F/  D /5+C;'63 <  G=  4'? H&% F/ #(D 0110) F)  4  # %) C1 )/ #  '   (# #''  '4 # /0  D /52*;'63 <  =, % ' ( #%@@' H'#   . (# # @@' &'    A  '  ' '# '&  A   H'#'& )

 %,   ' H (   & ' #%H '  ' #  ' ' ', & ' &'  ' (    ' '

G7 7  

, '' &    'D ' # " ' #% ' @'' # @J '# '&, #3  & %) 0 )0 #  '    ' @'' # /  /558; $= (4' &   ' #  '(  '#(#    (4   (?' ' @(#(  %64''  4'4 )  (&, '  ' # H'#  #" ) +) (( #  @  #(' '(   ',  (    4D,  4  # %) 2+  G  # %) F2 ) /  $) *)   '4&  ' ' &   '@' ' # #('' ' '?'   -( #% 4' # @, #   R  %  ((4>(  ' #()

  (? %'  @'   '@' '    @,     '   (# #''  '4 # /0  D /52*) G ' .  ' '?'  & ' #  #  # ( ' #% 4'  ' ',  &' %     %3, '&    ((#((D' 4 %(-( # #(')

 4' #3  #%#  &  #(''   (  ((4D  '@'(  ) 8) %DH # ' '?  # 4' '  (( ' 4(    A  '' J  (?   #'''(  G'  ' A  ' ')

G   ( D'? ' A %64''  4'4    ->'& #'''(  G',   ->'& &' "  G'   '4' ( '4, '' &  '  '  ' &' 4' A %(?;) / ) /  G=, A %" ' #  &' 

6 *7/16

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

 '4 '  #E  ' ' , % '' ' #   " # 4'   ('D ' #       (' '& #E  '4' ('#(# ;G /55C) /1C, G /55F) 008=)  '& ('@'& ( E  '  #  @' & E' (( (A   '#(# # 3 &E'    #  4';G /55C) /1C '#) 0DQ  /528) F+C '#) 0#=)

"   @',  ''     # #(?? #  ' '@ &' ' 'D > ( '&)  #'4' (# '  ' &'  ('  4' ('& D'? A ('     #  ' #E   '4     # ED # '  #   '')  ' '4 4 & E  4 #   #E3   (' '& # #" ? #E '4' (, ' @   ## & ((   (#'  #   '#((;G 011/) 0*0 '#) 0 Q

6 87/16

7/+8570110 G /552) 0F* '#) +Q

$ /0F  /80) '#) / S G /552) *8 '#) / Q

$ /00  02F S G /55C) /18) '#) 0=)

  4  ( #E  '4' (#(#  &E (   '  >'& #   # 4', A 4' & E' ((#' @@'  4'    ' #(, &E' #'  ' A #'' ' # E ' 6  4  # E'' (# @' #E" &&    '4' ( '4 6  &E'  '(" '  ' # E '; " < ' E  'D # @  # , '  ' A   # 6 T /550 /C+) '#) +DU= &' #('# (?,    ?# , #  #(  # E?' ' # 4')   ((    @@  @4 #E  # D#' ';G /55C) /1C '#) 0D=) ED4 ' #E  '  # 4', ED'? ' # #   # E4 # 4" '' &   A E'@   # ' # 4'  '    #E'#' #E  '4' (#(# ; /520) /C8=)  '& ('&   E('  A '  #   A  ('   ,   #E '4' ("( (?'3, #  @' #   4, '   # 4' , #  '  ' DD A  #E '(&' #  ';G /55C) /1C '#) 0DQ

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

6 C7/16

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

6 27/16

7/+8570110 &' (3#, ' >  ' # '#( &%'  "(  '4' (#(# ) 6'  #3  H '  ' #  ' ' ' (?) /1)  @', '' &    '   #  (#,   ' # ('D '  &  ( #(  ( '   ( ((4(  #  '4' ( #(>( A %(?, &    ' A  ' ')  >  # ' # 4>   "  ' ' '(  &% ('  4 #(  ( ' #  ' '  #  'D ',   &    '4' ( "(  G',  &%   #%  #(HA #(( #%# #  @')

6 57/16

7/+8570110    !9  !0/    / !

# 5 

#  H ' #  ' H (  %9::::::::::    #('' # /C #(D 011/ #  '   ?4' #  '  # G4'   #% ' @'')

  : 

 #( 4D)

# :

/) @'  #(''  &(   &%  ' A  ' '   'D '   '4' ( "(  G'   '' # %9::::::::::) 0)     ) F) 4'   "  ' ' '(  4 #('' #   # '#( ) +) #  '   ?4' #  '  ' #% '#' (# *11 @)   A '  # #() *) @   ' #  &E 4 @     ( .,   &'  ' "  ' '

G7 7 7, #  #(' # F1 H #3   '@' '  ' #(#( 'D @(#( # , G-N'O-@&' 8, 811+  ,  ' "')  #('   .  ?()  (' #' < = '#'& "  &E #(''   #(' D '  '   #  #(''  &(Q D= "  & '@ '  ' 4' ##     #(''Q =   '?    #  ( ) G'  ('   '   ' ((  (((    = D=  = '6#,  'D @(#( #         '3    &E' #4 #( '4D)  (' #   '   > # 4, &'  H' , '' &  #(''  &(  E4 # &   (("(#'(  ;) /F0, /18  /12 =)

6 /17/16

7/+8570110

 ?@@'3 <  ('#  <

XY  L !>  ! 

 ('6H'  < !' Z !!  ' @ # ( .   '@'( "  ' '' &%A %@@' @(#( #  '   ?@@

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

              ! "#$ 

         %&'()%*+,%&'-*%*+  %+.-%*', %+..%*'  / !0/    / ! # +& 1 +**' 23  4 5

  

67777777777   !

"#  $$  % # #& ' (' #'') 

 

!   !    ! *+,  # -., /012 34

!   8 ! 9 !!,

*+,  # -.,   , /0// 34 05 ' '(

6 07/16

7/+8570110  9!

/) %9::::::::::;'63  3 #  '   ?4' #  ';'63    ('#    ( /552 A 0111    '@'(A  -   #(  ( ' #  ' '  #  # /C #(D 011/, ' (   # /2E*F2 @) C* A '  #  ' '

G7 7 7

 # 3  B) F)

 . # ,  G4'   #% ' @'' '   '@'((?  #(  ( ' #  'D ' #%   # 0E/+* @) 81) +)    # C H4' 0110, %' ((     #('',  A   ')    ((?' (   ( 0270110  0570110;#3  / I 011F ?' (  'D   #  '   (

7/+85710

G 

7/+C1710

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

6 F7/16

7/+8570110 ' 4(    '4' (#(>(  G',   @#   #(  #('(>  '@  #'  " #  (' ) C)  /+ ' 0110,  '  4(&%' (' ''D # '#(  '' &' J' # '' '(  # '#(# ,  &%' @@ '  .  '4' (, %'  # '& ('& #%   %4'  (#(A # '4 '   '')   (? @' 4' &  %@@' @(#( #  ';'63 (  ' #()

  (? %'  @'   '@' '    @,     '   (# #''  '4 # /0  D /52*) G ' .  ' '?'  & ' #  #  # ( ' #% 4'  ' ',  &' %     %3, '&    ((#((D' 4 %(-( # #(')

 4' #3  #%#  &  #(''   (  ((4D  '@'(  ) 8) %DH # ' '?  # 4' '  (( ' 4(    A  '' J  (?   #'''(  G'  ' A  ' ')

G   ( D'? ' A %64''  4'4    ->'& #'''(  G',   ->'& &' "  G'   '4' ( '4, '' &  '  '  ' &' 4' A %(?;) / ) /  G=, A %" ' #  &' 

6 *7/16

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

 '4 '  #E  ' ' , % '' ' #   " # 4'   ('D ' #       (' '& #E  '4' ('#(# ;G /55C) /1C, G /55F) 008=)  '& ('@'& ( E  '  #  @' & E' (( (A   '#(# # 3 &E'    #  4';G /55C) /1C '#) 0DQ  /528) F+C '#) 0#=)

"   @',  ''     # #(?? #  ' '@ &' ' 'D > ( '&)  #'4' (# '  ' &'  ('  4' ('& D'? A ('     #  ' #E   '4     # ED # '  #   '')  ' '4 4 & E  4 #   #E3   (' '& # #" ? #E '4' (, ' @   ## & ((   (#'  #   '#((;G 011/) 0*0 '#) 0 Q

6 87/16

7/+8570110 G /552) 0F* '#) +Q

$ /0F  /80) '#) / S G /552) *8 '#) / Q

$ /00  02F S G /55C) /18) '#) 0=)

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

6 C7/16

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

6 27/16

7/+8570110 &' (3#, ' >  ' # '#( &%'  "(  '4' (#(# ) 6'  #3  H '  ' #  ' ' ' (?) /1)  @', '' &    '   #  (#,   ' # ('D '  &  ( #(  ( '   ( ((4(  #  '4' ( #(>( A %(?, &    ' A  ' ')  >  # ' # 4>   "  ' ' '(  &% ('  4 #(  ( ' #  ' '  #  'D ',   &    '4' ( "(  G',  &%   #%  #(HA #(( #%# #  @')

6 57/16

7/+8570110    !9  !0/    / !

# 5 

#  H ' #  ' H (  %9::::::::::    #('' # /C #(D 011/ #  '   ?4' #  '  # G4'   #% ' @'')

  : 

 #( 4D)

# :

/) @'  #(''  &(   &%  ' A  ' '   'D '   '4' ( "(  G'   '' # %9::::::::::) 0)     ) F) 4'   "  ' ' '(  4 #('' #   # '#( ) +) #  '   ?4' #  '  ' #% '#' (# *11 @)   A '  # #() *) @   ' #  &E 4 @     ( .,   &'  ' "  ' '

G7 7 7, #  #(' # F1 H #3   '@' '  ' #(#( 'D @(#( # , G-N'O-@&' 8, 811+  ,  ' "')  #('   .  ?()  (' #'  # 4, &'  H' , '' &  #(''  &(  E4 # &   (("(#'(  ;) /F0, /18  /12 =)

6 /17/16

7/+8570110

 ?@@'3   ! 

 ('6H'  < !' Z !!  ' @ # ( .   '@'( "  ' '' &%A %@@' @(#( #  '   ?@@