opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/253/2004

Genf · 2004-04-15 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

              

      

          ! "#$$# #%&#$$! ' ()(* *+*  (* +) %,  -. /  % 0 #$$! 

 1 2222222222 ! " #!!  $%!&&'(%(!&((  !  !  +33) *+*  4(*5)*6)) &)*+!,-./-//   0 (!(% 

   

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

   

1/,/+1-22- 301/-3 &( &!  '(9(!&& ?H8! !!(!&&%!&!;H)# +#   !(! %&((&.!8 -22/?$!!!(&=    4444444444  9% '  !(!  (7(! & 87( !   (! & &  (&(! &  H8 &!  !7 & )7 5(( !8# !5( 8H!(5%&(8 9%  :&  !('!8(! (!( # !!!3 !: &C%!(!!($)9(!&(7(5!(#=   !(( () 9(!  &( & !   (! & $ % !   !!# @# C  !7 & $ % ?  L&!(  $    % ? $ %  ! !(&& &! !  =

 !! !7& ! (('( (!&M +H9( -22-# !5($ %$D!  (!%7 % & !! ! ! #  $9( & $   %!(! &M ?  ' & !(9!( &   !# = $ % !!5(  8 & !! ! !  $9(!&$8%((9)! : 9!(9(!&(! ' O( 9&(! & 9 (  ! ? ! 9( P  '( 3!&(! '$(  9(!$ &(5((# *#  &! & -2 &%8  -22/  =  '( 9(!  (  : 7  (! & $(&!H'$  %&%?$E%&(5(  "4444444444# $ %(7(!'& (9&:9(((!&H  H #9(! 5((&& &(!(((('&! (!#=% (C! & :%!(!&$Q(C! !(!(((!D? $(!% ( #= 8H!(5%&(&= !!%!! C  &(55% ! % !( 8( (( '$  !:  3! 7( !% (  ! !% ( #  $E  !(!  &%6(! !H  9   (  &%: 7 (!! & 8  (5% (  & (! ! ( %!(! (8 & $ ( ! & $7( # = %!! %!(! ? (&%    !8((% ! $E !( &  :9( $! B(!  & &  (!!#   :(! 9 & :   !:%&(' !  (!  %&(!( !7('#  $9( &   !(( $ % $%!(!  8 &$E  %!( &69(! : 7 8 (5% (  & (! $ ( $7(  : ! ((!8! !&&   (  (( ' 5( &7!!(&8!# !5(& &  &$!(9(!%&!%!(!( !!!&$!  (!( ( ! &8! !  &%!   &  ! &(!  ! ( !  (!%&! 9(%!(!(8?(!!?( &!# /2#  /@ 5%9 (   /* ( -22- $ %  %!% (  8%%5( &$ !7 &$ (!!(  5(  !  R ? " 7# =  &(55% ! !(9(!% !('%&& &!  &!'!(!!(5   !

   

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

   

1/,/+1-22- 3F1/-3

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

'D!( ! ! &(-222 ==-222 /#0/(9& '(5(!(,K#  (& 7%9!(&$!(9(!%(! %%!(!(9' 9 !  !  &   &!( ! &  9( ()   55! ( &$&!! '$ !(8 &$! !%7C !!&&!% E:&(5!(&  !# (!& &(%!(! ! &$ : ( & ! 9( &,2 :  (! &$ & % :8&&( (5% ( ?)&!  (-222I,/@: S9( %('//1-220#*@ 8*#-K!!&(!D!  !%?..AF,25 #  # !E&$!(9(!%&.2N(&%! (!!&&-+$@-2 5 #

   

1/,/+1-22- 3//1/-3  ='!($()(& %& ? %&!(&!!5(& !( ! & D:!    ?    & $(9(&  ' $(!(% 5%&5(#!(&%(8'  ! %!:&( (!! &    G ( &(!  &%  ? $(& &$ 8%'(#   (  ( ! &%! % '  !( ? !3 !( ! ( 8( %% % '  (3!#   %'! (  H!(5(  $  &$&!! &((!(&/2N&(&!(9(!%'  !  (! E  9:&(#C (&$(9(&$%!8(! ?-.A20@5 #   %(:&(&@0A2+.5 # !&7(!&F*@FN#  !79 & (!? !!(C # //#

9&'( %C&&%((!!'% %! !!(C    &%  !&C/  -222# /-# & ( 8!!7(&(&(!%&-A2225 #( %? !(! &&%#  

   

1/,/+1-22- 3/-1/-3

  +)3  )(* *+*  (* +)

 -171   8  911 1  4:;# +   71 

%  98    (! H!%   "(  4444444444 !   &%((&-FM!-22-&$55(!&$ 3(9(&(!%S  71

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