opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/208/2005

Genf · 2005-03-22 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (3 Absätze)

E. 7 ( '!;"!!9   @*) '!* '0"  !"*  **";B"=  "; ( !""!   (" 09 >'@" ( (!"  !" E   (*!*)  0"@" *(  *"! ( ># 0" (*B. ! ( !* (! . )" ( 0!   !" ( '"0"* G;" *"" K@; (  !" ( '!*9     !B"* ' " " =!*  (* ( 54 ";! 566<9 3,9  (" ( 54 ! 5664 '!*  "!B"* !! "!  (* "*9   =" @!= . '==

 (   0! !!"" "  " ( '; ( / ( (!9    *@" ! !G*  ; ( "0" (  (* "  "*)' 0" 0*  (!"  ="   !*" B!() !!* ( ="9  !!"   . )  (* ( 54 ";! 566< "  . *" "  (!" .  !"

 "/! ! ;(!" . )' " "*@!* (  "@ ! *0! 0 !*   "* ( @ " *0"" . )E "  .  K !@)9 569 ! !*0 ( 4  5664 '     !B" ( !!9 539 >!     *"* @!(* . B@!9 559  "! **" ( =" !"" !" ! !  "") (; (  !"  (!" ( !*" !!T"9

 ") 39   @0 ! E!@" B(! IJ  *"* (=* "  ""* (/  3! A" 566<  !; " ( !   * (

E. 8  *" " 32 B@ ! I!"9 3 "9 ! " 82

J9

>" . E" ( E*" ( 32 B@ ! !  !; =*(*!  5- B0! 5664 I % 3<6  362J  !( @0  ("*  3< =*0!!  ( " "!"! !@" !"""  !; " ( !  ( *@!  ! . "! B@ ""!  ( E""" ( E*" ( 0K B@ !9 59 =!*" . '!"9 82  9 3 "9  G9 5   !; " ( !  V"  " ) ( """ !*0 . E!" 82 ) " !"0 .   ! E!70("* ( 3, B 3,8,9 >  *" ! B@! (  (E / "  *";9

123415664 7 ?138 7 <9   =*(*! !  !" @**! ( (!" ( !  ( 2 ";! 5666 I J " "!*  0@!  3! B0! 566< "!V"  (=" ( ;! ( " *@ (  ( ( ! 9 >!   "*!  " ( 0!) (!" ' ) (" T"! "!G* .  /! ( !   )  !/@  ; "   0@!  " C  =" B!()" (*"!"  " !(" I % 35-  42- (9 3 352  3<2 (9 4; "  !*=*!J9  !0G  ) !  !*(! " . (*=" ( !/@ "!"! "!!  0 (!" ' )  !*!0 (/  B! (  "!*  0@! I % 33- ,< (9 2; 335  <26 (9 4F  # 3,,? $ <-

E. 9 -2  *9 ?6J9

359  0" (EK! (   (E /  !"/! =K* !  B! !( !*"* ("  !*" !" ( (*!!)E ==!" ( 0"*  0 ( !"!  (! " (  !*"*@!! (  ! ( "!0 E"  K@;9 7

EK" (E !;("* +G"!)  *"* !" * "" !  ! ::::::::::)  *( ( >#9 7

 !"/! (  G!"* " (  (!* ( (!  "; ( =(!  !" (*=0!; . !  ( 'K@;"* (' ! ! ( '"0"* !=  !V"  !0G ="" !** 9 7

) E!* ==! (E !" "   " !"!  !" (E"*@!"  ( ""  ="" (  09  ==" ") (*!" !  *(  0   !V" ! F  "; "!* ! ;7= T   = 0"   0 "! ( ! ="9 7

 !!" E" * . "" !  G!@ +G"!)9  K !" " !"" @*)E " !  G!@ ""!" "G*!)"  "!"" ()*9 E"*!* E  0   ( "!"" *("K I"(* !!J9

 0 ( ) !*/( E  " ! . EK" (E *"" +G) !"*  *0" ;   "G*! ")9 7

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

123415664 7 34138 7 (*=0!;   !"  !(" !  "9  !!"  ("*   !"" (*)" " E  !  ! *! ! "!  ( "!   " ! ""! (E*0"!  (@  .  B! !)E *"" " (  =!9   !""  ! !* ( E!*) E  ! ! ( "!0 !)E  *""  ;  "!V*  "" (== " !@!"";9 3<9 ! !  E"; (EK!   ;(! ( !!" (/ !)  (!"  !" !=    "K (E0("* (E  56S "  0 ( """ ( EK !" ( ># + !"09 349  *@!(. ) !*/(  !! " !B"*   ( (*!"9

123415664 7 38138 7 , ")1 )!,)"  !, ",

 5.6   7  8   9: %$' ";   6 

39 *!  !! !0;9

 6

59  !B""9 <9 ")  !*(! " @!""9 49 =!  !" ( )E 0" =!! !! "!  !*" !!T" (  (* ( <6 B! (/  "=" !  !(* (!*  !; =*(*! ( ! >GYR!G=) 2 2664    "! K !9  (*  " T"! !@*9 

*! (" P J ()! K"") (*  !!" (*!;"!   "  (  (* "")*F;J K ! !) "=  " 0! ((! "" "! (*F J !"!  @"!   (  ! !*""9 > 

*!  ""   "! **" **!*  ""! J;J " J 7(  !; =*(*! ( !  !!  "!!  "/! !  !!)E (0! (*!! !!0;9 

*! ( !! "! !  + ( !0) !" B" )  (* "")* " E0  ( )   *"* K *(*  !!" I!"9 3<5 362 " 36? J9

 @!==/!P

#!7  Z

 !*(" P

! [   

 !*"!7!" P

K(!   

   =! ( !*" !!T" " "=* K !" )E. E== =*(*! ( !  !  @!== 

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

    

       !"  

        

#$%&#'((& )#'(*#'((+ )

!)!,)"  !, ", %- ./   ''  '((+

  

 0000000000   !" ! # $! % &   ' "( ( )  *" ( !!"

"!

"11,,)"  2!,34)  ! ( +,-. /0 "*

123415664 7 5138 7  1) 39 #! #:::::::::: !!"" (; "  " " *  3   3,-89 59  

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

369  *( ( EK . ! ! !" " *";) '""" .  "* 0"  ! *)  "0"* != (  3,,2)  "!0 K!* B)'! '*""  K@;  ! ( (! (! (*G* !  "  "" ")' + 0"  (" ( !(" (

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

123415664 7 8138 7 ! ::::::::::  @*)   "!0 ( !@!! *"" (*0!* ( /! @**! 0  !@!/ ( E=!")  "0"* ( "@ ! K  !" ; M T (  (" ! O9 'K !"  ()*  0!  !!  !**")" .   "* !*( ( "!09 >   *"" " ( !*(! .  "!;""! (EK " "! 0"@"  "" *"" (*B. ==" !*   F ! "!   !" *!"= ( !0!   "* ( G!G!  ( ""  "!0 !;;" !"9

3 !0 *( !*@

 I>#J  3- B 566 0 0K"* . (!"  0 (! G+ !+ GJ G! "!7 @  " =*!! 35 " !"G! "!7  G+! 87>3 (*;"" I#84968J9 7 >"*" G* ")9

 *( " ""*) E!* 0" !*"* (  3,,2 "  *  !/  !"!  > ( (! 0!* !""  0 ( !G !" " !; K "!"" "" *("K) G+"G*! ")9  (! E*""  .  *"( . E*  (!"     .  @G )EK = " K @K );@" '"*!* .  (* ! 0  9 > (! *"" ! -8S ( "  "!/ !"" "  ( !" B  /""9

'K ;" ( ""  !"" ="  "  0" "= *"" "!/ "*9 ;" 0 *""    @!*  !*" "0 ""9 "=)('!* *"" "!* !)) G ('"!  !0" "!/; .;@!  !""9  (! .   " *"" (== " '0"  ! !" 0  M "(! " O (  =;!+@9 ;!0"   ";R!! ( (! !0)*P ! K    " ( '!"/! "* !0)" ( (!  0 ( (9 #=""  + 0"  (!( "!  " 0* "  (* )  0"@" !(@) '+"  =! ('K " !  (!9  *0)"  (@" ( (! ="9

123415664 7 2138 7 'K ) +G"!) '  "!* ( (* ! B! ( (* " +G") ('K*"* @**!* ( "!; G;) ( "!; (  !"* !;(  ( "" =" +G"!) ( !")  ("! '"  !"! ))  "* ( "!0 B"=; ( " ( 0 *(7B!()9  '"  "*   ( !"!;" ( '0!" +G @!* '*@" ( !( G(  K * ! '!*9  EK"" (  ( "" =" +G"!)9

 !"*!") ( (! *0)* (!" 0@9  K !" " *  (@" ( "!; "=! (==*!*) '*""    (*"!" ! '"" (   "* ( "!0 M !"" (   ( '!*) 0" ("*  !H ('0( O9  "" ="   !G"@) *"" * K "!; (  "") ( !G P  =(!" *0"!  "!0  " G*  0"   !"" ( !G ) !"! ( G!@  !() 56 D "  !"7.7=K9 !"   "* ( "!0 K@;   +G"!)  '; ( "" !;("* +G"!)  "!; (!K   *"* "* . 366S9 >!   !G"@) (  != ('=!"   "* ( "!0  *"* *@" "* . 366S   " ( "!0 *"" !@)9    *( " "*) @;"   "* ( "!0 K@; *"" ( 366S9 389

 0 ( (*!") !*/(" ! (* ( 54 ";! 566  (@!* ('0("* '*0" ( . 366S9 E!*   . )  (* ( 54 ";! 566 # ! " ""  K@ !) !  B! !( !  0! !V"! "/! 0! !;" ( !")'  !" '*!"! (' 0  !"*   ( ";!

123415664 7 -138 7 ( '!;"!!9   @*) '!* '0"  !"*  **";B"=  "; ( !""!   (" 09 >'@" ( (!"  !" E   (*!*)  0"@" *(  *"! ( ># 0" (*B. ! ( !* (! . )" ( 0!   !" ( '"0"* G;" *"" K@; (  !" ( '!*9     !B"* ' " " =!*  (* ( 54 ";! 566 !     *"* @!(* . B@!9 559  "! **" ( =" !"" !" ! !  "") (; (  !"  (!" ( !*" !!T"9

 ") 39   @0 ! E!@" B(! IJ  *"* (=* "  ""* (/  3! A" 566 " . E" ( E*" ( 32 B@ ! !  !; =*(*!  5- B0! 5664 I % 3   *" ! B@! (  (E / "  *";9

123415664 7 ?138 7 !   "*!  " ( 0!) (!" ' ) (" T"! "!G* .  /! ( !   )  !/@  ; "   0@!  " C  =" B!()" (*"!"  " !(" I % 35-  42- (9 3 352  3  E!"9 4   E0("* "  (" (   "* ( @ !** !"  ( @ (!*) !*" (E """ .  "* G+)  " !0" (E =!"* @*" (E (  (E (" I=9 *@" !"9 ?  J9

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

123415664 7,138 7 !0)* !  """ .  "*  ! (E"! ="! "" !  "" *)  ! ( ! G*!" .  !"* ( E!* " ! K   ) (E!(!  "!0 I   G==! 3655 " 0"J9 -9 ! 0!  !*!  (@!* (E0("* E("!" I  B@ E +  !!J ; ( (")  *( *0"" (E"!  *" (0"  =!!9  "WG ( *( " . !"!  B@" ! E*"" ( "* " . ()! () ! " !) "0"* E!* "  ; ( "!0!9  "!  (* *( """  **" " ! (*"!!) "!0K  " ! !;" K@! ( E!* I % 358  523 (9 4 338  3   B! !( " ""!  ! ( E*!"! (E K !" B(!  =") 7 "" ( "!(" )E !7K !" !(* !  !;  ==!   ( /! 0"9  "! !) (E"!  *"

*""" (  "!!  " . ""! *!"  ("  !" ( (*(" ( EK !" E  " K!     "! !*"" (0!@" (  (  (!! !  B@  ;  "!"  *"!

123415664 7 36138 7   =! (E 0 K !" *( I % 33?  5,6 (9 3; F 335      "* ( "!0  0" T"! *!*  ! ( ! *(  ! ( ! !=9

 *( !*"* " !" .   "* ( "!0 ""  B"")E "0"* !"0 E" K@; ( !!" !   !) 7  " ( (!9,9  ># 

!*(* .  K  " " "K ( E*"" ( "* ( E!*9 !  =!  K !"  "  +* ! E"! ( (! "" !  !"=" ( *( +" K*  ""  !0" ( !") E  ") ""!) ! ! !" ; !  (!; *"+*9  /  /"  *"* !** "  ""  *"* @" "( !  K !"9 E*"" ( "* ( !!"  =" E;B" (EK  !=(9  ! !" " !"* "  K !" ( ># " !*(* .  * ( (* "( ! = ( !0! . (  !9  " ( 0 !G"@)    "* ( "!0 !*(  *"* "* . 366S (  != (E=!" ! "")  " ( "!0 " !@)9 E!* !*"" ( (! G!) (! " ;! F   !V" ""=) E; ( **";B"=  )  !"""  (EK )! E!@ ( (!9  *( " @* 

123415664 7 33138 7 (!( "! E""* K"!T ( " *@* "  """;B"0) *"" (*!*9

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

123415664 7 3  9 "9 9 -2  *9 ?6J9

359  0" (EK! (   (E /  !"/! =K* !  B! !( !*"* ("  !*" !" ( (*!!)E ==!" ( 0"*  0 ( !"!  (! " (  !*"*@!! (  ! ( "!0 E"  K@;9 7

EK" (E !;("* +G"!)  *"* !" * "" !  ! ::::::::::)  *( ( >#9 7

 !"/! (  G!"* " (  (!* ( (!  "; ( =(!  !" (*=0!; . !  ( 'K@;"* (' ! ! ( '"0"* !=  !V"  !0G ="" !** 9 7

) E!* ==! (E !" "   " !"!  !" (E"*@!"  ( ""  ="" (  09  ==" ") (*!" !  *(  0   !V" ! F  "; "!* ! ;7= T   = 0"   0 "! ( ! ="9 7

 !!" E" * . "" !  G!@ +G"!)9  K !" " !"" @*)E " !  G!@ ""!" "G*!)"  "!"" ()*9 E"*!* E  0   ( "!"" *("K I"(* !!J9

 0 ( ) !*/( E  " ! . EK" (E *"" +G) !"*  *0" ;   "G*! ")9 7

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

123415664 7 34138 7 (*=0!;   !"  !(" !  "9  !!"  ("*   !"" (*)" " E  !  ! *! ! "!  ( "!   " ! ""! (E*0"!  (@  .  B! !)E *"" " (  =!9   !""  ! !* ( E!*) E  ! ! ( "!0 !)E  *""  ;  "!V*  "" (== " !@!"";9 3 # + !"09 349  *@!(. ) !*/(  !! " !B"*   ( (*!"9

123415664 7 38138 7 , ")1 )!,)"  !, ",

 5.6   7  8   9: %$' ";   6 

39 *!  !! !0;9

 6

59  !B""9 GYR!G=) 2 2664    "! K !9  (*  " T"! !@*9 

*! (" P J ()! K"") (*  !!" (*!;"!   "  (  (* "")*F;J K ! !) "=  " 0! ((! "" "! (*F J !"!  @"!   (  ! !*""9 > 

*!  ""   "! **" **!*  ""! J;J " J 7(  !; =*(*! ( !  !!  "!!  "/! !  !!)E (0! (*!! !!0;9 

*! ( !! "! !  + ( !0) !" B" )  (* "")* " E0  ( )   *"* K *(*  !!" I!"9 3<5 362 " 36? J9

 @!==/!P

#!7  Z

 !*(" P

! [   

 !*"!7!" P

K(!   

   =! ( !*" !!T" " "=* K !" )E. E== =*(*! ( !  !  @!==