opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/201/2004

Genf · 2004-03-30 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (3 Absätze)

E. 026  (  # 7 ': 033D$  :  /  (&(</  '   /-  D3 7 ': 033D6   '  ('7   // K  '/  (&  /- 7     /7L   '  '&/6   7 /   ((  & <    )&   7(&( 9 (   (/ /$   J /'(6

! G123!

1243510332

* 

E. 26  (9&(  )(9 (;  00 (&': 2"42,.  / / '(-/     /$ %  2 (J 033D$  :  (   (6 (-('/' > ) 6 D 6 D  7( (  ($    (  & ) /  &9   7/  ( 7  &  (''(  (  (  ' %)!&  &&  ( ')(--  :  (   ($       <$   (   (  ' %) &  &&  ('',-6  6 G5 .6  ('7/   :  /   / : 7(;9  )7%6 06  (-//   7  9//  (  (  5 ( (: 0333, .   /  &9  2;& 033D$  O  (': '(- (   ('  )!&$ (''   < ( )  6 G0   (-//  )!&  &&   03 /': 2"45, .6  )7% ' ( -( /9 7  7( (  &9;<) D2 /': 0330$  /9  77 ( <  %9 77: (   &9  '(' (M  - ;<'

/ '   ( 7( , E 20=  45= (6 2.6  7( ( /9 ( % (  /    6 D6

H '  ) 6 #0 62  $  ( '  /7 () (''9  7 (<    ('7 (   - 7 &(7  /(  /7 (   /) / > ('7   '(' (M    (  (''9  $  ( $ > )H7 () /  <  > ('7   - (''9:6 ( ' >      7( ($  )9  )() /  7/'7 ( > (/)(--, E 220  #$ (6 4 P  2"#5 76 4"D.6 (<  (/&)   7: (' 7  ( 7/ >  /  77 (  7 (9 /$  /  77:, 6 #0 6 0  .6

 : -//  ,!7% E .  7(/  77 <)   ('7 (  A (  (''9 C     7( ( 7/ /$ > 7  '(' (M  ((O $  8 7K  )  ( <)(   () )    ('7    7 <$ <  (    7'  7  (&  ( ($ ' 7(; -  (:9 (  /7  (''9, E 225  =G$ (6 D: P 22D 

! 5123!

1243510332 2#2$ (6 0 P 220  #$ (6 4$ 2G# P 23#  G0$ (6 G P  2"#D$ 76 23#.6  - / '  (  (   <) )8  A  ( ( 7  7(- $  >  : C,-6 E  @ Q A I: :9  R(S $ 0%' /6$ 79 220.)(M /   7    /   6 46 ( ;7$    - $  (''9   %9 9// /;> --'' ( (<  (( (  /  7:/$ 7 &' (< )/   (( (, )& .  /7(/ 7( K  ( /, E 205  444 (6 DP 202  0D5 (6 4P 22"  "0 (6 D   /-/  /.6  77 )77<     -  </ 7  7(/ (''  ;9' ((  < ( (''  7' 7 >    (O   (''9, E 205  44G (6 D:P 225  == 

- P  2""G 76 2"" (6 DP @?

 ? $ 

9IS    ' I T7(T I

6 G0

@$  Q  2""2 76 D"" P '$  I T&-I I

6 G0

@$  Q

S  E9  '  9I 

@$  ! 2""#$ 76223.6

 -  ) </  (  7(/ (  (  7(/ (''$  - '  <  (  (''9 U /  '('  )(&    -  U  &  %9 9//  '('   7(   -  - ) -$      7: (    '   E (--   ('',E . /  / ' , E 20D  25 (6 G6.6

 )8 ! ! 7   7/   !>$ (''  /   %9 ( ;7  /, 2""3 76 D30  P

E 20#  20. <  (   &  (''9  &  'K' '7, E 20"  2"D (6 06D.6   )7%$   ?   (  (''9  23 ( (: 0333$   ;9'   L   -    (/ / - ) -6 G6  '  (-/  G; 0332 > ?( @++++++++++  /(  /7 (  (''96   (- (  (  &   /) / 7 7 ) 6 #0 6 2  6  $ ?( @++++++++++  -('/ (77( (  5 (J 0332 7%    ?6  /-   -('/ (77( (   / '7 7 ) 6 #2 6 0  6   ?$ 7(  7 $  7(/  22 7 ': 0332 (  (  '&/  )(77( ( 7%  :  /,7//''  (''(  (  (  ' %

1 .6 ('7    -/ 7/& > ) 6 00   (-//   7(/ '  &  03 /': 2"5#

! =123!

1243510332, . $ 77:   ('  )   &   ) 6 "5  , E 200  5G.$   ?  7 /  /  D3;( 7/& 7 ) 6 #2 6 D    (  (   &:6 G6   9 7(   7(: /  /-   7/; : 7  '$ H ( (  ) 6 G0  $ < 7/&(< )'7(8 ((&  (''9 <)  /  &(  77 (   (' ( 7 /99 9&6

)'7(8   7( '($  7(: / 7 )/ $ >  :$ H (9 < ( 9  ( (', E 20D  2G$ (6 G: P 200  55 (6 4 P 22"  43G (6 0   /-/.6

) 6 24 6 2  $  (/ ( &   6 D4   $ 7 < )'7(8 (/$ (  I< 7$  ( (  /  & ! >    ('7 (  'K' '7 <  7(7 ( (6  '7(8 (& '  7/(<' H   7% ('7 : (   &/ >  '7(8/$  '% >  <  ( ( 7  7 K  /  - )(:;  /(6 )(:9 (  )'7(8  7&( ( (   /9  ('7    VI  (7: 7  7  (6

 /9$  : -//    //$ > / // 7$ <  < /99  )('7 -  77 (    ) 6 G0    ($ 7 (/< $ /7  ( /  (''9  ((/, E 22#  2"G (6 0   /-/ P

E ( 7:/ @ D03132  @ DDD132  # ( (: 033D (6 4.6 ( ;7$   (7:) /99 9& )'7(8 < '<  )  ( <) I('' (:  (:&/   'K'   (    'K' ( 6  '   9 < )77/)7%  &( 9 < )( 7  ( 9//  $  ' %  9 ($) '7(8   'K'  /9( <   ) //6  7/) (/ / (8'$  8   77   7(  H9 /&%   < ( )  ( <) ((  7  77 (6  --/ ( ':: )'7( /9' (<) )9)77/  7(: / :  (9  )'7(8, E 23# 

E. 030 (6 D P  2"#G 76 G2 (6 02  76 54# (6 D:.6 G6:   ) (/ / (8'$  (()(9 7(: ( ) 6 G0     77  < >  < ( ) 6 =G4 6 2 6  7(: / (': H '':  ()'  ($  <)>

! #123!

1243510332 (   7( < )(7   9 ( (   < ($ ) !>! >  < 7  -  /( ('' /&/ H (9 ( < 7(&( >  9 ($ ((  >  -(' (   &(( / () '% / ' , E 20#  D3 (6 DP 22=  440 (6 0:P G=2 (6 DP 23=  DGD (6 G.6  - 7 $    % /&  /$ <  7(  < (    7(: /    (''9 (  )'7KI$ ) !>!)H -- &'  -   'I  --   (/ /, E 20#  D3 (6 D P 22=  440 (6 0: P 222  #4 (6 0.6

 '    7  :/   7(: /  & 7(' >  <  ( ( 7  --/  H  &/ ( 78/ >    (  <) - (- >  (%9 I9/  )'  (  7(  ) 7   &'   ( ( >    ('7 (6    (   &()H  I  &   7( I9/   9 ( 7( ) ('' <) (:&  ($     $  %9'      ( (/, 6 =25  6 2 I6 G .6

 '':  ()'  ( <  ( 7 I9/   9 (  (   7   & I< --  7( I9/   9 (    7/  ( ' 7&  '   ( L    (    'I  --$  (& 7 $     (:9 ($  '  /9%'  (   'I  --$ H9  77(   /  ' '  $  :($ '  9'  ('7/'   8    )/&  , E 224  00D (6 4 P

E ( 7:/ @ 05G130  D; 033D.6

G6  )7%$  )9  / '  7(: /  /-   < (  (!7'  ( ( 7  //   (/ / 7(  7/(  7 ': 2""# > ' 2"""6

 ('7(' 7-  /- ': K   (    (  %$   ' (M ;9 7/  !'K' /;> (  /  /&(    - H (:9 (  (7: <  (': 6  /-  ':  7 &(  7(/  ) 6 G0     ;7 8  &6 ( ')'    (''  & 7(' >  :( 'I  --  $  7 $  7'  ( (

 7%     ('7 ($  ((:   '(  /7  (    VI     9 (   )'  (   (/ /6  '      :( > (  <) - (- > 

! "123!

1243510332 (%9 I9/  9/ 

-  ) 7   /9   ( ( >    '/$ ( > --' <) )& <) L : $   (   /;>  (   /99 9&6  77) < ;7 ) (;( '( / /&%$ (<) ) 9)77/  7(: /)'   < /9 &(/ / H   9 () (/ /  < )/  (''(/   -    -('  7(%, 2""0 76 05#!05" (6 =: P 2"#" 76 22G!225 (6 4 P

E ( 7:/  0; 0332    @ "132 (6 G:6.6

 7& / (  - 7&  /-   (    (   /    /<  &  (''9 : 7  '6  -- $ ) & ( ' '/  -( ()'     (/ /$   7 & >  <  7'   ( ( ( ( -- /6  )  7 & <)   (   < ) 7 (  /  ()'  (   (/ / <  ( ( ( ( /)K  &/6

  '(   (''9$   < (  - )(:;) (   (  ) ( 7 ; > (6

( (  '(-$  (&)'   '    ?   7((  '&/  )(77( (  /-  &  5 (J 03326

! 23123!

1243510332   / + *+ **+  * +

! 47:7  ;  <77 7  =" $'(+>  :7 

26 / &:  '  '&/ /7(/  22 7 ': 0332 7   ? 9/ (  ?( @++++++++++ P ! :7

06 )' P D6  (/<$ 7((  '&/  )(77( ( -('/ 7 ?( @++++++++++     5 (J 0332 P

46  <  7(/  9   P G6 /:(   7   (    ( (  (( P 56 -('  7    <F 7& -(' ( (   7/ K   /  D3;( %  (- ( 7 7 (''/ /  : -//  $ IWTI(-< 5$ 5334   $  ( H'76  /  7 K  7((9/6  '/'( (Q . < H ' < /(  ( / (:     7   /(  </P :. H7( 7( < '(-   ' 7(&('     /(P . 7(  9  (   ( 7/  6

 '/'(  (  7  ( //'  /'// (   . :.  . !$  : -//    7( 7    ' %   ( <F & / &:6  '/'(  ( ' ( (  '(8  7&$ < (;( $  <  /(  </  F&(77  <   / / H7//  (, 6 2D0$ 235  23# .6  9--% Q 8 

 /  Q :   / !;  Q

E( ?   (7 (-('  7/ K  (-/ H 7   <F> F-- -//   ( 7  9--

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

                !" 

         #$%&'#(&&$ #(&$#(&&%)  *+ **+  * + !,&  (&&% '-  . 

    */**++ 01  + /*  *  * 2/  3 4   */**++ 01  +  /*  *  5* *6 2 3    ! "#$ %& ' (  7! 89999999999  '  )*++++++++++

,-. /-

! 0123!

1243510332 * /

26 *++++++++++

,!7%  (/ /. /   (/ / (8'    9   (''  %& 7  0 & 2""# (  : (   )/ (  7: (  7  (!  $ 7/'   (9 7(  7  ( & /6

06 %  " & 2""#$ 7 '    ( //;      9  &6 D6  " & 2"""$ 

  E   )    

    E    ?   B

  *,!7%   ?.  /'/ >  (/ /  '(   "F""D

-6 #G$ ( 0F"#4

-6 4G  >   7 7/$ (7( H ( ( 7  //  )!&  && ,( (

.  H ( ()( ( -' //,( (

E. 7(  7/(  7 ': > /': 2""#6

46  =; 2"""$   ?  '/ )'     (/ /  /7( 7  7/ > ( (  7( (  (  ( ( 7(  7/(  7 ': 2""# > ' 2""" 

20F5=D

-6 "G$ ( DF5D"

-6 4G  7 7/6 G6  2; 2"""$  (/ /  -('/   ? ()    //7I( ( (  7(  'K' - (

)'  6   (  /  2" (J 2""" 7( 

! D123!

1243510332 -(  H7 ( (% 

 /&  '('      (  7(7(  7  7' 6

=6 ;9'  24 7 ': 2"""$  :  7'%     /7: ( (    ')' & / / /&/6 "6  2D ( (: 2"""$   ?  /'/ > )H!'    (   7 7/    ( ( '78/ 7(  7/(  7 ': 2""# > ' 2"""$ ( '(   DF5D"

-6 4G6   /'/ > ?( ++++++++++  '(   "#0

-6 G3,7 7/  ( ( '78/ 7(  7/(  7 ': > /': 2""#.6

236  'K';($   7(   -    (/ /  '(   "F=#4

-6 0G 7%  )--  - 

&!$ (7( H ( ( '78/ 7(  7/(  7 ': 2""# > ' 2"""6 226  0" ( (: 2"""$   ?  ++++++++++- /'/  '(    9H  > )H!'  

?( ++++++++++6   '   ?

  7 7/6 246  0" ' 0333$   ?  7(  '(  /- -  23FD25

-6 GG   -    (/ /$ (7(  H ( (



' 2"""6

2G6  =; 0333$  -    (/ /  / / 7  $  23 ( (: 0333$ L / - ) -6 256  20 ( (: 0333$   )(   )H!'     (/ / 7  

! 4123!

1243510332 7)'7('  H '( &  () /)/7&    (   & H /7)  ) (   /&(  &  (:9 ( 

/ / ('/ 7& $ ('' 7( (!&'  ( (

6 2=6  G; 0332$   ?  / > )H!'    /(  /7 (  (''9 7(   '(   "F044

-6 0G (7( H ( ( '78/ 7(  7/(  7 ': 2""# > ' 2"""6 2#6  (  5 (J 0332$    -('/ (77( ( (    /(6 2"6     22 7 ': 0332$   ?    '(' /' 7/(7/  (   7  7' 7( )//  ( ($    & - 7     (

-%   (/ /6  )& -(  H7 ( (  ( (77( ($ ( 'K'

( &()'     ) &/-    (

-%   (/ /  > & > 

 '    (/ /6 036  4 ( (:$  /-  /7( 7 ) '/  ( (

) 6 D 6 D  7( (  ($    (  & ) /  &9   7/  ( 7  &  (''(  (  (  ' %)!&  &&  ( ')(--  :  (   ($        ('7   '(' (M    (  (''9  $  ( $ > )H7 () /   ('7   - (''9:6 ( ' >      7( ($  )9  )() /  7/'7 ( > (/)(--, E 220  #$ (6 4 P  2"#5 76 4"D.6 (  /  77 (  7 (9 /$  /  77:, 6 #0 6 0  .6

 : -//  ,!7% E .  7(/  77

7  '(' (M  ((O $  8 7K  )  (

 : C,-6 E  @ Q A I: :9  R(S $ 0%' /6$ 79 220.)(M /   7    /   6 46 ( ;7$    - $  (''9   %9 9// /;> --'' ( (    (O   (''9, E 205  44G (6 D:P 225  == 

- P  2""G 76 2"" (6 DP @?

 ? $ 

9IS    ' I T7(T I

6 G0

@$  Q  2""2 76 D"" P '$  I T&-I I

6 G0

@$  Q

S  E9  '  9I 

@$  ! 2""#$ 76223.6

 -  )  $ (''  /   %9 ( ;7  /, 2""3 76 D30  P

E 20#  20.

?( @++++++++++  /(  /7 (  (''96   (- (  (  &   /) / 7 7 ) 6 #0 6 2  6  $ ?( @++++++++++  -('/ (77( (  5 (J 0332 7%    ?6  /-   -('/ (77( (   / '7 7 ) 6 #2 6 0  6   ?$ 7(  7 $  7(/  22 7 ': 0332 (  (  '&/  )(77( ( 7%  :  /,7//''  (''(  (  (  ' %

1 .6 ('7    -/ 7/& > ) 6 00   (-//   7(/ '  &  03 /': 2"5#

! =123!

1243510332, . $ 77:   ('  )   &   ) 6 "5  , E 200  5G.$   ?  7 /  /  D3;( 7/& 7 ) 6 #2 6 D    (  (   &:6 G6   9 7(   7(: /  /-   7/; : 7  '$ H ( (  ) 6 G0  $   :$ H (9

   ('7 (  'K' '7

 '7(8/$  '% > 

/ // 7$



! #123!

1243510332 (   7( ! > 

 9 ($ ((  >  -(' (   &(( / () '% / ' , E 20#  D3 (6 DP 22=  440 (6 0:P G=2 (6 DP 23=  DGD (6 G.6  - 7 $    % /&  /$ !)H -- &'  -   'I  --   (/ /, E 20#  D3 (6 D P 22=  440 (6 0: P 222  #4 (6 0.6

 '    7  :/   7(: /  & 7(' > 

   ( 

 (%9 I9/  )'  (  7(  ) 7   &'   ( ( >    ('7 (6    (   &()H  I  &   7( I9/   9 ( 7( ) (''

' 2"""6

 ('7(' 7-  /- ': K   (    (  %$   ' (M ;9 7/  !'K' /;> (  /  /&(    - H (:9 (  (7:

 :( 'I  --  $  7 $  7'  ( (

 7%     ('7 ($  ((:   '(  /7  (    VI     9 (   )'  (   (/ /6  '      :( > ( 



! "123!

1243510332 (%9 I9/  9/ 

-  ) 7   /9   ( ( >    '/$ ( > --'

 (   /99 9&6  77)



(6

( (  '(-$  (&)'   '    ?   7((  '&/  )(77( (  /-  &  5 (J 03326

! 23123!

1243510332   / + *+ **+  * +

! 47:7  ;    :7 

26 / &:  '  '&/ /7(/  22 7 ': 0332 7   ? 9/ (  ?( @++++++++++ P ! :7

06 )' P D6  (/ F-- -//   ( 7  9--