opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/169/2007

Genf · 2007-02-21 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

             

      

         !""#$!$%%& '!(&)!$%%# '

* '+* ',  *  , +

-./ 0  $(12 $%%# 

  !"#$%&$''" (&$'')$* $+,-

  $

$  -  --  -! ./012! - !"* #$ % &$ ' '"  (&$' ' )$ .$ -

  $"&

   

3445131667 *1328*

   

3445131667 *9328*  3+' 2:   ! &  2; $ 1669 #  "#$'&$&+  - !$$?($$@@:A$$! &$$&$'$#@$#@#=' B-  C*#=DB- E: 1: 14>$1669!?(&$"&$$'%$""0 '(%'F* ""G .HF!&$&/@&##I #'#'%/'#$'($'%': 9: (&($'%'/'+H#$F$F%* $ ' =% C*#= D +E:   ##$ ' 14>$ 1669!  

!$$!$$&#&'(&#$F!''F&@ ''J!'(#$/$@&'J?&$$&/="$'&#& %/.$'&@"&:&/"$$&?'$22!21$91&$$* & $  '&  #$$ G  $*.*K// # $ ' #  ./: '/$&$&@"&!"L">!# !"&* '  % ' / '  #K? ' -% G

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

 ,+' 2: /%N/$>'CE&$&"'@&$$$&!'= 2M$1669! 0$'!"#&'8>/! '$  #&'$ $  %*#&'$! 8 ##&$ $ 27 >/  C$:2$:$87 E: -$GN$'N&$'27>/!# 0@&'& 15>%1664C,296267E!' /%'#$&!29@&%! '#$$$/$#"$$$ 0$'  ' &/   G $ >/ $$! ! ' N$$$ ' N&$'%F>/: 1: @"&"$G($:87:2$:.:4! 0$'* )$$?'$$$#&%GN$87' @&'&#$/&&''$''7$01666 C E ? $ $% G   @&'&  N*'$ ' 16" 2; /''N#=$&$0: 9: -N$:76:2 !'&'$'$$>: $@!'&* /$G !N$:267

!'$%0>?(92'&"0 1667!#&%$'&''$": (#=!'&##* $'92M$1667&$&I#$#$H$'"'$ ?'1;%"01667&$&@"&$"#$:$>$&'

   

3445131667 * $ 1669*'G'2>$1667: 8: F$"'($:7:2

!('##$"$!#$$ '( $ &   '('$ #@! '('$  #@*  $ ' "' #@:  #0$& ' (*'$ (&$'!##!G$$&?'""/0?$%$' ##$'$&$C,22;995':2!22 / F"@'$$"$'/"$'('"&'!$ ?'$L$$.&@"$G=/''/&'%"0#&* #'&$! ##?& /&&"$G(##&$'#%'( : !?(F$'(##$'G@@$$('$$

   

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

   

3445131667 *29328* %$&$&L$&G@>1667:>$&?$$"$%$'&0* "$"&&(&$$'#$$#?(&$$'&#@%.0$ ?'&0&'$%$'#:F#&?!#$!G@' $.&#!(&#&$$'%%%.$!'L%&#&$$@!' .&$$%#$&$%"$>#&$G#'''&* "L"0:'&&?(&$$'(&%$&%&'($ #$*$"$?!?'($0FF$'&#@"F$'/$?& '&0$ '  $.&# %  $0 0*"#@ $$& G  @ ' *: '%##$' $#@@""$"$%&$$ $'$: @@$!##$'15"1667@$&$$'('/$.* /&$'(&%$@%0?#"$$$'(L$$.&#'&0$'" '"1667#&$?($$.'$.&#&$$%/0!" ##$'$%(/: $G'15%"01667!$$ @"$("&$'&0'(&$$'#$$!"$@' $.&#"L"$"#?(L$'#$$'(*'$$ %'/$'$00*"#@!$$@'? '$##$'$&%(/:,$'$$? "&'$$$''F#$'%/$'(##$G($$%G @'$$"$'#K.$.&#$#''/$'@@&$' '##$$$'&$(&%$""@%0: #!$'?#&='?!F"#$'!  $%'&$$'##$'15"1667!&* #'$?"$G'?$#&#"'$'$$! $$!'$'"$'('$&$$ $0#K.?$(/$$%?$%'/$: = !  F#$ '     #"$$$ # ' '$ ' 0*@'&''+ : ':  $  # &?$ '&0$& '  ?L$ ':;: (#=!(F#$'"$?(F$$&$#$%(* '$'14>$1669!"$"?$$?#00"$$$$ "'>1667:$'("0'##$'(F#$?#* $$"$%&!'(#$!#(&%$@%0'(&$$'$&'(&? )$ *"L"  ' "F"F'#'&0$'(&1667!$ '($#$#$0'#$&: !$$$@"&# ?!' ##$'15"1667!"$&%$@%0%@"$'

   

3445131667 *24328* '&@$$'K"#$"$/#K.#$./?#"$$$'(* L$$.&#'&0$'"'"1667:

&?!%$'('"$$!'/&'%"0#&#'&$ ?!?(F$'$&$$(/$$0#K* .?>?("'>1667$?$$?&$&$$$'=" '>$: 26: $$&$$''$&'&?$#$L$'"(#=:

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

  &$*>$D    .##  Y  #@"'#&$L$$$@&F#$?NGN@@@&'& '$&#0?#/@@