opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/167/2005

Genf · 2005-02-28 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

                !" #

      

         $%&'$())& $*%+$()), ""

- "- .  -". . %/  .0 1  (' 23 ()), 

  44444444 ! "#! $ %&% '$(( )!* !&&+'%'!&'',  !

!  .  -  . 5.. $-!!! ./001  '!'%

   

2/3421003 512.65  6 ., "' "77777777  !'! !8'%.9/:! ')%(' .94:!'%&'!!%!%;% *!  '), !! !  '?'!?''!.99:!* %*! ! )%-@8)!&*A!  88% B77777777(1'.99C, 1, '  .. ?%) '  .949 * % ??!'! %8!&- & !!;8  '%!%D77777777(, 6,   &  &  ! )'   B77777777 ( !  ' %''% &  &*%%!& !5?A!  %?E '+%* % %!%!-8' ' !'  +'  %!% %  !E  .99C =   5'&! 

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

   

2/3421003 5/2.65 '!'&',* !* )''!&KE!?&!!&'??% ! '! *) !   !&' ! *!  %)!',

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

   

2/3421003 5C2.65 ' & '%8     = ! ' I8 !'!'   & *!!! & *%!'&)KI8 , 1,  ' ? %!=O !,:/,.!,-,: 'E! &   ' #!  '! '+ & !!!'  %) = * !':/ +'! !')='?%&%  * 5'&!& 10 .94.F'5 >

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

H,

*>  '! I!%60 1003! &%'' '!' &19&%E 1006%!%&%%&? !&%''% '&  !+*'! )E, :, *EI!&'!'8 ! +!'&*K'!&*) ! &* 5 '&!   E%%?'&  ! &)&*'&! &)'! &:'1006, /, (* !,.,. &'?%&%  * 5'&!&10 .94. F'5 >G

H! %=!'! E'8!' ? %!K&''!'&   %! '  ! )'  %  (';  '  ! )'  = &''   !'  !8''  )!'  '' +    ! )'!&&%&%!' &!'  !%8%, '?%&% 

   

2/3421003 542.65 !%!& * E'8!' K &!'!!'!8= +' %! '!&*! !&! )'F !,.,1

H,  &%E! !  ?' &  ) !  &*  ! %8'   * !, 6 

 +' &'+*  &'!??!&>I R! )'   '!&P ! )') !&*88!!& &'   ??! = *K' !' & ! !'>I +''!'R '?' & '! &'5'   ' F !, 6 , . ! 1 

H,  ' ?%&%  >8  %% !' !   !!' & ! +' &')! A!  '&% %  '   ?  !  ! & )!'     8!' & * F !,6,:

H, (*8'! &  ?' & *  = *K!'!' & & '!  '  * !, C & * & * 5'&!&10&%E .941F'5 >G

H &%! '%+'! %!%' &* !,6,1&', '''*8'! !! & '&'!% I '>  & * 5'&! E'8!'  & * ''!' &* 5')'&'!%& %8'&!'  ! &8'&'5&'!& 5&'!'&! ')% +' !) %  ' !  & '  '' +  '&'!% &*  5! '!%!F !,C,. !,E

H, * !,1,. &* & O 5'&!& -@8 & 13 I)'  .99/  %)'! +     -@8 +' '!  &'!'&O !,4&' * 5-@8&1:I'.941F H +' S')! & '&'!%? %! = O !'19  ! % = !'!  E'8!'  !   '&!  > &  , ( * !, 6 & * &O  &'!??!&>I R -@8 '!&'!'&O !'4  S'!&'&'!%? %! =O !'19   '> ?'!& &' ??!=OK' !' &! !'>I +''!'R -@8 '&'!' &O !'4  S&'&'!%? %!=O !'19   & '> ?', ?'* !,11,3 '&%&'!&!!& *'&'!% '&* 5'&! ?'E'8!' !) =  )! ''>!' =- 8, '' +' S'! &'&'!%&-@8! %! '&! ?'! ?', C,   &  &   %)!' & '&! ! & &'  ?' F!'! /&

H* !,43,1

 %)'!+ 8&*K%!')! K &*! )'+'!! '!&8  % !''> !K% K'&!!&' ?', '?%&%  >8+!'& '&'!%=)  K %+' '!& K'&*!')'!%+*' K S'!  %%&! E'!   %I&' '&% E &   )!!)! %!& &*!  !!'&* ,

   

2/3421003 592.65

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

!O'&'!% -8!&O!', !!& '> !'!  !!'&O ! '!&! ' !!' &% !') %)!'&'&!!&' ?'F $.1/ 103'&,1! %?% '!%T " 1000641,1:3'&,6H!

   

2/3421003 5.02.65  !!OK'!&O  )!&&''!&%'' &OK'& !,43,1

!C4 F !,4/,. H, !! I ' &%!% % %!& $ E'%&14&%E  100.:.3200, 4, *>  !*%!'!E%%?'&* 5-@8 &* !,4 19  &)&*'&!&:'1006, ? %! K &''!' &  

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

*> ' &.4?%) ' .999&*'!'%*!' &> +*' ! '! & *  !!  K'+!   ! +  ) !  &*  ! '&! ?' & ?'60I  >) !& & '> L'&'!% -8!&*!'N'!*  +*'*8'!  %'!%&* , &!'!*!E'&*K' '  ! '! &P & !&*'K!'!&& '8!&%    &> +*! '& '8!'K!!&&''!' +*' '! ' %= & ='!&'5'+  ! E%%?'''!&*) ! 

I &'&!&:'1006, !! %+&%'+!&?'!+*  8) !  

&* % E!!?'!+*'*8'!&*'&'!%) %    % ,  '  !!&8E+* '!&!   ! *')'! ' '  %'!%&+) ! &* %!'! 8%   ) ! & *   '! %!% &   = '   '+ '&!&) ! &* 5&' !!A% '&,  '+'&!%!%'&! !)$ "U&'*%100.   &'  !' , ..,   +'  %>&    O!  ! &O  &  !!'   O%)%!&:'1006+'*%!'!) !, %!'!&& '! 

   

2/3421003 5.12.65 &%'' '!'&19&%E 1006&?'   ?& ' - 8&'!&*'&! %'!%,  &'!&A!  I!%, 

   

2/3421003 5.62.65 " . 6 "- .  -". .

 72   8  9   5# *%(   2 

., %    )E,  2

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