opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/160/2006

Genf · 2006-02-16 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

       

         

      

          !"#$%%&  '%$%%'  ()(* *+*  (* +) , - .  ' /0 $%%' 

  !"#$%#"&!''(()  *  !+$,$+- !%#$* .!'/0/ 1 )2  ,

,

))       )    ) ! ," %345!+,.67!'/''   /0 ,#$

   

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

   

8'(098/774 *58''* ++AJ,,",,"E- *  ",$ A$;,E+>"-:4A777:*:)!"BB,$,++; $;,B,!"C,:H+J$A;+ #EA$+J!A,I#,+&,$+,,"AJ$ ";H,:A;,BB,JA++,,#+G$,A$,, + +& " $"  +: A,  B" J  %I, "  #+,&,$ #   "# ; $,$ +B,#,  , " B, J  ,,A$,,++G$+JA$,,J"$","A"" +,$ " +#,O  B $,, "$,$$  +#:   H+J$;I,#+;$A+"A$;,B,!+J ;, +$  ##, " #,,  $   +,:   I$ J  #+G$;,,C$,$+G$CJA",#:-#,!A, JA;G,",,A#JAA,$I$E"$+&:$,$ $,,&""",,#,EB"A$/77/!+J &,#$"$,$$,&/77.: "A"!,A,II$E+G""+,+$!,

-:'A747:57:,!#,+,: H+J,3,%K#I, "+J"A;"-:.A477:*+#!,,$";3,, ++&",""##I: ,$I"!A,"I$"#> ",ABB"B,J"$#I+##"$=6A777B: ;@,H+J$JAE;!L,$,$+$B$&"+$"E;, ",!J,+#""$,$$: A++" "!+",A;,$,&+ABBJ#+,/77/, /77."$,$: $E++$,"#,!;,J $;$#,+,$EB,A$,,++,,,J#%" G;,!,+3,;";,B,B""$,$:  ,   B  I$  ,, B> "BB:   B, #J JA  *#3#,,+",BB#$JA+,;B,,, +&: '0: "#,+",+,",A",;,? * +>*;&"A,I,"'6,&/77.$,&+ABB" B,?,J#&"$$,,"A;/4+ ,,"'70A777B:"",,! * &"$,$.'"$#&/77/B,++P,+," 4'A.45B:O * & "  $,$  .' L, /77. B, ++P,  +, " 64A(/(B:

   

8'(098/774 *48''* * ;,"#%",M"#I!$,&+H";,=,,?-:'7(A.40:57@: /7:  , B, , +! ,,J"&!"+,D ",D" +$,CI#,:  * +)

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

   

8'(098/774 *68''* 5: H,#"A,:4/ :.  )!",;I">'C; /77.!",""#"$+,"A"##I+,"H+> J"#+,#+$,,""##I,!",!J+>;""##I: D##,"""##ID!B,,"!>II$$! ##,Q,"L"#+,!B,+;"A,,, &#, HI&! J  ,   +#,,, + " ;  ,,! # +;, ,P A&I, " $+  "##I =) /77' ": . +: '04O ) /77' ":/ +: 0(O ) '006 ":.&+:'9/O)'004":/+:'60O -''00/":.R)'00. +:''7O -''('04":.,$B:,:R)'00.+:(.O)'00.". +:(5O '00/":4&+:/64O -''694":.&R '007+:5'4O

-''.'('":/R '0(9+:679O -''/(":5"R  '0(6+:50.O -''/'4(R '0(9+:/'9@:B,"$,#,,"" ,,JAAGD",+,+B,!E",&D=B:-,%! D)%"&,&I"SMD!/>#$":!+:''/@!"AQ+,":)  B, F, J"$    +$" "    +$" ##!B,"#,,J,;""##I ,;,>II$$##,"+"J"," B,B,"A,B!","+&,",,#"-) $,, "$,#,= -'/.'6":4R)'009+:/'0@:

A+>!B,$,$+"","/5;#&/77.: ,B, "$$+,""##I/(,&/775!"#+, "+,$"$+$;+"+,$I: 4:) A,: 4/  )!, JA;ICJA.'"$#&/77/!A#+G J!,,#,+$III;!A&;+"++,,    "##I E   " #+,! ,, E $+,:) AI,+#!+&,$+,A$,"!E,,&"! HIJ,I#= -'/.'4":4&!'//66": 5!''0574":/,$B$@:  ++ "#, ++&  A+>! ">  J   C+"!   " %I#, " >I " ", ,  A& " $I#,,,,!",;I##,QB,C"J#, "$,#,  , +", , +,, = - '/9  569 ": '@:  "#,! A,: 4/ : '  ) ;I "+  ' C; /77. +" A ,: 4/  ) J#,  #"B,: ,# T " #+,U , #+$ + TU = #" ? #+#, " T I%MU + T%IUO , ? ++ " T "

   

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

   

8'(098/774 *08''* #3#,$IJA,$$= '0((+:6.5":4O -''/'40 ": 5 R   '0(9 +: /'9O  '0(4 +: 4' ": /O -'7(  /7/ ":.R '0(.+:'76O '0(.+:.99@: ,!C+""#,BB,JA+;IJA#+G "##IE"#+,;,,,#, ++,#,>"A )!J,P+,,&I, " $+  +$C":  ,   J A&;, " ++, ++P,!;",!##$I,#,B,;= -'7('(6 ":'&!'0.":/&O '0(4+:67.":/!659":.@: ! +, ; JA ,",  +#, " ,,! A#+G +; E #,  ,+ ;! + H#+  "A + "$, " ,$:   B, ! + JA, #+,#, ,#& + ,$#,   + " A,: 4/  )! J A + "#,, J A#+G ;,!  ##, Q   +  "$! "  $ , &C,; " + JA +, AJ,, " ,, " "  "$ &= - /9987'"/0L,/77/":/O -'7('((O '00/ +:/6'":5&@:  C+" F"#,  $,$ J " #>,> H+, JF #+G+"$"","+#,",,B"#, ,+;"F+"$,",$= - '45877" //L,/777":/@:B,!F,JF#+G"+!##, Q+""$!"$,&C,;"+J$,$ + FJ,, " ,, " "  "$ &! J  #+,#,F,+B,B= -'7('((O '00/+:/6'":5&@: '': A+>!B,",,J,A;,$$#,&C,B" +J,,B>"$,$+,":"#JA AI,EJ"A+"+,: +,!,""+#, " ,,   , $," ", + "A $ +JA , ++;/77/!+>""#+,+$$",: + ,!,"#,,J,;,"$, &C,;"+J,"">I#,",,H  A$,, J +I!   "  C+" = ,!; 

- '/'  /5.@:  A$,, " + ,$! H ", +$ +  C+",I+$"!E"BB$+#,",, JA;,,+G$!+"##,,$II I;,$+A,:4/ )= - /9987'"/0L,/77/":.@:  , $$#, ",  B,, #+, + ++$  +&,$ " A#+G$""A%&,"JA+,;+"BB $""#+,,,AJ,,,"A,",,+ +,! B " &$$B "A B#, , "  ,+ + 

   

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

   

8'(098/774 *''8''*   +)1  )(* *+*  (* +)

 234/4   5  644 4  78 '$ +9   /4 

': $;&:  /4

/: " , "  J    AII E; E   " #+,#,,"+,+$!,-:'747:57: .: AG"#,,J"&: 5: C,,++: 4: ,J+$",I,,: 6: B#  +, "  JF +;, B#  ,  +$, 3, "  "$ " .7 C ">  ,B, + + ##"$ "$  & B$"$ " !)%\V%BJ 6! 6775   ! , H#+:  "$  +, 3, +I$:  #$# ",? @ "J H,#,J"$,"$&,,+""$ ,,J$O &@ H+ + J #,B  ,# +; "#" ,, , "$O @ +,  I,   "  +$,,:)  #$#  ,, + , $$#, $#$$  ,, @ &@ , @ *"!  &B$"$"++,#,>JF ";"$;&:#$#"#,#G " +;! J , C,!  J  "$ ,,J$ , F;++ " J$,$H+$"$,=,:'./!'76,'7(@:  IBB>    --  +$",    S) S +B#"+$,3,,,B$H+,JFEFBBB$"$ "+IBB