opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/1440/2007

Genf · 2007-12-18 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

 

      !   "  ! #  $% % 

     

       &'()&*++(,&-..+&*++(,,/ ,     / 01"  - % -) 21"  *++(        !"#$  % "&'( #'!!")#'! !*'%  +' '    '         ) %% ,       !-./   '"#

    01/20344/,3053,  3/, 56  78(!&9'5.24 '(#""":! 3444 7 344;6   !#&#  3 " 3441  !"! &8 ! ) 

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

    01/20344/,1053, ""'!)6%#''!(')"#&8$"!)A'6  '+#&'?  ''@ #'# "& & ('6   '+#&'?  #'# "& & ?  &'' )!+#' & "&8'"'  ''"' "#!"'$'$$>!"!#')6 )&&!?)$&'"!'#&) ('@$#7544C&'#!'( ! )# !  '('# !&'#6  !8 ?) ' #(' ' $>##6@$?'7"'$!14C"$""6 '$"&' & #' ' '' "&'  "' ! &A8" !? " #>"'!''''!'@@)#D6  !  "&' & '  "I" B  )#  &!'  #"#!''#'A&"#!!'!)'!)>! E3.'A344/ ?)(''#!)!>''6  )' &  #'# ? )$&' "!'# & )   )' $"# ? !'!J!"' "I"!&!!"#!6 5;6 % #'#>!#7B>6

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

    01/20344/,53053,   4,/3 ,/ ,     /

%   5 1

56 #(A6 % 5 

36 B''6;6 '#""'!344@67+>!'6 G6 @"  &' !  ?N &(' @"  '  &#' I' !  !# !;4 B !8  '@' &8 ! A @#!# '!'!"!'P!' I' !#  A @#!# & ( &'  & ( #'? $ !' ! )'6 G3  6  &#' I' '  &8  & ! ' (?#"""-!&( !('I'B'7)(6  >@@8   , T  #!'   U  &@"!&#'I'''@#$&'?N7N@@@#!# !&>@@