opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/143/2007

Genf · 2007-02-08 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

               ! "#$

      

         %&'()%&**+

%,+'%&**) !!

 !    !   -.  ' # / 01  &**) 

  !!!!!!!!!!"#$%" &  ' (

(   ))  ) *   "+# ,-") ($%

   

*,./0*,--1 &,*21&  2

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

   

*,./0*,--1 &/*21&,.3 #4$,--/"!!!!!!!!!!#A%A:(A+( + :% 6  6$7 5 $ A: :+( ( #%   !!!!!!!!!! D @? 6  # #  (( (  # (  A#5(3?A:(6A:%(>A: 5(#$#$6(3,13 #,1$,--/"6((%(%+(%D56+( # A( A: @(( 6   J!!!!!!!!!!3    %(% B6A%A:%#(#:+(%#7++(#A%A: 6%#(  # % D :( # $%#&#(( # 7+3 :( (( #7 A  ??%%$#A(B6("$>#AJ!!!!!!!!!!3,H3 #6(:+A%#$(5#%(3,/3 2-E(,--/" >#%###:B6(3 $#(5%J!!!!!!!!!!%((+(9 3 ####3 >3)%"6#(?$(67#$%# G(((%(3 3

B$(3 #3

(>66(#%(%(%6#BA(+(9 & (=$7#%(%#U & +#:%((?%%#6(("($N&+A6# #B$6((55(666%U & (E(#6##B$6(+ U &  6 #: 6(@7 $+> %(>(&  5( $((U & ($N&+A6#:6(@7$+>(55 (666%U & (E(#6#:6(@7$+>U &  6(( 55( 6  $%# ((( #  !!!!!!!!!!%6#(&B66#:%$(%"# :#%A((#:55(%#(($(UAU & (%(%E(66>(($(66%6+ U &J(((>+(??((3,03 J!!!!!!!!!!#66(#(#,,6($>,--/3

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

5" :?( # $6$(#+ 66((A:+(%(% %+A%$$(#:#("J!!!!!!!!!!#A%A(G6# (( 6%((  :6( (@%6(A 5B 6(% ((

   

*,./0*,--1 &4*21& (5A$(A6$A:6(#A(#(( ((555(#B+(%:55(666(55( 666(#B+(3E(#:6(#B%%$(+ B$" #?6@" B((" 6(@7 6+ (3  ( %+% D C:0.H53,-3($%A:((($(:%((6#A%#(( # :%   ( %% + #B $6( ( #B  6(( >6 6  ( ( 6%(( (($( $ # A 65(3   +% A  66( # $%#& #:#$ :% D @( # 0:H-- 53 &  A  66@ # E( #: 6(  (($( #&(6I(+?%#67:#(( 6(( +(  %(% #(" $ A : 6%5%(" @N  5(  #(" #55%  %(#:6(:(6 ($%((:(6((((>(%55(3

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

244CV.063.2/#3.>;3 13 ( 8(3H/(/-;3 H3  (? 6(   A( # +   (($( #( > 6  (#(I(6@?(((%6(6:>?(# 3 /3 :&$#%?$(#6((#:#(#  $ T   #( : $  6  @? 853 (323,  ;3  :"  :( 6 ((% A  (($( $%+%A#:#(6@?6 #((A:$>#7D:$##:($(73 03 #:#("#:(323,(3> ":>?(# 6#@?E(#$I$6((A:#$#8(3,C  ;3 " :?( #  #(" :(3 .2 3,   #A A

   

*,./0*,--1 &22*21& : 6#  @?  E( # (($( # % # G(7$ #  $((%6#(3 C3 :(3.,32 6%A6((6@?6: >?( #  #+( I( 55" 666% ( %$A3 :55(%#(I(#%$(%#$%(@#(5A3 43 5$%$( D :(3 H0 3 1  "  $%#& #  + D :  # A( $%#  A  # A( (+ D  %$%((D:66(#(53B$6(#( #6@?#:6((($63 2-3 6(((55A:6(> #:(((D(%$(A6G@A8 J2,C2/H #3H*L

,---WV2.,63,C2#3,>;3  A( #  (7 666% :66%  5( # >%%5 #?(  (@%6(A # :66( #   6("  (( $6(#AAG(%?##>((@%6(A8 J2,021H/ #3 H;3  (7 666% 7+  66 # (7 $%#B (  5#+A(#:#($%#9A:#($%#( $(%(>"(7666%#6((:(%?$(8 J2,H 44#31L

,---V2.,63,C,#3,;3

:67":($%#$A#B(7%(($63 (#" (7#:%$(%#$#(?B3  (766((E((>%%5#$A" #   (" #55%( 5$ (* $%(@# # (($( 55 ( 666%((?#$6(6$>(($#8 J2,0 21/#3HL

,--1V,0,63222#3.323,;3 :($% 66 A  (7 %$A # 6(( $6 B #6%#D>(E((>%%5#(($(3):# ( (($( +?> 6$( #:+  >( @@%  %(( >$( $ $@% A  (" :% : 6 #(  $>$( # 5 # (($( 6 %B3 6#(" $I$ # 6((E(#+(I(6@?6:A::B( 6 #:( $%(@# # (($(  D ((  $ 6 # $%(@# 6 %$A(AE(#$(6(>?##66# 66((%8 J2-412;3

   

*,./0*,--1 &2,*21& 223 :67"("(($(>(#%%?##(## $$#%A(3:#$6$A:B(#(($(#(E( ($%+%96#:6(@7$+>#:6(3 66F(6#(D(#66(#J!!!!!!!!!!A( 6%% 6 :($% &  6(@7 $+> & :( 6  +(? A: 6(  $> # 6$ ># 6A"   ? ($"  (F(#:((+("6(@76(66(#(A 5( 6 I( #$$?%3  ( ( %((  (  %(#+>((3 #(#I(%(%3 ( D  %( #: 6("  E( ("   ($( # J!!!!!!!!!!"#J3C:0.H3,-DJ32,:H./3&3(((# 6>$($$@%A6A6(%(3  6("%(#:(6((%(%($6((##( +3   J!!!!!!!!!!  %?$( 5( $A A" #   # ("6(#A(#((55(3 6("($%A: ((($(:%((6#A%#((#:%(A(# $6( (  6(( >6 6  ( ( 6%(( (($( $#A65(3

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

   

*,./0*,--1 &2.*21& 6>>$(%(%%%":(%I(#6(((%(%%??%(%( 6$6((%(%#66>%$(A#5(#%6(3 6("A###(#:$(($%((%3 "  :" :%(>$( # #+ $(  20 $,--13   ( #7  6@  ( #  6 + ((# : #  6%#65((3

%?#B#%(A6%7#("(#$3:# 6%#"$(%#5#:B6(($D@?#:($%3 

   

*,./0*,--1 &21*21& !  3 2  !    !  

# 450 .. 6  7     8 $,(& 9:  0 .

23 %+>3 # 0

,3 :#$( (   #% # 6 :($%  #( #, E( ( 2, +$>,--13 .3 #$ :($% D 6#  @?  5 # :(+( #( 6(A%A   V%((55%3 13 (5#:B6("D@(#J32:,--3&D@?#:($%3 H3 (A6%#(?((3 /3 5$  6( #  A= 6+( 5$  (  6%( I( #  #% # .-  5%#% # ")@XN@5A /" /--1   "  ( B$63  #%  6( I( 6?%3  $%$ #(9 ; #A B($(A#%(#%>((6##% ((A%L >; B6 6 A $(5  ($ 6+ #$# (( ( #%L ; 6(  ?(   #  6%((3)  $%$  (( 6  ( %%$( %$%%  (( ; >; ( ; &#"  >5%#%#66($(7A= #+#%+>3$%$#$($G # 6+" A ( A6?55