opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/1286/2007

Genf · 2007-11-20 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

               ! " #$   $

     

       %&'(&%)**+ ,%&)-.%)**+ !, ,  , ! !  ! / ) $ &' 01/ )**+      !"#$%&'() *!)   +!),)( -      (()

)( ..     + -- /      ( 0#$  ) !

    12#"21344$ /3134/

    12#"21344$ /"134/ ! 2, 25    6 /'(78  (()9 !  2#:;)) ( + ()  )(* !   )( '( (2(')=(2#;$"4? 344"( ( (*  @A7*2#B() '( '( ( 3+$;4  &B   +(&  6 /'(78 E!)= ) B') (E9!)! D-  )    E!)= )B') (EF!?(!243$)=(3444' A E!)= )B') (E6(''()2H*=(3444(  (! )())95 "5   AE!)= )B') (EF!?(!3$)=( :!=(3444(()!))D)(I)& >))(70'! >5 >+33*=(3444!)! *('B '( ''5()'I)(*(!('B ) )())  ! A+   ( ( '( ))  (()  =   3; *=( 3442  (!)  )5+!*)  ))(E!)= )B') (E H !=( 3442 '(  !?( A  E!)= ) B') (E 6(''()  H !=( 3442  ( 9 F   !)! ))! >  ( )(' (/!')+&&(*)A'') ()!(DG) (!!>! () ))?( =  '(!)  () >+ )95 H5 32?* (3443(()!'!'(7+..    + -- /   6 /'(78+ 9'())  +(/ * )!)) A +)( + ()5  D') >+ !))  ')!)) )(*  '  + ) ; )=( 34445 +(/  )   (() !))   -- - ('( ) '( J K   + -- -6 /'(78+( )95 $5 ((''():  )!((  6')B(D9  *))B( >!B ((EE)/!' D+!'())) ')/(')  * )( (! ()  ) /!' D    >  ))')/(!) )!)&!'(()B( > * )5- I(=(> ?))8))')/B0)!() 2#;#))')/  ) 'B&'( (() 2##:))')/()B('  ) '&D*()))  &)(!)!(('()( +))'(7=( )(*) !2#$;5 ! )())))))+ ')!)(* ))' ;)=( 3444+) *)!+ )('( (A%4L5;5   (''() '( +(/ * )! )!  " ?  3443  (  !()>)() )B( >*')B(D) *))&B!) +( ()B( >B( >) 0'!   (  )(* 5 245 -  (5     *    '&   E!)= ) B') (E  (()  '(!)) '  ))   (' A+ )+!))')(0'!!()!*7())) + &&!()) '0B )(>6(''()!  )(!  (3H ')=(344"95

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