opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/121/2004

Genf · 2004-03-09 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (1 Absätze)

E. 7 4 4!/!! !!;   !4! & <2  &!G 4  !  /4 4&  !!  4   !% 4< =  4<   22  ! 4<33!  !5  4  !;   ! !D .3+ ! IJ 0+   /2 4 !5 4 2  !! 25! / 9G 4  4</%+

(+  ! 3242   /! G22 4 4! 4  ! 4 J 5 (888 . : = #78+"0  2  &!G  " 9&! (887; O 4

' F)*'

 5 4!3!! 4  4 ! 4  !+   4</% 4  3! 2G! /  4!/!!  &!G 9D< 7" 42 5 (88(;  2G4  /!!/  D  9G 4  ! < / $ /4  !42!  4!3!! 4 4!  4 <2 /2! $  4 42 ! 4  42!! !!G! . E "(*  FJ*; !4+ "; "("  #7J; !4+ "5 N 3+ 2G  4!/!! !!; + #(+ " 4   +  /2 !!G  / 2D 1 !2 $   !% 4 4!/!! 2G  4 %G   < &!!  &!&  &!G 9D< 7" 42 5 (88(+ 7+ 92 4  42!  3  2G1;    &5 .+ #F 4  ! 3242  < &!!  &!& .!'/%  =N = #7"+"80  &!G  7"+"(+8(+ F+

 & 4  9!/4 3242 ! &! 4<//!D  4!/!! 2G  &!G   4 3! /! . E "(*  FJ* ? "("  7#J0+  &!  < 4<//!D  %G 4  !  4 %G   < &!!  &!& .!'/%     =0  D< &!G 9D< 7" 42 5 (888; /!D  !!     4 <2 (888+

& D !  $  D<!4!D   4  4!% 2!;  !! "666   /   !! /!D D   4 "6 5 (88" /   42!! 4 !! (888; 4 (# / 5 (88"  D<   < /4 4&  9!4!! 4 2+ I+

  4 3!   = /2&H! $  ! (I  /24 14!! 4 1! @/  4 /! 4< !&!2 !& !42/4  4 4!3!! 4 5 4 &@; !! 24!G2 :

@=! <2    !&!2 !42/4  !  5 4 &  5!; 4/!  /2!4 4   / <!2 3! ;  4!3!! 45 4 $  G  4 /3!  4<25! ;  !  ;

$  4!/!!  $  ! 4<  4 &; $  2/!! & 4 & 4 <1/!!   $ <!&!4!2 4 <2; D! O  &!! !5 4 G!;  ! !  ' K   &   3!1   5  !! /  42  4    4 <!&!2  4  4 G  9D< 425 4  /! /2!4 4!! 4 !!@+

!! 3'! ! D <2 !  2  !&!2 !42/4; ! D  5 4 & ! 5!  4!3!! 45  ! 4< G  4 /3!  4<25! ; / 1 /+   42 D< G  4<25!   33! / $ 9!3!  /24 14!! <! <! /!D

' I)*'

/ 4 4!3!! 45 4 &+  9!/4  3! 2 D  5 K  4 & 4!& &! 5!  4!3!! 45 / D  ! & //!!+ <+ (I  =   4!/!! 4<1/! D  4! / K !/22 4 !% 1!&+  // 4 G  ! / . E +P+ 4 8I+8F+"6#(;

E 4 "J+8(+"6#60+   /! $ %  !;  !G!3! D   2 !D 4 <!&!2 4 </! 4! &! 22 34   4!3!2+

!! 41 !2 D! 42!4 4 !D!4  !22 ! D! /!& 4 4 '4$ 4  !D!4!   &! / //!D <+ (I

 = . E

++ 4 8(+8#+"6*# !  "6*6 /+ I"0+  K   !22 H  D! 1! 4/! 4  5 2  /% &  ! !4!&!4 < / !422    !! 4! & '! 4  D <+ (I  = < / //!5 . E 4 "J+8(+"6#60+  K   3 4 !%G 4< /! /!  4 ! 4 <!&!2 4< / !42/4 < /  G  // $ O  4!3!! 4 5 4 &; K  <!  2  <  / 4 !%; 4  D <+ (I  <//!D /  / . 3+  "6#" /+ 7780+

  4  9!/4  !2 D  ! 4  4</%  9!3!! / <//!! 4  24 14!!+ < /;  G  4 ! ! < /  / 2D 4 4!3!! 5 4 5 4 &;  4< /;    %&

 ;  /G 4< ! !4!&!4 1/!2   !22   !3 1/!2 $ 41 /!  ! !4!&!4   K  !G 1/!2 $ &  /  !    G  4<25!   !; ! !D   G  4 ! !+   !  5; !  !%G 4 </! < G2+

< 4 $

D  !  //!D2  24 14!! /  3!4!! 4 +

< 2G  $

D  !  !; 4   4 & 42 !  & /M 4 </! @C----------@; /! 22 /    /% $  3!4!!  D! < !  K  !%G; !  K  5 D '!+ < $ 9 ! D   ! D  41 /! ! 12 4 3M 2/2+

  42 4 !2 3!  !  ! 4  /!+  !  5 /  !  !3 /  9G 4  !+ < /; !  ! !   4 & 42 !  4   4 /! // GG2 4 </! . E ++,+ 4 "*+8#+"6#*N

E 4 (*+8(+"6#IN

E 4 "8+86+"6#(!  "6#7+("0+ =! 4  !

' J)*'

 ! !2 /   !! 3! 4 <//2!! 4 &   !42!;  <! /!D   D< //!D  24 14!! 4< /;  D< !  & 4 41 !&!2 4!! 4  4< /+

 !;    4 !;   42!! 4   2+

 D  /& 4  2/!; /  ; 4 42!! 423!!!&; ! 5 $  !;  D<$ 423 4 /&  4& !3!  42!! 423!!!&   5 4 /2 K+

QQQQQ

' *)*'

  * 4 * , ,*,   ,  

   70 

"+ 2   &5+  70

(+ <4 + 7+  2D   42!! 4 (# / 5 (88"   42!! <H  /2 /  !! (888+ F+ ! D  /24  G!+

I+ 3   /! 4  D< /& 3     /2 K 4  42! 4 78 9 4%  !3!! / /!  42 42  !5 3242 4 ; =R!S3D! J; J88F  ;  ! 1 /!+  42!  / K /G2+  2 ! 4! : 0 !4!D 1  D< 42!!   42! 5!  !  / 4  42!! D2N 50 1/ / D !3 ! !  /&! 4 4   42!!N 0 /  !G   4  /2+ =!  2 !  ! /  ! 22  2 22   0 50  0 !'4;  !5 3242 4   / /   !%    D<! 4& 42 !&5+  2 ! 4  !   H 4 /&; D!  9!; !! D  42!! D2  <&// 4 D   22 1/24!2   .+ "7(; "8J  "8# 0+

 G33! : !

 =

 2!4 : 5 =

 /! 3  4 /2 K  !3!2 1 /! !! D<$ <33! 3242 4  ! /  G33

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

              ! 

         "#$#%"&''#(&() *"#&#"&''$  +*  * , ,*,   ,     -  &''$ &.  / 

  

0 1111111111

20      ,* , )( (3   4 * ,   * ,* *   ,* 546  ! ! "# $ %&

 

' ()*'

, 4 *

"+,! ---------- .!'/%  0  1/!2  3!4!! 4 " 5 "66*  78 9! (88"   ! ! !& :  ! !4!&!4 ---------- 4 " 5 "66*  7" 42 5 "66*;   3  4 ---------- ? ---------- @A----------@ 4 " 9&! "66#  7" 42 5 (888; /!  ! !4!&!4 ---------- 24 @A----------@ 4 " 9&! (88"  78 9! (88"+

 /%;    22  1/!2  !22  ! 4!&!4   ! ! @----------B C----------@; 4/!  " 9&! "666 9D<$  9+ (+  42!! 4 (# 9! (88";

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

' 7)*'

4<//!D  !+  4 4 D  !&!2 4 " 5 "66*  78 9! (88" /  3!4!! ! !422    !&!2 !+ *+

 " L (887;  ! 4  4!3!! 4  ! G&!  <G!! 94!!!;    22 322  & !5  4  !+

#+  ! 4 7 / 5 (887;  !5 4 2 < 42 $  ! 3! 4 &! !  2G! 4  &! 22 +

 2! 4 "* 42 5 (887  ! 2/4 D<!  1 D   /24 4!! 4 1!  2 "66*  "66# 4&! K /!  !42!; ! D<! <G!  < 4< /24 14!!  ! 4   4 & //2 ! !2 4 <!&!2 4 @C----------@+  /4  G ! !& $ <+ (I  =    9 4 +  !4!D &! !3!2 41 1! 423!!!&  9! (887 1D   < / 3! //!!+ 6+  ! 4 * 9&! (88F;    &! M  42!! 423!!!& 42 4 7 9!  "# 9! (887 12 $  /4 4  !  %&   4<4G+  /4  G !+ "8+

/% &! 42 /! 4  /4 $  !  6 9&! (88F;  !5  !4!D2 1 /! &! G42   $ 9G+

,   *

"+  ! G&!  <G!! 94!!! . N

(8I0  22 4!3!2   !!2 4%  " L (887  !5  4  !+ 3 2  $ <! 7 !2 7 4 4!/!! !!;   !4! & <2  &!G 4  !  /4 4&  !!  4   !% 4< =  4<   22  ! 4<33!  !5  4  !;   ! !D .3+ ! IJ 0+   /2 4 !5 4 2  !! 25! / 9G 4  4</%+

(+  ! 3242   /! G22 4 4! 4  ! 4 J 5 (888 . : = #78+"0  2  &!G  " 9&! (887; O 4

' F)*'

 5 4!3!! 4  4 ! 4  !+   4</% 4  3! 2G! /  4!/!!  &!G 9D< 7" 42 5 (88(;  2G4  /!!/  D  9G 4  ! < / $ /4  !42!  4!3!! 4 4!  4 <2 /2! $  4 42 ! 4  42!! !!G! . E "(*  FJ*; !4+ "; "("  #7J; !4+ "5 N 3+ 2G  4!/!! !!; + #(+ " 4   +  /2 !!G  / 2D 1 !2 $   !% 4 4!/!! 2G  4 %G   < &!!  &!&  &!G 9D< 7" 42 5 (88(+ 7+ 92 4  42!  3  2G1;    &5 .+ #F 4  ! 3242  < &!!  &!& .!'/%  =N = #7"+"80  &!G  7"+"(+8(+ F+

 & 4  9!/4 3242 ! &! 4<//!D  4!/!! 2G  &!G   4 3! /! . E "(*  FJ* ? "("  7#J0+  &!  < 4<//!D  %G 4  !  4 %G   < &!!  &!& .!'/%     =0  D< &!G 9D< 7" 42 5 (888; /!D  !!     4 <2 (888+

& D !  $  D<!4!D   4  4!% 2!;  !! "666   /   !! /!D D   4 "6 5 (88" /   42!! 4 !! (888; 4 (# / 5 (88"  D<   < /4 4&  9!4!! 4 2+ I+

  4 3!   = /2&H! $  ! (I  /24 14!! 4 1! @/  4 /! 4< !&!2 !& !42/4  4 4!3!! 4 5 4 &@; !! 24!G2 :

@=! <2    !&!2 !42/4  !  5 4 &  5!; 4/!  /2!4 4   / <!2 3! ;  4!3!! 45 4 $  G  4 /3!  4<25! ;  !  ;

$  4!/!!  $  ! 4<  4 &; $  2/!! & 4 & 4 <1/!!   $ <!&!4!2 4 <2; D! O  &!! !5 4 G!;  ! !  ' K   &   3!1   5  !! /  42  4    4 <!&!2  4  4 G  9D< 425 4  /! /2!4 4!! 4 !!@+

!! 3'! ! D <2 !  2  !&!2 !42/4; ! D  5 4 & ! 5!  4!3!! 45  ! 4< G  4 /3!  4<25! ; / 1 /+   42 D< G  4<25!   33! / $ 9!3!  /24 14!! <! <! /!D

' I)*'

/ 4 4!3!! 45 4 &+  9!/4  3! 2 D  5 K  4 & 4!& &! 5!  4!3!! 45 / D  ! & //!!+ <+ (I  =   4!/!! 4<1/! D  4! / K !/22 4 !% 1!&+  // 4 G  ! / . E +P+ 4 8I+8F+"6#(;

E 4 "J+8(+"6#60+   /! $ %  !;  !G!3! D   2 !D 4 <!&!2 4 </! 4! &! 22 34   4!3!2+

!! 41 !2 D! 42!4 4 !D!4  !22 ! D! /!& 4 4 '4$ 4  !D!4!   &! / //!D <+ (I

 = . E

++ 4 8(+8#+"6*# !  "6*6 /+ I"0+  K   !22 H  D! 1! 4/! 4  5 2  /% &  ! !4!&!4 < / !422    !! 4! & '! 4  D <+ (I  = < / //!5 . E 4 "J+8(+"6#60+  K   3 4 !%G 4< /! /!  4 ! 4 <!&!2 4< / !42/4 < /  G  // $ O  4!3!! 4 5 4 &; K  <!  2  <  / 4 !%; 4  D <+ (I  <//!D /  / . 3+  "6#" /+ 7780+

  4  9!/4  !2 D  ! 4  4</%  9!3!! / <//!! 4  24 14!!+ < /;  G  4 ! ! < /  / 2D 4 4!3!! 5 4 5 4 &;  4< /;    %&

 ;  /G 4< ! !4!&!4 1/!2   !22   !3 1/!2 $ 41 /!  ! !4!&!4   K  !G 1/!2 $ &  /  !    G  4<25!   !; ! !D   G  4 ! !+   !  5; !  !%G 4 </! < G2+

< 4 $

D  !  //!D2  24 14!! /  3!4!! 4 +

< 2G  $

D  !  !; 4   4 & 42 !  & /M 4 </! @C----------@; /! 22 /    /% $  3!4!!  D! < !  K  !%G; !  K  5 D '!+ < $ 9 ! D   ! D  41 /! ! 12 4 3M 2/2+

  42 4 !2 3!  !  ! 4  /!+  !  5 /  !  !3 /  9G 4  !+ < /; !  ! !   4 & 42 !  4   4 /! // GG2 4 </! . E ++,+ 4 "*+8#+"6#*N

E 4 (*+8(+"6#IN

E 4 "8+86+"6#(!  "6#7+("0+ =! 4  !

' J)*'

 ! !2 /   !! 3! 4 <//2!! 4 &   !42!;  <! /!D   D< //!D  24 14!! 4< /;  D< !  & 4 41 !&!2 4!! 4  4< /+

 !;    4 !;   42!! 4   2+

 D  /& 4  2/!; /  ; 4 42!! 423!!!&; ! 5 $  !;  D<$ 423 4 /&  4& !3!  42!! 423!!!&   5 4 /2 K+

QQQQQ

' *)*'

  * 4 * , ,*,   ,  

   70 

"+ 2   &5+  70

(+ <4 + 7+  2D   42!! 4 (# / 5 (88"   42!! <H  /2 /  !! (888+ F+ ! D  /24  G!+

I+ 3   /! 4  D< /& 3     /2 K 4  42! 4 78 9 4%  !3!! / /!  42 42  !5 3242 4 ; =R!S3D! J; J88F  ;  ! 1 /!+  42!  / K /G2+  2 ! 4! : 0 !4!D 1  D< 42!!   42! 5!  !  / 4  42!! D2N 50 1/ / D !3 ! !  /&! 4 4   42!!N 0 /  !G   4  /2+ =!  2 !  ! /  ! 22  2 22   0 50  0 !'4;  !5 3242 4   / /   !%    D<! 4& 42 !&5+  2 ! 4  !   H 4 /&; D!  9!; !! D  42!! D2  <&// 4 D   22 1/24!2   .+ "7(; "8J  "8# 0+

 G33! : !

 =

 2!4 : 5 =

 /! 3  4 /2 K  !3!2 1 /! !! D<$ <33! 3242 4  ! /  G33