opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/1168/2007

Genf · 2007-10-25 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (1 Absätze)

E. 26 ' (!*' !'"@)''(" ?'!7-" C233>'0-?')23346 06 &!'(&'(!!(!''6 >6 '!'"@A)''("?'!7 -" C233>'-4 (C2334') ("D(A4E' "'(6 46 '!'"@A)''("-*433@6A(( &'( &'(A"&6 16 @ ! &'(  ;G!! &)( @   ( !' &"( " '"!'03?7'(@ '('&7 C'!@""'! -333  

 -> @"( 'K'( !.2!'!@""'!!

C'!@""'!-.?2334# $%J!" (;!  !(@(B&)(&(!':'( '( ''('J!(D('"' C'!@""'!&')&('!&') "! (;'K (!*'( !>2 $6'&"(" (!&7   &   '( );"  B  &) )( D( ?(A!*)6   ':@@7    '$$  '"(8    V'  V  ' "('5?(8  ' `` ``   & @&"('D(((@"'K&'(';GA!G@@ @""'! '' &)"&'!:@@!

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

              

  

     

       !""#

$$ %!""& ''

() '*+), , , ( )', * -.   !# /0/.  !""&    0  !"  #$% &''( ') "! ( !!*"('+(    '(

0/    ,'!'-. 

 ("

    /0010/2334 52/2-5 , 1*

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

    /0010/2334 50/2-5 '('( !' "    !)(  &('( )'( ';6  (@ '( " '!  2- &(C 233> "('C! &' !    I:A :'B#$%?(A (( &' &" '(;!*"('( '("!G'""('(A!GI' (!! &'(C!') !'&' ()(" &@!!6  ('(( " '! &" "('( ?:" '(@''( '  &!(6!!" &)'(&");GA&!G '&' ("(')'! &)'(   '((';!G'"&'(& ' ()("'!( ':"6 96 -4 (C233>!' '"&;G!!'('(!G"('('"  0'H( 233> '; !!  -4 &(C 233> "('( "; !  " 5 ! ! "( K " &' !G'" G"('( &! &'(C! ')  ' '!'6  ((@ !G'" &'(  ' ()(" ! - ?') 2334  &" " &' !   !G(" ?'!7 &'(   D()"" C233>6)' IG!GB')'(&'& !'&)'( !* '&' ("  !G'" A &  '  &@ ( &'('(  C!:'( I I'(&!&!''&("A"('('("6 -36 '(0" C233>!G'"'';"&&(;'(A!'"   !G'  ((  ( ')(  !G(" ?'!7 ' 03)C 233>6  ((  ' ! ' !! (" ! &'': A !G''  )!!'!GIB&(I7N!&('( )'( ') !' @  '&&(  (')'! ( ' '"  K&!'  ( :""'! G'' #  %6 --6 '(-F?')2334!G&!B'"!"!'&&((')'!') @@( ' 0- ' 2334 '!!":'(;G! G"('( &'   G@@ A !G'"  ' ()("''&("A"('('("6 -26 &"(" &'    ') '( !G'" ' )(" !'   '(  -9?')2334A&!)(!G("?'!77!; "('('("G"('(&'('C!" ! @'(!6  &" '!($," (('!'I'('!''&&( '("." C233.6 !! !G'"@@'(!!C'C'A(  (B& " '; ) ! -. ' 233> '&7 ') !)" ')   !!7:  &(  @@':  03 A >3 O:6  ! "('( '&&' ! !''!;!G'"@@'(&'!C'!:'&'')'(6 (( ':(  ! "  ' (  (C! ('(; ( ":""'(@  ' I ') ";!!'!' I' &'(I"(':"0A-  '(I &(" 45- ':!'( 45-  ''! !C' "(( :"('!I '!45-A(';";!!B ' !' - ( ')  'C!(  "@!K ' I!!" ( ( B@ (

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

    /0010/2334 5F/2-5  @!''&!@"  !''(;!'"@( '"A!)('(-0*019@6>4') ("D(A4EA &(!''(B23'23316 246 ' " ( '("  1? 2331!'"@'@'(');G!!')'(& ''      !G'"6 !  ('(; ! ' C('(' &'(I(I '!&'(* '&' ("&IB;( * ( (" @@'( K&!('C! ' ! ' *  !'( &@!6'@@'('(A' (  !'( -99>  (C!  '( &B I; ('(  "6 ' '!! !  !'( &@! '&7  !*(& = A 7) ')'( "C(" ! 1 @") 2331 ( ! ')'( "(" &" "" G &"5(': 'B'( !5D  " '   " C 2334 "?A6 @(" &'  "!"( !' "@'&("'&" "(  !6 216  ' ' "(;" &'   20 ? 2331; ! !   !' "@ G' &'   '&' ("  :' '   '&' ("  (')'! '!"(K "''(' ()("' &('C!6!'!!7:')@'(! " '&':"&'('!!!"!' '&('( J!!' '; !!'C'(&(! D( & I"6  @'(; !*  '( (";    "''&('( *&'( ( !' "('(;G! G"('( ?;G'! &'    &(')'!' &('C!'  6 2.6 '  &'(&!!*((!03)C23316  ((  ' ! ' ' K&!;"; ! (': "C("  @") '&7  !' '=(? )'(('*')!233.6 (('!!'(C&(!'(&&"A6*':'(' ()(" :( (   (  ' I  I'( &" "( ");" ! ' K&!;";*!!')'("("?:"''&("A"('('("&'"  '!'N!!&!;'( )!'&('FI'( '!D;*!!@'!!'('!(!&(6 &"('(!'"@'&'&'('(;!*'"'('"A ((&' )&@!!&;7!*'H(233>! " 5 ! &" '!(  !' '(7 "('( ')" A !'  !; ! '&'(&' ()("('!(; *(;*@") 2331;!(':'"C("6'"@'&("'  !6 2F6 ' -2')!233.!'"@' ;"' C'! "' A'' &!'&! G'' !'()'&!'('(@ =  & !!'@@"('&!*K&!('( (( "("';!'"&A!''*@@= -4

    /0010/2334 59/2-5 )C 2332 !'() A  ''  ( ! 'K B !'() ( ! (&'( !7(!'&&(!*'' 6 296  C'! "'' ;"(':  (''(!' ''"(":'"A?:6  , ('*

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

    /0010/2334 5-0/2-5 C%&(  !(:' ;*!!(*(!A(&!' &"(&7 (!'()'(8                                   !       " #   $  

    %      & '    ( ) 

   * +   ,% -     *,%, (    &        &   .) &          /   0*      

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

    /0010/2334 5-1/2-5 % !G'?(;!*'(61- *(&'(&"'(@# @6'(69.(9F  % ! &'( &)'( "@  ": @@"(6 ! ! ( &' K&! !C!&");!*'"&(D('&&!"A((A ) &@!! '  ' ()(" &'( A ' &(  '! A  ''  ( A  '&(( # @6   = S >FJ   = S 01 ] ^U 2/-990 &614%6  ( ":' !   &(  !G&7 ; !G'" ' ( '( C!:'( ('( !!  "& ' "!'  '&('(A!G ("'(('K&&( "''&('(&@!!@@(&'!G (((A&@(' '&' (" (')'!' '&' ("(')'!"!!&@@ ((L I''&("&! @' !'C'C' I&@!!@@"(6 % C'! @""'! '   &" ";GA !' @@"  G I':(  &@; &( A !G'"    ': 5 ' G( C ! ': C &' !G'B'( (; ( "('( 5  (('( A &@(  '&' ("(')'!;GK(&!''&@' (!!!@'(& )  &('( G ( (!!;G ( G)'!(" G' &' & @@(   ! ':6 !; C""@ '( * ''  *(" ?'!7  ''!'*' (!!' & -1F/233. 606262%6@'(;!*'"& A M("  ( A  (" ?'!7 (  '  D ")"( ':'C!&"(( ('('&)" '! ( ( &'C! !7) &!(M( !';(  !  &"(( &)'( A'(# $&C!"-1?!!(233.> -1F/233. 606260%6 -26 '% !G&7 ')'(GK'!G'"G( @"A!GC!:'(" ! ': &") &' !G'(6 1-   ! )(  "( G! B '  ( ?;GA;!! '(   '&' ("  (')'! ! ! ( G''  )6 C%GK(  G  '&' ("  (')'! && G'C !*( (  @'( * " '!6 ' (L I  "  &" " &' !' ?&  ( A &(  ?:(  !*"('(  '(" ( A ; ';!!  ( &;!!' ()("!*'"( '&'C!(')'!!6(!"" '! (((  "!"( (! & "(;! (')'K  &(   ''C!(K:!*'"# $-2421- 6>J--4-0> 6 2J-->0-> 60 J-34-4F 6-%6 "" '!&((( :""'!('&&" '(C? () '# $ &C!"1'2330 .12/32%6

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`)!&X I( >7 "(  -9F> &6 -01J U )W'!(:5  I(&@!:27"(&62.F I64%6 -06 '%  !G&7  !   "  ('('( ' &" "  '(  2'H(233>"&A;(';!'"@!';! ' @@'( G  &'(I ( G I  '! A !G: G  '&' ("  (')'! (7 G " "("6  !';(  ');!!)(:'(/(I"'&"('(" ''@"''&(;&C!!G '&' ("(')'!!'::""@ '(!G&!; G"('(&'''&("A!''("(!'&!' GK&(6 C%''&&(2-&(C233>! I:' K&"(7  ((;!G"('('("!G'""('( &'(C!') !' &   ' ()(" &@!!6  ('(( " '! "('(     ')   "!('( ?:" '(@''( '  &!(6 G '&' ("  (')'! (7"('( "&)&'((6 %    &" '!( $,  "  ( (  '!' I'('!' @"'(." C233>!'&" CK (C! ('(; ( ":""'(@  ' I #('(  &'(I "(':" '(I &(" ''! !C' "(( :"('! ( I  '!%6  ('((&IB(I"'&("" '( C"A'(5@!''( (  !'K'(  !' )'( D( (@" ! &( G ( "('( )':'C!6 G '&' ("  (')'! "('( (7 ' ! "('( ! !   &"'("  "   !G'" &)'(   &)  ' ()(" ' 6 '% ) &7 " '!@ ( ('(;!!GC! "  !(" !G'" &"(   '&' ("  (')'! (7 ' !' &@' !'('( G"('( &' @@'( ('C!" & ') ')  ((  ((  '&' (" "('("@()D!('C!':""'!&(('((G& (')'!'' ()("'!6@6'":'!(&" ";*P' (!!(Q !G' ()("  ' ; !G"('(  '("  !G'" "('( @@'( ('C!" &;G! G( "'(( '  '( &@6 !' ( G'('( &!)'; !' "@"@7' 0'H(233>-4 (C233>>(2> @")2334(-3?2334A')" 5 !;G(?'' "("&()"A!'& "6 % &('C);G':'(!G"('('("!G'"!G"('( @@'( ('C!"  )(:" ?;GA !GK&( @@ (" &' ! @6 '23346 &'( (('(!"('(&C!(; &((!G"('(' I(&!:(!G '&' ("(')'! &  !G' ()("  ' '-4 (C2334  !' C' G  '&' ("  (')'! (7 ! !   @"( A !G'&&" '(" '!  (  # '&' (" (('! ' ! "(  ' 4@602&'? ;G(&'!(:K6 -46 @!'!! (!)(*("D('(6 '  ; ":(! ('( '( !!'((! '(( !*(" 7:! ! (  !*" I"'   !' "'  "!('(  ('( *'' 8 !!5 (" I>''&7!(N!*'' -'!6- %6'  ((((@&'&( !'  !';!! ( 7 ! ": )(  !*'(6 -33 '!6 -   &' ! '(6-32 6"C(*C!:'((&'!*(&!!'( "'  #'(6 -32 '!6 - %J!;!?!*K" ('"(""("* ' @K"&'!*&'()(*(A!!")"(' B * ')(( ":! ! "C( (    &' !' ! K&'( ?#'(6-32'!62 %6*("D('(54E!*'#'(6-3> '!6- %5(HA&'(?)'( !N!"C('  %6

    /0010/2334 523/2-5 !*&7 !'*' "*(&!!!'"@&!)( &('(*'' 6! )(&''!!GC);7!'( '&&(@6A!'5'2334!'"@')'(; !G'"G"('(@@ ()(&! '&'C!GK "('  ' 0- ' 2334 ! ("D( '(  ! (" ?'!7 ( ' " 7 ! - ' 23346 G':'(("?'!7-')!'0-?!!(2334!("D( '( (  7 ! !'  "&M(  !' '  ?(  ! 21&(C2334 !!5 )'!'((&!!'(6 '(A!G("?'!7 - 'H( ' -4  (C 2334 !! G"('( &'   " I !  "&M(  !' '  ?(  ! 21 &(C 23346  ' 'B'( '&!@"   ! ! 0 @") 2331 G':'(!'&"&("'"&M(!' '!21&(C2334! )((&!G("?'!7 -'H('-4 (C2334!''(B03)C23346 -16 ) ;&" 7!''(&'(!!('(" -*433@6"('('!!"''A(("&6  

    /0010/2334 52-/2-5 '  2 *1  '*+), , , ( )', *

  3/ -

-6 " !'!'' )'C!6 3/

26 ' (!*' !'"@)''(" ?'!7-" C233>'0-?')23346 06 &!'(&'(!!(!''6 >6 '!'"@A)''("?'!7 -" C233>'-4 (C2334') ("D(A4E' "'(6 46 '!'"@A)''("-*433@6A(( &'( &'(A"&6 16 @ ! &'(  ;G!! &)( @   ( !' &"( " '"!'03?7'(@ '('&7 C'!@""'! -333  

 -> @"( 'K'( !.2!'!@""'!!

C'!@""'!-.?2334# $%J!" (;!  !(@(B&)(&(!':'( '( ''('J!(D('"' C'!@""'!&')&('!&') "! (;'K (!*'( !>2 $6'&"(" (!&7   &   '( );"  B  &) )( D( ?(A!*)6   ':@@7    '$$  '"(8    V'  V  ' "('5?(8  ' `` ``   & @&"('D(((@"'K&'(';GA!G@@ @""'! '' &)"&'!:@@!