opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/114/2005

Genf · 2005-02-16 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

                !" #$

     

         %&'()%*+++ ,%&&'%*++- , !,! .,"  !. ". '/  01   &2 34 *++- 

 .  ." ,"   "., !  ,! !"#$%&'(&)) ' * ++,-'+(&'' &+  &'%- +*())(''( (  5555555555 ( + .'/ 0 -  5555555555 1&'+-2+3$%  5555555555( + .'/ 0 -   (&) ( (')  (&'',  * ++,'-'+(&'' -4+ / +&'' +  ('-- 

  5 ' .   ' ((+' 

  

6!"7869::: /96!9/  6, !; ('--

 5 '.  ?'&10'(%+*'&&>--('-#$%''  0' + (&&  9@ (A !8B@; ' ''  0' + (&&+$-'(+('--'CCCCCCCCCC+&''/)-'+>--4'+*'0'+'%'+CCCCCCCCCC+&''/ -'  >--4' +* '0 ('% # +   CCCCCCCCCC +&''-0&>--4'+*'0('%#+   !88D('--,'(&)'%'('+*&)(E-)&>!88D  &+-  %( 4' +*-+'  ''( 4''$;  F%' !888  ('--

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

-- >(0-;   +H)$  (4(' -0')  +')(''(  %'0 F,H7!+-&>9::9-0+)'')(,$0))'> (%'0&(&(N4'F'+',&+-&'()(+' ;(, +('+-'%+*(&')(+)-#+-'+)')'(+) (0+-+-'))'> -4-=; &(&+O('++(&&0P'4+$00--  &(& (N  ' + (&)'( ' +A  + (&)  4')%+*'('(>& '0'>,'(44'%)&') +* '0 )'& + (''( &')(%' K *(>'0'(+-)+(&&0 -4-=;

*)$('--

 5 '. (>!94-%'!888' ((+'+' &(';8&!888+&+)(+'- 0(>+79BH""D4;83+(&(+33H7994;D3'4 (''()'' ./ /    -+-'+B F'!888(&&'''(')'&+*+'%'+++ 9:I -'+('--  !888  '> +)&'$ '  1(&((0-((+)()(-)('--)(+'%'+++7:I +-(+'')E>++-'+@:F(+$*-4(+ F0&)$$0&+-)'%'-0'-++-)+)-'(++'((+' !888,',*>'' +(&&0 =;  -%-&

  

6!"7869::: /@6!9/ (''#0'((0+('--'(%>4'(' +-'+)-&)'(+*-+*;D9;! .; ('4'+&+  -)'( + +(&&0 # *( + +-4+  ! 4-%' 9:::  +&+)-+-')-&)('+',;  +-4+ ( 4(&- ())(''( )$ +  '  &) '   +'$,'&'%-++-'+7:F(;*', ())(''(,,G&'%-(%>4(& %) +)')'(''+(&&0#'+ (&)'(   # -)'(; .' *&)(E  )( &(  )(>''-)*-+#'>'+'' (0,'(0'((&  !99  @@ ('+; " !!8  ":3 ('+; 9   -4-=;

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

  

6!"7869::: /86!9/ '(''4#* '!88B*(0+-%''(*)(-'4'

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

  

6!"7869::: /!!6!9/,('()4%(>)('> -'4A1(''(+'&'- +(&&0+'(%)(,*+'%'+++7:I('%-;  '( + 44( +-)(E-  ( +&- '&)E-  (''()( (% )-'(+ +, &(')--+ *((' + ' ((+'('4-&')+&+++3(%&> !88D"+-&>!88D"F%'"4-%'!888 ') ';  SSS 

  

6!"7869::: /!96!9/  . ",6 ,! .,"  !. ".

 03   7  8   9$ &2* "   3 

!; J('  ,G  &'%- + ())(''( 4(&-) ' CCCCCCCCCCL  3

9; FL 7; (+&'#)E#1++-4+(&&+4;9H:::;/#' +)'')'(#4'+-)'',*# +&+'L "; ->()'+((('('(L 3; 4(& )' + ,*)% 4(& ( ( )- G +  +-' + 7: F( +$  ('4''())' (&&+- +-  '> 4-+- +  .1T'U1(4,' @ @::"     ('  &)';  +-' ) G)((0-;  &-&(' +('R = '+',  &,+-''((+-'(>'')++-''( ,-L >= )()(, &('4 ' '&)(%(' +&+   +-''(L =)(  '0 (  + ( )-; .'  &-&('  (')  (' --& -&-- (  = >=  = '/+  '>4-+-+)()&'$(,*' +%+-'%>;&-&('+(&'((&(E +)%,' ( F(' '',  +-''( ,-  *%()) + ,--)-+'-(<;!79!:@!:D=;  044'R  V'+ 

      -'+R  '           ()'(4(&+)-G('4'- )''',*#*44'4-+- +(')044