opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/1086/2007

Genf · 2007-10-09 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

 

      !  "  #$#% ! &' ' 

     

       ()*+(,--+ #(.-)/(,--+ # #$ #     $ "01  . ' * 2 1 ,--+         !!!"#$%#&'()("*")(  ( +,+-!*   ( (*     *(    +  ++

 +++. ++   + .  +!/***(#0%%$   )(*'"*!  !!."*1*(+ !!( !*!"

    23452$%%5 6$2#76  3$# #8   "  #455 *('!!*  ** 9 ** - /:;+ )!($%%$ * ) -"?/!(! 8 *!*("*!*(" *((!9.!* ()*!'* )(&   +  ++

  +++ . ++   +.  +A!6)(&+ B*   ++ +8 $8  $% C!* $%%7   "*" '!*! . !* D  ((!'*  ? .

* ? EE   ** 9 ?/!)! #4 '?($%%7C9.I"?($%%78 C !*< )) !*!  ((!(<("#4C!$%%0)(((*( )"!!*,(/*  E!G*(9O F)!.!*$%%7G(!  EA(* B*  (*/)"!* A( B * * C (  * ./-) */& *(*!9) ( G)!9(  **  I < 08 )(!( (!  E A( B 9!  H!*  ; )(& .!* .)) CE( )(!&( '(*&?( (9!"*!*'!!?(;*.))("! +/(8  ()(*C.!* C ("*" '!)(. (!E!*(*!9** '(*"?(G8  ( * *  (!  "' 9" !6 C )G) **( .'!   + *"!! F8 .(")(!(!H ("+ 9.'!*") ")(&  .     . ++ 6     I  '?( $%%=?*. ?*!()(!/(E.( '(! )(H! 8

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

(!?"#4C!$%%58"("9 F  ()) (* (!  E!9 HH*" < F"*?!* / )!*!(F  $# C!* $%%7( !!9"9.!.-'!*)!E"! ) *6 *(*!9 ("(')(!( ()'(*"?(G (G8.*)(( 9.(E )!HH*)' !( ((**)(!&('(*&?(  (8(&'9.!.*)H!**! !+/(9!) (** *  ! ?! '!!?8 )("! 9 ** ! .*)  !"("    ! !'!*8  "H (*!  "!H (  '(*&?( ()'*K*(!E.**!!! +/(8 (&'9* *'(*&?( ***!*.!-!+/(*)*L*?  !*<)(*!(648

    23452$%%5 602#76  .  $0  '?( $%%7 ! * HH*!'* H!* "** F.! **F8 )** *<H!*'  !(!(9.! *!)!.!*8

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

2 +!E*/*E' WX/Y(#44%)8 =$D 6 + ! Z(?!* '  !/*(  (:* ! ( + :!'(!/(E*!"!!5#2#44%)8#%47B8  *((!  ! E*)9**9 !'*.*)("*?!.((6!*

    23452$%%5 642#76  !*)((</(E*(!**."**!H)("G!**( U!"*"" EE('")(.!*8   (**(.G!*.!!*"*(!HH!*9."'"* ("  !* )(*! < . (!E!  .**!* <  *"8  "** "E""(*!H  (?! *"(!( .G*) .G!* . "!   () ( !!" <  !* ) ( ** 9 ."'"* !*   ! "/"  EE('" .**!*)("G!** A' !(   #7 ( $%%5  2=7$2%5D  #$7  I7  !8$?)8 II ##0  #I=  !8 $)8 #I5 *  C(!)( !*"D    $%%#RI7=)877$[((K*8=C!$%%#7432%%\D H(],! HY/!/ P^()(/Y!EE ! O + + #440)8 4ID  H _ P (!*! (/*!/ (E!O+ +#44I)84B8(!( .EE('*! !E!H!*!'* (?.HH*! "E""(*!')("G!**   '(*"?()(!*.!*.*"*?! C(!)( 9 (9(! E()/!*"'!**?!*'(*&?(  .))(!*!   .E(!*  "!  )(&  *(*! A   $%%% R707)8I= !87*("H"(!*"B8 58  *G*))(! (!*<)(**! (&E 9 H()('))(*!*<)(*!9!!' 9))(! (!* A $5 * ?($%%=7342%ID  $%%%R707)8I0 !8$* ("H"(B*(* !"(*! .!.*)) !?()(!!)!9!!* !(."*?!((?.))("!*! )('"** H!* 9!  E("  '(!?)(") "(*  (()  <  ("!*" A  ##5 $0I  !8 7? *  ("H"(B8 )('   !)(!*!   !  !*"*( !*)K*()) (*")()('H*("*(E(< .!*8  *  (  !9*! .G!E( .((6!*)(' "E*!'9.**!*<*"?!*) 9)( (" * ("'*)(H!**"! !*<* * !"*?!(E(" '(!?)(") "(*9!*.**!*<*" C *)(L* !'*!!K*( !"(" -*!)( A((K* 8  7%  '?( $%%I  $$$2%I 8  #I * ?( $%%I  002%I * 8  I * ?($%%I#=42%IB8 )(!!) G!(!.**!*<*"* (!)*?<.!*   .*) A** 9  *  ** 9  !B (  ?  (!*&(   '(!?)(") "(*   *!&( )('    !  ( !A #$070% !8=?D#$=#4= !8$D  )?!"$$%2%$0 Q*$%%7 !8$87B8 38 !*"*"9*!.)(& ( (!!(/ *.G)"(! '!H!* !"(""*!*)()(<*(1(HH*E(!9!.*)(!*('("**)(!*HN E""(H' (!")( * !( * A  #$=  I0#  !8 = *  ("H"(B8 *H ! 

    23452$%%5 6#%2#76)(".**!*<*")/-!9)(?&!*""9* )  E&( ( .((6!* (")  !  )!*!  ) !E!&( * ) E(' 9!  )(!* /?!**)   .G)"(!"!A ##3$4# !87D##570= !8=2??* ("H"(D +  .(6!* ?!E* !( ! O +/V!:(!/ '(V*E(/*874B8 48 + )(!!)!?())("!*! )('9!T))!9!?!)("(!!*(*!'9T)("(( ((!*!!*(*!HA(*8I%   (("*! 'T(*8#4 D(*84=8$!! '(*8##7* #7$BT!!*(*!  CE))("!!?(*)('K*(!")( (&EH ()("*<))("!*! )&**(!E ()('8& (CE !*G!(!&( ?C*!'*  -)('99T !*)(')!"!(! *<!) !*! )(***) (*(CE*'?((!*!*!E!G8 (9()) (* "!G * *(!* !(CE)**(/(.HH!(!!9( (! ) ( 9 !  H  ( )!!  "! *  ) (  *(8  * "E( .""* "*(!* .* ! . (!E! !  "!E*!   -)(' ()) (* G)(*!!  *8!) (*9) !*!*!E!G!) (**!*H!*. ?C*."*H !"9()) (* H  (  G )* 9.!)( "E*   !"(*!  )!* G)(!" 9.! !* "*" "*?! )!  !   !( A&B9(!)*! !*(H"("! !*!(*H!9  ! .G)(* !*?! *!'"A #$=7=# !87B8 #%8 +(**()(!!)!?())("!*! )(' (!? H""(() "!E!(*(!9! (!&( .))("!((*!*-).G)(*! ()) (*"!G8 !!CE)*  (()!'()(?*G()) (**G)(*!"*?!)("! + ! E*)9G6!? *!*<("** '!* 9( !  !*"(!* *!'"9'! *!*)  *(!*! *9.!! (*)(****(( ?!6H "8!)H!*9"! *"*!"<.(()(()) (* *('!)(*) ( *(. ?C*!'!*" ))("!*! !  )N ( )("'*!  < ."E(  .("8  .* 9.)("  !( *)(*!!&( 9   *  C*  .!)(*!!*" . ))("!*! )'* K*(  !"("   ?C*!'* H "8 **  " .!) (* H"("G()) (*"!G(!*( ! !-!* *H !) (G!E"'&(9*<.!)(*!!*".G)(* A #$=7=78 !87?2B8(!(9! (()) (* "*?!)("!*(!**CE)** !**!()*H!*9  .G)"(!"!*(!***E""(*! *<)(()(*!) ( )*!*(! (*!  H!9!.!*<(!( A #$=7=# !87?2??*B8

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

    23452$%%5 6#$2#76 .!* * (*!)!9 .(" .)("*" )(?& "! 6 /!((E!'*."'"*8 !!) ( *!H9.'*.!* HH(!*) ( ( .(" *!*9.()) (*!*"*( !*K*(!*(6! *.!*$%C!*$%%78(!* (!(< ) !*'(  (E**! ('!(!*< H"(()(!!)F) */ (E )(*(/ F '()(?*9.!.)  (!?H""(("C< . !   )("!( <)!( ()(! A  ##4  7I#  !8 $ ?2??D   #444 R7I#)8I%3 !87?B8H!*9-)*L  *!H*"9.)(&('.!*)* *!*(!!! HH!*)<"*?!(()) (*!*"*('*!*8 '!* )(!!) . (/(/( ."*!  E! *  '"(!H!( ( ** ? .G!*  ()) (*!*"'."'"*("8 '!!'(E*(*)(***!!)

(!?"."(*( !  '!*(8 #I8  (!?" !&('9!)("&9.G!*.! !*"*(*(*(? (G*.!*$%C!*$%%76< 7%C!$%%I.))K*("*?!E("'(!?)(") "(* (9!)(C(!)(8   !*!    !*" *( ."**) ("!" ! .- ) ! ) (!'(.-!*""9*8 !( ( !*6!K*((C*"8   

    23452$%%5 6#72#76   4#$3  #$ #     $

'   5 0

#8 "(( (('?8 ' 5 

$8 (C**8 78 !*9)("(*E(*!*8 I8 H ( )(*!   9T)'* H (( ( (  *( )("* ((K*   "!  7% C ( &   *!H!*!  )(&  (!? H""( A+/V!:(/ H9!00%%I  B)(' !( (*!&((!*)?! H ("*G(*83$ !H""(( (!?H""(#5 C! $%%= A BD  " !(  ( (  !* !!9(   !   *!H * -)('*) (*(!E*(( (*  *!(D! !* K*( ("  (!? H""()( ' !) * )( ' ! "*(!9 G  !*!   .(*8 I$  8 )("* ((K* * )!& ) !   ( (*!' 9"  -)(' !'*K*(C !*<.' !8  E(HH!&(   (!6 ! Z  ("!*    (!_  )! H ()("*((K** *!H!"G)(*!!!9T<THH!H""( *")?!9)(E(HH