opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/1060/2005

Genf · 2005-12-06 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (5 Absätze)

E. 5  /+ 27   $" " %- ( $88 " ( $'% 95 %-  :  2;" 133* "  (&5(  &"& ."   8. ( "" ("  03; 13367

17 """ < $&  $&"" % %&"&,  "" .    %  23;. 1334, = >! $88 &? ( %'" 95%- : ! % (& ( 2; 1334! %&  % ( (", $('"& ( <; %  ($@ ;"8&7

$  %  .& < $& ." (&;, 8" $@;" ( (& ( %! $)" % 88"&  >> % ($'% & ."  %"  >A'?!  $&"" % %&"&,  & ($8'" B  ( 2= C" 133*!  $D! " )" "'%  ' ( '>& ( ". 9 : % %"& ( ". " .'@ " (&'@ 133*!  ""8 %( ( "8" '&(7 $ %% %  < $& @&&8 (  "-' (&5( ($('"7

E. 07 $&  8'& %%"  13; 1334! &?" < EF 8" >" ' <  B ' (" (G5., 2* > %  (88&" "A " ; H   >?& ($> 9= >:!; '  8" %(7 ; ( (G5.!; '  %&"&, 2* > %&! '  '$ "(" (  .7 $  &(?&  %"" '" ($D <$  @ .;(, ' >> ( ' ( (&'@E7 *7  (& ( 1I;" 1334!  % &'"  ;"& $%%"7    88" (&& <  D%" 8 % $&  " ""  D .@! (-  <$  '@" ( " . %&  (" " $> ( (G5.7    ""& <$ 8D"  (& (  %, <;! "  ''' %&. %  @-' ( B  %  " '<'"! $ ." %"&  %% (  %%""&7

47 $&  ";"&   2* %"'@ 1334 " (" (&  %%"7

67   &% ( 1= %"'@ 1334!  % &'"    ;" ( 7

I7  %" " &"& "(  2 .'@ 1334 %  @ ( &7 $&  (&& <  ." % $"" ( 23;. 1334  ." &"& ' %    ' %%  ($ %&&(" (G5.7   8'& <  (" " $>  ." &"& "'" (<&! '  &%&"& <$>@"&, J" .<&, 2* >!  &"" .  (G5., ""

/0122/1334 5 0/6 5 >5,7  %& 8 . ""&  (& ( % ".,   !  <  "8&   ( (&8" ( >> % ($'%7

=7  0 .'@ 1334! $  "'! '' .  ( $( ( '%" %!  " ( (" ( "" <$."  $& .    %7   &"! <$."  23;. 1334!  <" (G5.! " ." &"& 8D&, 2* > " , 23 >7

"" "  &"& ''<&, $& % 8'" "    &"& ?(&,;?7

  + 27   ?.  K?";( 9:  &"& '(8& "  ""&! (-  2 C" 1330!  @ " (  ! '%& ( 4;?! ("  %&(" "  .5%&("! 4 %%&" " 26;?  9"7 2 "7

" 46

:7

B", K" ( K&" ( 26;? ! %  @ 8&(&  1I;. 133*

E. 9 # 203  236:!  ( ?.  (%"&!  20 8&.!  (%" "" ?" %'"""  @ " (   ( &?  , ";? ""! ! ( K""" ( K&" ( .D;? 7 17 8'&'", $"7 46  7 2 "7  >7 = !  @ " (   L"  " < ( """ %&., K"7 46 (   8&(& ( 6 "@ 1333   %" ?&& ( (" (   0 : < " ".,   8&(&  K5 >A'? @?" " K('"&   (K.@"& (

E. 14 ; 2+=1 9 :7 B '%&" %;? (  (K%- "  &"@7 07  ! ";"&  "'% "! " .@ 9" 46 " 63  :7 *7

D "' ( $"7 2I  ! K& < 8" . ( %"" (K ("! . K" ( K88 ( ". '%&""! "%( ""  <K %" @'" D? (  % &."  >A'?  K@&?7   '@!  %"! ( >> ( ".!  @  (> (  %8 <K DF" %&&(''"7  (" %. %%"  %. ( 88" <K  87

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

 (& (  % < (" J" %%",  ?."& (  8" " ( 2, 24;   ( 8" &?-! ( 26, 03;   ( 8" ( ?."& ') " ( 02, 63;   ( 8" ?. 9"7 03 7 0   " *4 7 1 "7 ! @!  ( $(  $5>A'? 5  :7  B   &"@  @-' ( %  <  $&   %&" %  @ (  %&"  D .@, $"" (  " ( "A , ;& ($8'"! %  %'- 8  % ( (", $('"& ( 4, =; " %&N $ $?" (  ( 8 ( +, 24;7

"8! <$ & '< %   "" ' <$ %. %  '%"'" ?&& <$ %( @?" ( >A' " ( @&&8 ( %"" "-  &D!  $)  %  (  %( (  (", $('"& % '%"'" (&<" 9 1333 %7 232:7

67  $%-!  8("   @-' "    "., $('"& ( >A'?!  1330/ 1I1! D "' ( <  $& @ (  %&",  "" (  " ( "A " <$%- $ J" ( '%"!  ""(

/0122/1334 5 4/6 5 "" '%'" ($J" .<& % $D " ;"8!  '%"'" '&" ($J" "&! $  %(  (" ( $& %(" 4;7

I7 $&  D%<& . 8(  > " $J" (  (G5., 2* >   ( = >7

!    %&"&!  $)  %  ( %(  (", $('"& ( $& <  (,  "" (  " ( "A ; ."  (G5.!  <$ -? ?&&  8" %. ( %""&7

)    ( . < "! $&  $" % %&"&, $"", $> .!  " ""8 .  'J';! "  ''&("'" &(?&  '" ($D! D%<"  8 <$ ." 8" "  >7  @ ( & "", " &?(<  <" (G5.! " ."  88" &"& 8D&, 2* >7  ;"8 (-  ($ " '%"7

 " . %(" <  '%"'" $" % &%>@N % (& ( %  " &"& "8&7 D %&( " ( " %(" (."  @ ( &7 )   &<   % ($  %! ' ($ &(  (&, (D;7

/0122/1334 5 6/6 5  " +/  + "+   "  " $ 0.1   2  3   45 (,'  #6   1 

27 &   .@7

$ 1

E. 17 ('" %"'"   " &("  (& (  %, (D;7 07 " <  %&( " ?""7

*7 8'  %" (  <K %." 8'  "  %&" J" (  (& ( 03; (-  "8" % % ''(& (&  @ 8&(& ( ! B>OG>8< 6! 633*   !  " D'%7  (&  %" J" %?&7  '&' (" M : (< D"'" < (&  " (& @"   " % (  (& ""<&N @: D% % < '"8  "' %. ('( "" " (&N : %"  ?"   (  %&""7 B  '&'  "" %  " &&'" &'&&  "" : @: " : 5(!  @ 8&(& (   %

% "  '"-    <K (. (& .@7  '&' (  '"   ') ( %.! < ";"!  <  (& ""<& " K.%% ( <   &"& D%&(&  " 9"7 201! 236 " 23= :7

 ?88-

5  P

 &(" M

 Q     % 8' ( %&" J" " "8& D %" "  B&"" (K "", K&' %  ?88 

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

    

    ! "  #$ 

        

%&'((%'))* +%(),)%'))* +

+ "+   "  " "-  ($, .  '))*

  

  !

"

"

##

    $ ! % &'"!  " ( ) *+, -. "'&

/0122/1334 5 1/6 5  /+ 27   $" " %- ( $88 " ( $'% 95 %-  :  2;" 133* "  (&5(  &"& ."   8. ( "" ("  03; 13367

17 """ ! $88 &? ( %'" 95%- : ! % (& ( 2; 1334! %&  % ( (", $('"& (  > % ($'% & ."  %"  >A'?!  $&"" % %&"&,  & ($8'" B  ( 2= C" 133*!  $D! " )" "'%  ' ( '>& ( ". 9 : % %"& ( ". " .'@ " (&'@ 133*!  ""8 %( ( "8" '&(7 $ %% %  " '  %  (88&" "A " ; H   >?& ($> 9= >:!; '  8" %(7 ; ( (G5.!; '  %&"&, 2* > %&! '  '$ "(" (  .7 $  &(?&  %"" '" ($D > ( ' ( (&'@E7 *7  (& ( 1I;" 1334!  % &'"  ;"& $%%"7    88" (&&  ( (G5.7    ""&   ." &"& "'" (@"&, J" . !  &"" .  (G5., ""

/0122/1334 5 0/6 5 >5,7  %& 8 . ""&  (& ( % ".,   !  > % ($'%7

=7  0 .'@ 1334! $  "'! '' .  ( $( ( '%" %!  " ( (" ( ""  " , 23 >7

"" "  &"& '' 7 = !  @ " (   L"  "  A'? @?" " K('"&   (K.@"& ( 14; 2+=1 9 :7 B '%&" %;? (  (K%- "  &"@7 07  ! ";"&  "'% "! " .@ 9" 46 " 63  :7 *7

D "' ( $"7 2I  ! K& A'?  K@&?7   '@!  %"! ( >> ( ".!  @  (> (  %8 & ( ". %%, '&  %""(  %'"N @7 D "" ( ! D & (K8'" " D "" %&& .&, K7 4N 7 ( 8  ('" %'""" (;? K " %"  %'"    ". %%& " .@ # " ( "" 7 47 $"7 03   %&." A'?   "" ( K""& '%&""! "''" 8  ". .@!   %&" %,  ' ( '>& ( ".  K"'%"  '"8 .@!   '%'"  '%J>! %  '%"'"!  (&'" (  '   &" (  @"7  %  (&"' ($%-  ?."& (  8"! '%" " ( (" % ( $&7  '%"  $ ( %(  (&" ""  " %%   ($%-! "''"  '@ "  '%"'" "& ( $"&& 9B !   327+1 >88 1*I:7

 (& (  % A'? 5  :7  B   &"@  @-' ( %   A' " ( @&&8 ( %"" "-  &D!  $)  %  (  %( (  (", $('"& % '%"'" (& A'?!  1330/ 1I1! D "' (   " $J" (  (G5., 2* >   ( = >7

!    %&"&!  $)  %  ( %(  (", $('"& ( $&  .!  " ""8 .  'J';! "  ''&("'" &(?&  '" ($D! D% 7  @ ( & "", " &?(7  ;"8 (-  ($ " '%"7

 " . %(" @N % (& ( %  " &"& "8&7 D %&( " ( " %(" (."  @ ( &7 )   & OG>8< 6! 633*   !  " D'%7  (&  %" J" %?&7  '&' (" M : (< D"'" < (&  " (& @"   " % (  (& ""<&N @: D% % < '"8  "' %. ('( "" " (&N : %"  ?"   (  %&""7 B  '&'  "" %  " &&'" &'&&  "" : @: " : 5(!  @ 8&(& (   %

% "  '"-    <K (. (& .@7  '&' (  '"   ') ( %.! < ";"!  <  (& ""<& " K.%% ( <   &"& D%&(&  " 9"7 201! 236 " 23= :7

 ?88-

5  P

 &(" M

 Q     % 8' ( %&" J" " "8& D %" "  B&"" (K "", K&' %  ?88