opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/1040/2005

Genf · 2005-11-29 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (1 Absätze)

E. 12  *((66(( >44( 6AB* .$)(.//#((? *(( ,.=(.//$2 $2 '(%>44( 6AB*6' ' *(( (*2

   

+,-,-+.//# 0,1+,10 #2 (?6* B(2 92 (?6?((@6()6*)(4* *6( 6' 4)    6* "   *(  1/ = &  (4(( 6 6( )) *  *  (8 4* *   G!V(P!4?(99//$  (@)6(2 )*)( (C7 ( (?@)? *(( *(8((6  *(( ?*I 87 @6 6 ?)(4   () 6'( )    *((I 7 6  (B      6*2G()*)((6(**)*)** 7 87  7 (0   (8 4* *    6 6  )(&    ?>( ' * ('82 )*)(  )()F 6'?(=()*)(>(>B(  6(&  6(  2 G *B) =( )*)(  *(( ?*  >'66  ?   ** @6* (*   52,1.,/9,/-72  B44(   ( G  *(C   8G      *(0=(C  PP(((PP(        6(4) 6*"(4(*@6(((?>%>44(4* * (6B44 

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

                !

      

         "#$#$"%&&' "#&(&"%&&'))  )* *  ) * +  % ! %, -.  %&&'

    //////////    00 *  ) 1   !"#$%&'  (()*

   

+,-,-+.//# 0.+,10  0,2  *(( 344( 30('((*5(06& 7 ./ 8,9')8.///: );;;;;;;;;;* (& >0('((*((? > )6*)(6*6@%6( ,=(, 44( 6 AB* 5(06&C 3  7  )   6( )6*)( % >0'('('('((*2 '  )  B((  3    !B  (  ) *    D (  ,E'(.//, 344?"'  *)(    6*  6 (( ? 3*   4 ())8((&  (( 6( 6 (2   66  1, 8 .//,3?")))(*'(?3**(66(*( > !@:F0 0(5G7!*, ?((( !'(**6()4(*)F 6" * 6)&H 3* >)6!F6!*(2''* ** !*( 1//3///42 12  (  9 ')8 .//, ? *( =(  *(( * )") = >    (4)* 3* ?3 6(  6'( ( " '*   *)( '  *62 3*  4)* 66(( *((6( .-')8.//,2  6*  >66((4('(?' !>*'(% .,#3/// 42   6 % 1//3/// 42  ?   !(B6!( ** '(" * (2 $2   .#).//.>  (4(*%>* ' *((@ ) ? 6()6*)(6&(('(

*('),4*'(.//,1,).//.23  )6  34())8((& ,,.3#//46& * (   !(B6!(2   !F6!*(  ** * (   8(? *6*2 G  8(? 6 (  8( ())8(( >    6(  )6  ' ('  ! ,13#// 42 5% 6( , ='( .//.72  6()6*)(6&>('!**'(%3*% 6( ,'(.//.( 6()6 >B( 3('(*6( )(I8( 3) (*()(2 #2 ( 1/=(.//1>  4('(?B(6( )(?( '((9/&)*(66()6(('(*>*% ))(?''* 66(**2 *(( .=(.//1  6( )6*)(  6&  4* * ?   **

   

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

   

+,-,-+.//# 0$+,10 >*'%13/ *(*(? 6()6*)( 6& .-$426)(>*(644(2,.2 >  **6( 366((  ,# *)8.//$2,12  1 ='( .//# 3    (4(* %    *(( (' @ 6()6*)(63*.//#)6 3B)(  : G ) ('((*  @=(2,$2  *((66(( .$)(.//#>  4()* *(( ,. =(.//$)(4?)6()6*(2

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

*)( 51 2,  72  *B)( ()(( *B(  6( )6*)(54221$#2,2  726( )6*)( 4( ) '  *62 F(%*B  >6* (((6()6*)( 4* *)6()6 3*6)")2 #2 2 ('4* *' *)()6))6 ( 4)8((&())8((&5212,28 7?(P(&)  4 )N *6$/>///42665212, 2   7   6(   6( 6*((? F )6(   > G > 5212,2  76  4 F (> ((5212,2B 72 82  4  *'*   &B   *B((  >()6D  (   )(( 52,E 2,  3  4* *   6()6*)(%30'(('('('((* ,# ='(,  ())8   6 >!8((  ?*  %  6 )6(      6( )6*)( (  6(  )6 %  ' '* 52,E 2 $  0

G+ 72''* 3())8 (6'44((  '  )) I  8(   *8( )F 3

   

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

*)( *6'''@ 8'(   * (( ?  4 @( %   % ?  !B) ('(2  6  %  6  6( )6*)( 

   

+,-,-+.//# 0-+,10 ?) (4(((4*(%,./4652.#2,2 0

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

   

+,-,-+.//# 0,,+,10 ''*2 &B) 366((('!  (6(( *)(( '(' 3())82

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

,2 *'82 ! 4-

.2 >)6()2 12  *((66(( >44( 6AB* .$)(.//#((? *(( ,.=(.//$2 $2 '(%>44( 6AB*6' ' *(( (*2

   

+,-,-+.//# 0,1+,10 #2 (?6* B(2 92 (?6?((@6()6*)(4* *6( 6' 4)    6* "   *(  1/ = &  (4(( 6 6( )) *  *  (8 4* *   G!V(P!4?(99//$  (@)6(2 )*)( (C7 ( (?@)? *(( *(8((6  *(( ?*I 87 @6 6 ?)(4   () 6'( )    *((I 7 6  (B      6*2G()*)((6(**)*)** 7 87  7 (0   (8 4* *    6 6  )(&    ?>( ' * ('82 )*)(  )()F 6'?(=()*)(>(>B(  6(&  6(  2 G *B) =( )*)(  *(( ?*  >'66  ?   ** @6* (*   52,1.,/9,/-72  B44(   ( G  *(C   8G      *(0=(C  PP(((PP(        6(4) 6*"(4(*@6(((?>%>44(4* * (6B44