opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/1014/2005

Genf · 2005-10-25 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (3 Absätze)

E. 5  ." 78 

9(#&#( +&/  9::# ("  9+"#;#5 +&/  < ( $# & 9##(#"  $($ "0&(  :0& /  7& "("=& 244-8

  (&0#$ +"& " $+"' ># '+"#(#(9 =&? @ A>9 B4 +(=& 244-! % C4D   +&#& (+ +# % 744D / A0#& 244-8 "  :#E  #&!   &$#$  &0   2*744 :&8  7& A0#&  B7 $=& 244B ( 3*444 :&8  7& A0#&  B4 +(=& 244-8

28 & $##"  7B $=& 244-!  # (" ?0"#  EF?;#5 +&/  #< ! "(((> 9#($&$ 90#(+ +&"0& 0"#& ::(#0(&G  #&  3*444 :&8 +& "# / A0#& 244-! $  ?# &$ &  ",  #' &#& "#  #& &$(("E$! "#(- ' 2*744 :&8 H 2 ' 3*444 :&8! (9 ## :#'$ % B*4C6 :&8   "#$&$ > "+( (  :#(>9% +&(#&  7& & 244-!  "  "+(  9(&+&# I "+( # J +&$(#( " $?(#: 9 +&((9(& +&(>  &0$  "+(   > #::# +"& 9$ 244- +&"#(+& 9&$ $(#( &0$ 9 "+( +&#0$!  +&0  0&(::(#: 9 #&  3*444 :&8 90#(+ $($ $(=#  / & 244-8

B8 9&$  "(($  2C A0#& 2443 #( $##"8  '+#> > " $+"'  &G  E$&#(?  (  K 0&# 244B 9 "(( K4*444 :&8 ># 0#($($ +$ &  "+( "0&(% " " +&/   > #::#8 9((&?(># 0#(&0# % " $+"' % "0&#&  E&? &# ( :(&  :"&#& A>9%  #>#(#"  "+( 

E. 6 0&# 244-8 -8 & $##"  C A# 2443!  #  &A($ 9"++"#(#"8   &++$ >9# 90#(+ $($ $(=# % (#:(#"  &"#(> 9#($&$ 0#(::(#0(&G  #&   3*444 :&8  & % +(=& 244-! &#" +"& >  0#(&(  +$&#" ( +(=& 244B % :$0&#& 244- " +$&#"  "(#(#"8

38 9#($&$  #(&A($ &"&  26 A# 2443 "(& #( $##" L I " &# ("# 0" (" '  #?(& &  "+(  "(& "A"#(8 " &# 9   +&#& (+ + 0" #A(& 9&?(+&"0( " E$&#(?;K4*444 :&8<  " (&+&#  :#(>  :#  5# $(#("& #8 (&?( $($ 0&$ &  "+( " %  > #::#8 "&> 9 =&? 9(&(&"0$   ?& #::#($! " &#  ( % 0&& 9(#/&($  #& %  (  % ("(" +&"!, "+&# "#5M! A>9%  >9# #># 9::#&8   (##$ % (::( &((  &(&(! & #,  0#("&! (  "+$($ +&  +&$/0( & " "+(  

1223312443 5 B16 5 #::#8  #& "( ("((+! +# 22 ! $($ 0&$  # % #! " # ("&  "(   &(&(J8

  "E#($ > "#(( (&"#   "/?  (&0#8

C8 0#($ %  $(&#&!  #  +&#($   (&   $##" & "++"#(#"8

68 "#&

(  ! '5+",$  * =&?! "($($ (  - "("=& 2443 +&  &#=  $8 "#&

9('$! $(( $+(% 9$(&?&8 9&$  &"$ % " #(#"8

 ' ($"# "((&0#$ % 9 =&? @ " &0&!  +&#&  7..K % 244-!  "  # 7..C % :# 24428  "((" ' ":#&$ >  #& $(#(0&$  # % #! >  +(&" ++#(E> +",$ % ("&  &F  " =& +"& # "& " 0"++ %  :#  "#! > 9#($&$ $(#($?(++$   "&(8  "($?(":#&$ >9% & "#  0&( #&  # % # $(#(   &(&(#"8 "#&

 $&$ >9# &0#( #&   -*K44 :&8!    B*B44 :&8 (+"&  +# (+ ( 2*244 :&8 =&(+"&  #5(+8  ' ($"# "(::#&$ > 9#($&$ (&0##(" &08

K8 & >"#    $($ ?&$ % A?&8

  " 78  "# ?0"# & 9"&?#(#" A###&;<  $($ "#:#$ ( #(#($! /  7& "N(244B!  &#= ("  & "#! "+"$  3 A?! "( +&$#(( 0#5+&$#(! 3 ++$( (7C A? &;&(8

E. 7  ! > 9#  &$($($ +&G +&  (&0#& &( +$&#" +&""?$ (>9# 9 A# :#(9"=A(9 "(((#"; 2447 +8 22K R 7...! +8 2K R

) 72B  62<8 68   "#  & "#!  A? :"  $##"! : #+"#(#" "(&#&   "#! &  :#( >#! :( 9M(& $(=#  #/& #&&$:(=! ++&#("  + 0&#==! 9(5%5#& ># +&$(( ?&$  0&#= +&$+"$&(8   ::#(" + >9 :#(+# M(& "#$&$ ("  E,+"(E/ +"#=8

&# ("  $$(  :#($?$ " 0#?=!  A? "#(!   $E$(! &(#& ' ># # +&#( + +&"==;) 72C  BC4 R 723 B 7.3<8

# *'#(5(5# +!  &"#( & "#!  +&##+

1223312443 5 316 5 " > *##(&(#" "  A? 0&#(((&!   "(!  :0&  *&$;) 72C  B22<8 & #&!  +&"$& (&$?# +&  +&##+ #>##("#&! " >  :#( +&(#(    "#0(M(& "(($ *"::# +&  A?8 #  +&##+ *(+ ="8  +"&($ (&(&#( +&  0"#&  +&(#  "="&& % *#(&(#"  *::#&8 #5# "+&  +&(##& *"=#?(#"  +&(# *++"&(&!   & "P  +(M(& &#"=('#?$ *!  +&0 "$ +&  (&  #(#? ( :#( #0">$! :(  >"#  &#>( 0"#& ++"&(&  "$>  *=  +&0;) 723  7.3<8

K8  9+/!  #  &( " +$&#"  "(#(#"  &(> # $(#($(=# > 9&$ 0#(&G  #&! "#( ",  #& 0&$ +"&  "#  +(=& 244B % :$0&#& 244-8    ::("(($ >  "  "+(  9(&+&# $(#($?(#: +# & 244-8   $?(&0$ > # 9E$&#(? 0#(::(#0(&0# % "0&#&  #&  9(&+&#!  90#(+ M(&   > A>9%  #>#(#"  "+( "#( 6 0&# 244-! (" + A>9% +(=& 244-8

.8)"& ( "((& >  &"&( 9 + +&"0& >9 0#(&$(&G  #&   3*444 :&8 +# A0#& 244-8  9 + $($  &  +&"#&  &0$ =#& " +"(! $?(>  #& $(#(0&$  # % #8  (0&# > 9( #& >#  $($ $&$ ' & "# (>#  / "& $($ "# % "(#(#"

5 8 "(:"#!  $&(#" 9#+F( ( $"+(  #& (#$ % 9   "(#((+  ",  +&0 ::#(; 244-! +8 773 R

)  2- +(=& 244-! 

B414-<8

 (0&# >  ($"# "(0 ":#&& >  #& $(#(0&$  # % #! ( >  $(#("0(9?   &(&(#"8   $?($($ $(=# >  &"&( &0#(" #&   M #&"( >  (& +",$8

 $&(#" 9 +  &0E M(& :#( &  "(( #&8 ,  / "& #   :"& &  :#( ># +&$(( ?&$  0&#= ::#(8 &! " +(9$("&   > 9$+"  +(&" &G"#0  #& # #+"&((! $+(# 0&$ %  &0& ,( M (,+ 9'+$&# >9! "& > 9(&+&# &"(&#( ( #::#($ :##/& >*  N & ("( (#0#($ / +(=& 244-8  &"&( "(#(>9# $(#(#+"&((+"&   &0"#& " #&  3*444 :&8 +& >9# # &0#(% (&(#&  :# I 9(## "# 0 " #&  3*444 :&8 ># :## 0#0&  :# J8 9( :#(#?"&& >  =$$:# &$#$   &  9(&+&#  9$+"'! (&+&# '+"#($ % (#(& ##0#! $(#($#&(&$#(9((8  9(& (&! >9#, #( =$$:# +"& 9(&+&#! " >  =$$:# "#((##$ +"& +,&  #&   &"&(! &0#( M +"&  $+"'8  '+#(#"   &"&( "(+ "0#( % ($?&8

1223312443 5 C16 5 748  &#=  $ &/0 +& #& >  &"&( $(#(&$$&$! " *((((#" $(=#  B "0=& 244- +&  #  "+(#"

 % > $(#(::##$ *(&+&#  " $+"'! % &#"  2*744 :&8 +& "# +"&  (#0#($  C4D  244B; 2*434 :&8  2442 (2447!  2*444 :&8  2444<8 # *" &(#( M =  ! " "=(#(+"&  +# (+!  #&  B*344 :&8 +& "#!  ># (+ +&"E  &(  # +&$0 +& *"& &# ?0"# ++#=   (&  *EF(&#5&(&(#"  244-! "#(B*K24 :&8! >  # $?$ +&  &"&( / A0#& 244-8

 &#=  $ (## 90# >9# 9 + $($ +&"0$  ?&$   0&#= +&$+"$&( >  #&  3*444 :&8 #(::(#0($($ +,$ / A0#& 244-8   +(/ "& M(& +&#  "#$&(#"8  *( ::(+ 0&#== >  &"&( #(&$#$  A0#& % +(=& 244-  &0 $+(#=( "(( B*344 :&8! "& > *(#0#($ $+",$ $(#(&($  M (>  #((#" :##/&  *(&+&# $(#(+&$"+(8

( % $(&#&  "(( #& % +&&  "#$&(#"8  $(E" ++#>$ +& *  +(M(& &(   & "P   &+" &  = $? ((+&((&=#(&#&8  &0E! #,  #  "((& >  #& ## +&$0 +& *"& (#"$ ( B*K24 :&8 *( "$>  "((># & &(  "&( >  ?# &$ &  B*K24 :&8

#  &"& (5# +&(#(#8

1223312443 5 616 5  + ".  " +"   +  + $ /-0   1  2   34)5&  #6   0 

78 $&  &"& &0=8

$ 0

28 *(+&(#(    "#$&(8 B8   $##"  C A# 24438 -8 #(>  +&"$& (?&(#(8

38 :"&  +&(#   >9 +0(:"&& &"& "(&  +&$(&&M(  $#  B4 A"& /  "(#:#(#" +& +# &"$ &$  &#= :$$&  &! ES#Q&E":># C! C44-   !  (&"# '+#&8  $#  +(M(& +&""?$8  $"#& "#(L < ##>& '((> $##"  &"&($#& "=(#&  # (+   $##" ((>$R =< '+"& +"& > "(#: # (# +"0"#& & (( (& $##"R < +"&(&  #?(& "   " &+&$((8 #  $"#&  "(#(+  (&"# $$( $$&$ " ((& < =< (< #5!  &#= :$$&  &  +"&&

+ (&&  (#/& &  &"& >9# 0& $&& #&&0=8  $"#&  &"& (#"& "&  ",  +&0! ># &"(A"#(! ## >  $##" ((>$ (90"++  >   $($ '+$#$  &"&(;&(8 7B2! 74C (74K <8

 ?&::#/&

&#5"#  T

 &$#( L

"&# U   

 "+# ":"&  +&$(&&M(("(#:#$ ' +&(# ( &$(&#(9 ((% 9$""# +&  ?&:: 

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

    

    ! " #$ 

        

%&&''%&((' "%)()*%&((' "

" +"   +  + +, ) $ &' - &(('

  

 ! "###$ % &' &"&(

"(&

))

    * ! &"+ &$(#"! # &"(  ,&# -. % /0 #(#$

1223312443 5 216 5  ." 78 

9(#&#( +&/  9::# ("  9+"#;#5 +&/  # '+"#(#(9 =&? @ A>9 B4 +(=& 244-! % C4D   +&#& (+ +# % 744D / A0#& 244-8 "  :#E  #&!   &$#$  &0   2*744 :&8  7& A0#&  B7 $=& 244B ( 3*444 :&8  7& A0#&  B4 +(=& 244-8

28 & $##"  7B $=& 244-!  # (" ?0"#  EF?;#5 +&/  #  9#($&$ 90#(+ +&"0& 0"#& ::(#0(&G  #&  3*444 :&8 +& "# / A0#& 244-! $  ?# &$ &  ",  #' &#& "#  #& &$(("E$! "#(- ' 2*744 :&8 H 2 ' 3*444 :&8! (9 ## :#'$ % B*4C6 :&8   "#$&$ > "+( (  :#(>9% +&(#&  7& & 244-!  "  "+(  9(&+&# I "+( # J +&$(#( " $?(#: 9 +&((9(& +&(>  &0$  "+(   > #::# +"& 9$ 244- +&"#(+& 9&$ $(#( &0$ 9 "+( +&#0$!  +&0  0&(::(#: 9 #&  3*444 :&8 90#(+ $($ $(=#  / & 244-8

B8 9&$  "(($  2C A0#& 2443 #( $##"8  '+#> > " $+"'  &G  E$&#(?  (  K 0&# 244B 9 "(( K4*444 :&8 ># 0#($($ +$ &  "+( "0&(% " " +&/   > #::#8 9((&?(># 0#(&0# % " $+"' % "0&#&  E&? &# ( :(&  :"&#& A>9%  #>#(#"  "+(  6 0&# 244-8 -8 & $##"  C A# 2443!  #  &A($ 9"++"#(#"8   &++$ >9# 90#(+ $($ $(=# % (#:(#"  &"#(> 9#($&$ 0#(::(#0(&G  #&   3*444 :&8  & % +(=& 244-! &#" +"& >  0#(&(  +$&#" ( +(=& 244B % :$0&#& 244- " +$&#"  "(#(#"8

38 9#($&$  #(&A($ &"&  26 A# 2443 "(& #( $##" L I " &# ("# 0" (" '  #?(& &  "+(  "(& "A"#(8 " &# 9   +&#& (+ + 0" #A(& 9&?(+&"0( " E$&#(?;K4*444 :&8   :#  5# $(#("& #8 (&?( $($ 0&$ &  "+( " %  > #::#8 "&> 9 =&? 9(&(&"0$   ?& #::#($! " &#  ( % 0&& 9(#/&($  #& %  (  % ("(" +&"!, "+&# "#5M! A>9%  >9# #># 9::#&8   (##$ % (::( &((  &(&(! & #,  0#("&! (  "+$($ +&  +&$/0( & " "+(  

1223312443 5 B16 5 #::#8  #& "( ("((+! +# 22 ! $($ 0&$  # % #! " # ("&  "(   &(&(J8

  "E#($ > "#(( (&"#   "/?  (&0#8

C8 0#($ %  $(&#&!  #  +&#($   (&   $##" & "++"#(#"8

68 "#&

(  ! '5+",$  * =&?! "($($ (  - "("=& 2443 +&  &#=  $8 "#&

9('$! $(( $+(% 9$(&?&8 9&$  &"$ % " #(#"8

 ' ($"# "((&0#$ % 9 =&? @ " &0&!  +&#&  7..K % 244-!  "  # 7..C % :# 24428  "((" ' ":#&$ >  #& $(#(0&$  # % #! >  +(&" ++#(E> +",$ % ("&  &F  " =& +"& # "& " 0"++ %  :#  "#! > 9#($&$ $(#($?(++$   "&(8  "($?(":#&$ >9% & "#  0&( #&  # % # $(#(   &(&(#"8 "#&

 $&$ >9# &0#( #&   -*K44 :&8!    B*B44 :&8 (+"&  +# (+ ( 2*244 :&8 =&(+"&  #5(+8  ' ($"# "(::#&$ > 9#($&$ (&0##(" &08

K8 & >"#    $($ ?&$ % A?&8

  " 78  "# ?0"# & 9"&?#(#" A###&;   "(((#" +&$0 % 9&(8 3C   "# :$$&  C "("=& 2444 &  +&(# ?$$&  &"#( & "#; # "(&(#0 %  "# :$$& & 9&5

1223312443 5 -16 5 EF? "=#?("#& (9##($   9#"0=##($  23 A# 7.K2;  # ("=( "&( "& * "  +#& &++"&(  (&0# &( +$&#"  &$:$&!, "+&#  "(#" &$?#/&(0&$ ("0 "(&((!   & "P   "(+  ##($ +"& #"0$#( #$ % *'$(#"  (&0#8

 ?# &$ ($ &  =  #& ",  #' &#& "#  "(#(#" ># +&$/( $#5& *##(#" "  "Q &#& "# #  #& (+ $0$;&(8 B6  *"&" & 9&5EF? 5   # "#(M(& (#:#( +"& ((& >  "#(#" &(#0 %  +$&#"  "(#(#" "(&+#! #+#> $?(>9 #& "#(&$(0&$  (&0#&; 7.KK! +8 7. R

) 77B  B32 9 $"  9#(&+&$((#"   "#! 9'#? 9 #& ::(#: +"& ((& >  "#(#" &(#0 %  +$&#"  "(#(#" "(&$# +&$( $?(90(?  +&$0#&  = ># +"&&#(&$(&   9"& :#(#: (&  +",& ( (&0#&  A( #& >  +&#& 9?? "(&((% 0&&  ";&("("&> 9+",& ( (&0#&  "( &$#($ >9  (M +&"  9#  &$($($ +&G +&  (&0#& &( +$&#" +&""?$ (>9# 9 A# :#(9"=A(9 "(((#"; 2447 +8 22K R 7...! +8 2K R

) 72B  62 #! :( 9M(& $(=#  #/& #&&$:(=! ++&#("  + 0&#==! 9(5%5#& ># +&$(( ?&$  0&#= +&$+"$&(8   ::#(" + >9 :#(+# M(& "#$&$ ("  E,+"(E/ +"#=8

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

.8)"& ( "((& >  &"&( 9 + +&"0& >9 0#(&$(&G  #&   3*444 :&8 +# A0#& 244-8  9 + $($  &  +&"#&  &0$ =#& " +"(! $?(>  #& $(#(0&$  # % #8  (0&# > 9( #& >#  $($ $&$ ' & "# (>#  / "& $($ "# % "(#(#"

5 8 "(:"#!  $&(#" 9#+F( ( $"+(  #& (#$ % 9   "(#((+  ",  +&0 ::#(; 244-! +8 773 R

)  2- +(=& 244-! 

B414-   ($"# "(0 ":#&& >  #& $(#(0&$  # % #! ( >  $(#("0(9?   &(&(#"8   $?($($ $(=# >  &"&( &0#(" #&   M #&"( >  (& +",$8

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

1223312443 5 C16 5 748  &#=  $ &/0 +& #& >  &"&( $(#(&$$&$! " *((((#" $(=#  B "0=& 244- +&  #  "+(#"

 % > $(#(::##$ *(&+&#  " $+"'! % &#"  2*744 :&8 +& "# +"&  (#0#($  C4D  244B; 2*434 :&8  2442 (2447!  2*444 :&8  2444 # (+ +&"E  &(  # +&$0 +& *"& &# ?0"# ++#=   (&  *EF(&#5&(&(#"  244-! "#(B*K24 :&8! >  # $?$ +&  &"&( / A0#& 244-8

 &#=  $ (## 90# >9# 9 + $($ +&"0$  ?&$   0&#= +&$+"$&( >  #&  3*444 :&8 #(::(#0($($ +,$ / A0#& 244-8   +(/ "& M(& +&#  "#$&(#"8  *( ::(+ 0&#== >  &"&( #(&$#$  A0#& % +(=& 244-  &0 $+(#=( "(( B*344 :&8! "& > *(#0#($ $+",$ $(#(&($  M (>  #((#" :##/&  *(&+&# $(#(+&$"+(8

( % $(&#&  "(( #& % +&&  "#$&(#"8  $(E" ++#>$ +& *  +(M(& &(   & "P   &+" &  = $? ((+&((&=#(&#&8  &0E! #,  #  "((& >  #& ## +&$0 +& *"& (#"$ ( B*K24 :&8 *( "$>  "((># & &(  "&( >  ?# &$ &  B*K24 :&8

#  &"& (5# +&(#(#8

1223312443 5 616 5  + ".  " +"   +  + $ /-0   1  2   34)5&  #6   0 

78 $&  &"& &0=8

$ 0

28 *(+&(#(    "#$&(8 B8   $##"  C A# 24438 -8 #(>  +&"$& (?&(#(8

38 :"&  +&(#   >9 +0(:"&& &"& "(&  +&$(&&M(  $#  B4 A"& /  "(#:#(#" +& +# &"$ &$  &#= :$$&  &! ES#Q&E":># C! C44-   !  (&"# '+#&8  $#  +(M(& +&""?$8  $"#& "#(L  & '((> $##"  &"&($#& "=(#&  # (+   $##" ((>$R =  "(#: # (# +"0"#& & (( (& $##"R  9# 0& $&& #&&0=8  $"#&  &"& (#"& "&  ",  +&0! ># &"(A"#(! ## >  $##" ((>$ (90"++  >   $($ '+$#$  &"&(;&(8 7B2! 74C (74K <8

 ?&::#/&

&#5"#  T

 &$#( L

"&# U   

 "+# ":"&  +&$(&&M(("(#:#$ ' +&(# ( &$(&#(9 ((% 9$""# +&  ?&::