opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/1012/2005

Genf · 2005-11-22 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

    

         

        

!"#$!%&&' !(&(%!%&&' 

) *+) ,  ) ,* - . ( %% / . %&&'

  

 ! "#$ % &'() (*+

,

,

--

    . //  (  !   " 0 12 % *+ ,#$

342536778 (6396 ( 0* 9:  !)+! $  9141! $;, ,   # ,  0 "=,,! >  "$;,$  >>,) "  ?=  ;"$ >  " >, ;@,#, +;,, "= -  91AB: 6:   ,,+$ "*  6 >,#; 91AB , >", >* " 66  ## >, >* " =,> C :

B:  ># ", , +  911A +  &, " "  0, ,D$  ,#, " +,*; 2: > !    ,,:

5:  ", " 65 +#; 9111!  ? =$ ,+, )0>,!  )$  "  ", +  &#; 0#" , =, $>,$ + ) ", >$! "=E  , % (:   $,$ )$ %  , >  

! >$,

-F  #$" ,: 8:  97 >, 

",$ " B # 6777!  

!  H>$ + ,,$  "$ ,, > , ",,#,  ,  : 2:  B9 # 6777!     ,, "$& #$  $+", % = ,  "#"$   ! >$,

-F  &),&>$"?! " +  >,,  + "= ,&>:

A:  

 "),?$  > " $ #$ ") ", >* ,&> " (: 1:    ! #$" "="#, "  / !  H#$  >,,  ", " A +#; 6777: =$   "$$ ? )  &0? , ?= +, " " >,, % = , )$ $,, " ,?, "  >&0,&$>:

    ,,$ ? =$>&#, , ",0> #$? >,, , ? ,, 0#>,#,)! #)$  +,), >>  ', H>?$ > =,,: ,)+#,:  

342536778 (B396 (,#$ ?  >,$ ",+ " =$ "  #$, " >, ;@,#, $,, " 87I:

97:  "= + H# >     ", " 6 # 6779! (  ,,$ ?  ,,   #" : H $ #)$,?  ?= ,&> =+, > $ % ",;*# ?,, ,,:   "$$ ?  >,$ ",+ "  #$, " >, $,,,G " 87I # ?= #$, ,, >;:   ! &),&>$",!   $, ? "  , ,+,$ =$ >,,+ &, & > G:  #'#!     !  >,$ ",+ " =$ $,, " 87I "  ,+,$ ,#$ , " 977I "  ,+,$ ">,$:

99:  65 + 6779! =$  "$>$  "#" " >,,

  *  K  >>$ " #,, =$ %  # "=,,  ,#; 6776! ,,, ? =$+, $,, ,, , ?  "), >$ >  #$" ,$ $,,  +, L (&">,& ,(,#,? (,& ", >,(,#,?

(H ,&> ), &)  G 6777 ,  + 6779 (,#, 2 >,(,#,? J911AK:   >>, " 66 M, 6776!  , "=,$), > ;,$ " $">, =$:  >,$ ",+ " =$ $,, ,*! $,, ," ?= "+, $+,  >, " &) " , ?= ,, > "  >, ,,?! ,, ";,! > "= & % "H & "= , ",+  >#,,, =, " >,:   $,$ )$ ? =$ #,, ; ))#, , ?  " $,, #, ,$ +  > "= ,+,$ >  ,, ? (, #>, "  ,,, %  ,$ JG#;! "K: =$ +,  # $,, +, $,$ ),:  $?!    >>$ "=" % =$  >), "  # >  "$ ", #     >G, >,#; 6776! =    ,#; 6776  98 "$#; 6776:

342536778 (5396 (

,# " ,, >),!  + /

J K   ? =$ >+, #,,  +  > >,$ ",+ ,, ?=#>0$ "  / J&## &)$ " =,,! ,,,&?K:   >>$   " 9A #! #>)$ " ,&? >$ ,,; #,:

9B:  "$ " B # 677B! =      "  >, "=,, "  / " 94 "$#; 6776  67 G 6775 , >,  &) "  ",&) " =$,,$ , " =$,?  ? "    # $,?  6777:

 6 ,; 677B! =   $)#, # =$ ;$$ $#,    ! #$",,,! =$ =$,, >, " " > #>,, ):

  >>, " 9A G 6775!     ,, "> 6776! " , ? =>,$ ",+ "  " "  > , $,, " 27I , ?! "  >,$!   ,+,$ % >,#> $,, H);!  "#, $,, $", " 87I:   ))$$  H>, ? >#,,, "=$+  >,$ ",+ ,, >*  ,)

: 98: / #", " + #$" $)

 J/K!  

- ! >$,

-F  &)!  ," , H#$ =$  B7 M, , 94 >,#; 6775 H ,:

  >>, " 5 ,; 6775! =H>,  >$$ ?! , %   ,+$ ",+! $,,  &O#) ">  B7 G 6775 , %  && "= #>:

/  > #$"! > ,,#, =$,,    ), "  >, " " >#,! "=,,$  ,  >, ,,? >)$!  >, 

342536778 (8396 ( ";,! $,, #,$$:  !   >+, >, " &) "$>, 8 P:   ? , ) ",! =$+, $,, >,O, ,   =,  ,, "  0>& "  >", " #,, " 87I "  &, , ,D, #, J  "? 2(AK  &0>(0>& " B8Q:

/ =H>,!  >> #, , ", #>;  >, " &) "$>, 8 % 97 P:   >>,!  + " ,, ,! ?= ,+,$ "=), " #,  / $,, H); %  & # " A & > G! > ,, ? =$ > $+,, ,+H ", " &) "$>, 8 % 97 P , ? ,+ >#,, " &)#, " >,  , ";, $):  ", ",! +  ,+,$ ">,$!  >,  >, H,: 94:  /!  ", " 9 +#; 6775!  > , "  ?   -  ,$ ",+ H); "  + ,+,$ "=), " #, $,, ,* , ! #)$  $, " =$ ? ), "  >+ #  977I:

92: "$, ? =$ $,, $ "  "$ " 68 +#; 6775! .    , ")  , ;@,#, ,  +  >;  ?,$ "=#>0$ " #,!  >+, $  + H,  ", %  ,:

9A:  ,, ##"$ " 9B "$#; 6775! =$  >, %  "$ " =  , ,$ ?  , ##?$  >>, " #$"

! >$, ?= +, "N(+ +  #$",,, ,  +,:

 6B "$#; 6775!   "?$ % =  ?!  #$",,,  ,, , &? " " #)$ > ;>, G* " #$"#,:   +, > #  "#, >$ % 87I J"#(G$K:

91:

 "$  >>, " B9 G+ 6778! =   >>$ % .$ ?. =$,, ,     -  ", " 5 ,; 6775 ,  H>$ ?! "= >, " +;G, ,$ ",+ " =,+,$ , ? $,, ">,$:  )#, +$ " .>>, =$,, >

342536778 (4396 (>,; " #" , " +:  $?,!   G,$ =>>, ,   J K +, "#"$  $$+, ",H ",+ % 977I >* " =, S  

% ., " .&O>, (/$G , ?= +, "N(+ &N   "    J#$"( " = K  6A +, # ?= "#, " 87I   & " &) "  >,! " , ?= ,,  , "=+",$: 66:   >$+ " 68 + 6778! =     G, "  ,  #, "  "$ ,,?$: 6B:   $>? " 6B # 6778!  ,  #,   " 9A # 6778! "#"$ ?= + H>, , "$ , ?. , " 87I  , $: 65:  95 G 6778! =   "$$ ?= =+,  #? % , #>$#,, ? "#"$ =>>, > $: 68: / "#" " = !  ,  #>  ,) "  , " $">,, >  " 99 G,  6 M, 6778 % 87I  ', #":

 , , " >>, $,;  B7 >,#; 6778 ?  , +,;> " > %  >,   + "  >,$ ",+: , ! > ,, ? , #,, , >  #>,! ,,  # >,   >,, ; $ " &)#, " >,!  ,, &# ?  $,, ">; ,  +, "  O,$ T &## %,, $, , ,#$ ? "  ",! =>,,"  >#,  >, H);!  $+ " =+ "  #$":  "#, " ,  ,, H + " 47(27I   >,#> ,! # >+, )#, % A7I  ###   #(,#>:

342536778 (2396 (64: / !    $,$)"$ % G):

62:  , $$#, >,, " " , > ,, ? "; "  >,  ", " >$, ',:

 ,* 9:  )+  =), G" JK  $,$ #" $ " 8 G)! ",  >$", ,  +(>$",! 8 >>$, , 94 G)  J,: 9 ,:

, 84

K:

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

  " .,: 6A : 6  !  $">,,   >,$   , ", ., .,  ) " #>, ?   $">,,  ;: / ". "#" " ,  >>$ %  > % . ". $+ " (! ."#,, ", " $" ".  ,$ ") >, ! ,, +#;! ', +)"$  #$$ " #* ,; J,: 92 : 9  K:

/ .,: A : 9  !  $ +"  #$ ". +",$ ##, , ", H # " $">,, ? , $ , " , % $,;  >,$ ")! % .#$! %  +)"  % ;;: .$  ",  #, "  + > ,$ ") >, ! ,, +#;! ', +)"$  #$$ " #* ,; J,: 92 : 9  K: , $>,$ +"!   " .,: 92  !  ",  "#, "  >,$ ") ,,,  , ! ,H " 67 I $,, G)$    G>" J - 965 997 ": 6;K:  !  # " #,  , ,0$ ?   , $ , " , % > %  > $ ? HR,  ,+,$ ,+ +,  + " .+",$  >;,$ ") >>H#,+#, $?+, %  ?  : A8 ": 9K: /, "$$ ##  #,  # " * &*+#, ". *  "$;, " .H ". ,+,$ ,+ 

342536778 (1396 ($;! > #,  > #$ ;#,  >,$ ") J,: 4 : 9  K:

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

91A8 W 454 >: 657 ": 5K:  >>!  G)  =$, >  #, $, , #$"! ,@& " =H>, $,, >$$#, " #,,   >$ %  ">, "  G,  , #$"H "= $,, " "! >, ,,   "

342536778 (97396 (=$, "= H>, G"  , "$ > ;   $, $#,,, " > , >, % #,, $#,  ",  >, " "$", " =H>,! =  >, H!   !  ,>$,, "+), "  "  " >  G) ! ;  ,, #>$#,   , #$" J - 99A  617 ": 9; V 996  B6 ,  $ > >  ?!   G>" ,,!  0   "=,,& > "=#>, H ,,,   >$, ?=% =>>$,   #$",,, J 91AA >: 875K: 1:  =>*! "  >>, >, ,$ ",+ " , % 87I! "   >,$: !  9A G 6775!    ! #$",,,!  $G, " =$,, ") V    "$$ ? "   > ,$ $" ",+ " B7I , ? "  ,+,$ ">,$!  >+,,+ % 977I # +  "#, " 87I:  5 ,; 6775! =H>, #",$ > = !  

- !  ,#$!  + " ,, ,! ?= ,+,$ "=), " #,  / $,, H); %  & # " A & > G! > ,, ? =$ > $+,, ,+H ", " &) "$>, 8 % 97 P , ? =#> >#,, " &)#, " >,  , ";, $):

=H>,  >$"$ %  H# #>, , #,H " =$,, " ,$ " =$:   >0$  =, " "! ,##,   , ,, >+,! " , ? =  >, ? ,, ?  >>, ;   "; $,0$:  #* #>*,  $,$ $$ ,  >,,  $,$ )#, ,": / $,, " ,$  > >, , ,$ , =H>, , >+ % "  : ; ,,  ? =, %; ", ? =,,$ ,#$ =, $ H  " =H>, > ,  >,$ ",+ " 977 I "  >,$:   #,,, " #,,  ",   " =H>, , "  # E  >>, $>" %,,  H) G>",   #,*!  +, "  D, > + >;,:

  $,$ ,##, $,;  $?+? ? =$+, ") ", $,, ,  =$  "$;, "=$ ,

342536778 (99396 (H ,,, "  #$",,,  G 6775!  ? =$,, ")  >$G, "> 6776:

, $)"! ; *+ ?= " ,* = $,$ ,$  " "   , >",  #, > >, $")$ % = " & "=HK:

,  >$, " =, " $">,, > >, " B7 >,#; 6778! ?= > ,#> # +  "#, $", " 47 % 27I: ,  J), " #,K ,, =>, "$:

97:  " #$" $,,  + "  ? >$*" #>,!   " , +, %  H>, >>$#, , # &$ % =  " =+ >  #>, ?  >;*# ):   ,  "M#, H#$,,  >;*# , " $ ,#, " +,*; ? .$+, ") ",: 99: &N  $ ,  " +:  !  + ",+ ? .+" >,;,  HR, .,+,$ ?. >, ;#, ,," " ! >* H$, $+, " # " $">,, , #>,, ". ,, $?;$ " #&$ ",+! , #>$  + ?. , >;, . .$,, > +" J,: 6A : 6  K:  #> " + . ;  #,, "  "H + ,    #,,, "  ,H ".+",$:

 =! =   #>$   ?  , ,;,  +",$  6775 "   > 0$ " #, "  /!  ;, >    // 6776 J) ,$ % 6775K:  ,  >> ?  , ;,  >, ")   $,$ ,,$:

=, " % G,,, ? =   "$$ ? =$ =+, > ", % " >,,

: 96:  $)" H "$, ? >$*",!   ", ', G,$:

342536778 (96396 ( ,*0  *+) ,  ) ,*

  123   4 5 6   578 ("% ,9  5 3 

9: $   +;:  3

6:  G,,: B: , ?  >$" ,),,: 5:  , "  ?= >+, $, ', "  "$ " B7 G "*  ,  > ##"$ "$ ; :  "$  >, ', >)$:  #$# ", L K "? H,#, ? "$  , "$;,   , > "  "$ ,,?$V;K H> > ? #, + "#" ,, , "$V K >,  ),   "  >$,,: /  #$#  ,, > , $$#, $#$$  ,, K;K , K ("! ;  > ,  #,*    ?= "+ "$ +;:  #$# "  #,   #0 " >+! ? , G,!  ?  "$ ,,?$ , =+>> " ?   $,$ H>$"$  , J,: 9B6! 974 , 97A K:

) $",

 Z   

 $,(G, L

H"   

 >  $, ', , , ,  ?=% =  )<<