opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/1011/2005

Genf · 2005-11-22 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (6 Absätze)

E. 6  0* 78   ! $  7.59! :($(+& " :;; ( " :#+ <6+&  =  0 >(0440 ( "$6" ":"#(  $($ '( ;' "& (( "( ?@: 7 >(044-8

:($$  $($ #  A$$; ":"#($ " :6BC#D "( "$6" +$($8

E. 08   ( D' " BC#D! ,(++ +  ' " @E( @ :($$ '(( $($ F G  D( " ##  5 >(0440!  # %  ( 6BC#D " : <6 +& G H=  " + I# " :+(("  +#(" :($$ "( "$6"8

28  "  $+"  0. (A 044-  @( $(A +  G H ## (J

                       

+  # ":>(0440 (?@: # " '#A 0440 ? #:  +$ (  ? % + (#+8

      !  " "  # $   $   %&'' ( "(     )  ( * +     

,  , - - $.   

! ?: '(" :D(! ?:' " I  "6, <04 #0=! ?: B($  "(!  #+#(! ;I8 : '(' + " H) 04*444868 / 0(#   #    (. 

     -     "      $ " "(     (      -   )  $

 :' + ":#+,$! " # #:("$! # % K A + L8 1          2  $345      60  7 8 99        $  

:             (         (     

    



:';( "$#B +& "  

G + #: ## "$+"((+&  ( +# # ?  +$ %  

G

/0123/0445 6 2/77 6 <( " BE 5-= + " @ ?:E( :('($8  

G #: ": $(  ((( +$" " ( # (?: $+" % 68 :(($ D$ # D @: '"('$;  %  

G (?  ((%;(":"8

7 0  "   #     ((  

       +, - -       #                " +

:(  @ $(((( " A ++ "   "6, ( # : 6$ < (("  (  $($ $(A=8  '  , # " H) -5486 %     #+(8

 ($$+B! ?   "(@ ? M %   ( '  # " ?' ;$' 04428

 "#"! ? +$ @:( '#A 0440 (;$' 0442! ?: ($   +  #($ <"(! (8= @ :, ('((

+ $(" <++" ;(N (8  'I D=8; 0     $ #

(   ) 

-  <  5                =

:'  D ($$+B@  # "  $($! @ #+(( D G < D + )I!  +  ($$+B ( + ((=! B "  D ,( ++ #$8

 : + $$ % :$+@ (( D!  ? : (;$$ BO #8 :  "#(@ +( "$#(8 :(($ D$ # "#"  +8

  ( ?: $$ (( D + BD (A(  D #$@8

 "#" " :(($ D$ ?;  ?(;(;

> 0     "    !((   (.  $     ( "  $     #     ? &'' ?   "  (      +

 : +  (,+ " "#(8 @ A   ) $  $      2 +  (, )#(    !     +

 3 H 44 % 79 H 44 +"(( # "+ >(04408

/0123/0445 6 -/77 6 B 0((  #  !    +  -   !  " "   )) %# ( " *

 BB " ( +  A " K ( L  " GN#8  BB " A(@ " 'E(#( +(A ":B( # #B"8 : ;( @E( "(?: +$ '(<@(=8  : ('$  (! ?:  " $+! #  B(8

9  $   ( #   (  

    - 

:(# @ #  +$ " :B(" #($! ":$ % : G! (8   $  -(        $ (     "  

;8 $+  +(74  :   ( $         +

 : + " #+( +  $($8

/ & #

 (    -   # $     +

"# $+ 70 1 0(( , - !    #   (            )-- /   ( $ ( "   > 8 99       #"      $      "   

 @( " '  ?: +($  #+ $ % + (#+ +"( +B " +$+( "  $($8  $+"  +  +# #! (>(0440 (( ?: +($ ((#+ "&  # " +(#A 0440! $'"##(?@:% ; " # "$6"  044-!  ?:' (($  +(#A "$?% @ # $($  #B(+8 7 3 !   " "(  

$      

5      "  $ " "(   

(         

P8 -8  "$ " 0;$' 0445!  G H  "$$ :($$ +(  +#($(('#( 0 >(0440! "$(@: :$((+ "+A + 

/0123/0445 6 5/77 6 #+, "& (( "(   "  $( "  (+8   % ($D" ++$ @ :($$ '("@$ %    +!  5 >((05 '#A 0440! @:  +$+(+ "' "$+"(! @: :'(+"(+ +(+$ %  $ ":;#( + A$$; " # ":D#(% :I ": ( ('($ (@: :'(?# D$ ' ( $($  D( " ##  5 >(0440 "$?%8

58 :($$ ;#$ ++( 

E. 09 ?' 044- <) 724  741=!  "  D'  "+($!  72;$'!  "+( (( D( +#((( A ( "   " $D   % ( ?D ((! ! " :((( " :$( " 'I ?D 8 08 ;#$#(% *(8 51  8 7 (8  B8 3 !  A ( "   S( ( @ " ((( +$' % :( 51 "  ;$"$ " 1 (A 0444   +( D$$ " "("   1 = @ ((' %  ;$"$  :6 BC#D AD( (:"#($   ":'A($ " 05 ? 7.30 < =8 G #+$( + ?D "  ":+& ( $(A8 28  ! (?($  (#+ (! ('A <( 51 (

E. 9 # 0445! +$(@  (+ ;((+! @:  D"(+ @ K   (?# L8 18  "$ " 02 ? 0445!  + $#( "   +(#("# :++(    @:  ;#$ :+(("  +#(% #+( " 0 >(0440! @*   'B  :+(("  +#("&  7;$' 04428 98 :($$  (?($   07 ? 0445 +& " A " $8

38   +$' " 7. +(#A 0445!  + $#(  +($ "  (# "  "$  ++( " 02 ? 0445! ++(@ :($$ '(+$$ %   " #+(

G6   0- '#A 0442 @: '($  ('($ "$+"(  27 ?' 04428

.8 (" +  A " $  7 '#A 0445! :($$  "$$ J K : ;#$ #  " # ('($ "$+"(8  '(@ ?: , +"(( # + '   +'(;(8

+& ( #! (%; (A 0440! ? #  " #+( @: #;(E(8

: "$$ % : G @ ?:' $ (( ('($ %; ?' 04428  +$ % ($D" @ :('($ 6#E#  $; (A 0440! # ?@:%; ?' 0442 ?: D"$  A " I8  : + $ # +(  D( " ## + @! D#(+ +& " (;;!  :, '(+ " $@ % 8 &; (A ?  #  + " ((+$ " (( $($8

: '   " QA D "  " " BC#D! ?:+$ ('  #+ DR %  8  : #B#(+ $($  8 :   :"$ " (( '( " 'E(#( + ((8  : + #B$ " ((8

 (: $($ ($$ % :B(" 'E(#( L8

748 G @    $($ D"$ % ?D8

 ,*

/0123/0445 6 1/77 6 78   D'  :D( ?" <=  $($ #";$ ( (($! "&  7 >(0442!  A ( "  ! #+$ " 5 ?D! "( +$"(( '6+$"(! 5 ++$( (71 ?D  <(8 7 (8

(51

=8

G( % :( " :$( " 71 ?D ! +  A;$"$ 

E. 14  =8 -8 :A?(" (D +(  :+(("  +#(" :($$ " 0 >(044-  27 ?' 04458

I (# " :(8 52  J K  "$ ( "$  ++(;##(+$ ; (# % $'  :$  : "$' A$@##(";( 'I #+((  (' " 'I #, " +' @  +'(E( +"( +'(8 : +('   "$   "$  ++(;##(+$ ; @: (#;(#($ (@  (;( 'E( #+( (A8 @:% :' "  +$' % :(($ " ! : +("$  "$   "$  ++( ( @    $($;#$ L8  G H ( + $#( $((;"$ % ' $(('#(:+(("  +#(!  ;#$#(% (( "+( $D8

58  :+&!  G H  "  "$  0;$' 0445 + @  (( :+(("  +#(" :($$ $(('#( 0 >(04408

/0123/0445 6 9/77 6  + $#(  ;#$ :+(("! #   #($  "$  27 ?' 04428

G  ?+"! @:  (++$ % (B " #& $(('  @( " "(% :"#($ " BC#D "$?% (B$ + :$!  (( ":" "(#( ((( " #(( '$ % ((<)  +A$

37/47 " 77 (A 0440! "8 782=8  :I( " " (   ( ?(;(@ : (B " #& +$A  @( " "(% :"#($ "  "$  ((( "((8

  ' (#(@   #(% :(($ (  @( " "(" :$ % :"#($  ++( " :(8 37 8 0 (8    <"  (  'D ?@: 24 ? 0442=8     ;;(! :(($ ( (#+$(( + "  "$ " (((   +$" ":"#( $$!  @( "  ((( " +(( $((" ("  8

 :+&!  G H! % @   ( D' " BC#D '(#  " + I#!  "  "$ <(8 37 8 0 (8   =8

) "&  (" (( @* $((;"$ % "  "$ " ((( " "(!  @( "  ((( " +(( $((" ("  8

E. 18  ' "(% :"#($ " BC#D! :$ "(! ( ( "(! E( +(  +#(<(8 3 8 7 (8;  =8 ($+($ +(  +#(!  :( 75  !  BC# @ ("+$ % +(  (' (( # ( "(" ;8 :+(("  +#(#+" "I $$#(8 G  + A?(;! :+(("  +#( +  :+(("  ('! :(6%6" :+((" +B,@ (#( % #+  ('8 :+(("  +#(' ((; +  @ :+(("  (' T B@ + +(  (' :(+ (? +(  +#(T % :'!   ":+((" #+&(  ('! :+(("  +#("(E( $8

C($ " (+(A?(;! :+(("  +#(@( " :$ @: (A?('#("+$ % ('8

 "&  $@ ## +(  +#( @ :(+ "+$   # " #(( % "+( ;($ " (' <G$((": ((% :$#! <6+& G=! 8  /478.0! B8 90=8  A;$"$ "    "$$ @  "+( % +(  (' 'A #+@  #( '($ " +"  ( (' :  +$(! #   "+A($ ;;( @( (#+ @ :$

/0123/0445 6 3/77 6 +( %  #+ (@( #A ":#+, +(( <) 775  -21 T  7..5 +8 59=8 G  G!   '($   "$( ":E( "+A +  +#((;;( + "#(( :+(("  +#(8  +!  ID " :$  (((" @ ;&( (( '($ " #& ++(A8 :A " "$#B  " "+( + + :$ (S  $D( "  "+A($  +#((6  +( +$' "  '($ ":E( +$  " BB  #+8

! :$$#(A?(; "(E( ;#$ + :$$#(A?(;8

,  +(("  +#((##(@ :$ :(+ "+$   # ":I  ('($ $! + @:  (+  'D ":(+"  ('($ "$+"( ( +(+ $@(+ E( +$ ## $   +(  '(+ E( DD$ "  # ##(ID$ +  #+,8  + ": ('($ "$+"(  "(+ #((  @( :+(("  +#(<G! (

.-/7!;B 2/1 T

) 770  209 T  7..0 +8 720=8

G  A;$"$ " ! ;(@: $ I  ('($ "$+"( % (#+ +( (( BB( ' #+  ;;(+   % I :+(("  +#(8  (B (( @(! ;(( #+( " ( "  (! (##(" +(" '  :I ": ('($ "$+"(  " $@   "+A($ " :$ (" @ # <) 770  721=8 ;(  "#"!  D" " :#A " ( "  ":+&!  :$ '(  '($ ":+(  (' (: $(( # " +"  ( ('  $D"  (#+ @: (+  %  #+ ( #A " #+, +(( < 7..0 +8 70.=8

($D"!  G   : " +$ @ :('($ "(:B " (' :(+ (CA "(E( "$$ ##  ('($ % + (#+ <(

.2/7;B 9=8  :D(!  ( '  "' " :$ " ((#((  ' + $'(  BC#D  :A$D <(8 79  =! " "$(#  6  "$"$ ":I  ('($ "$+"(  + #((; %  BC#D! # #+#(+ @! "$+"##(" (( "$( $ %  +( ": #+ +$$"(!  '(:(( " BD " (,+ ":('($8  @ :+(("  +#(("#!  + ": ('($ "$+"(  "(+ (;  +( +; " :$! # ;$(  $(  BC#D ( (( " "#  "##D8  ($ @ :$ +$;& I  ('($ $ #! @:  " #@ " + '(!  +  ('($ "$+"( @: ( #

/0123/0445 6 ./77 6 ":A" (;("  "$ ++( : ('( #+ $+($ 'A < 7..2/7..- 770 T

) " 00 ?' 7... "   =8

! @  "+( @ "(+" :$ + #((  +"  ('($ "$+"( (S( AD( +! ?"@ (@(%  "+A($ ( @: :(+  # ":+(   ('($ $!   ++ "+$ % :+(! :+(("  +#("(E( $ <G! (

.3/7;B 73/9=8  "+( ('(#( $ <AD( + (?"@= % :I ": ('($ "$+"( "'(E( ('#(##! :(6%6" @ :$ "(+'  @";#((@:  "'(+ ((  A( #+(( (  (#+ ( " :$ %  ('($ $8 G  ('($ "$+"( "(:I :ID  '(#(+(  "$+ #+(( +'(E( +  "$( ## D (#$" <G! (

.3/7;B 73/3=8  "(% :"#($ " BC#D ": $ "( 'B :$(" @  "$#B  ' ": ('($ "$+"( (% ( +('$ @:  + + +(  ('($ $  @   (D& +A! :(6%6" :   (#(%  +$+( ": ('($ "$+"( < 7..2/7..- +8 070=8

 !  : +("$"!   ++ "  + D" '#A!   A " ( A?(' (A?(' <"+( +! AD( + (?"@! (#+ "+A! '(#(! "$( ":(( (8= @ :$ :(+ +(  "+$ % E( +$! :"#( "(E( I <G! (

.3/7;B 73/.=8 ;(@ :$  $  &D D$$  '! ' @: ' ## "( +$+(;  ##$"(#(+&  + ": ('($ "$+"( :, BD 8  ;;(!  C " :6BC#D :(+ ";  "  +( %  $( ":(+  " ' " (( @: $ + ": ('($ $ %  ('($ "$+"(!   " ' " @@ @ ":(+ < 7..2/7..- U24 +8 070=8  (!  $  (I'#(% ;"( (%  #  +" "  (+  +(E( "$$ ## +(  +#(!   "  ('($!  :( "+$ % +(  ( ('!   # " ; < 7..4 +8 05=8 98  :+&!; (" (( @  "$( " :$ :D("  "( % @   $ ":I  ('($ ":"$+"(('$8    ;;("@$ %   " #+(  01 ' 0445 @ :('($ '(

/0123/0445 6 74/77 6 $  27 (A 0440! ( 0- '#A 0442 @* *D(" 27 ?' 04428

,  $D#( " ' @: * + #; %  ( "  ! +&  27 (A 0440! ( '$  "#(G #+((( D8  I+( " :$ (((" ?(;   + @  '(D "  ( :(+ '  A " $8  "$ " + $#( "$(@: $((+(  +#(" 0 >(0440  27 ?' 0442  +("&  E( @ ;#$8

 "$  (((  '#AA#((;$ % :$ +  8 :((( " 6 ((($  ;(@:    +A($ " "#"  # " :AD( " ((8

/0123/0445 6 77/77 6  ,*0  *+) ,  ) ,*   123   4 5 6   578 (#" ,9  5 3 

78 $   'A8

 3

08  ?((8 28 (@  +$" (D((8

-8 ;#  +( "  @: +'(;#  (  +$(E("  "$ " 24 ? "&  (;( + + ##"$ "$  A;$"$ " ! GBNOB;@ 1! 144-   !  ( I#+8  "$  +(E( +D$8  #$# "(J = "@ I(#(@ "$  ("$ A(   (+ "  "$ ((@$T A= I+ + @ #(;  (# +' "#" (( ( "$T = +(  D(   "  +$((8 G  #$#  ((+  ( $$#( $#$$  (( = A= (= 6"!  A;$"$ "   + + (  #(&    @: "' "$ 'A8  #$# "  #(   #, " +'! @ (?(!  @  "$ ((@$ (:'++ " @   $($ I+$"$  (<(8 720! 741 (743 =8

 D;;&

6  V

 $"( J

 Q   

 + ;# " +$(E(((;$ I +( ( G$((": ((% :$# +  D;; 

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

    

         

        

!"#$%!"&&' !(&((!"&&' 

) *+) ,  ) ,* - . ( "" / . "&&'

  

  ! "#$ % &' (

(

))

    * ! + $#(!  ( " , -. % &'

(#$

/0123/0445 6 0/77 6  0* 78   ! $  7.59! :($(+& " :;; ( " :#+ (0440 ( "$6" ":"#(  $($ '( ;' "& (( "( ?@: 7 >(044-8

:($$  $($ #  A$$; ":"#($ " :6BC#D "( "$6" +$($8

08   ( D' " BC#D! ,(++ +  ' " @E( @ :($$ '(( $($ F G  D( " ##  5 >(0440!  # %  ( 6BC#D " : (0440 (?@: # " '#A 0440 ? #:  +$ (  ? % + (#+8

      !  " "  # $   $   %&'' ( "(     )  ( * +     

,  , - - $.   

! ?: '(" :D(! ?:' " I  "6,  0     "    !((   (.  $     ( "  $     #     ? &'' ?   "  (      +

 : +  (,+ " "#(8 @ A   ) $  $      2 +  (, )#(    !     +

 3 H 44 % 79 H 44 +"(( # "+ >(04408

/0123/0445 6 -/77 6 B 0((  #  !    +  -   !  " "   )) %# ( " *

 BB " ( +  A " K ( L  " GN#8  BB " A(@ " 'E(#( +(A ":B( # #B"8 : ;( @E( "(?: +$ '(

8 99       #"      $      "   

 @( " '  ?: +($  #+ $ % + (#+ +"( +B " +$+( "  $($8  $+"  +  +# #! (>(0440 (( ?: +($ ((#+ "&  # " +(#A 0440! $'"##(?@:% ; " # "$6"  044-!  ?:' (($  +(#A "$?% @ # $($  #B(+8 7 3 !   " "(  

$      

5      "  $ " "(   

(         

P8 -8  "$ " 0;$' 0445!  G H  "$$ :($$ +(  +#($(('#( 0 >(0440! "$(@: :$((+ "+A + 

/0123/0445 6 5/77 6 #+, "& (( "(   "  $( "  (+8   % ($D" ++$ @ :($$ '("@$ %    +!  5 >((05 '#A 0440! @:  +$+(+ "' "$+"(! @: :'(+"(+ +(+$ %  $ ":;#( + A$$; " # ":D#(% :I ": ( ('($ (@: :'(?# D$ ' ( $($  D( " ##  5 >(0440 "$?%8

58 :($$ ;#$ ++(  9 # 0445! +$(@  (+ ;((+! @:  D"(+ @ K   (?# L8 18  "$ " 02 ? 0445!  + $#( "   +(#("# :++(    @:  ;#$ :+(("  +#(% #+( " 0 >(0440! @*   'B  :+(("  +#("&  7;$' 04428 98 :($$  (?($   07 ? 0445 +& " A " $8

38   +$' " 7. +(#A 0445!  + $#(  +($ "  (# "  "$  ++( " 02 ? 0445! ++(@ :($$ '(+$$ %   " #+(

G6   0- '#A 0442 @: '($  ('($ "$+"(  27 ?' 04428

.8 (" +  A " $  7 '#A 0445! :($$  "$$ J K : ;#$ #  " # ('($ "$+"(8  '(@ ?: , +"(( # + '   +'(;(8

+& ( #! (%; (A 0440! ? #  " #+( @: #;(E(8

: "$$ % : G @ ?:' $ (( ('($ %; ?' 04428  +$ % ($D" @ :('($ 6#E#  $; (A 0440! # ?@:%; ?' 0442 ?: D"$  A " I8  : + $ # +(  D( " ## + @! D#(+ +& " (;;!  :, '(+ " $@ % 8 &; (A ?  #  + " ((+$ " (( $($8

: '   " QA D "  " " BC#D! ?:+$ ('  #+ DR %  8  : #B#(+ $($  8 :   :"$ " (( '( " 'E(#( + ((8  : + #B$ " ((8

 (: $($ ($$ % :B(" 'E(#( L8

748 G @    $($ D"$ % ?D8

 ,*

/0123/0445 6 1/77 6 78   D'  :D( ?" (0442!  A ( "  ! #+$ " 5 ?D! "( +$"(( '6+$"(! 5 ++$( (71 ?D  (044-  27 ?' 04458

I (# " :(8 52  J K  "$ ( "$  ++(;##(+$ ; (# % $'  :$  : "$' A$@##(";( 'I #+((  (' " 'I #, " +' @  +'(E( +"( +'(8 : +('   "$   "$  ++(;##(+$ ; @: (#;(#($ (@  (;( 'E( #+( (A8 @:% :' "  +$' % :(($ " ! : +("$  "$   "$  ++( ( @    $($;#$ L8  G H ( + $#( $((;"$ % ' $(('#(:+(("  +#(!  ;#$#(% (( "+( $D8

58  :+&!  G H  "  "$  0;$' 0445 + @  (( :+(("  +#(" :($$ $(('#( 0 >(04408

/0123/0445 6 9/77 6  + $#(  ;#$ :+(("! #   #($  "$  27 ?' 04428

G  ?+"! @:  (++$ % (B " #& $(('  @( " "(% :"#($ " BC#D "$?% (B$ + :$!  (( ":" "(#( ((( " #(( '$ % (((0440  27 ?' 0442  +("&  E( @ ;#$8

 "$  (((  '#AA#((;$ % :$ +  8 :((( " 6 ((($  ;(@:    +A($ " "#"  # " :AD( " ((8

/0123/0445 6 77/77 6  ,*0  *+) ,  ) ,*   123   4 5 6   578 (#" ,9  5 3 

78 $   'A8

 3

08  ?((8 28 (@  +$" (D((8

-8 ;#  +( "  @: +'(;#  (  +$(E("  "$ " 24 ? "&  (;( + + ##"$ "$  A;$"$ " ! GBNOB;@ 1! 144-   !  ( I#+8  "$  +(E( +D$8  #$# "(J = "@ I(#(@ "$  ("$ A(   (+ "  "$ ((@$T A= I+ + @ #(;  (# +' "#" (( ( "$T = +(  D(   "  +$((8 G  #$#  ((+  ( $$#( $#$$  (( = A= (= 6"!  A;$"$ "   + + (  #(&    @: "' "$ 'A8  #$# "  #(   #, " +'! @ (?(!  @  "$ ((@$ (:'++ " @   $($ I+$"$  (<(8 720! 741 (743 =8

 D;;&

6  V

 $"( J

 Q   

 + ;# " +$(E(((;$ I +( ( G$((": ((% :$# +  D;;