opencaselaw.ch

ATA/661/2006

Genf · 2006-12-12 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (1 Absätze)

E. 1 K #$>  #D!@ #$E ; &A&@ DD ; &J&@

"A$$"!$$> 2/./@

"J&!"!$$E2/./7'    . H.2/6?=.62/ HHIN/6.?..H.2.2.. '6?5.5N?22/.63?. 62;+.5..6/S2?2;...//22/ 2. .5.66;H.((=./;((' 22222.?.22/25..6/. 2H.6L62';..' 2//0..0+.../+55..6/ '   2F.=5262;5..6/' 5;.;//H.5../#DD%,.= 5/=.05/0..2///6' .,.  22/  ;B.6 6 ?.  2/ 2  6L6 ./L F.?5.66;?=5/F225..6/'  

H.,62.=..5.66;.;=  1F.7 3=  2;/6.? ?. 5 2 // 5./L 6. 6 .= .. 2.?    2/  2  . +  2//  /6  ?  5  .  50. 2  2// 2;...25222.;'

#$"## 

"!$%&"!$$%   5.?.L6.' %'  +86..553=622;...   /..  A /6; !$$>  H6  2..2   22../'   2..222../22?6..0..2 +2./?8 .2.2L.2 66...=' ,....6.. +;=./  8.0  22 .;  . .   ./L 2;.  2.=/ 626.1 K#!!!&%.'E";;2'!E%@##DE#.'E2'E&@##D &EJ.'!2'&>&7'   5/6../.H./26.2? ..2=.L/52..22.2..2  22../' 5./  H. +   6 .  /0.+306.,.5./L2;.//52+ G.H.660?/6...6T5=0,.. . 2=.;H.../+.5.NF /.H.T.66H6.' .?. 25./=H.62..25+?5 2/2 2  /;.  .. H6  . ? 5/=.  .=/.?./2.1 L .;H//# '#J$"!$$! #D/6;!$$!@

"&DE"!$$>&#6.!$$>7'      523   6 22 + . ; =./  53=6  2//  /6'  C  53=6  2  2T 2 8.H 2 5..6/ ?. /.  F.HH 5HH. 6  <KA$P$$$' ' A'  6.'/..A/6;!$$>H.6/ = /.  &#G=.!$$A.62.+5..6/2H6+ ./..'/66 <K#P$$$' 6.+F05..6/ ?.6;1'JA 7'    UUUUU  

##"## 

"!$%&"!$$% ' " #       ()*+,- /=;.G/!G.!$$%2.3= /..66..6.3.!#=. !$$%@ *+,.- 56@ H.6/...3=A/6;!$$>.62.+5..6/ /.&#G=.!$$A2H6+/..2/./@ 6+F05..6//66 <K#P$$$' @ 66.?  2/ L +  .  3= .. ?5+ ()))))) *+  +  66..6.3.' *./04-6=N,2/.,-'NF3,-6<.,-' F/.,-6, G0'

6 .;6...H4 0HH.3 G.G'4   -' .  =. 2/.4   '=N  

2.H6L//66.?/82.'  3=,     0HH.34    

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

          

                           !   "##" #   "#   !   "# " #  $%%%%%%&  

!"## 

"!$%&"!$$%   #'  ()))))) *+,  -. ))))))  ./ 0/ 1. 234 5..6/7,82. +5.0 9()))))) )))))):.;,=.0=.6. 2;. 1. 234  =.7  / ?  82.  66 6./=../,..,.=62./62// /66.2;.,+=.4   ..1/;7=..2.9)))))): 5@   222.?/2.25..2.9()))))):,.. ?.=6....5=.$,A$62!,>$6' &'  ;B.6//./2/.632/0/2306 2/. 2..=1

!#C#DD$7,.//6.2 2/=. +  66..  66,      . 1. 234 -*7' E'   !> =6; !$$>,  -*, . 2    66.. 5F.,  66.?/  2..   . 96  2G 6.H./:4   95;G.2+2G..;.2/3 F.   , .. ?58 .= ..2.'  ,  66../H=;222.?/2.,?6? /.562.25/;B.6,2.. .8?./;B.6:' >' 

A/6;!$$>,=./..?.. 5..552///6..'H. 5..2///6;2/=./0.H -* .62..  /.  >G=.!$$%2/222;...'  2/..?5./.2.;6.H.2G626? 66..22.//2I565.. ?..?.5=.H.5;G5;G.2  -*' %' 

0.2())))))*+,-'))))))+5. /.. 23   66..     6.3  .1. 234 - 72.!!/6;!$$>'52 .=?/  6.H + 522.   , + 582.  

&"## 

"!$%&"!$$% 9.62/F.:,H/23=5.66;?/ 25..F.,6/22F02F.' A' 

5.%=.!$$%2= -,2. 2./.' J'  /..!#=.!$$%,.H./82.22.!6.!$$%, - 6.())))))*+'   =.5/2/=. -*=.. ?5..' HH, -*5/=.25;G.?+5.. ,? .6?.//6F.8.;.? 2..0.8'   .2..5.##./!306522... 2///6##;!$$$1  K&!$'$#75=.2 // 6 22.?/ 2.?  2//  /6 ..0.8 5/. 2, 2202.,./+2!6'/? H6/6+8.362F5./=./,.2=.L5F 2/.+J$6'3,H.?5.8/.J$6F5/.2 6.HH2'22./?+5./6...=  /6. .  .6.  2// /.  ?5. 2=. L ./   8.36 2F  5. ## ./ !  '  =  5.2/,.5/.2/.F?.5/0./ .6 =5.66;2/...6;= 1?F.7' D' 

!&6.!$$%, -*, 66..F.,  = 2/=.  G  //6 2/  .. 2 5/;.6 ())))))  2/. 5=. 82.6/    !! =6; !$$>,+6=.6.2;..4  9  +2G. .,0.62../6/.6;. 2/  3 F.     . =..; 562.1?.5/.2=2//.. H65;.7'  ,222.?/,20MH

2. . /2 5   2 5/ ;B.6, 62  2H. N6/.  582. F.  5/  5.66;  2 .. .8?./F/.?HO;B.6:'    66.. 2/.. ?  6  5. G...,  //0.566;2/=226?'

E"## 

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

>"## 

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

A"## 

"!$%&"!$$% 5./ . .=.  = + /2  ?L  .. ;H6...6' 23=...2/=. /., 5./ . 2  6L6  /.. ?. . 623 1

"%E>"!$$>E;!$$>7' 56,.2.. -* 1   .  2/=.7 ? .  = /2  6 5.. .= +  /0..  2//  /6 2/ ...6'*.=/265.. H62+5O/..62.,.23+58/. 6.H6./22."/6..23=..62. =.6/.>G258/1.&$7'   G.2/1

"E>A"!$$%&#C!$$%7,.=+ /..JG.!$$%,.;///..0 .2=.H62? .=.2./..6. H6./ = 6L6 ?  = 5. // .=./ + /2  65..'   /..?/523//.+G.2 2/./1A/6;!$$>7, .;6...H/H/+. 2.?1

"%E>"!$$>E;!$$>76.3' &'   -*.L/2/;625.//..2  2//  /6 22/   .66; ./   2/.63 /.6./23062/.8. 2..=1'A'# ..2///6DG.!$$$ K&!$@'#$ .....=#E=.#DJJ1  > $>7' E' 

*  G.2;. /;.,  .;  /;=  .  2 /=.  ;.  22 22/.. +   66..2/=.2?5./.H/..=5=. .1

"#$>"!$$%A6!$$%L./7'  ' ?5./5/2/=., .;6...H2=. .;65.2/..G..?./6./,6.I   0  583   5;  2=., 58.   .;/ 522/..  56...,  6 5   2..2   22../H60/2/=.H=;2 5./L 2;.   5.  5.. 60/  2/=. /H=; 1

"E&J"!$$%&#C!$$%7' ;' ?  .   -*  .62/ 2  .,  . H3  2. . +  2/=.  522/.. ?5 6/+HH5./1

"#AJ"!$$>>=.!$$>7'

J"## 

"!$%&"!$$%    .;  / .0 5/   ?523  /..  =.62/ -, -*2=...+= .L..258.3662/=.,? 6/!&6.!$$%5.5L,2/=.= L2.././.!>=6;!$$>1

"!EJ"!$$E!& 6!$$E7'     /..  A /6; !$$>,  =. 62/  .=.  2/=.   -*'  -,=F,//.2/=.6.H ?5. /. .. 2.?5. 6.  2   6. H.  2//22.?/?8//66?.6L66.3 //6F.8'   52.. - .L.=.' HH,5.=.? 2/ 562,.5626. ?5. 50. 5 //6 /;  ?5.  F .36 5 ? ?5.  0/  H' .., ?5 .    ?5 5;=I/,H2H.6=..;' =F,2  .6=.;  F   H. 56   2'  .6 .HH/8//62;...2 -*/.G.H./ 2/=.2=.L//26.H'   586.H.226? H62;+.5..6/./2/.63,2  // ./  8     /0..'  5. ?5 62, -*5H6/+2.?'  

=F -*56.30//F.828 8.0..66=.8 =.2 ?5F//6F.8./1

"!EJ"!$$E!& 6!$$E7'  

523,22/25..6/.6220 ?2F..6.362. .5/5.66; G?5.2,..F.5'  

=?.2/3,.265/2/=. -* /H=; +  2  2 2;...' 5 .. +; . ?  .=..2/=./..A/6;!$$>' =L6.26.H/G+,.5N2.586.2;/6.? .6.5.0' >'  5..6/  2. 5 ./0./  .6  /0 ?  66O.6L62/.63=../2///6 62;.62./'

D"## 

"!$%&"!$$%  ' 2..25/0./.6/.5.J 5=./ ?....66;;./.HH/66.  .. 2/  .HH/ .  ./  6.3 ..?1 K#$J##E7' ;' *  G.2,  G..;  .  2..2  2/ =..65./0./.6.2..2/./? .622.?/+,6L6?5, .OH22..5.2//22.?/1 K##> D&@##& ;&#&@

"A$$"!$$>!>;!$$>@

"J&!"!$$E!% ;!$$E7'   2,  2/22   2  5./   /..  ?/=/522.?6+5=..2../0 ?.    H. 22.? 2  =. ?. .  ;/ 1 '  ,5/0./5./0./,R#DAJ22'!J#,!D$7'  

=F,.5./2.+6..2.?./0  5. N   /. .  2 ?5 = 2.   .,  .N26?H=/./06+... +. 6L6,H=2H.?5./6.H.2.?./0 1 K #$>  #D!@ #$E ; &A&@ DD ; &J&@

"A$$"!$$> 2/./@

"J&!"!$$E2/./7'    . H.2/6?=.62/ HHIN/6.?..H.2.2.. '6?5.5N?22/.63?. 62;+.5..6/S2?2;...//22/ 2. .5.66;H.((=./;((' 22222.?.22/25..6/. 2H.6L62';..' 2//0..0+.../+55..6/ '   2F.=5262;5..6/' 5;.;//H.5../#DD%,.= 5/=.05/0..2///6' .,.  22/  ;B.6 6 ?.  2/ 2  6L6 ./L F.?5.66;?=5/F225..6/'  

H.,62.=..5.66;.;=  1F.7 3=  2;/6.? ?. 5 2 // 5./L 6. 6 .= .. 2.?    2/  2  . +  2//  /6  ?  5  .  50. 2  2// 2;...25222.;'

#$"## 

"!$%&"!$$%   5.?.L6.' %'  +86..553=622;...   /..  A /6; !$$>  H6  2..2   22../'   2..222../22?6..0..2 +2./?8 .2.2L.2 66...=' ,....6.. +;=./  8.0  22 .;  . .   ./L 2;.  2.=/ 626.1 K#!!!&%.'E";;2'!E%@##DE#.'E2'E&@##D &EJ.'!2'&>&7'   5/6../.H./26.2? ..2=.L/52..22.2..2  22../' 5./  H. +   6 .  /0.+306.,.5./L2;.//52+ G.H.660?/6...6T5=0,.. . 2=.;H.../+.5.NF /.H.T.66H6.' .?. 25./=H.62..25+?5 2/2 2  /;.  .. H6  . ? 5/=.  .=/.?./2.1 L .;H//# '#J$"!$$! #D/6;!$$!@

"&DE"!$$>&#6.!$$>7'      523   6 22 + . ; =./  53=6  2//  /6'  C  53=6  2  2T 2 8.H 2 5..6/ ?. /.  F.HH 5HH. 6  H.6/ = /.  &#G=.!$$A.62.+5..6/2H6+ ./..'/66 .62.+5..6/ /.&#G=.!$$A2H6+/..2/./@ 6+F05..6//66 <K#P$$$' @ 66.?  2/ L +  .  3= .. ?5+ ()))))) *+  +  66..6.3.' *./04-6=N,2/.,-'NF3,-6<.,-' F/.,-6, G0'

6 .;6...H4 0HH.3 G.G'4   -' .  =. 2/.4   '=N  

2.H6L//66.?/82.'  3=,     0HH.34