ATA/560/2004, Genf

Résumé: Refus d'octroyer une autorisation de construire une palissade en bois fondé sur les préavis défavorables de la commune et de la commission d'architecture, lesquelles avaient considéré la palissade inesthétique. Confirmation de la décision par le TA qui s'impose une certain retenue chaque fois que l'autorité administrative suit les préavis des commissions consultatives (rappel de jurisprudence).

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

!!"#$#%& '#()$ $$ !!"#$%" " *++*+ *+ *+*+ #% , - . , / +-

&'()&

(*)+,('--.

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

&.()&

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

&C()&

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

&B()&

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

+ */ G 0 # % G## #" "0 $ " %71 /B+ "#P"@# #"G###''"%07*)C*L L '-BI /+./*# /"#"0## #%*' 07 *)KBL L B*-5/ '/ /

% 9 #*$ $ # "# "$% " " # " #" F 7># 9 "# #"/ #7 "G"0#D# # "0#? "# #" 1

(B)('--C'-G%#'--CI

(C,C(*)),+"J *)),

(.B)(*)), *-G#*)),5/

&+()&

(*)+,('--. 7/ 9 7#0 " #""9# #"0 "0# 7#$ " ## #" ? ># # # " "00# " " ## #"#&#4 9@"00" 7""?0##" 1 /*./*"#"0#7#'CG#*)+*LL*-B5/ 92$D #"%"### " # "0#7# "#%">>0"% $2"D""# " 0#2 F G "9 0" #>/ ./ / 9 #*B#"D 0 # #"9 "#D "%0"#># #"$ " " #"D#$#0#"$# #" "" 4 ### 2"?9# F 9D #$9" 960#$9# ""# %#77#1/*5/ ##" 0 >" " 00 %# "00##" 96# "$""7G D#" "" $#"00##" 0"0 $ # I # "0 @0 $6 $ 40#"00"%#"0 0 1/'5/ #"# #"@>09 6 #D$" G# #7 # D9 " # " #" G##D # 0#$ # #"%"#9# #"?90## #"$&#9 #0# D 942 " 97 "%"# 9# #" 1

(B)('--C '- G%# '--CI

(+C+(*)),'." "7*)),I /; $# "# 0## #>$ 6M $ *)KC$ / ..'&...I / Q $ # "# 0## #>$ M R>" &&&!#$*))*$/.C&.+$ $ > #"# #" " # 4 "#/ "DP %# "7#@ "#$#"%# 0##0#1

('B.(*)),''%# *)),5/ 7/ 6D >"# D P "# 0## #% # %# "00##" " #%$ P "# ""# P#0" # $>" #" " # ? 6# #@1

(*')('--.**0'--.I/ $ # F %G@0## #>#/&/ /! $ @"7# F $"# 9%#"0 0@0 # "#$M R>" &&&!#$*))+$/'-*5/ "# "#0# ?40# # 0 P 0" #>" J0 7#%# P "# 6#D" #%$"0"## 790 G@0 "% 7G #%#0 "# #" @2 4 7 " #" >#4 "# 1

(+C+(*)), '. " "7 *)),5/;9@# "00##" " 0 #2 " #"$ &# "0" L " 9 #*C.L4 #" "#007$" # $G@ #70#2# "A "0 # 0 #2" #"$97#0 96A@#27#D1 /*C./* C5/

&,()&

(*)+,('--. R"0" ### $"00##" ##4" N 6#DD#70## #>/ "D "00##" " P %#$ #7 0## #> %"# #70 P# #" " #" G##D # 0# " N"P@P42 P7"%"#$P4# #7 P# #"1

(*,,(*))K.*0*))KI

('BB(*))+,0# *))+

R/'*0*))-5/

92$ "00##" 96# #0 D # # #0 @ #>"#7# ID#0 " #"# #@#%9# #"# 0#2?D96# #F % /"00""@A"#D# # # D9"%# F 0#D66#%@ /# "00 "# " ? 6# 7 67 L "0#7#/$767D #" "% "?" "A# "# #"4" / "DL 9% 0F0 4&# L # #@ #0# $ " #""# %"#6# "0##%/" "4"# &#0# ##"%@ #/$9@# 9 " #"$ %# "00 # "00##" 96# # " D ?" 2# 6 #D/ @ ? ? "" 4 %#$ #7 0## #> #0D 0 9 #@#"# #" @2 ?9"7G # #@#4"D9#7"4DD0#2D"# " "%"#9# #"/"D $9 ?7""# D9#>#% 9 "# #""## D"00##""">#0##"/ C/ ;%D#2$"G / 0"0 ER *P---/S 0# ? 6@ " $ # "G"# 0 "##0 $D#"07 1 /K,/* 5/ TTTTT

&K()&

(*)+,('--. * +. 01!2&("#3 %7 " # G *. " "7 '--. "4 / " ##" "00##" " " 0 #2 " #" ' 07'--.I !2& 3 G I 0 ?6@" $#"G"# 0 "##0 $0"0 ER*P---/SI "00#D F ? ! !" #$ %" " ## DP? "00##" " " 0 #2 " #" 0 P0@0 $PD#0 "@0 / 45#! %'3 !0"%A$# $!!/A62$6#$;6# !0E#$G@/

"0#7 0## #>3 @>>#2&G# 3 /#"&;#@# %#&# 3 /"%A "#">"0 F "00#D4 #/ 2%$3 @>>#23

&)()&

(*)+,('--.