opencaselaw.ch

ATA/422/2005

Genf · 2005-06-14 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

         

                       

       !  "#$"%&'"  "        !  !       !!! !  "!# $%       &&!!          !!! !# $%  &&  !  

()*+,(

*+-./*)..0 !    +1   21 1& "3### 4 5'&  " 6   " #" 7##51   "8#+99)&+99, +990&"" :7# "; #'3  9?,&+.& ?-.&@/  .99&-.1   " 8 #"77 4A#3B  "+99,4+99/&A3##  #" 7# "C#(5D = EAF3#3 #" #    # " %      67#  GA# '#    "3 6##1  8 #"A"  "   "  7"1)1   "33)9"H +99@&A = "' " '#7# #" "      7# +99, 4 +99/1  #'# #   " #66 4 7"#   #  %""#    # "   #'#+99)4+9901,1  " #66"# "3 G#)," "6+99@1 01 

GI A = &7"#+.7'#+99?&"#"   '#  " 3"J& !"#KKK 1KKKKKKKKKKK&%#  &"3### =12""   '## "#  A# &#L,"H  +99)&!1 1KKKKKKKKKKK&G# "#&'# #3 6 )..1( ## #"%#77A77#1&#'#  "# 36"3 7#LL#"7"3A#3#  3  3"#  '#& )-.1( 7"7# # ' "M 7"# A C"#  ?-.1(  E1  3  7#%  #' 8 :7#  "; "     8# "3 6 +99) 4 +990&  7#  3       #" ' 4 !1 1KKKKKKKKKKK  3" #   #'3 4).9&,.& .9@&?/ ,9?&+/1 /1 

3A = &" #66#"33#G)@F# +99? "#'6#"#'#+99)4+9901 -1  ), 36 +99?& A =   #7"3  "#    B    "'#7# #"1 #3# "#6"8 #7# #7 )? 36+99?"3"  3 A#3B #' D  ( "+99, 0+?&0.  ( "+990 00?&+.  ( "+99/ -/,&//"#  "  /).&./1

(,*+,(

*+-./*)..0  

  3"   AF" #   # I     ## GA 3  .0.1("" 487"#3"  A#3B " # 1    7# & A =  '#  "48 J#DA &  '#  3#   #"  7#    #"    3   !1 1KKKKKKKKKKK4"?N#6 #(#3 1

'# "#""# D  ( "+99, 0/91(  ( "+990 ?9?1(  ( "+99/)991(  " #66A'# F #7#7#1   A   &  '#  " 4  # " +99, A "33  ??91( ""  4 +. N A "   #G 7 & 3#   "#   +99) ' A # : 1KKKKKKKKKKK;& 7  " "3 6##1 #G7 & ))3&))'#&))3#&)/F# )@ F#  +99) A #  '  #'3  4,+/1(& +..1(& +..1(& /..1(  ?@.1(&"#  "  ??/1(18 3#5 " #   3 #" :J  %5G;   "#  "#   %""#" &"# # #" '8&"# 7#3   %L 11 @1   " #66  ' 3 #" )@ F'# +999  "     3 A#3B &A3 # I  1    3"   ' 4 !1 1KKKKKKKKKKK A'#  67## GA4  # " # # 67#GA# #1 "# I #GA5!1 1KKKKKKKKKKK # '1  3 # G7#7"7# #A'#  G #3     #"(G# %"" "3"J&"3#4A#3B 4 "1   #&A3 # #"" #"L#(3& A # +@/   "# 7  A#3B  7 #   +0 36 +99. C= O 2 -0)1++E '"J  "  "  #" A#3B  ""33&  3##33 # 38#33 #A#3B 1 ?1  A = F 3 #"+-7'#+9991   7#7"7# ## I G#7#5"#1   4 A3&   #"#   "3" 3  #  #"   "#   

(0*+,(

*+-./*)..0 " #8#3B "3 6## #7  A   3F #7#77 #'1 91  "# # F "5"33##" ""  3 #5 A#3B  C#(5D !E  +) 3 +9991   " 4 A #"#777 87 ""3 6#### GA4#3# #"A3"3" #7F4'"G1 +.1  A = "F "1 ++1   " #66  3#  #(#  ++ F'#)... 5 '"# # "#"A = 1 +)1  +.'#)..)& !#'# "# 4""# #G7 ""3 6## " A#7"3 GA# #" "#"7#0" "6)..+C=#O,+@E '#L +F'#)..)&7"3 #"#F # "' "#61 +,1  " #66A 3#7 1 +01  ##")@F#)..)& ! #3 3#"1

#"7#  #" 3 3# "4# " #  "4% +.N3 #G 7  " "3 6##1   3  G" #   A3 8 P  A#3B " # 1 +/1  /"H )..)"# # F "5 #63##  #7 "  ##"1 +-1  2   +@F#)..,& #63##  #73#"& ##" G& '"J4 !""'##"& 3" #7G"# AI  "# '#  '#"&(#AJ   #'#  4   3#   # "   #G 7  A  &   AJ  #'# 83 4 #""# !'#L#  7"3 #"#F&A  C

*09,*)..,+@F#)..,E1 +@1  )+ F'#)..0&  !  #7"3  "#  GA  #  " 4  # # L  #G 7 &  G#  Q#   L3  #"A31# # #3 #+.7'#4"# " ""1  # "& !'# "#  :A83#"   L=#;1 +?1  +.7'#)..0&"# A  3##'"G # #" 7#+99," ##G7 1&  #3# G !'# '#"##6"7"#  4  

(/*+,(

*+-./*)..0   A '#L=#""47"3 #"# F1  

3 # '%#46##+.N3"   #G7 &G# # "3 %LJ #'3#57"7# #1

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

 '%&  8# #" 7"#   "#   +. 7'#)..0 AL# #G7 3#+99)" "  ??/1( #  " # "#1"'# AL#'#L # #GA# # 7    "#  A'#   3"   3"# %L   #" '  #G 7 1 A =  #  " H " 4  # "   +. N   3"   3#   " # & #" " G  ! "#  4  7"3 #" # F   #  ??/1(     A 7#

(-*+,(

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

(@*+,(

*+-./*)..0))1  2G"#&"  L4FL1  !   +1   F  3 #' F## #""3  &""  '6 C 1 /, =#S  1 -, 1 + # 1    "#   " 3##  #'+) 36+9?/( ( /+.E1)1  A  7# 8  # #G&(#" F"#  # #"A #@. 1,1 1 +F'#)..)  '#L"#"7#0 " "6)..+C=#O,+@EG#3"#7#"6"L#"# #"  1=#'"# " 33 &4" #?-&G5L" A#G 5A '#L "#8" 1 A#  GA 3 #5  "&  =# A#G 4 "  1  &   "#  " #   #G3   5L  "& 3# L3   5L 3 # G# J "    # L "  #"  "# #GL# #'1  61 2"F# #67&G #""# 3 # " "7" #""# '#L"#"7## #L# CI   #6 7)10++*+99?  ) 1/-?*+99? ,+ F'#)...S

*,+*)..0  +, F'#)..0S

*/0@*)..+ )? "H )..+S

*,-?*)..+)93#)..+E1  

" A77   " #7 4  # #"# #"  "#  3 # " 8 G(# "' "#"7#&"G 3"#7# #""# 7#3 #& '#L+F'#)..+& "  "'& '##  4 '#  "   F#  #6 3##  #7#(C

*9?9*)..0)9" "6)..0E1  

7#& " A # /. #) =#&  !   3I3 "3 GA = " 8 #"1

1  01   #6F43#AI " 3I3 # C

*09,*)..,+@F#)..,EG3  3#  # #L   #4A '#L+F'#+99/"#A#3"# #" "3"), 36+990C!O,+/E&#"# #" A  #'8"3"&6"L "'&3#  #61

(?*+,(

*+-./*)..0 /1   # #L" GD  ( A &#7# A = )?36+99?+.N#G 7  " #  ??/1( #'4A7#+99,&##GA4 A3 ""  4 8 7"#  3"    A#3B  " # &  # #"A #,0+ &     ( A   &  7"3 #" # # 4 G  !  "  ##")+F#)..0&  " # # 7 3# 3 A347"#3"  A#3B " # &# #"  A # -9 #) =#&  7'"6 4  " #66&   # I    &    # G A "#   3#5 #   "#G#"#  8#A3A # # 1 -1 

 A #-+#+=#&"# A# "#" A#3B A # #857##"7#"G 8 #" 7" # #"35 1    "# "A#3B &#A # +/5 7##"7#4G#" C 1-+1,=#E1  

'7# #(&7" A3 G# " %4F"1 @1  "#  8# #G4"3 7##" 7#C 1))1=#E  "G#M57# #"7#C 1))10=#E1   #'"#A#3B # #G4"3 A  7" 8 #"C 1),1=#E  "#85 7#A" G 8 #"  7"C 1),1, =#E1   8&# #"  " 3 #"&""'##"C 1))1)#  ),1)=#E1  

'"J 6"8 #7# #7)?36+99?"A 7#+99,&A =  ## 1 !7# 3I3    )+F#)..01   " #"A #77 #A"7# # #"A #,-? & "33A7#  !1

(9*+,(

*+-./*)..0 ?1   483##" ##& !'#"## 6" 7"#  3" #7 GA   4   &   #  "  "#6##  A77 7"3 #"### 4A '#L=#1  

4A #9 " #  #"7+?'#+999C  7O2 +.+E& '#L+F'#)...& ' "A36A #'#   #G&  ##   6" 7"# "75  # "J  "# & 4  # "# #"& A8#L  A "#  GA  "7"3 8 "3 " GA#7#   "3"7#GA#L# #33  (#C =+,.)-"#1?1+1-.S+)9+-+"#101+1 +@. S +)9 ,-+ "#1 @1+ 1,?+    I  # E1 2"  F#& A8#"#  "3#8"# #"#' D  1 A "#  "#  I  # '   #  #" "5  4 AL  " 3#S  61   "#  '"# L# " I   '"# L#   #3#    "3 S  1  A3## "# '"###""#4'## A  #' G#L"# S  1 #"# AI 7"  "#"# #"GA##  3"#7#6#F#S  1 "#"# '"#%L#3"3 "TA " C =+)+ 0@,"#1)10@9S %#'-/1-0"#1/1-9& I  #67) 1,+,*+990 F## E1   ##6"7"#L# L3 "   "#  7#    " #66S  "#  7#   " 7"# "3#   ##   L# &   "  G  ##   6" 7"# A GA#7#3# & " A# "7# '#L#  C71 1/ 9  S =++?6,+)"#1,61,+-S +99@'"11 /-+"#1,6*1/--&) 1-)*+99/S %#'-.1/,"#1,1/-&) 1,..*+9?9ESI  #67) 1,@?*)..0,"'36)..0& "7#3 A

*0--*)..0)/3#)..01    "# #" A '#" #"  ##   6" 7"#  "   "   ! A 7"#   4  " & 3I3 # (# "'#  A  4  FL3  G# 6&    # #"61 &"#J %LA# '&A"# #" # A  "    #7# 1 L#7" 1

(+.*+,(

*+-./*)..0 91   "# #"G#5 G !'# ""#   " # #G7 "33A7# &5'"#  "# AI  " 1 +.1     6#(7"    #& "     #,)/  ,)-  &# 8# #"" # "#"    7 & "  # A   "   GA A"     "3 6##   GAA" ' L F #4A#3B 4""33' !1 1KKKKKKKKKKK1   "# #"&#4% +.N3 ' #G7 F #7## 1  

7#&  #6      '"# A"" #  A ##"& "7"33 4A #-+ G'"#A #/,#0=#1 ++1     3"    A3&  "  AL   G   #5# # 1    !7# # #"4F  #  #-9 @0=#& 7'"64" G #,0. ,0+ "  #" A#3B L#L1  

# #"A #-9#)=#77 &:5LL& A3 7#83"  A#3B " # 12#7  L5&A3  I # FGA #3"  S#7  L'&  I  #;1  

7#8 A347"#3"  A#3B " # O# 87"#3"  "33A = A'# 7# O !3#4F  #  L#L  #'3  L'   " #661  !  ## 7#  # #"5LL# &" #F #7#A ' " #" A51 +)1  "" A ##F 1 1= +,1  # #L" #3I37  A33# LA=1   "A7#+99,&A = #)?36+99?+.N #G 7  # #L#&  # #"  A # +,+   "# 7  A#3B 7# +036+99.& '#L+F'#+99/ C=O2-0)1++E ""37" #"A #,0+  G#' 487"#3"  A#3B " # 1

(++*+,(

*+-./*)..0 +01  ##"),F#)..0& !=83## #" L"# #63"3 "T7# A # "# &"#   # +),& +,,   +,0  AI   "# 7  9 36 +90. "    #" A #3B  7 #  C#(5D =E   " A3&" #++, ++@4+)? =&#6"L#" A #+,/1   # #"  #G 57##" 8 #"J   L#53  # "3 "33 ##G #(&  A  4  F"   # 1   A =A# #  # #"6"&#7 #GO" #6 7 C = +99/++?&1+)?E(+/# "# " # #"   "#    A # +?0 C'  A # +).E =13I3# #"6" 7# #/?#, "#7A%3"# #"#3B #  " "33 +036+99.& '#L+F'#+99,C ...1(  3# 4  %L1KKKKKKKKKKK21 1C 1?@ E1 UUUUU $ !

 !     

 '()*+*,+-.-/0 F"#  *+-./*)..0  *+-)?*)..0"V *+-./*)..0S 1+*23(.-0 '6"# F )9F# )..01KKKKKKKKKKK21 1"  ##""33##" ""3 #5A#3B )+F#)..0    "33##"  "  "  3 #5  A#3B  7 #  ), F#)..0S *230 F S 3 4%L" 3"3 L"6 ...1(S #  G& "7"33  8  # 9@   #'    "# 7 >"L# #" F###& I  I " AL# A#3B 7# &'"# "  "#  3##  #7&     F" 5  " #7# #"&  '   #67S33"#""# ##G"#"&3" #7 3"J ' " #L " ""3 #S#"# I   "#83#3"# #67&+...+0S I   #5"#"" &#'"G"333"J'&"#' I  F"# 4>'"#S

(+,*+,(

*+-./*)..0 "33#G    I  4 !  "# $"%& '"    " & 4 A3##  #" 7#  "& 4 A3##  #" 7  " #6 #"& 4  "33##"  "  "  3 #5 A#3B  ## GA4  "33##"  ""A#3B 7# 1 2#L D!3"'J&# &!1J%5&!3<#&!1 %#&!3"& FL1

"3 #63##  #7D L77#5(F# F1D   !1 ""#  '#(# D   1"'J   "#"7"3 I  "33#G8 #1  5'&       L77#5D