opencaselaw.ch

ATA/326/2006

Genf · 2006-06-14 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

         

              

           !"#   $$ %%%%%%  ! "#$%&  &  & '()) ''*)+,-&''  (, *  !'()$%&  

*+,-.*

,-/-0,+11- '  -2  "-& &3-45+$!6 777777$-48+$ " "   &"  '9""$ &"  " &  %"( "& " :"*; %"& >(2  

  " $   "   ;  ? (6" "&#  ' "& : " (  %&@  ' "& A "*; 2 & $ "$"%%"ED""2 ? ""H%"&  > (  ?&&   ;%    "$  - G%" -445$   D""'9""&'%"%'2 2"&&" D""  D&6  '9"&  ;% '2 2 :"*; "D$%3&?63(&2 ?  >*"$ &   -440$ %&@" $     6$   "   ""     " 2   "&" "&6 "; " : 2.="&" HJK( " &6 " "D">;(6      :B+ &D66 B/&C&66=2JK(&6 " &%"  & D&"L 3"EB1&D66A $&3& " & E "&  /4,80 C C3&6" %"     %"" &6; $""HJ  "& " &"&& E  '"6 : 2.2+=2    "  "" " %;0.&C&66 00& D66$&" 0% JCD">    :C"DD .2/=2

*/,-.*

,-/-0,+11-  

%"-44B$'9""& 3"$%J&&" "& &$"%6&"D" "&D"  "" ( &"-440 ""6 " %  GHJ  63 -44B     DD   6 -445$  " &%  > "&6 L &ED"-445$"""6  &%  -& &3-44B2   &">:M& "&-44B,+111NA"*; & @ &%&"?(( >663&6" ? "2   " &"J"H" E & &&6"&  *$   ""6  " %     J    "& & J "&D& "&$ -G%" /-63-44.2   'J("   "&"E " $"&" "&J " .  "  & ? " " "H E    &"  '9"" %"& -4402 02      -1 &%63 -44.$ '9"&   &D"6 E !6 777777 H$&D&66 E   "$" 6"E "  "" /- 63 -44.2  &" D">"    "    "&   6&"   %6 " "; $E%&"& 66  %&& & ":O=2 

&D"6 "&%& &3 "&%&" "&6 "&$& %&"&3"%&&"&%&@&"G&" E 6" %& "( T2 B2  !6 777777" " E %2  "&&6" "&  (";6 %-G%"-444GH?ED" 63+11-2   6&  % "6  F)8+/201E " "6?* 6"2   "   (6  &C  6"  ?& &3 +11-$ 6&@ "&&" D%? 3"6 3"$""H 6"  &  6&"  &%63 +11- E D%" +11+2  &6   "DE"6 &   3"E?* L '9"& 2     (6    (";6  % E    & " "& 6&@,6&@& & & GH?E?K( " &6 !6 777777:B+=$3""?D& &" 6" "'9""2 52 

&%63+111$' "&"D&6!6 777777HJ"& J(6  "&  JK(    "   D66 E B/ $ " E B8 $  %6   " &"" &&(&H2 .2   - &%63 +11-$ ' "&   E !6 777777    ""$J"D&6 HJ"&"&& "& 3D""" $ J " 6JDD "6   "&% &" -44B,+111$ &"   "6   "   "   ""      "& " &"- +26&@& " "D&6J    &"3""  J&3 "      "   6";  ""    "  %&@ED"%&"&" &&& & D"" 2

*B,-.*

,-/-0,+11-    &&   3& ? "D  D"6    C&6&&(  +1 G" +11/2 42   + &%63 +11-$    "D&6 !6 777777 HJ "  " % " 6"; ""$J"%"  EC&"" %6 J   "J" 2  

  "6"  H        M " L   "3 DN J&3"(" $  "&   & && " &C  ' "&$ E %" " 6"; "">&3& %    "& " 2'  "&$%6"; ""$"  3J&6; & " "&$6" "&6  " L E&" D"+11-   " &626&   %D" ""J&3G J3 6 & >6&   "  &62 -12 2  -0 &%63 +11-$ !6 777777  "( '9"&  %   G"" "&?C&6(%&""6  F)--B?18+281%" L 2

 D&"     "&  ?"> "&  ((6      &"-1&%63-44. &"-44.2  32 '9"&   &  G  " (   62  &  "   (" "6 "&"%D" %&"H' "& " 3" "   "& %    &"2  6 $   %6  J " UE!6 777777$;&HJ%"   "&  --2  &"+$4$-0 +5&%63+11-$!6 777777?  E   D" ?&3 "  "(6    &&" "&  %6   ""  "&%&@2 &C" "  ""%&"H " &H$"?@C" 2  

"6E'9"& $;6"*&%63+11-$( " "6 &  "&%&"-1&%63-44.2 6" 6$ ";  6 ";$E3""  &"  &3"" $     %"    "& &%$ GHJE &"  G(   & %   ?C&662   & D&"  & "6 E D"D%"+11+2 -+2   +4 &%63 +11-$    ""H E !6 777777 H? %"  &3"( &"6  ""%6  %""-&%63 &-63+11-2'&% ?""563+11-$ %6  3 " 6&"63+11-2 -/2  &"/63+11-$!6 777777? &&%6   "" E&6 -63+11-2 " " &  6  & "& " &  & 66   D&"  ?

*5,-.*

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

*.,-.*

,-/-0,+11-  

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

• F) -?4412*  6&"  - 6" +11/  /- &U   +118 :-B>=$ &"  F)/-?.812*A  &  &   F) ./?/8/2+1$     H J("  J 3 "    "$6" & CED"6&"& 2  &C "  F)-?4412*6&"- 63+118 /1%"+11B$"-+D&"J2 &66J   $& " "& ' @ "%% $> 6&"-1&%63-44.$L &  !6 777777A  * '?("    $  ? "   %  3 "  E '9"&   %6     "& HJ J "  (( E %"$ 6" %"  E

*-1,-.*

,-/-0,+11- !6 777777 E" J&3"( "&"DD $H"" " &2  "; J "  % "6&   "        "   - 63 +11-$ &"  -5 6&"  S  H % > 6  &"  -1 &%63-44.$ %"  & " J $;  $  "& *"2  $    " %"    %"  6";  ""2   "  & D&""D"EH""  ""%" " " E  "" "6 %2 " DD  3D"( EJ 2.2/2+2  3-=&">'9"& -4.4 '9""-440$H "&   " H+P&H "  %J&66 %$&HJ " 4+,/PJ%6  " -56&" &66  J;2 $    "&    %"    "6& E !6 777777&6 GHJEJK( " $6"%" A

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

*--,-.*

,-/-0,+11-   ?L  "3D " "  GH?E& 62 &66(3" " 6&   F)/-?8+02*2 +82  -/D%"+11B$ ? (6  6"2   "  6"   "   ""  - G%" -444$  "  "& D"";!6 777777 " "%  " "  &G&  &   %&@    6        &"H&   " 2'&*"$3" H & &    %" "    "" & D"  ? -44.$  "   DD""E " &3"( &"$E $" E&"&?&   " %'9"& 2   C $"?(" 6"H&   "& E!6 777777$" "&" &  2 82 2 %&@&D"&&6J636"  3 & "% & 6  > & K($ > %"%    > "%"$ 63 %    "&  J %""$ %"%    "%""  D : ', =$  6" "  "%  %"  6"; &"$ &   " "& J  J %""$ ; & "%"" : 2-2-=2  32

   ? " -1 $ J &3"( &" &66  6L6 6H&  %":2-=2J&3"( "&JL EJK( &"" " : 2-/=$"& "&&  %"& &&H"6""66J  " : 2-12+" E=2

*-8,-.*

,-/-0,+11-  2  "3 D  66  C * & 66      ?DD" &&   6 E '9"&  : L   "3 D 8 28/B,+1180&U +110=*H "&%&""  "&"E 6"   "  &%"  & L  &" &66   & &  %" 6"HD&6 G""H " E CC & $?>" " >*"2'& F  &$"?(" DD   "&H"&  &6"6 & " 6&@$ H  6" E "&" "&  " > "  D"6 &"$6" DE G &" &   " " %"2?6&@""&%H"  3" 6 "  "&G""H"DD;(;$E ($  &X  %" "    "3  ?&3"( "&  D&"    "& GH?E?> " "&&  %":)-/+/+0&U +110=2  

?;$6"E "  ""6? D"  3? D$H*"""H" 6&6  &X? "%" " D" ""   "&>H6 " &" "&2&" %G""H$  &" &DD 6&"D" "&& &  %"($E%&"&   %"2 6@   &DD$"  &%&  $ " 6"$"  ":)-/-B1B2B-1&"282-=2  

%H";$ "3 "&H&    " $ &  &"-44B,+111$H"&   %"6$?6"D">&  %">"     "; '9"&  H*" &H  DD""$E "  &3"( &"$ E  $ ;  - G%" -4442 ?  ?"    3$ H?  G%" -444   &%63 +11-$ ?6&@  !6 777777$  (";6 %E & " "&6&@,6&@2  

 " 3"""$ "3&$H&66& ?"6& H&   6"$"" L 6"D"&   " ""&" 2 02  -63+11-$D" " E?&"&& " ' "& &"6&"3"" JDD "6   "&% &"-44B,+111:&" "6 " "  ""    "& " &"- +=""D&6!6 777777HJ"  "% " 6"; ""$J"%"  EC&"" %6  J  "J" 2?("""?>6""  " D&E && 2 B2 2

> 6C"DD8? "-/;(6 " , Z :"*; "6"6T2  32  "3    "&" "& C"DD 8  ? " -/ ;(6    D" 6  "2  %6  ?   " &" 6  D%  ?   &6" E > &" "& 6 "%$ E %&"  "  ((6  " E   D"  ?6&@$    D"6    ""  :%&"(6 EG 

,511,+11/+/ 63 +11/=2  2

D"$ ?("    "" "& & & "6   & "3 "&$  & "  " H ?" "  "& ?%"    &"   ""  &   ?DD"" "&"DD" (;?6&@2D" ""H "&" 6 H&"  "&&  "  L  >"(  ?" "  "&$ & ;(   3& D&" :2 !$

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

*-B,-.*

,-/-0,+11- 52  6&"" D" "&&66(3"D"  ?%6   ?K(    " $  & & 6 $   2  D" $   "; ?"  "  "    6  ?%6  K(6&   2  

""HJ" &"-1&%63-44.$" E "& & "%" $!6 777777"  %6 &" &" * " & " ; $&"  H"% $-%"+11/$   " %2 6&6 *E$" & "E%&"$  '9"& $6&   F)-?4412*E " &  '2     ?;$ !6 777777 J  % "6&          " -63+11-$&" -56&" S HH" " "" "6  %$      & "  J $ ;    $    "&  *"2 $ " %"6"; ""2 & D&"$ ";  "D" E  H" "     " "  %"  "   "  E    "" "6 %2 DD  3D"( EJ 2.2/2+2" 23=-= &">'9"& -44. '9""-440$H "&   H+P&H "  %J&66%$& HJ"    4 +,/ P   J%6  " -56&"&66 J;2 $    "&       "6& E !6 777777 & 6 GHJEJK( " $6"%" 2   &66(   & " " " "&"DD   V  &6 $&"6  "& % 6"; ""  "&" "&H ""& & && " &  ' "& D""  J&3G $ &"  E &  H  "; " 3" "2!6 777777%&L  "  "& &&6"H H" "     " "   %"  & 6  "H((6 %6E6";&;(6  &   " 2   &" "&  H?& &"-+63+11-  L    3   %6       - 63 +11-  &  &H L &D"62&"%&@E D"H?&; > %6  "$&%?% "6" "&2 .2   " "(6&6 V: 25/2+=2  "6"   &  F)/?1112*  & E  6$ E C( 2

*-5,-.*

,-/-0,+11- * &' ,   '     45$6#78 %36" G ++63+11-!6 777777 & &" "(%&@' "&-+63 +11-A $6#8 ?6 A &  H!6 777777  DD""E " &3"( &"E "( %&@' "&;-63+11-A %&"E "(%&@' "&&H? %  "&E!6 777777&D&66 >&" A ?@&6  H3&"A " H?"? V?6&6 A &E!6 777777"6" & F)/?1112*EC( "(%&@' "&A "  H$ &D&66  >  " 45   "%    &" D ?&(" "& G"""$ L  L & $%&"&&" 6""  "D$   G&;& "D" "&$; "3D2"    L  &&(2  66&"  &  $  &" >6"$  "3D$'C9"RC&DH"B$B118A &66"H L E! "#$%& & ""H?E! '()$%&  "(%&@' "&2 '"(   "2  ;%$       (DD";<