opencaselaw.ch

ATA/119/2006

Genf · 2006-03-07 · Deutsch GE

Résumé: Renvoi du dossier à l'instance d'indemnisation des victimes d'infraction qui a fait siennes les conclusions de l'assureur sans examiner elle-même l'existence du lien de causalité entre l'acte illicite et le préjudice subi par le lésé.

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

         

           

  

              !!"# $%&  &     !" # "  $  "%!  " & ! $   

'()*'

)(+()(,,- "   ./  !01111111111$2&"3"3&$ 111111111.45*   &0"""6%&""/ (/  -&%07(,,8$""%"2322  &00"3%&"$" "3"97 "&7  99 & :& '0&"$&" &$ /; "#" & '&%/ 8/ 

00  " < "%" "  ?% :"'?@ =;  07A&0B0$0"& "3& "C#D&00& "& 7%7?% &" #& 0 "C/ 5/  E CB   0"'&"  2'"   !0 1111111111$  ""   F#" "   F#& #"    < ".*0(,,5/E&& $!01111111111 " %" "02   & ' 0 "C%&"0""&&0? / +/   (8 0 (,,5$ F#" F "%"!01111111111?. 07(,,830   %&""3& "C#D "     & ' 0 "C/ -/  (( 07(,,5$2'" !01111111111 ""&&&" "&& 23"&& %"  %" "0/  

 7 $ 2"  C2 %"  7" %"  B      3&"" 3&$ & $" 3%"  0&F$     "9" "&     A"  "7 9  / E  " ?   ?  ""?0  "0"& 2"  " % 0 0"2?$& C 2<" 2"" C %" B "/   2F 9" 2&7A 2&$ ""& 9&/ */  8,0"(,,+$!01111111111""2" 2"0" "& %" "0 2"9 "& " "    &" 9  2" < %" "0 2"9 "&5& &7(,,.: GE8.(/+;:"'?@2" ;2 0  "0   =68H*5*/(+ :&0   9" 0"<    9  "%I&'&%#";  "& & 0&IC2 %"  7" "  I 23"& " $ I #   =6.H,,,/' G   "& & I =6.,H,,,/'" /

'8)*'

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

NEJ8(/(,;/ .,/  %"  I   0" C   &$ 2"   "    ""&J9%"(,,-/ ../  EC&"$ 3IA3/ "  $  ./   A   0  " %   A"" "& &0  $  &   %7 : / +-   &" H&3" "&A"""((&%07.45.' ' (,+N /5?30  "9I2" 2"0" "&%  ..&O .448'"'?@?30 %"'5.,/,(N /-8/.  /&"&0""  "%.( 07.4J+' ' + .,;/ (/  &9&00 I2 "-4". $ "7 " &"& "/2 %#"0& "9C'" "%&C /     0 &M  & &  I &9"0 "&""&  CI2< "&C "&2"0" & &F "  "&

'5)*'

)(+()(,,- & & 0&$ "70""  "9"0" I<0" C "&/ 2&& C$  C2& &"&00 =68H554/(+:& 9"0"<;  =6(,,/':I " 2"0" &NI&&$ 9/2

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

'+)*'

)(+()(,,- -+N.(-.8&"/*)77/.*N.((.*&"/()77/(8N.(.(,* &"/(/(.8;/  7/

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

    2?/   "& $ " 2   0""7$"#F& #?$C2" 9"&"& 2<0"'0B02<" 2"" I0"?  " ?   &"  5 "'$ 9 I &00   "  A "9&0/ & &0029" $2 &" " "0%"&&"  9/ +/ / 2 &" " "02F &I2<02&  02"0" "&& 8,0"(,,+$"A "9"2 & &&  (, 07 (,,+    0    " %&F  &"&&%""&&" : /-4/8;/

'-)*'

)(+()(,,-  7/ 2"" "3$0&0  =6.H,,,/'0"I#3 2"  2"0" "& :

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

'*)*'

)(+()(,,- E"3 @!/ F#?$ " $ !0 &%F   ="$ !/ #"$ !0 &$ A3/

&0 "70""  "9@ 399"?'A" @   /"&'E"3"   " @   6/F#?   &"&9&0 B  &00"C< "/  ?%$       399"?@