opencaselaw.ch

ATA/117/2007

Genf · 2007-03-13 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

          

        

            

 !!  !" #$%  %  "  #$"%&'  #()  "!!  !&$&%% #$%      " "" " *" "      +) ""  "    "  " " # ," " -    

'()*+'

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

&&#3 &&  == &  E2&E&  &% %G31&%&&@"&%&  $%&& & E@%&%E33? D%2  >JBE&&E4&  &%%B4%&%$1&% E&&    4%&%$ %$&  K  2L &    E& $ &% " 3MB E>==2 1 $>#E@%&%E3 3? & &22&  2L & & &==&&1=&3#+/N % %$ >%#&&#D%(//27 3# %$& K 2% 2 41 >&== &  D%4  $ "E7E 

',)*+'

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

';)*+'

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

'.)*+'

),-+.)(//0 E 23&   &   & &>  %2 69# B E& &  D%   &     %G E>D%41  $&  32   %&  * % %# &7*,>3& &2#%%22&&%%91  

=&# 2%&  &   2$& =%&  E%%  B  %  &% E 23& E  &%$3%%D% & #%"E @%& & '2K2  &%$& 23&&& 1

  %$&  && E%% $42 #  %2   %  &%  %#B &$& "E@P& '2K2#%& &%% 3%% &%1 *01  %*.% %4(//+# % I %#B %=&2 &%&&%%22&&%(1 %  H>%H#  %   $&  %$& B;/27  =P#F & #$& &  = %&   %&"2 %"&%& 2%&2  &27   & 1  3# 2%&$%D& "%&&" " & %2& &&   &%$3 & 2%&&2%  # 7%"E& & $& "& & K %21    & & %E &*/ $&  &&&2 &$2 3$$%&&F #"%&4  %  &%$& &%& &%%$& K  & 1

* H#"&%"@%& % @%& &  &%"&# E$2 @ %&&#$ 3$%223BE>%22 %BE$&%2 #%& 2%B%  &% % &% E$&%2 1 &2%BE@%&      E&  &% 3  >%&&  22  " #     & & &#2 >&"& # E$&E&  &% E%3& &%D 72E 1  41

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

== #%E &*; # 2  = %& &%# % 22 # %"E %  &% %  &  &%  K    E&%$&  3$ %  3#  $%&&3 %  4& 6 1 9#  2& %& &%&  4& "E@&3%@%&  &%% %  && &% 6 1 49#  2&    %& &%  &     4&  ==&  B E3  $%&& %  4& 6 1 9 % %==  3  &&6% 22 &&#2 &%%&$%@%&%9#&= "  4& &==& %% & ?% %  &%6 191  41 E & *;      &%& &%  %& %  E%4I &= %&  B & %  &% &  &%%I  "=&& & & %&6

)*(&" # &&#&  &% 2%&B%@&2& 6 1*; 14#  91

'**)*+'

),-+.)(//0  1

 # % &2  B  & %2& & 32  3&   %& =6 "&&%%8 Q**.4*+.R**,4((/R

);;*)(//0 ,* %J  (//0  

);,-)(//0 ,* %J  (//09# 2& B E& E 2 &76&%$& == B& &%#% 22  "&%  &%2 $>&%2&3& %# $%&4&8 Q**-**(1**;'**+R

),**)(//0*,I&(//0R =1&

)(,()(//0(2&(//0R

)-- 4&  &%#2%&3" & # &$&  &  &2%  % &%R@&3%  &%%  &$# >&"  %3& &%%  &%@&  6D%& & 91   '(//27  %4&8%4&3 &%E 4&E$ &%  E& $ &%R $ &%  2 %3& &%   %  &$

'*()*+'

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

)*/+)(//0.2(//0 =& 91  

E7#>%2&%22# %  %& % % &$ $&%& &= E %& &% %2 $ %& &%2& 1    &%&%2& &4"    IB @ K22  &=&1  #   D%  & # $%& 2K2   & #  %24@ 4M &2  2&&  &=# & &   2K2 E>4&  &%# %=&2 E@&  E  %=& # $%& E &%2 &4&&     &2    &==  %4I &= "& %  %&$&    ?% 6@%&  &%  4&    %&   $%2    ?% & &  &91%E %& &%& &3&=& E%4I E @2 7%=%&  2  %22&&%% #

'*,)*+'

),-+.)(//0 @"%  %&$&=#E  #E%==& %   & &%&&"$&&  4&  1 %  E>&%  %    %& 1  2 %  &$ & %    $ % &  &" & B  $ E &  2I %$ F 1 &&#E&   &%=&  2 E & *; #% @  && ?% %2  =& " %  &% & &3& E32     2&7 &3&=& &$  3 %  &&%@&  IB#E % &B%&1 $  %   &4 2&&  &= %&  =& $ = B  & &% >&"#=& "E&   &% & &$%& &%&2%  4#  &%& &%&32 K %=%2B' & 2%&=& %&%1 .1  I %%& #E32 & &2%" =E %& &%$&%& &&E3&  & 2 6% @   &%  2%&9@2&1 -1 

=&#  %    2$ E&$%" B E&  % %  & 2%D#3 4&#%"E@%& '2K2# && #  &% 23&1   & %=&B E4%& 1   4&1 &"E32 BE$&%&&&"#  &$& & E&%$& 3$1$%& #&% #%22  2K2 &$& #=& "E @ &#%& % & %  &%$& 1E&#B2%2 #% E2&=  % &  &%  &2&  %  & % &&  &"  %P  B E@%&  &%%  &%'#"E&&&  % B=& %&&4 =&1     && &2% @    "E  E&2%  B ' 2K21E &*;  &  % K  &&B =&1   %& &%#%  &%$&3E L #% % #&%$& 3$E &*;  1

'*;)*+'

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

'*+)*+'

),-+.)(//0 %& K  &4=#*///*;#$%&% %$%&  %&" @ %& &%  E &;(  Q1    K     &7  %&%  % # &$%" %22 2%D  $# %&$  K  I%&  B E$%&R %22&" K B!" #$%  2%&51 1#B!&$& %% # $%   % 5>A&? 5B    CD%2  5& 51 # && "EB  %22&&%  %  %  2 &7  %  &%     2   %  &%  >%%3&V&=%2 &%1 5&3 8!1D>7#& #!2%$D C&#!1 >&#!2%# I31

%2 &42&&  &=8 3==&7'I& 8   1&%'5&3&   & 8   Q1D>7   %&%=%2 K  %22&"@ &1  7$#       3==&78