opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/885/2004

Genf · 2004-11-08 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (1 Absätze)

E. 07 /"    " = <" Q   "@  " " & ' " %"<"'7 B7 G"; "<"(""'%/ % "&$; ( &%"&,49&. "<" "&% 7 67 <   " &  '$ /  <     %  F  &  &%" &,4 9 &.   "<" "  " &% &%  "@ <%&% & ( CAU"HA<'" 2( 244B   (  " ;"7  &%"    F  :%7  %" &" Y J "&"' ;  '&%"" &%"@ "" &&%""  '%R @J ;  '  "< "  " /" &&     &%""R J    ":    &  %  7 C"  %"   "  "%% %%% J@J J"5&( "@ <%&%&  ".'$"&/ &% "/@7  %" &   "  ) & /('" 9" (""'&%"" '% $/&' % %;%&"% I 7,0-(,42 ,43J7  :<<"Y   " C  %"& Y   @C  % "59" Y   G!     "<&% F   "<"%; """'$=$<<"<%&% &":<<

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

     

      

          !" # $%%%&' (')'$! '  !$ %* &%!%* ' $%&' & *' + ,-  . .  /0  

 /. 1111111111  !"! # $% & &'"%" &""  

  22 &' &%!%* ' *($%&'3 %4*  !'(  & )*+(,-,,./,0 " "%

   

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

   

1,2,31-44- 5+1,65 -07  0 " -44B(  "@ & %  "<%   " ' $@ &    ". &$5"/"&" % /"  % % 9"    

1,2,31-44-5-5    '  <<" "  /'%   " & "7 / "&,B"-44B( "@&% &% "& "=$&"&39"-44B7 -B7 "&B9"-44B($ /"% "@&%'$"%<%" = %%& %" 7&"  &&  8888888888&,B 9/"-44B& "%=$"<$%/ "&$%  & %& "  & $%-4407 ($<<"/%'& /"  " =& <" / %" ;&%""" ":"("'"% "    " &  %  %&7   "  &   & & 

8888888888&,B9/"-44B' " % " )&&< ": A"'( "&@:"=%% " "(&" :"@" % && & @ %"7  /" /"  % % &&%   -440  &  8888888888&::":A% 7C"/" % % "@&%@ &$ A&&&$)&&;A"'7

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

   

1,2,31-44- 5,,1,65 "(<" '"(< &$F % @"&"."%< @("    /"@@( $ 5=5&" '" %    &:% & /"@ %&% 7   <<"  &  '$ <"  " F  "&%%     A) A. "@7 "   %%  & <"  %:%  /":@(9:&" (%A% ( ";'"""  @@ I G,-2  024 "&7 6  7 @,-6 ,*6 "&7 A7 -    %<%J7

""( 9:  ?%  "< "% "<& "&? ; " %&"(  < ""9&"""( SA&?;  %  %"% &    " %" =  &"" " &  9 "  & $&""  "<"&?%" %&";&?%  &<" &%7 C  9"&(    "   " & ?%  &? ; " I9&"""J<" '5" "& &" "('?; " &% "@"<""&"./" 7   ('&? %"" %  &"" " =  %" &  "&&%& "&?; ( ;( (" %  "&"/: &"&&"9: (  @"(  "  " % "   < &? / ; "%&"I G,-606-"&70@1 %<%J7

 << ( <%   "" "'"" " '" %:"   %& &  &" &  "( ?&""  "    &?&  "  " % " '  %: " &  "    %%    &&"'".  7  ""(&"   /; "'?"Q %"&"<" %&"; &  I G,,+  -30 "&7 BR  ! ,*36 O 2B2 7 -B4 "&7 BJ7  /A( " ?&""  "   9:(  <&    %" " "" & / <"   "/ ": " ;' " &"/  %& &?<<"(   /" '  " <"  %    &:% & /"@%&%  '&? @ ""  &"<"   %" "( "   < &?&""  &?  / I%" "  ""% & /R O"(  U :/<A " & CH"/"A:( 7 -,-( V B64R OWH1EX( U :/<A & U :A <:&&(-%&7(70*(V,,, 7,,+(V0-4R):"( &/U :A <:(-%&7(7-+BR<7" G,--B2*"&7B(,----0"&70(,-4@--*"&7-@(,,*0BB"&70 %<%J7  ".&%&/"&" &?F  &? 7-*7-  7IC-44,V,47-3"&7B@J(9"&&?"& ? 7B  7%   9/@I G,-B*B"&7B@(,--,2-"&7,&  ?F " %J7 !"":'?; "&" F <&%&  ".   &&": "%"(F  :S=&""/" &

   

1,2,31-44- 5,-1,65 " %(     & % ;A "/    %'"/' ; ' " % I!"( ?; " %&"  C" Y  "<" 5 ; ;": & '" % Z"C ,***70+J7F([A;'? ; " &"  F  .  '  ; <"   ( =  "   ; %;' "%7 &" F %A"@(   A & "  & &"  I[A( U : & "A   & CA/ X&":(" ,***762+J7 @J $.(< &  '$; "&& G8888888888& "&$/"-44, " "'@="%:& '$ /"  @"'  &". "" %& /"%"& &+6D7

" "(  "@ &%   '  ; "&& %%    & /"  @9 "<    <"( /" <" &";7 << ($; (:-& ./Y\&& ":    "       ;@%   " / 7   ("I J  .@" "" &( ""'/:( <A =@A("&.'$" &$ "  &$ <A ( "   ) =  "(  & /" ]^7"(:+(\.%: / &9&" M"<"  5F '' "  /;('$"/%("$  &";&%&" "^7  " 5  <&  @9 "<( "  &%  5  5"" & $;  = $%:&&$%'"$ &""@/&$@9 "/" %& ;   %<"/7

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

   

1,2,31-44- 5,B1,65  ;":& '?" /  / %  & %" %:&& /"7;" %: ? " % &?" &&%&  "<"7  %" & %&(  " %:  & : &%"     =$  &<" '$; "&\""/^&%9=% % << %( "  9 "<" &$& ""   5; "  L  ' &$  &%"" & $    & " /)  ( %&  "@ /  9"&& "@<%&%&7  "(  " " & $ 7 0* &  "   %& &""  "/ I J( &9"&(&%"&,49&%; " %/ % "&$; ( " "&' "%"<"'(" & '"""&$; ""'% ! /"&%  & &" 7

   

1,2,31-44- 5,61,65 $ &' ! 2 *' !$ %* &%!%* ' $%&' & *'

. 55/ 

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