opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/801/2005

Genf · 2005-09-12 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

       

         !

"

      

         #$%%#&%%' #(%)#&%%$ *+ ++ ! !+   !+

)& , " &%%$ 

 #    !"""## $%&&'()(* +, --./(-$%(( ./ $ + ! -+!!0%(-12$(#" #"34)$%&&'(-' , -- ./(-$%(( ((%/ 

   

56""5"7 1#561 + . 8 .,9,/)(:-$(;/-/,1%-( $(&(./94)/((% &(0:&$%&/%(8 #8 ??@, 22   2   2

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

   

56""5"7 17561 #8 !E(#""!2  222 B.()(1%&%&/A '1;$%/  .L  (&/($ -  -/(($ &4 - $(;/-/ $%$;(-,/)(-%(&(;(($  #""!  $(;/-/  E/  -%- -,(&/($8 38   % #""7   5P  22 1'    >(--,.L)(9$-%         1

  $(-, &&;(.,)-&$(-A878?6(-A878"//&&(./ $-(%%>$(8 ;()$(.-&(E)(#""" ((.;/(%()($-0(:(%>$(9(; C(;/%$&1&S82,:(-%/(-%/-(% 4:.,&(//;/9-$>-%$M($///%/  & -  C - > N -,$&/($O $ &$(($ !"38- + . $%&- -/E9 ( %/-(%  %/(8  ( ( 9  -/(($((--A- E)(#""((./>(;B9 (&$)($(B4:%-!E(? &($. -,$&/($()(&$$&/$($//;/$ +$ )-&$(-A878?68  ()$.-/(($- $(;/-/-@ % #""!  /% ,&&(($ -,) - &$( - A8 78" &$ 

   

56""5"7 16561 ()($%(9-(&$(($--,$&/($-()( &$$&/$(8   /&(-;-((. $/9((.-&(E)(#""" $(8 DE$/;(-%(((;(0/$ 9-/%(($-%$/%/.$//(%/9#6R-%$ $-;$(A8 @,6""8118 /:%-%-/$-%($- ((.9(/L-6R9$%&-E)(#""#-.($&$-9 -%$D-&($(-J%&S8  C&(./$) -,$>(:($--/&$.L&$):--$($((/ &$(>((/-,%&(;($-/-($($;$($-/(($- $(;/-/$-2  222 8 @8  -/(($ - # % #""7  $(;/-/  E/  $ - 2  222 8  $(;/-/  $/ .  4:% -(;;/( -  -/(($-@%#""!-&,>$:($-,8#8#-4:%""687  - & ,C($ - 08 6 - -(&$((; -  -/(($ - @ % #""!8 ;(  4:% &$(  /(/  $)  (;( ://  >( &&(> 9  (;(($ - &($ %>$( - ((. &()/ .( &/(( ,/- - &($)(/ &  4:% (;( (((8  &$(  $%>(&$$&--/(($-@%#""!8 2,:( - -/$-   &$( - )$( . /( &/(/%  &($$%>$$&-)$( + $(;/-/$/ .  4:%  (-(. .  0%& -,&&(($ - (; &$( (.%&($--,$&/($-,((($-,($- )(&$1$&/$(&$($)4:.(&/(,): -)((-E(-(.8 $(;/-/)/.,(,/(& C . ;$;( &/) -  4:% -,$(:( ( :$>/ -, &($ .   -,$&/($ ,((($ -, (   )( &$1 $&/$((>(. $(-, (//-0(;;6--(&$((;- -/(($-@%#""!.(;(C((;&$&($$-;$;(8'( $(;/-/&/(/9/:-.,(,-(&-/;(( ./(C%&($$%&(-;$;(8 8  !" % #""7 ' '   (;$%/  (> >( .,  $((&$-/;-(/L-((.)/($--$%((8 ?8  #@ )( #""7  -( - $((($ ,  -)  (> >(8     (-(./ %((  $($  $) -/(($ - $(;/-/,D&&%(-&)(9$-)((.8  9 ((. /:%%(&$(($(%.-/(($-

   

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

 $ .  -(%(($ - ) - &$( ,&&(. 9 $ 

   

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

 -(- ((.-  />(%/:% $;()%&((&$-(($-,(%&((/.(8 #68   /&$ - ! $J #""7  ,((- -,($%&/    , -,>$-/;//CE:%-&   A-&$/- &4 .(  -/E9 // %($/ &8 2$  -  % $M  &/($$;$-/$(,1%-( (>>( $%&/82,:(-/:((%($();()$(.$-(($- ,C(-,((:;$(-&($1(4.(&$ &(((:B%(;%%&(,&48 &&. ($(&/)$(;;()%-CD4%-%$-(/-&(%1(- (:(-(&DB(,:(9.-%$-(/-&(%F --C;$&(0:&,8  4) .  .($ - )$( ( , &( -(% ;$( - &($ $ %>$ ,/ , & -/%( &$  $%&/ -

   

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

+ -$(//)/.,()(//$/&,-((. %&(( -$ /:%  $-(($ -, /($8 &4 - %(& &/(&/(  ((. ;(% -/(:/  $) >(   &$ - '-%1$(TTTTTTTTTT/&/-((.&()/& L/- $(-, -#@E(#""68  ,;()$(%$(;- /($8 # 8 1%&&$(-!-/%>#""7((.&$-(-/(($ -& $(;/-/--!$)%>#""7-$&&$ 2  222  $(-, -8 ($($., -%$-(;(($/$()-,(;%(1%>$(,(()-D4% -(:/&)/%$&1&S8 #?8 $(-#E)(#""6  ,/$/--,L&$-(   )/ ., $(-/ @  $(;/-/ ,/( >$/ 9 -( -  .($-)$((&/($-($(-)(L%/:/;)- ((.&$()9$($.E(;((&.& /)(-$(%>$%-$&1&S8  )/. & $(;/-/,)(;;(%/.-$(C((-,8 !"8 2//:-/9E:((-8

   

56""5"7 1?561

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

   

56""5"7 1"561 &$(($&((4-Q$-;$(-&($---   ' 0- 2  PW)(0: (F 20X(K(0 -)X:0 H2I 2$K( 2(00( &8 #! 08 7!G ;- '     PW)(0:0 &8 @#G '  #""7Y P # 3 &8#?$(-87G A#!# "$(-86=8 >=   A   &/(/ . >( . (  $( $$&-Q8 ?  'E(&-$(-4.$($>$&&/$(. $ Q( -$(8  ;;   '  ($-(  $) %/:% - D4% - $)($ (;(  ( -  -$%(  &((& - 4 /$$%(. - &($ (:($-$V$%($)($ $;$% 9  $(  9 Q/.(/ ($-./(&/>%Q)(-2)(-&(C G'  PW)(0:0Z ??3&8 7=8Q$(($-2)(-&(C9&$/--Q&&$>($- $)($ (;( &% $ % -Q  $;$%(/ -  $)($&((&-Q/$$%(9Q/.(/ (&/(.(&)C(O ($$Q%&(-$)

-$(&$;;-/-($%&/%/(-(>>($ $Q8 ? '.Q(Q&;$-/&C%&9C%( &$/-Q-Q(-C($-Q$)($$(($$ -%/-(;/-/($$-(1%-(;(C)-&$( #""$(-8>=8 = ,&4&-$($-./&$(.% $-%($-((.-/;-9(&D$&1&S&&(($ -(;$%,C%-$;$%(/--(.  -/E9;( ,$>E -, -/(($ - $(;/-/8   %  ((: &$.($-,&&(($-(;$-(($$4 $%>-$-$%&/;$($- (>>(8 &;(.  (-/&$/-%-:$>&$$/(D;($> (/P!?5?6-E(??3$(-86-.(/;4 (1%L%9, A $&>(/P"5?#-#?$$>??!=8

   

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

-$( (/C A#7# =8

;(()/.Q8#! ' -$Q(&(Q863 '$( & - &(&($;$%  Q$>(:($ - (($ -;$( - &($$%%-%/-(8 Q.()(%/ (>;/-/ --L;$-%-!-/%>?3? -(^W:&;(0W($0(;8

0 -( >-](0 $0; ] (0 -K (08 ( - :-

8#! P)&;(0 -( _K K X(0;(0 0-:X( (% >( %0(> 0% -  -%( ( 20K)$0(;;^ -( (0 - -( P -8 ( (- :%] 8 ! >8 ! P)&;(0-(PW)(0:0--]K-:((:W(K >(>82(%^;2(00(-;^>(-(-(^>$%% &;(0:;^W` 87P=8aX(W(0:- (K(& - :((:W( - K ( (0 (:;]0(:W( 0> -( P -;^ K $: - -( _K -( ;(0 K X(0;(0 0-:X(>;$:8( ;:>W`((00((0-:0 X-X(0>$:X](X(0;(00-:(%)$>K0X$00(&W(0::K;;-^;8(%0 % (0 0 -( '`:(0W(  $;; 0 a0:;^ &;(01 - 0X(-(: 0-: K)X(:8 A$:(0(: -^; >( >0 (: K^W:;$- X- X (0 0]:(0 :(> - ( K 0>K$:X$-(-8 -;X] 8#!P10:0 - 8#7^>- 0)$_K1X(:0-($(08(P (- %( - *$ ::^> - %0( (0 (0 :0

   

56""5"7 1!561 0%](: ;$: (: X(-  (K(> -%( -)$ 8 #! KX(:- :;$- :K(0 a-)X(W(0 - ::>; X(- 0:X(-81-(W:0^>(:0 8#6 >8!P-)$ - - P ( ^W;$-:&0 ::^> - _K K0 >(%%-$0--20(-:(00K]-(:(X-+$$)$% (0 :0- X(- - - -( P K >]-(: $K;^0: %]0(: ( $0 ^W(0 -; $> -( 0:)$% (0+$$0->(>K0X$-(8[ =8  A   -/-( - )C &/&$( -   ' %($/&0.Q8638#8 '$-(;(&(..( $ /:% - Q8 ? 8 !  ' . ( )$(8  -(4 -(&$(($&-;;4:.(;(:(&)9Q8#68! '   #""# Q8 7@  2  &&(> & $:(  Q> - -(&$(($/:&$(9(($-&($-Q1%-()/(-J%-&&$;$(-&($ (/\8-#!$)%>#""7HP35"!I$(-8787G(%&((%

A !"  !@@ $(-8 @87G &$ Q( -$(  '  #""! Y P#6" &8 #3 $(-8#8??!YP?#7&8@#$(-8!=8

   

56""5"7 17561 $)(&--$.,/)(:E)(#""!$(;/-/&(://--$(-$( %(4-&$/- &4 - (> >( $ -1(;(:,8#6(; 9  (($ -&($(-J%$0/-$&-- ,87@ 28

((-$(--%-(($&(&/9$%&- %$%$MQ$(-;(%9Q$>(:($-(8 ':/  %($$:( %&$D/ &  /:( ( Q:( -Q -/( - &/%&($ (:($-$(( ??@ #4% /-8&8 @? =8 2$E(&-Q&/%($ &/%&($ - $ -$(  (( -  -/( -Q / Q$: - %/-(($$)($Q(-$((($/:$(>>(-  -%-  (($ - /-- %#""7:(%&(8  

   

56""5"7 16561   *.  !+   !+   / 

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