opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/757/2005

Genf · 2005-08-30 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

    

    !"   !" 

        

#$$%&#'(() *#+,+#'((, *

* -*   -  - $. -/  " %(0 '((,

  

" 1111111111   !" ! #$"! %& #    ' "( (& )" ( !!"

"!

21111111111

")

*++,-*.//0 % .*+1 %  3* +2 #! 34444444444 )  +-0, )") 55)  +! 6! +--7 !  )") 84444444444 3  "" & 5"!2

 ""! )"" !) "!  ("  !9 ( :44444444443  !;5"! "  )"!2 .2 3  ()!" ('(" ( +.  +--- '!) 6")") 6" (' (" ,/ 6! +---2

! &' ""  !;! ;!

'BC " " ( 962,2 3   "%!()!"! (,/ 6! +--- ( !

4444444444 (  &  #   (

6)!) , " .+ 2

G2   !"E")( ( .- F" +---  ! 4444444444  '") (  ' '") (  HG I)"" !)6 (9  .1 F .///2

-2  H F" ./// #! 4444444444  "! () ("  !( 6" > '!)2  !!" (  ! !" ( ./ F" ./// &' "" )!" (  "" 6")") "")2  ;""  !;9 ( "!" "  ! +// I ('  E (  ( F"2   (6" ( J"!

*++,-*.//0 %,*+1 % &() ! D ( !(!! && " 2

 E F" ./// '!)  ! !  "!6 >  " 2

+/2 3  ! !" ( .G E)6!! .//.  !2   

!(5  !6) &' # ( ) '6"  ()"!) ('!5" !  ")K)" ( )2  D"" ! "!  (!" L(9 ( "  !)("  !5!((  ) D"!  " 6;2

++2  ! !" (  ! 4444444444 ( +/  .//.  E")"" (' 6 "!6"  6)"))!)  +/ ";! .//.  ((!"2 ')!"  ")   D (  E" " ( ""  N "!  6!"! !  ; E%") E (! D"! ( (!(2  6")") "6) !  !)(6 ( MK") (!& ( E=   5 !  !(!! !  "  5  O ')  (!"2

+.2 3  ! !" ( 0 ! .//, ( ' "! ( "! ( '! '!) 6" ;  "!%() 6! ;! 6! '6"2 3'5" ( (" ( ')   "" > J"! 6 !  !2 @4444444444  ! (' 6" ! 2  6")5" ( 

G/ I (9   ( F " > +// I (9   ( F"2 3 '(" > ')   !" !;;"  ! !(!  "!6 > G/ I (9  +G ();! .//.  > +// I (9  +! F6! .//,2 3'5" (  ('!) "" ( )!" " F5" ')"" "E" 6!;2  " & ' !!" ;!  )& (  ("  (  "!(>  E .//,2 +,2  +- F .//, '!) )") 6" (' (" > ( "   ')  5 G/ I  !)62  "!"" )") "! ! 6 )6" E6!;2 '!) )")   ") "" ( "!6 F&' +! P" .//, (" > &    ! !(!  "6") !E > G/ I  > HG I (9  +G  ";! " > +// I (9  +G ";! .//,2

*++,-*.//0 % 0*+1 % +02   ! !" ( +/ F" .//,  !2 @4444444444  (&) > '! &' 'K 6"  (' ") ( "!6   & !"  (2  !"" ""E ( (EE") !"" >  ! ')  5  E "! (  " (!"2 'D !"  )  (5" 6" Q • !; ()5))!"E ( (D)   K ""& > (!" &'> 5  E "! "! ( " (!"   ( ") "! 6 ')6)" (,/ 6! +---)"" "!9  !;; ! ()6) (!" > (" (  ) "2

 6 ( (D)   D""   (" )"" " 6! D (  E D"! ( " (!"2  "" 6" D!!  !E > +// I2

 "!""

*++,-*.//0 % G*+1 % !"! ')"" )!2  "D ('""" > '")5!") ( G I 6" J"! !2 E 'D (  "" )

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

.02 ! !!! ( . E)6!! .//0 '!)  E!) '!%(" &' 6")"))!)  .+ F6! .//0 " &' 6" !6!" !)")  E"! >  !%(  !)!6 ( ' (  !)(! (' "2 3    ( ") ( "")!" 6 '(" 6!" ! '!% (")"")6("2 3'5" ( "" ! """ > '")5!") ! ! ED) (  () ( +/ ();! .//,   ()!" ('!((  !6! > ""! (' "2

.G2 ! () ! " ( - ! .//0 '!  E!)  () ( +/ ();! .//,2 3'5" ( "! !" ')  5 (" (  "!2  6" E!)  6  !9 "!" 6 )( "!""2   6" EE!! & ')6)" !))""   !;;" > '!5 ( ' !" ( (2 "   '5"% (

*++,-*.//0 % H*+1 % (' (  ; ! ('"!2  !6 ')"" ( )";  (5!) (  6!; !) ()!"2 !  & !"  "" ( ')  (!" '!  6K"  ! & "E '!) !!" ! !)"(! > ( !"" > !" "!2

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

.H2   !)  ( 0 P" .//0 '!    !F" ( !!2  !  &" "5)"" 'D" ('  ( ") "!  "!"" ")!!   ('";! .//, " '(" (,/ 6! +---2  '6 ( 'D !" (")   ( "))"" "!9  !;;2 '(" ')"" > '!5 & (')"" "! !  E D"! ( ("  'K 6"  ( ! " !(! >  62 ' !)" ( 'D !")"")"K) " ')"" !   ( 9! 6"  !  !!"  ! )()!"!2 )"" !!) ( (! & 'D !" 6" D5)  "!"" &'  6" ) (';)  ")2 E  "D ( G I !"   & ! '""" > '")5!") ')""  !   ( 9! )! !  !!"2

.72 ! !) & (,+ P" .//0  !!"  ! ) &  !!! ( ! 4444444444 ( +G F6! .//0)"" !E"" ! &" > 'D" ('  ( ") "! '(" " '"!6" ( .+ F6! .//02 'D !" ( ! 4444444444 '6"  """ D   ( ")  '6")!")2 3 6 ;" ! " !  (" > &  ( ')"" ()6) ! ! !" >  "! ! &  ! 4444444444

*++,-*.//0 % 7*+1 % 6" D &) & ")"" ( E")"" (P  () " ( ; E% ")2   ! S  ! 4444444444 '6"  """ D   ( ") " &  ! 4444444444 !""  D" 6 E!")  (6" (""! &  !!" 6"  !")  !6 (   ( 9! !) ()!"2

.-2 ! !!!  ") ( +0  ";! .//,  !!"  "! (D !"E")(D  )"!  !; ( )  !" (  ""!  ! 44444444442  !! (  !"E" ""   ! !" (,/ ";! .//, ( ! 4444444444 !(5 E")"" ( "" E!" MK"&2  (! !" ( .+ F6! .//0 6")") !)(5) !  ! U4444444444 " E" " >  D

&   !"" ( (!   "))"")"; ( 9! !) ()!"  2    !)E)! >  6" ( ! 4444444444 " '6" (  !)  ( MK") (!& ')""  EE"2

,+2  .7 ";! .//0 '!  "!  !; ( )  !)  ( ! 44444444442 3  !!! (  (!! ( .G ";! .//0   ( ") !"" "!9  !;;2  ) ')"" ()6);  !9  "!" " > (" ( "! ) "!2 'D " () !  ! 4444444444)"" "!9  !;;2 'D

 !)"  !)" ( ! 44444444442 3  ! 4444444444   ( ") "!)"" > ')6( !  "  (" " !)6&) !  ! 4444444444 ')""   !"" & % '6" ")2    !" (' ! )"!5! (  " ( "" ;" J"! ()&"" ! ; ( ) !)2  ')""  ! !" & ( ! )"!5! !") 5"  ")!) !6&" !5!6"  5J EE" ! "6!  ""2,,2  - F .//G  !; ( )  "!   (  !!! > '")2   *

*++,-*.//0 % -*+1 % +2   56 ! '!5" F(! ?A )") (E) "  "") (9  +! P" .//,  !; " ( !   ) ( G F5 ("  !)(" "  6% !)(" G  )" " +1 F5 ! ?!"2 + "2 ! " G1

A2

3" > '" ( ')" ( +1 F5 ! !  !; E)()!  .H F6! .//0 ? @ +,/  +/1A  !( 56  (")  +, E)6!!  ( " "!"! !5" !"""  !; " ( !  ( )5!  ! > "! F5 ""!  ( '""" ( ')" ( 6D F5 !2 .2 E!)" > T!"2 G1  2 + "2   '!" G1 (   E)()! !  !" 5))! ( !  ( 1 ";! ./// ?% !9 Q  A & " !"6 >   E)()! ! '!% (" ( ./ ! +-7+ ?% !9 Q 

A2 3 )" ! F5! (  (' 9 " )";2,2   " "!)  65!  +! F6! .//, "!$"  (E" ( ;! ( " (  ( ( T!%("2 )5!( !   &  !95  ; "   65!  " S  E" F!(&" ()"!"  " !(" ? @ +.-  0 (2 +2.A   !  ;   (' 92  EE"  "5 !" ! ')"" ( ") ( !!"  ";! .//, "  !   !! (  () (,/ F! ?!"2 1/ 2 +!  A  !9 ( "!; ( ! ( " ( ( ( '!) ?!"2 G7 2 +!  A2  "9! ('!% (" ""E  ()!5" > '!"2 1/ 

 () ( !! " ( "!  !  () ! " !"" !  !"" ('! ?!"2 +/1 

A2 ) ) (  () " E! !)6 !    !! " !6;2 G2  &" &   " ( 6!  '" > F" ""! & '!%("   E >  !   '")5!") (6!)5" J"! 6)!E)2  !!" '" ()!) ('!(6  () (  ! ( +/ ();! .//, !"  (" ; D)  " (" ')"" ')"" )!) ( !" & "" () " "!)  E!2

*++,-*.//0 % +/*+1 % 12  6!" ( T!"2 1 2 + 

T!! ("  !) (( """ >  ") & !&T "  !" ( ")  " "!  ! ()&" 6 T)6)" !) ? @ ++- ,,G (2 + 2,,HA2  T)6"") S   ( ") "! T )") !6)  " !  !E (TD! T D"  ! !" ( ") ()&" ? @ ++- ,,G (2 0 2,01A2  (!" > ( !"" ()" (T ("   (T;!("! T)6)" (5; ( !"9! (" " T""" >  ")   ( ") "!2 "" D5 " !  !&T K   (T(""! &  ")6)" ("  (5   !"  !(" ( ""  &T  !"  !6 (  J 9!2  T"  )!  !6  ")R  E" "  EE" & T)6)" (5; ))6"" > (T"! E"! " !6&) T""" >  ") %(! &T  !)"   ("  &  ( %2 36!  T)6)" !) " T""" >  ") " ) !  ! !" ( ") "! "  &" ( E" & T("!"   )  !95 ( (5!) ( 6!; !) ()!"  &) 5))!" > T !)" ( !6 ( T! 2

 !& TD" (T ! !" (  > EE" "! T(" "  (5 !$" ;  &T  "  J"! &E) ( !;; (   !"!  (!" > ( !"" E() ! T(" !) (" J"! ) ? @ ++- ,,G (2 + 2,,HR ++7  .71 "  !)E)!A2  ") " ()&"  (T !9  ! !(! (  "!$!  EE" ( 5! (  & T" !("  !6 (  !)""  !" ( E= 5))! E6!) !  " !" ? @ +.-  +7+ (2,2. 0/G (2 .2. +.G  01+ (2 G "  !)E)!A2 3  F! !(   ! !" ( ") 6 T(" ")";   6!; !& T!! T" ()) ( ;5" (T"!K! ( !"" &  T("  ""    "! " ()&" ( T""" >  ")2  J & ! T)";" (  ( ") "! E("  (!" > ( !""  ( !" ( !"9!  ( T(" )5!(> T""" >  ") ( T!) (" J"!)";  (5!)

( !""  E!( (  !6 T !""  > T!)  > T!! ? @ 

*++,-*.//0 % ++*+1 % ;) ( H F" .//0     +H-*/, R  # ./// V ,1, 2 01 (2 .A2  !" 6  !"" ("  !!" !)"( 6!" ? !"" !  !;!" ( E! " (") F!9!A  6" (TF"! &T 6!" ( T!"2,1 2 + 

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

*++,-*.//0 % +.*+1 % &T E"  J"! ()!) "  

!(! !" !  ""  ! (  !" ( E &T " )2  ("    E" &T ! !")( ")"; >  (( (T !"  F"E    ( (" &" >  6! !;"2  D !" !)") !  !" " ()5" 6!  K ( !62  F5 D!   " ! ! > ""!  (" !  " "5D !"" T  "   ( TD !" (") !  "!; ? @ +.G ,G.  (2,;A2 72  ' 9  E" &  !!"  ;  (" ,/ 6! +--- " ( !  !"2 3   &" ( 6!   "!; ("   EE!"  6 (  ((!" %(> (  ('";! .//, " & " F"E) '"!6"  6! 'D !" ( ! 4444444444 " '6 ) ( ! 44444444442  ! 4444444444   D !" ! &  ! 4444444444)5"   D  " " "D ( ')"" ( ") ( '!)2  ! 4444444444  !6)

*++,-*.//0 % +,*+1 % & ')"" ( ((!" ( '!)   5J" ; (  "!6  "C"  (  E "! (  " (!"2 3 'D !"   ( ") "! "!  "" (

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

6  D " " 6" ! "  ! (  ("  )6( "!  ) "  ;2  ! 4444444444 ' ('!  ) &' D""  !" ("  !)) &' 'D &!" !  ; () " (' ; E% ")2 ""

!(! !" !  ""  ! (  !" ( E &T " )2 ! ""  ! '6 D !) !  ! 4444444444  !" !""!  ("   ( ! 44444444442

;))E (  & !)9(   " ( ! 4444444444 (6" J"! 62 9 ! '" > F" ""! & '") >  E  6!" ( !"" ()" ( '(" (,/ 6! +--- >  "! ( . ";! .//,2 -2  !" > D!   !!"  (!"    "" >  (") ! """ > '")5!") (T "D )!! >  ED) ! T")2 +/2 3 ! " (T ("  !) EE! (T """ !"" " (!; >  ")5!")

 ("))&"; ! """ > T")5!") ?!"2 .0 2 + 

A2

 """ > '")5!") " !) ") (!; !&' " !)6; &' ;"! 6    J 5!6") (" ""  62  " !) ") !"" !& '")5!")

'")5!")2  !)6 '" ; &'  D "  '55!6" " !"" " ')""  !)6; ?!",1 2 0 

A2 T""" > T")5!") E" ;"!" ( EE" !"! &T " D!! !  (6( ()R  "!(" )6" ;"!" 6; ! "  !)2 3 " ( !   " [ (5!) ( 5!6")[ ""!;; >  " """ > T")5!")  '")5!") " )  E! ( !""   "2   ("  D)(!  "" D ( 5  !) > T) & ( T(" "  ") T")5!") ?!"2 .G 2 + 

A2  6!" ( !"2 .G 2 . 

",1 2 +! 

  E)()! )(") ( (!"6 !   ( T""" > T")5!") """ TD , ( T

&  !" ;!9 ( """ > T")5!")  ! " ( "" D ( 5 !)2 ;!9 % !

*++,-*.//0 % +G*+1 % E! >   %  ""  ))!" D  !" ( %2   ( !" !" (' !5  (  5 '(") ! """ > '")5!") " !)("  )&R ""E  (")  ! 6!) (   S  "D E)!! > G I ( "" D ( 5 !) !"  &)2  (6)( (  3 );!) ( ";  )"!  ()") ?E!" (  (6)( (  3  GH > 1/  & 1.A &  !; E)()!  F5)  "; 6 TD, 

(  ! S   """  ( !95 ( (!")!"6   " ( (" (") > 5!"! T)5") ( "!"" "!  !) ? @ ++1  +G1R ++,  .+7A2

++2    (' 9 '!) '" 6 !$"!  """ > '")5!") ( G I '5" ( (5  ((!"2

 "D ( "" (") )") ED) !  ! 4444444444 (  D !" & ("  6! !$"!  6! !;"  &' ' 6 % (2  !!" ' !" ))")(  "; ( ""!  ("  "D !" ! 'D !" & " !  !  E! >  & () ( '

" ( ";)"; !  3 2  )&  "D ('""" > '")5!") (")5" J"! E!)2 +.2

;))E (  & !)9(  !! ! !F")2

*++,-*.//0 % +1*+1 %  - *3  * -*   -  -

" 456   7  8   9: $;'  ! 'EE E)()! (  ") ;& !  5!EE