opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/651/2006

Genf · 2006-07-06 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (2 Absätze)

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

   

0(10+))1 2(0.-2 #?*'#'#"!#"'*:#%''7/ 78#!:!'#C8/*"7*/!'"/*!'"7':'#/'#/*!' >!9#>/!*#'73 *!"'#C8**''!!#'='#/' /#&'*!! #.6"K#+))6%####8*'#/ #!:')M;:!';'+))(%*'6)M<78-.'+))(*"! '38!/8/#"*!'!8:"'!!N:!#'#C# /9!"!78:'#*!/'/#8'="!!'!#'""*!"&@ #/3 "!#"J9!J%8!//9/7!'!=''#*!:8 ##'#!!"9##/*!'#C"!"'#%7*'"#!/="#'"% =/:!'!+))(%*'!"@9:'#/''"/#7'#7' !/9'#8#!*!'8:'#//9!!3

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

   

0(10+))1 260.-2 .+3 !"!!'!,<:'!+))1%8!/'#!<#/!"!"#!##/''"3

@9:"'!'="!/C*'!!*!'"*"4!7>!"'7  *!"3  ='# :"'! 7  '##'"  "2==#'= *!# 8 =!/7#/C:"'!#!:'!?'/'==/!##CJ='! :##J#!?2'%C:"'!==#!':!'"#!#C'#!% #I>7'8#!'#*">'!>!93 '*#%"#!9#'" '#!"''/%:'#8"*!':#'!%"% "!!#'"<"!?%#3 8''978"'!*!">"7 *!"='"'"!78!'"7*!"%/#/"#!'# #!:'!?'/"9/>&"'!#%<78C"' 8=='/3 #C"##'#'!!*#:'2C2:'8'##9!% ='# :"'! 7 ## *!" /#'#  * /*!'# : &" "&!  "&"!#!#7%*'"#!/="#'"=/:!'!+))(%'4* 87'O'''##/''"3:'&'!/9# !"'#!:'#C8"!'9'%"%/*!'"!:3 # /9!!/=@!!#'='#/'/#&'*!! +("K# +))63

8**''!%!"!#*!"'#':!"#E 2 ###/%"##/+<:'! +))1% :"'! #!:'/ :  !"!# *'  "'  /&! +))+3

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

%7'#!:'/*"!G *'

E. 5 '#'9':!#:!""*"!##*"! "&"!#!J3 .(3 :'#/C*!""!%8 %!/*"+.=/:!'!+))1%*!'#/ #!   /''"3 8#"!'#/ '#'/  "'/!/ 7  7#

   

0(10+))1 2F0.-2 !*!">/ C 8!/% C :"'!  ' '"!!#  '#%  ##'# '*#/:!>'/!!>'#"&"!#!#"2!*##'@! "#!D  >"!'! /"#'#  7  *!"='"' #  !'9! !#' # % '/*#  ='# 78' ?'# " "  *!"&@ '/  7*!"3 #C7"#'#/#'"%'/#/!:/78!9!  8&  '!"#%   =# "4 :'# /#/ !# C 8"#!8!/3 .63 '"*!#'"*!"#87H#'-)!+))13   % !*"&  !"! >' 5 % #C#'#!#/"'%?*'7/:"'!/#/99/'47#!3  ?*'7/ 7  *!"&@ :  !"!# "# !: !#  #!"' !'@!/%7##!'@!%7'#/89#8'#''@! :'#8H#!'#%9!/&#"!'#:!'#%7'8/#'# *#"<"!%78'4:'#77*'#%7""*"!##: !#'9!':'#/9#/#/!*!">/3

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

   

.3 "'9:"'!U"!9'#'"<'''!AB/#/"'='/#'#'#/%@ .!"K#+))-% !'&#"!"'%"*"/6<9% "#*!/'##:'2*!/'#%6**/##.1<9!A!#3.#3 !#61 B3 '#CU#'"U/#'".1<9!%*! !'&=//! +;<:'!+))(A V.-).)1B%! "'9:"'"*#/%.-=/:!'!%

   

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

V.+,("'3.3+R V.+;(1;"'3.%.+1.-1"'3(&# !/=/!B3!@9*!"/!7#C8**'7#!/!:@ <"!"#!/:'9!A V..;,-"'31&%..+-1)"'3(R 

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

   

0(10+))1 2..0.-2 *'"!"'#C8''#/*#*#H#!'='9/C8!/7 '"*"!##!*!">/C'2'#'!#/#&'3 "<!'*!#"#!'%U#"!'#/''#!#':"<9"':# "'/!!  ='# " *!":/ 7 "!7U' "# ":'   !/'#/ AP % !!'  X':'*!"O!>#% (@ /'#'" ! .,F(% *3 .-1R G%:!Y#9!>#*=9%+@/'#'"%*3+;F>36B3"' !"'%<9="/''"%='*"'#'""#!'! "'%!='#7'%=#UH#!/#&''@!'!!/=#&%**!'#"  * :!'&&% U#2C2'! 7' *!/##  9!/  :!'& *!/*"/!#3   =='# " * 7U ='# *' H#! "'/!/ # "  >4*"#>@ *"'&3 !' #"  //#  ='# /9/ " :'9&%<9"'#%/>/#%!#'!?7''*!'#* *!"&& A V .+1  -1) "'3 6 #3 & .+6  .,6 "'3 >3 + #  !/=/!B3 ' U?'#2#2' *  !"'#  ! "'%  *!''* "7U''#!#'""<9:!'###!%"#%=:! U!/A V.+1-++"'36#3B3 "!78'==/!"**"8!/C"*"4!%=='!#'" !'!=='#*C/#&'!=#"##/*!8!/#""='!/ *!8#!*!:"''*#C":'!8''#!#'""<9A V ..+  +(6 "'3 . #  !!H# '#/R   +)). Z ++ *3 .;) "'3-R  $ %P"#!O !&'#":!'>!99#O%3.)!#3-B3  4  =#       "!7  !:  >D9 U# * '*#&C=#!"&<#'=U"!!"<"#!'C"*"!## 7U'#/!/*":'#/:'#!#"#U!2>D9U*C!/*"!3! '!%"##U!/7U'*'2H"9'7U' *!/:'3@"!%!'#@!*&''#/!#*!<!'*!#  ["*"!## !'"&# ?'9'&\  U!/3  =#  !  >7  U*@ '%  :  #"#  '!"#% " *":'# !'"&#?'9!#!:'!7U'"!:I#*#!:'AX%  ='  "#!# '':' #!:'#!"'#?''#/U!2 >D9%%#>@.,,+%*3.1;#*3.;6B3;3 !/*'"#*!"*"!#'"C9!:'#/=#U!/#  *# ?/!% *! "#'=  *'"% 1) <"! A!#3 -) 3 -  B3 " U!#3(63+U"!"=//!!U!2>D9-."K#.,F- A B%!/*'"#.C.6<"!=#/9@!%.1C -)<"!=#9!:'#/"4#-.C1)<"!=# 9!:3 #='?/##"*##"#'!"#*!#''! # 7  "&'%  '!"# *!" AI9% /## ':'% /##  #/% /*/:#%:'!"#"'%':="!#'"%"' '9'#'7#3B%'!"#*!#''@!A"*"!##U*"4!"

   

0(10+))1 2.+0.-2 "@9#!:'%'##!:'B#%*!?*%=>4*"#>@ 7#CU/##='#%*!?*7#C!#'#U"&#'!":*"' "!7!**"!##!:'"#/#/!/''/U""!3 F3  8*@ ' ":'#  /#!'!%  :!#   <!'*! !**/ '2 % ' 8#  "*"!##9//!!"!#7'"/'C" "9/'#%78'4'#""!*!">8"!!*!"='"C'='!3

8"!!%'==/!"**"8!/C"!'!*/!'!>'/!!>'73 *#%/9#'"!"!#*!'#!/'&#!'&/ !"T8"#*:!'/#*#"T"#"!!"&"!/ *!#'*#/"'998'"@93!"!#78==#':#% *!"'#/  !'! '## 9!% "'! %    !/*!'" /=# ! 8&' 9//!  #!:'3 ' * #%  #'"  >!@# "# /#/ ="!/ :! ' # % *! 8#! *!" 7  !"!# 2H3 ='% 8*"4!%  /'#   /*!!'#"'! %!"79#'"!'!2C #"#"'2*"'#*!"&@3

 /=''#':%   //# "&<#'= C !*!">! C  !"!# "#  *'# 2 " /#&' 2 7  '# !'# ="!/ C " "#!3 !% 8'#!#'"='#**!S#!72H8' 4*'#2!'@!"# '#!:!##!@"!#*#*2"*!/C!/!**"!# #!:' 2 # 7  "*"!##   !"!# 8?*'7'# *!  /*!'" 78 #!:!'#% 7 /#'# *!/'/#  "/7   9#'"  *!"*/!'!7'='#/#/''/3

"/7% !'&/#'78'8*/#/'!#/#&'7 8#  "*"!##   !"!# 7' # C 8"!'9'  " ''#% "!"'78'!'#!**"!##!:''#&3 "*##8&'!"#%!**"!#*!#''!#!# :  '## 9! "# ' **!S# 7 8##'# 8/#'# !#'# * //#"#!*!">%8/###/8!/%"#'#:/!/78 #!:!//*!'""#''#*!8#"*>@!7'!/9'#"!!" '  #!:'%  !'&  / # 8:' 78' "'# H#! !"/ C #"# *'"3,3 /9!?"'/!#'"7'*!/@#%!"!#'3

   

0(10+))1 2.-0.-2

   1  +*    *   " 234 -- 5  6     7 8)%& !9   4 -

.3 /!!"!!:&3 " 4

+3 #!"!"'/!#3 -3 /''"+6<'##+,":&!+))63 (3 '#7*!"/!#9!#'#3 63 ="!  *!#'   7U *:# ="!! !"! "#!  *!/# !!H#   /'  -) <"! @  "#'='#'" *! *' !"/ !/  !'& =//!  !% >Y'O!>"=7' 1% 1))(   %  #!"' ?*'!3  /'  *# H#! *!""9/3  /"'! "'#E B ''7! ?##7/''"!"!#/'!"&#'!'#*/''" ##7/R &B ?*"! *"! 7 "#'= ' #' *":"'! ! ## #! /''"R B *"!#!  '9#! "   " !*!/##3 '  /"'!  "#'# *  #!"' //# //!/ " ##! B &B # B '2%  !'&=//!!*"!!*#!!#'@!!!"!7U' :!/!!'!!:&3/"'!!"!#'"!"!"4  *!:% 7' !"# <"'#% '' 7  /''" ##7/ # U:"**  7/#/?*/'/!"!#A!#3.-+%.)1#.)FB3  9!=='@!     'VV  !/'#E     P!' P "*'"="!*!/#!!H##"#'='/?*!#'#!/#!'#U ##C U/""'*!9!==

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

        

         !"

      

         #$%#&''%  #%()#&''%  

* +*    *   ,-.  / " % 0" &''% 

    !"!#

"#!

          $  %! "#&!'#()%*"#++,-%.+..   +  '#'/

   

0(10+))1 2+0.-2  1

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

   

0(10+))1 2;0.-2 /&#8/+))(%8&'8#*!"="/#/#/!'"!/%7 ''#"##'*'/#7*"9/J#== '#*!%!"T:!#'#!*!''# !&'#!'!J%7'2H8#='#''!*"!=#9!:?"' *!@ :"'! *#/  ="#'"  //9/ 4'% 78'  "! '#!"'#*!"/!?*!8>"78'!*"!#/#7 !*!">='#C!"!#"#7"'3 2"'! %"##/.+/&! +))6%###/:"'!#!:'/!#'7:!"!#3='# /##  "&! >! **/#'! ==#/ *! ## !'@!%*"4:#"==''#/843 2 ='%  "!!'! #/  -) "K# +))6% !/ *!  4'# '#!*!"='"#!:'##!:'!A BC'!#'" 5 

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

  ?*!'/ 8:' 78' 84 :'# *  *!"&@  "2==#'=% #"#  !"'# 7%  ='# 78' #!:''# &"* :  /#'#%  #!S'#!"#3 !"!#/#'#9#*"4:##!:'#*"!5 %"'/#/ 7' 9@! #!"' '/ ! @: E LL %   #  3 "":'!%!"!##!:'/?!'!%7' "#'##777#'@#!3 #/"''#":'!78':'#/#/*'!="'/#/!*!">/C!"!# !!&'*!" 'C =/2J/#'&!!J3!"!#!"8H#!*!="'!&' *"!*6C.)'#'=='!/78/#'##" !@#*4>""9'7C""#!3  '78!!':/##*!":'#"'#C J>9##4':9#J3'!#'":'#"!"*#/ *"! J #4 *#2H#! "' *!''= 78*!:#J # :'# ' 8# ! 8'3*!":'#/#/'="!/"!8/3#/"''/78' 4'#J:9''#J*!@8!!':/"'! 

   

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

8"!!%'==/!"**"8!/C"!'!*/!'!>'/!!>'73 *#%/9#'"!"!#*!'#!/'&#!'&/ !"T8"#*:!'/#*#"T"#"!!"&"!/ *!#'*#/"'998'"@93!"!#78==#':#% *!"'#/  !'! '## 9!% "'! %    !/*!'" /=# ! 8&' 9//!  #!:'3 ' * #%  #'"  >!@# "# /#/ ="!/ :! ' # % *! 8#! *!" 7  !"!# 2H3 ='% 8*"4!%  /'#   /*!!'#"'! %!"79#'"!'!2C #"#"'2*"'#*!"&@3

 /=''#':%   //# "& ! C  !"!# "#  *'# 2 " /#&' 2 7  '# !'# ="!/ C " "#!3 !% 8'#!#'"='#**!S#!72H8' 4*'#2!'@!"# '#!:!##!@"!#*#*2"*!/C!/!**"!# #!:' 2 # 7  "*"!##   !"!# 8?*'7'# *!  /*!'" 78 #!:!'#% 7 /#'# *!/'/#  "/7   9#'"  *!"*/!'!7'='#/#/''/3

"/7% !'&/#'78'8*/#/'!#/#&'7 8#  "*"!##   !"!# 7' # C 8"!'9'  " ''#% "!"'78'!'#!**"!##!:''#&3 "*##8&'!"#%!**"!#*!#''!#!# :  '## 9! "# ' **!S# 7 8##'# 8/#'# !#'# * //#"#!*!">%8/###/8!/%"#'#:/!/78 #!:!//*!'""#''#*!8#"*>@!7'!/9'#"!!" '  #!:'%  !'&  / # 8:' 78' "'# H#! !"/ C #"# *'"3,3 /9!?"'/!#'"7'*!/@#%!"!#'3

   

0(10+))1 2.-0.-2

   1  +*    *   " 234 -- 5  6     7 8)%& !9   4 -

.3 /!!"!!:&3 " 4

+3 #!"!"'/!#3 -3 /''"+6 Y'O!>"=7' 1% 1))(   %  #!"' ?*'!3  /'  *# H#! *!""9/3  /"'! "'#E B ''7! ?##7/''"!"!#/'!"&#'!'#*/''" ##7/R &B ?*"! *"! 7 "#'= ' #' *":"'! ! ## #! /''"R B *"!#!  '9#! "   " !*!/##3 '  /"'!  "#'# *  #!"' //# //!/ " ##! B &B # B '2%  !'&=//!!*"!!*#!!#'@!!!"!7U' :!/!!'!!:&3/"'!!"!#'"!"!"4  *!:% 7' !"# <"'#% '' 7  /''" ##7/ # U:"**  7/#/?*/'/!"!#A!#3.-+%.)1#.)FB3  9!=='@!     'VV  !/'#E     P!' P "*'"="!*!/#!!H##"#'='/?*!#'#!/#!'#U ##C U/""'*!9!==