opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/495/2007

Genf · 2007-05-09 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (1 Absätze)

E. 32 A!  7#   >M 74# A!  #  7"# F#   " ,0 < 6  #A# 76  8 A" " B&?UH?A>11005  C74 !#6  # 78A!"!#=#2-/ A" " 8A" " .* < /003 B $CO  !"!   #  >   !#A # !( 74#7#9# # ! #O # F#  "  8 A" " 7 4 7#  7 4 "#> =  #  %#2 5/  $2  7"# F# #  76  7  #4>"!!!( 74 4#F#<#:%42  9AA6    @ 

&  7" #   (     "#'<#E        !" &   7A! 7"#F###A"=7#>M:MAAA" " 79AA

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

           ! "# $%  &! !

     

       '()*+'+,,- "'./0'+,,1 "  " "#    # 

23 0 ! / 2 +,,1    !"  #

# $$   % && '    ()*    #!"

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

    +,-./+/001 ')+.1' %## A# % !" 2774"#8 # %": 7##% !## !"  #A2 %77"#  "!" 4F#!7# %##79  #=#2 %"4# %4 #"#S?  !"  # : 7#    >!#7>#4#"%"#78 #42#  " ###  ""!# # 7 "#! > #4=  7# 8!#=9 %"B $./3/1. 25O..3.,5  2/O..5,.5 2,O.03.3- 2.C2 !7##  AA#"!#6 74:"#8%=#    !7 7# 8 77"#  #=7##7# F# "  !6 A! : %"9#"  ##!#  "2  # "9!# A %8 >%#747 "  !#: 7#7!### 7# 7> A    7 !"  #7 #2 %""!# "#!# 7478# %77#!" %#9 "9# !#2 #"9 !7#>7##9=!7### A#%8 77#A  =!!7# >%7"9!# "#7#=7!">%#"#""#8 7    B!6C >  7#  #A" !" ##A> %=7##8!#4"2 &!##77 877"# 74 8 A" " 7" 9 #>!6 %77"##(7 %=7# 77#!" =B $./3,3/  2,C2 77  '# # #>%=7# "7#8A!   !6 4#2  # > %# 7"# "!### 7#7#:!##"!# #7#  " #  %=7#   7# =     #7"## 49#   7 %=7"!" #### 9""!#  #:7 7#77##  # A>%#: 2  %:%77"# %7#" #47!"  A!B $./3,3, 2,8+#"A" .))37255O .)--72305 2/C2  #!>A##7AA!!#" " 77?=# =#E#4(:% !##7 !7"!# %## # 7"  '!F! :  # ## !7"!#24:% !##>%78# %"#8%"##  A#477 !7#"# 7 #" 7" 77 >#B /00.72.1)C2 -2  "#9%#!"#>###:#" #AA #%# 6.7#!8/0037 "77#"  #42   A  7        # $27####>%#78 #4 8#4  #@2 C &%9#  AA# 7?(>  "#  76   >  #AA  : % 2  9# 7" # : % # #  "#" 4#!  #  . 7#!8/005"### 9 # "?9   !"> #  9 ###'!8B77#   - #!"  % !# & >=!"# # -!#/3 7 9#7"#!#2#7"## " 8  % #2 $7"#?9#?7" > 77# #" /*7#!8/003=7>">%"  #4#"#"#!# 9#>"#> " !">%"##7 %9#!#> "##742A7"">!F! # 9!#"#"%"##7 ## ## #    9>#7#>#=7!"2  ## !7# 7   %!8  77"#  !"  #"2 7# ##!" #77"##2 #?"##4#2%#>77#  !7### #    #2 !" %#7" 7#77"#AA#"7 #=7>"  !6 4# 7 > !#A  % "##2 &  # ?"# # N!# !#4"2 7"#%#7 AA#"=! > #2 7 # ##AA!!# %77"# !" "#88 %=!7 #7!###  I#  7 A 78#  77# !"    $ B  /00.T5,-72,53C2  #  (    4 >      # $# =7"#?9#?7" ># #2 &= 9#7"#!### 9 ## !8 % 7"# %"!# %7 #7#:!##"!# #7#   #$2  7# '  # F# "#"  7A#  %4    #  !"  ###  #  >   7"#  7#"  #4 ##  ## #4#"2  # 

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

    +,-./+/001 '.,+.1' % # /005###I"7#" #4## %=  %#4#" ?8#  #>#2 !F! "8# %7#" #4%7"#"A="7""!#7@ ( #>%: #  "#9#7"## " # %=!   #8 !#A! = 9 4 #" 2)2 ###:#"7(?>74#!!###7?(>#I 4 #" %#252. 4%#2- 2  6 7 !!  "> % "## 7(?> ! A  7 !!  AA# : 7   ?9 7 %'4 #"  !# 7#" 9>%"7#!7F?A#74  8 4#"O  !   > # =98 # F# "#!"  8 78B $.0/.13O&/00.72//5 2/8# "A"OA2 $./*/)- 25AC2 77# %=7#####7" %###7(?>(#4  ! '# #8!#A! ='# #  "!##78AA#7>%7  !## >% !##   7#"  #4 4F#  #6 4 # B $ .,0 ,3, 2 /2/2,O?Q' &?#89AA  8#AV?9W#  #9 &H4?9!#?AR  W!!49?   4 #V#8!9 E " &?AA?+$H&?B" 2C&?!H  8#AV?9W#&#2/00, 72 15 42 # #),C2  #  =#  7"!7# >  #8 !#A! =AA#74#F#!#"7AA#  4#"8!#=982#6=98 "#"9#  7 #47#"# A# "#!">7##"# # #778 A#AA# 4#"2 #AA#%" 77 "74  2># 4#=7##" #F##?" :!6  AA"##62 7!7 A97" %!8 #"7(?#>!7##794#" #"# "2%##674#F# "#!#2   AA# 7 ?> %7! A%"# # 7 ""! 8B(!7#!#9?9"794C % 7# %#"9#   ##  !A##   4 % "## 7(?>#""4#787#?"7#>"## % 7 "A#= "# A#!77##9!#  7# 47(?>B7A#7!#" ! A# ! C  %"? ##!#!8###A!=69 %# B!F!4 AA"##(7 ##!#C "7# %### 7"#4

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