opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/466/2005

Genf · 2005-05-24 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (2 Absätze)

E. 5  4 %7

* 

*8888888888 0 

E. 9 : %6;6 # .  00<  ,  (. = 5)> ,? <  .)   % @<  %666 (( (    . -0/) . @ 00< 07   &   0)   .)A   5)A  )> .  B,

,, ,7

$7  $% ( $33$ ,  0 & - /  ()C0 AA .- (. )A   .- .   . #  0) .  < (5 @<  $33$7 )(    00 . )0) *.( (( 8888888888 0)!    .  ()   5*  88888888887  5 )0  $$ ( $33$  . "  . . )!  . -0)  . -<5# .  <

0) .C     (0 - ) 0 . <  . )  & %33D . $2  $9 ( $33$7  $9 )(# $33$  (0.   A(0 - /-  -<) < )  &    .)   2% ( $33$  A (0 /  5 0 & <  >( )# . <  .)   $3 ( $33$7 27  2 # $33$ -  (   & , 7 E ))  00 0# )  

8888888888  8888888888 %F  $G A0<  $332 H

)(    ))0   "00 &    .) )  0( . # . ,   < & . # (5 / / 0 (( (. )A   . ))  >( -0 I   00 .   AJ  ; A0<  $3347

 E)  0) 0 /  . # H

5 " 0)0  A =(<( . #C" <  C  )/  ?

5

)   . <  =   . . (  )0 A / .)/    -)) # .)  .  / +  A "?

5  0 . <  =/ .  !  A ! I         "( @ <  . AA  .- 0(   .  ((   () # .  .0?

5) A   . <  =/  #  ))   0.   ( . @ . <  0 A & .E   @ I -(  . @ . <  - 0)0 . AJ 0" <   .?7   <0  () !00"00 0 . . "  / A 0  .- .   "<  .-

0) .C   .   .- 0C<  ) <  .- .   . <   .- )!   0AE7 

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

,-"  . -0 )    E)  0. 0  )) .  8888888888  88888888887    0"( . ) A  .-#< -0 .   < 0)A 7   (/0 /  5) &  (  .   "  "M /-  <  5(P( A 0) 0.   ( (( 0  . A(  . -    . ) ")! /7  /-  -C <) . 0   / #@ A    ()0! # / < &  0   &      .0(# .-  ()  >    E)0( 0A00 & -C .0 0 & /  < )0.0 .  )) . # . %F A0<  $332   /  #)00) -0 )<  P  .00 (( C   )A  A()0).0   .   =A7 )) . $G A0<  $332 . ; A0<  $334?7 47  .0   . $6 @  $332 -  A(0 - 00 /-  A .).  !"  # 0  #  & -0) .   (A / E5 )<  P  .00 ((  (. )A    . -7 6 .   A0.0 . $3 ( %69%  -5 . 5 

7;7 -0  A(0))    $F : & .  .0  7   .> /  . .  AA   0 & -E  . )A  . (7

1%2%31$334 5 416 5 G7 -5(.  / &  -) A(0))  7 F7  .0   ))   . %6 ( $334 -  A (0  .0  7

97 - 00  @0   %F @  $334  .  .0   ))  7  E) / /- <   . (" K    L  00 ( )  ( $33% / .) )  >"  ((0 &  . .  # .  /  /M ( A  # . P . < ) .   ) . 0   ( 7  )! E E) . , . -P #0 &  .0(   # . )) (0. E7   &  /- E)  (0. )  ()  0 0 . A   .07

67 < 0 &  .0( - .  (0( . 2% : $334   @ . 7  )) &  0". /  .0A    . / 0  -7 6 7 % 

 >   <  E " /  (.   . . ( >)0).0 . -E  . - < 0)A  & . #  <  &   <E7  )) /  . " )0  A ")     E! < . -E % & -. . $3 .0(# %69$  -5 . =

?   A  /  0      .  0   /-.0/ < - < 0)A 7

%37  $$ A0<  $33; -  (( /0  # . 0 )  . .E P .)  # .  .  . . )  # .(  A . !'  $$ <(# $334  %3 A0<  $33;   & .  @0) . >" . , . ) . A  (## & )0 7  .E P -) 00 0   .>  0  A . ! @"07

%%7  0  . -  00 (       00 ".0 & @"7

  %7   "<   -"   @.    =?  00 (. A 0    0 .>  % : $332  #  .    ()0 .; @" . )0 .   < 5)0 .; ))0  %G @"  =7 % 7

;G

?7

,  & -  . -0  . %G @" )  # A0.0  $F @<  $334 = Q %23  %3G?  .   "<   .)0  %2 A0<   . )      ")(  #  .

1%2%31$334 5;16 5    .  0"   &  @"    . - . -0  . <E @" 7 $7 A(0( & R7;G  7 % 7  !7;   #  .    +    / .  )0< & - ;G  /   < &   A0.0  -5 . . $3 ( %69% =

?7, ()0) @" .  .-)>    0# 7 27   A0.0 . G # $333  )  "00 . . .    = ?  0  < "  % @<  $332 + . (# (. A   .  .(  . -  .7

E ( . -7 %%9 7 % 

)  .- 0)   . /  < < -0  < " .    0" ) -  . 7 )0   "   0/ E(0 &  (> . . )   .  

 < " @/- 2% .0(# $33$7  <!  >" .)0.  ((0. ( )) # =7 9$  I

Q %$F  4$F  .7 %?7 47   /   .0 .  -7 G3 )0< /   . P .0)0 .   @  <   A   .  .0   @ & 7 -7 %3G 

)0  ). /- .0"  & -7 G3 

 .0 .   .  ()  .0   ))  )  )  .-7 0)0 .  A(  .0 ()0)   )0   <#7;7 ?, -7 6 7 % 

 0)0 (. )A   (.  . E <(  . ( >)0).0 . -E  . - < 0)A  & . #  <  &   <E7    A0.0 0#    .  #   /  .  <E  . AA  /- )</7, A.   .00"  . ()0   / -7 %4 

   A0.0  .0 & -E % . -

   . #  < .-)     .   AA    / . <E / )</ .-)7,  @ ).  .0A    . / 0  .)   <     A "  E % & -

 E! < = * %699 S )7 446  .7 %?7

#?

E ( . -7 6 7 $ 

  0)0 (. )A  =   .  "00?   (.  .  )<0 /-  00 0 E <(  . ( > ()0).0) -E  . - < 0)A 7   "00

0).  #  . (# .-0<  / #   .    /    A0.0  !"0 .-0#  < . -7 6 7 % 

= Q %%G  %4%  .7;   0A0?7,  @ ). -E " .-   E <  ()0).0  0 0 /  (. )A  0 &

1%2%31$334 5 G16 5 F;D  ( . - < 0)A  = Q %$G  %9G  .7 $# %%6  $3%  .7 $#?7  .- (  A /   .- )  "))A  .0(0   / A ) (#E / E " 0 . ))   "00 = Q %%G  %42  .7; I  * $333 S  439)7 43F?7

 / - <0 *   =,!T M ! A< !"!)7 $$$?  .   .-))   . -7 6 7 $ 

  ) # .-P ()  / . .     ()  . E ")07  ))    /  (.  0 . -E)   .-   .0 &  /)A  C) /  !07  0<0(  / ) 0/   () )) .  (0 0  AA ) = Q %$G  %9G  .7 $ #?7

?

)  )   # A0.0 .   E(0  /  . <  -E " .-   E <  ()0).0   . -7 6 7 $ 

 & ))0 ) )(   < . #

0) .0(" / (0. (           )  > . -) )A  / . <)0< =((

Q %$G  %92 I  * $333 S  439)7 43F?7   AA   U   ))0 /  (0.  "00    .  & AA ) / ( P 0  .0.  &  ( > .-   (!0( /7 ()  . > ()  / .  (0.  /-)< .  ) P ))0 &)) .- 0 . A (0.    # )N 0  .)0. & . ()  < .-  .-  &  0 )  (0!. . < ) -.(   . )<   (.7   .  /  . <   . / (  (0. )  ". . -0 .   .  .( )   .   .- ( > "00 . A(   - "  .- AA  (0.  @  N .0  A . -.(  . )< .   7,-  ))+ ((  A .0(0)    (0.  /-   .   .- AA )  >  -)) # .)< / 5  . & -E  .-  < 0)A    ! . /  .-)) )< .    .   0 / A 07

,  @ ). .  ( V )< .-   .  0 / A 0  -E)0  (0.  )) P ))0 . ( > "00 -.(  . 5 .  )    E7  <!     (0.  "00  () # < -E " 0" .-    ()0).0 <  E <   AA     < 0)A  .0(0 #    !()) . < "  ()0(   < .-0# .  )   -E  .   0 / A 0 = Q %$G  %96  .7 4   0A0?7

1%2%31$334 5 F16 5

 -)>  -) . # /  . )!  . -0)  . -<5 # <

0) .C  . AA     )  AA  0)0 (. )A    . -7 6 7 % 

    0# )    A0.0 =E % & -

?7  C  .>    . .0(   < . -7 6 7 $ 

 AA   00 0 . AJ)0).0 =F;D  (?) )A  . ( / - 00 E . -0/) . @ 00< 0 . ,))  >() -    .-   . (" . K  L7

  # EJ  (P( C) .- < 0    . , -0)  . # . ((# )0  -    0 .   O,  ))0   (0. 7 5  (.0  

8888888888  88888888887   )) . %F  $G A0<  $332 E5  0 /  # 0  < )> - .  . < C>( . ("    /  . " )0 . AA0  A(

 ) )) E  /- )<  ). P ")0   .0 "  "00 / K )  <   @  L 5 ,  ( .) )   0) .0 "  (# . #  )0 A /    < .  < 0 0)0  < ((  <  & -0 /  ))   #  -    . < ))  . (" (# 0< . /-  -0 ).)) # .-)  . < (0.  .- . A  . 0  .-  (5/ / )0 A / /  ) )(    <      (0 / . & -() .  ))  . ("7,  # .       0 -E  .- (. )A  .   . -07

) )  @"  R0)  (A ()0 A .   .R E)  (0.   '! . RE) 0)0 0( . (    )0  &  . )   .  @  A  . R0    ) (0. E .R 0 . A .07,  @ ).)      . R0 .R E)   A / 5   . .    /R E)  .0)  #  A (    . ( > < 7   / .R )0   0( .)     ) & ( 0 (  . )  . .0.  . RE)  ) E     )0  . <" .   .  . )  @"   #     ()0(    A( .R < E)  (0.  = Q %$;  2;$  .7 2#1   0A0?7

*   " / RE)  . P A.0   .(  ()>  . . " )0  P  "' &  .   <  .   0  )) .

0) E! <   0/ </ E / )0 =*  RE)  (0.  ,  H  A 5 E E " . / 0  W  , %666)7 2F ?7   (P(  XU  E) /R E)  . P ()> / E A   &     E

0) E / 

1%2%31$334 5 916 5)07  . P ()0! #   ) ! .)  . . =XU  T" .  !  .,!<Y. "   %666)7;GF ?7  C    .  /  )) . 

8888888888  8888888888  A.   C (  )   0. ))A.  .   . C) ,   #  .(0 I  (0.  ))  >( <  0) ) . ("  #<0 ) . < 7  -  ) 0  .-.  < E)  ((  .(.  7

 ))0   . E)  <   # . 0  <  . (0.     AA ) & 0  . /)( . -0 .   . 

8888888888  88888888887  0/ A  .  /-   .  0 E A  ()0).0      -E  . - < 0)A  -) 00 0#   .  @ ).  < & -7 6 7 $ 

7

 5 & @  / -   0  -)> -E  .- (. )A 7

 C   )   . < /  #E !'   <.     .  @0) .- ( . ,)  (P()#0( /  A. 0"(   )) . 

8888888888  8888888888  . (P(  .00 / -AA  .0<))0 )< P / A 0 . (. )A 7

1%2%31$334 5 616 5

 ! 4  -, !  ,! !

# 6/7   8  9   :; %*("<   7 

%7 0   <#7

# 7

$7  @7 27  / )0.  " 7

47 A( )  .  /-)< A(   )0 P .  .0 . 23 @ .>   A  )) ((.0 .0  # A0.0 . ,!T M!A/ G G334     E() 7  .0 ) P)"07  (0( . H ? . / E( / .0     .0  #    ) .  .0   /0I #? E)) / (A   ()< .(.   .0  I ?)   "   .  )07,  (0(   )   00( 0(00   ? #?  ?  5.  # A0.0 .  ))   ( >    /-  .< .0 <#7  (0( .  (    (C .)< /  @    /  .0   /0  -<)) . /   00 E)0. 0   =7 %2$ %3G  %39 ?7

 "AA >H

* 5   Z

 0 . H

  [   

 )  A( .)0 P   A 0 E)    /-& -AA  A0.0 .  0)# /)  "AA 

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

    

     !  "# 

        

$%&%'$('') $)**$(''+ 

, -, !  ,! ! %. /0 1 # ()  (''+

  

# 2222222222





-3 ,!  

!"# $% & ' ( 

()) *+ !   ,   - . ./  0 .( 

 (0

1%2%31$334 5 $16 5  4 %7

* 

*8888888888 0  9 : %6;6 # .  00  ,?   .  B,

,, ,7

$7  $% ( $33$ ,  0 & - /  ()C0 AA .- (. )A   .- .   . #  0) .   ( )# .  ( -0 I   00 .   AJ  ; A0 ( . ("  (  0"(   0 . .- . ( . ("7  /  .  ( .  ( )  /7  E) A  ))0    (# . (     E)0( 0A00 & -C .0 0 & /    /  . .  AA   0 & -E  . )A  . (7

1%2%31$334 5 416 5 G7 -5(.  / &  -) A(0))  7 F7  .0   ))   . %6 ( $334 -  A (0  .0  7

97 - 00  @0   %F @  $334  .  .0   ))  7  E) / /-  "  ((0 &  . .  # .  /  /M ( A  # . P .     )0).0 . -E  . - " . , . ) . A  (## & )0 7  .E P -) 00 0   .>  0  A . ! @"07

%%7  0  . -  00 (       00 ".0 & @"7

  %7   "   % : $332  #  .    ()0 .; @" . )0 .       0# 7 27   A0.0 . G # $333  )  "00 . . .    = ?  0   . . )   .  

 " .)0.  ((0. ( )) # =7 9$  I

Q %$F  4$F  .7 %?7 47   /   .0 .  -7 G3 )0 )0).0 . -E  . -  ()0).0) -E  . -  . -) )A  / .  .-   (!0( /7 ()  . > ()  / .  (0.  /-)  "00 . A(   - "  .- AA  (0.  @  N .0  A . -.(  . )   -)) # .)  "00 -.(  . 5 .  )    E7     -) . # /  . )!  . -0)  . -     . .0(   () -    .-   . (" . K  L7

  # EJ  (P( C) .-  - .  .  ( . ("    /  . " )0 . AA0  A(

 ) )) E  /- )     . . " )0  P  "' &  .     / E A   &     E

0) E / 

1%2%31$334 5 916 5)07  . P ()0! #   ) ! .)  . . =XU  T" .  !  .,! (  -E  .- (. )A 7

 C   )   .     A  )) ((.0 .0  # A0.0 . ,!T M!A/ G G334     E() 7  .0 ) P)"07  (0( . H ? . / E( / .0     .0  #    ) .  .0   /0I #? E)) / (A   ()     /-  . H

* 5   Z

 0 . H

  [   

 )  A( .)0 P   A 0 E)    /-& -AA  A0.0 .  0)# /)  "AA