opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/380/2006

Genf · 2006-04-11 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (3 Absätze)

E. 1 %  A ! (   B!  ! C ( !!! .2& = J!' D4 (  ;2(2   .! >22 ( (! (   (

E. 4 !A 1000 : < C ! !& =    J*&(!2 (,6 7,6D6 : <'

#J>! (  ).2!    ( A ( 2% J!' -6   & @ (.! ( 9>)!  J*& ! &&! ( /, !A,685 : #<% ! . .22)! = J!' 100  # ! J!!2 ! (  ).2!!' J!' 100 ' /  # .2&!  C   ! A>!)! 2 ! ()2 = J2!>% J!!2 ).2!! . B! (  !  ( ! ( C J).? ( J2   ()   9>'  J% ))! ( (2.L! (  (27=%  ! 2!! 2 ( $ !! ( 9&'  A ( 2 ! ( ).2!! =  (  . B! ( .2! '

# ).2! . 7> (  (J.9 !  2!A' 1' 2.2 ( ;) ! (2 2>@%   ! &A :!' D4 ! 40  <' /'  !> .!   (! ( $!22 =  .  +> . $* &(!2 (; ..2)! ( = $+! ($ & &2+ 2C.2 ($ +>)! ( &! !)!C'

8' @ !) ( $!' 1,  M

EJ2  (!% (J.9  ! C (  ;2(2% @)? @ (!   A . @  !&!2 !&  ).  !&@ +A!% .)!  )2  .!2 ( >% . 2!(% ..( )2!   .;!%  = (; (J!);!' ; ( .!+9 (!% ( !! ! ( ..! .!  ! .  +> . J C  )? @ !  ).2)!).!! ())2( ( 2(.!!' J2 C% . ! (  &(!2%  A (J.. K!@ .  (2.% 2!A ( !! &  !>  (2&..  !) .%  (!%  2>(=  .!2 ( >% = ( !)? @ ;)2)! =  ! CJ2!A  ;2(2'

344531004 * D35 * J .( +> )? @ (J)(9 ). ! (2C! !  )!  !! ..2!2   .G!' J2 ..! ; ..2)! (J !)(9' J2 = C )? @  2!2 2  ).)! (JA7! CJ ! (K C2)G) J J2!! . &( .! G! ! ( .!. @;E'

# $!',8 ( 9>)!  $*&(!2 : <%  ! ()? @ &2 = J!' 1,  ;! JA7! (J ( ( (2.!)!;2(2 ( J!2% N ! 2>)! 2(!2 ( (.! ).2)! ! !))!  ) ()? @'

$!' 1 ', ( $( ( 16 &)A,654 !  ) ()? @ . J*&(!2 : <% .2 C$! (! @)? @% (  )!;@2% .  !  @%  2 C  ! A .  (2.% 2!A ( !! &  !>  (2&..  !) .' $2 $ (! C$= ()? @ ($)(9 ). ! (2C!O  ..! ; ..2)! ($ !)(9 :!' 1 '

E. 8  <'

 .!,0'0D (  !  @ ( $ % ! @.2)! .2&  !;)! ( &2+ =)! 2!2 . $&(!2'

$;;;2(2 (   :" #<% (    )? @ ( $ %  +',0'0D'D% .2 C  K! 2 =  AB! ( &! !)!C   ($+! ($ & &!% $! )A2 . $  C   ! ( 2 . $&(!2'

D' )2( ( #  !% = 7! !!% .2  C! ( &  $2&! (2! .    % !!>! !)!  (>2 ( )!!;! ! C  (! ($ &2+ 2C.2 ($ A! = &! !)!C .&!  G! &>2'

4' % =  ! ( (@ ..!)2(@;>! (  (%  ?   ( !! C$ $2!!%  !) !)!C $! . ( (.A . .)!!  ! ( ('  ;;!%   ! C ;) ( ! ! &2% C $!+ $! .  .2!% C ;!;@*@! ! ;;!'

$.9  7.(%  ..C ()9 >22 (  () ( $*&(!2  ..  C  &( (!% &! ( C2 ( .!! ( $*&(!2% !.( (  .. +; !!  C$ .! A)! !!( (  . !!2 )@ .A  2C (  &(!2 : ",1/  1// (' /%,,5  15- (' 1A% 800 (' 8A !  G! !2O   *P "P %  ;+! F #A!&!Q!>% "A>,666% .' D5% DD, ! D51O   %  R)!AS!.F.)

344531004 * 435 * +QF+ #F&+>+!% !+9 R+,66D% .' 4,O T *  # % (>!F UA ( &(&+> VW (!' 1-  % .' 11,<'

 $! . !!2 C  ! A!  >G ( ;! (  !!%  A ( 2 (9 .(!%

 & (  7.( )!2 C$ ;;! . )! !! >G ! @>A  $2!!'

  %);(2% (!* G! 7!2'

344531004 * 535 *  + 0  "* +  *+ +

! 123   4  5   67 .$&  8   3 

,' 2   &A' ! 3

1'  7!!' /' ! C  .2( ! >!!'

8' ;)  .! (  CJ .&!;)  !  .2! G! (  (2 ( /0 7 (9  !;! . . ))(2 (2  A;2(2 ( % #+QF+;C 4% 4008   %  ! @).'  (2  .! G! .>2' )2) (! M < (C @!)! C (2  ! (2 A!   ! . (  (2 !!C2O A< @. . C)!;  !) .& ()( !! ! (2O < .!  >!   (  .2!!' # )2)  !! .  ! 22)! 2)22  !! < A< ! < *(%  A;2(2 (   . . ! )!9    CJ (& (2 &A' )2) ( )!  )? ( .&% C ! 7!%  C  (2 !!C2 ! J&.. ( C   2!2 @.2(2  ! :!',/1%,04 !,0- <'

 >;;9

*  R

 .2(!

 X     . ;) ( .2! G! ! !;2 @ .!  CJ= J;;;2(2 (   .  >;; 

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

    

    ! "  ! 

        

#$$%#&''$ #()'#&''$ 

* "* +  *+ + +, - . ! .. / &''$

  



!

!

""

   #

## #  # 

$   %  &' ()(*+,-%  .! /,00%,1,,    1 !)2

344531004 * 135 *  0,'  % 2 ,650% ()2  "%  2!2 &!) ($ (! (  ! ),660'

  (2.2  1, 7& 1008 .9 ( $""

   #

## #  # 

$    :*.9 ;;

  ($)? @% !  AB! = &! !)!C'  9> C$=  ! (  (!%   A  !)!) (  7)A >+ ! C$  ! (& ( .  . (;; ($! $)A?> (  &!'   7! =  ()(  ..! 2!A .  

 7!,660% @ !) (C * ;) C $!22  .2!2  !)!) (  7)A >+ &;! ( !A !!2 . !2?!+9% ( . (  +& >+ & 2 !( ! & !!2 +>)! !  .! ( A! !2 !!2 . >;; !2' 1' (!2 . $;;

%  #      

 :#  ( &! ! +!  &2+ !)!CE'   (9  ))C2  (2 ( )2( !+.2(! ! !2.!+'

D' !>2 . $;;

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

344531004 * /35 * &! !)!C'  9& C  )!!;! ! C!( ! C $2&! &  &  .%  & ( !!  .9 &)! . )A@ ! !! ! ( !'  .2 C$ !+(9 !A* !> (& G! ..2'  !  C  .!! +A!!  (   ( !&% 2!!  !7! ($ &>! ()!  &!%  .!2 ( !& !)! >H = $! ($ &! = AB! = &! !)!C'

4'   ..! (2 = $;;

  10 &)A 1008%   (% !2.!+% (! & !!2  )!! ( )A!2 (  +& >+ ! .2  &;! > ( $!! !A*! >+' 5' &!2 =  (2!)%  #% .9 & !>2  .2! )2( ( 2(.!!  #%  !!2 C$ $.9% ;) 2!! &2% C $!+ $2!! . !!2) )!  (&% C  !!)2C .! ! )!2 (  +& (  (! .  ( ! & (  !&% $2!! . .).!! C  ( (2.)! = .(2 =  & C!(% ! C $2 7!  >;'    (22 C$ 2!! 2>!) ( ()( = $2%)G)  .@ ($ ! ;;!% ( )!  >G;! . 2(  ())>'    ! (9  . .. .!!%  $2!!% ($! )!9  )? @ ()(2'

-'  (2  ..! ( 18 7& 1004% $;;

  ;)2  (2 ( ; (,D .!)A 1008'

6' $!22  !7!2   1/;2& 1004 ! (! (2'   2;9 @.2)! @ ..! (    ! ( 

! > C    (&!  &  (!%  C!   ($> (  . .& (2A?'  .. ;  .@ ($ AB! = &! !)!C% ! /$D00 I"'

,0'  

2. (,4) 1004% $;;

 !  7! ( '

,,'    2!2 !) = $!22 !   >(2 = 7>'

 ,'   >&  J>! 7( : % (!  .2(! !  &*.2(!% D ..2! !,4 7>  :!', !'

! D4

  % .  A;2(2  15 7& 1008 : ",/0 ,04 &  (.!2% ,/;2&%  (.! !! >! .)!!!  A ! (   ( 2>   = ! 7> !!% % ( J!!! ( J2! ( &@ 7> '

;)2)! = $!' D4  ', !'  +' 1 %  A ! (   B!  ! C ( !!! .2& = J!' D4 (  ;2(2   .! >22 ( (! (   ( 4 !A 1000 : ! (  ).2!    ( A ( 2% J!' -6   & @ (.! ( 9>)!  J*& ! &&! ( /, !A,685 : # !)! 2 ! ()2 = J2!>% J!!2 ).2!! . B! (  !  ( ! ( C J).? ( J2   ()   9>'  J% ))! ( (2.L! (  (27=%  ! 2!! 2 ( $ !! ( 9&'  A ( 2 ! ( ).2!! =  (  . B! ( .2! '

# ).2! . 7> (  (J.9 !  2!A' 1' 2.2 ( ;) ! (2 2>@%   ! &A :!' D4 ! 40   .!   (! ( $!22 =  .  +> . $* &(!2 (; ..2)! ( = $+! ($ & &2+ 2C.2 ($ +>)! ( &! !)!C'

8' @ !) ( $!' 1,  M

EJ2  (!% (J.9  ! C (  ;2(2% @)? @ (!   A . @  !&!2 !&  ).  !&@ +A!% .)!  )2  .!2 ( >% . 2!(% ..( )2!   .;!%  = (; (J!);!' ; ( .!+9 (!% ( !! ! ( ..! .!  ! .  +> . J C  )? @ !  ).2)!).!! ())2( ( 2(.!!' J2 C% . ! (  &(!2%  A (J.. K!@ .  (2.% 2!A ( !! &  !>  (2&..  !) .%  (!%  2>(=  .!2 ( >% = ( !)? @ ;)2)! =  ! CJ2!A  ;2(2'

344531004 * D35 * J .( +> )? @ (J)(9 ). ! (2C! !  )!  !! ..2!2   .G!' J2 ..! ; ..2)! (J !)(9' J2 = C )? @  2!2 2  ).)! (JA7! CJ ! (K C2)G) J J2!! . &( .! G! ! ( .!. @;E'

# $!',8 ( 9>)!  $*&(!2 :  )! 2(!2 ( (.! ).2)! ! !))!  ) ()? @'

$!' 1 ', ( $( ( 16 &)A,654 !  ) ()? @ . J*&(!2 :    (2&..  !) .' $2 $ (! C$= ()? @ ($)(9 ). ! (2C!O  ..! ; ..2)! ($ !)(9 :!' 1 ' 8   ! !)!  (>2 ( )!!;! ! C  (! ($ &2+ 2C.2 ($ A! = &! !)!C .&!  G! &>2'

4' % =  ! ( (@ ..!)2(@;>! (  (%  ?   ( !! C$ $2!!%  !) !)!C $! . ( (.A . .)!!  ! ( ('  ;;!%   ! C ;) ( ! ! &2% C $!+ $! .  .2!% C ;!;@*@! ! ;;!'

$.9  7.(%  ..C ()9 >22 (  () ( $*&(!2  ..  C  &( (!% &! ( C2 ( .!! ( $*&(!2% !.( (  .. +; !!  C$ .! A)! !!( (  . !!2 )@ .A  2C (  &(!2 : ",1/  1// (' /%,,5  15- (' 1A% 800 (' 8A !  G! !2O   *P "P %  ;+! F #A!&!Q!>% "A>,666% .' D5% DD, ! D51O   %  R)!AS!.F.)

344531004 * 435 * +QF+ #F&+>+!% !+9 R+,66D% .' 4,O T *  # % (>!F UA ( &(&+> VW (!' 1-  % .' 11, G ( ;! (  !!%  A ( 2 (9 .(!%

 & (  7.( )!2 C$ ;;! . )! !! >G ! @>A  $2!!'

  %);(2% (!* G! 7!2'

344531004 * 535 *  + 0  "* +  *+ +

! 123   4  5   67 .$&  8   3 

,' 2   &A' ! 3

1'  7!!' /' ! C  .2( ! >!!'

8' ;)  .! (  CJ .&!;)  !  .2! G! (  (2 ( /0 7 (9  !;! . . ))(2 (2  A;2(2 ( % #+QF+;C 4% 4008   %  ! @).'  (2  .! G! .>2' )2) (! M  !   (  .2!!' # )2)  !! .  ! 22)! 2)22  !!  ;;9

*  R

 .2(!

 X     . ;) ( .2! G! ! !;2 @ .!  CJ= J;;;2(2 (   .  >;;