opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/29/2005

Genf · 2005-01-19 · Deutsch GE
Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

                      !

      

         "#$%$"&''& "&("&'')  * +,* -  * -+).  /0 1 #(2 &'') 

   33333333333 

 -44+ -  5*6+7++   !"#$%$$&'$ (()*

   

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

   

+$,-,+.% /-+$-/ 3)(') $F...50 'E55*G *)4%..$0 3& 3)()3 *)4%..$6**')>()* 6  ;(*)) K$"5*'(-'(%..%0$H?( %..% ( 6)*  6  ();  (  )3( 5( 64( )()  0 #0 D' 6(**6   ) *; ( )3(   9(4:7(/3&(8%$K%..% 3* ; ) $F...50  6*?>6;A(( *0 A3(>*('(!* ' $?'($""@-.4%...  6 *(( 6/('((*>6*((A *((

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

   

+$,-,+.% /,+$-/  $F... 50    0  )3( ) * 6)( 3 )(())'(0 $%0 ( %,5*'(%.., (4 * ) * 3 (  4((5( 6/) (( ((>A *3 (& *(( (( D(5( ( *33%..- *)3 (3)(  ?'(5*'(%..,?(5((53)  %..,(( >'* )33 )34(-$?'(%..,0 $-0 G)%..,6*5(3( ) >((>6( 3'( ) $F@-#50((>6)3*)()3*3 ,"$50>(( 6/) ( *3*( #,H507-#,50A%8>6('(  %F#H%50HG  (( 3 D 3&   (  :'(  )3(  >  !6*'(;$F%H,50  A3(>*> *3'((36!>(5((6(   '(3 3(34&) *0 63(*:)  BC)*:&0    '* 3  L M  

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

   

+$,-,+.% /G+$-/ $#0 ( @4%.., (4 * ) *;6   ( 5( *( 3('*5( 3'( ((: ))'*;(  '*;(  90 $H0 ( -')4%..,6  3 ( *(A ); ( )3  *)3 *3*       90 ) 5( *)*6*'(;$$,F$."50 @$FG@@50  9'*3G%FG,-50   0 6    3 ( A3*) (:* >  4( 6/) ( ( ) (((*( 4(  90 $"0 35(*:*3( 3(3(> 4( 3(O (P(/3&0  -+ $0 (:'(6:((? (((78**) (5(*((* & $K%..- (4 ()3* G?: 3*('(/3*(G33*$@?:70$0 G@ 80 D(;6( 6*( $@?:3 (45* * %#?'(%..,7 9$-.$.@8  (:'( 3*$-5*'(  (3((((:3) (4  (  (*:  ; ( ?: ((   6  6*( 'A?:0 %0 5)*);60-0-  (3(((( () (5((  6:(( ? (((  $, ')4 %..%   ( ( ' 6*  '(:   (  3  ' ))((     ** )( 655( D((> ()(&  9 7500G@80D)3*3 ?:  63&((*4(0 -0    >(  Q* ) (5((   ( 5* *  6/ ('((* $"?($"G"7 8 &:) $#?'($"@$7 8(( > (5* *6/'(('(' %. *)4$",@ 7 D8 6 3 33(4  63& &  >  ?:   (63;3 (*() (5((  ( 6*  5(3*(;  *)(  *((((:(7 9$%#,@# (0$$%$-H@(0$4R50*:) (3((((0H%0 $  80  3* ((:   *> A)(*;  )(&  (3((   &:)'(:?>6-$ *)4%..%0  (3((*: &(* (0

   

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

   

+$,-,+.% /#+$-/ 7C(55$.G.G8 553(4((* )33*33) *( >(* *(  *4(E )E)3)(33 5(*( 3( '  ( C(>   (;3(*('>*7 $"G@30$",T

9 $"G@@.1(C  O))( (6/ '(('('P)* 0O*(*($"HHP30%-G8  /* (E*C3(7C(55$.G.H $"##30,##80 (( 3 A)3  (  ( 3* ;  )3( 6 *>6635('(')  *( 3(3(3*'; 60,# 0 %  D0 )E)   ( 3* ;  )3(  ') C*;  / ;  *(  (>  3*' 3  ( 7  30(030%-@8  /)3(6(>3**'  (5* *0

((   A  ) I  * :4  *  ((5 * (7 9 $"@"30%$,(0-T $"#. 30,G-R   $"#H 30 -%.80  * ( )) '( 3 4?  3()3*)(;(' (5* *3( )3*)(;6/'(('('('((* $")$"@G 7 8 7C(55 $.G."  $.G$% 80   *; )3     )(   (  &'  ( 5* *0  (  )3(  3' 3* ;  )3(  * '  ( 6)  (34(5* *0 ((33(4 )3 3(*C' 6*  ( 34(  )E) '  )  *4(  ( 6:(( ; 6*  6( ((  *    3*'; 60 %. 0 %  D 7  30(030%-@80

>(6*  ) )3( (45* *   7 9 8 )( 5( 33* >  )3( 6   )((4 )I6)((( (3))(())'( 3;(R;*: ( )(())'( >(( ( 3( 5((7 $"H@30-., $"H- 30@"R $"H$30-%.80)) *)(3?:6(!*  :E(I *4( '(6>(  ((I *((  )3(  3*  5  3 *> *') ( I 6(*  9 >(750 9  @ ?'(%...M$@,+""(0-80D6(* 6>E55*  3*  6'( ;6)(((3?: >'  *4(6)) *3*)(())'(  ( 3(3 )3(A(  )3( ( ( ) )3*0  'C 6( 6'& >6(** ( )3))))(5*(;

   

+$,-,+.% /H+$-/  >6  )( >  6*'(* 6 )3( )55*?>6; 6)35(4 ( *?;*()) 6(()3*)(('( 6(; )3(55(')3**0 554(>)(())'(6(3

**:( )3(55* *4('3)) 6(( (( (55*>>((3** )3(7 $"H@30-.$R  30(030%-H80 48  63& ( !  ( 63* (((!3 3( '*36   &>*((3 (')   9 7@$FG@@ 508    7G%FG,- 508  4( 6/) ( 7-#F@@, 50 @.  $HF,H. 50 '* 3 6    $"F$H, 50 @. '* 3  '( 6/) ((/3&D 18 5( ) ( GFG"#50 @G0 8 >( 64 )3( *((    6) G%FG,-50'   (4 *  >6 6 3 3(4 5)*) A (3(( *: 3*(*0 *: (!( (:> 63**'*; ( 6' 6 ') 6 ))63* ;  6     (;  (  %$ K %..% 73(& %@ 5   80 6**    3* '

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

   

+$,-,+.% /"+$-/ 3( *(( ((!** ,"'(%..$ (  *( (>3*';60,#0% D)3(( '  * *  '  ( 5* *0   ((; A)( (  (> )4 4(3( )3(0

 ' 3:3C  ) 6(((4((*36*%..G %H 4%..,5(36()('E)(:!)3( ((3 *6( :)5( (( >  *3 3 6*(:   *(>   :J 3  (( 3*   ')  *4( '('  3 ) 44)( (34 $FGG.50> (EA  (( 60"- (5* *3(3 5(( $$'($HH"09*:)3( )(())'(!55(53 :)C)4C:36*(:*(>  :J 3  (( >(  )3(  )(())  4  5(  C55:   (( (  > D+   /) ( 73:3C  C0 $ %  -80  (  3 (  ' >  '   3*  3*' 3  (('  )(& ( 33( 55('); 6   '*(5(> )(())'( 6*(3)*3 )3(0 55(( )3(*(&'3/)E) 3*(;( *4(( )   )3(0  33( 5(;  (  )3( *(& 

*)(3*4( >))3(3(4   '(;  > 6* )4 3 /  )(()) '( 7C(55 $."%G 80 6 & ; ? ( > 6    3* *;  '*(5((3*' 3*'( (4 * $,)(%..,0

 '  (' ) 5(:  (  *3  '  3'E*4())(S  1 4)33 U$6G.. 508  ! U$6%H, 50 7( :*())4((&)((3 $#4%..%8  /) ( *3A U#,H 50  (( D+ +   U%-% 50  (( D+ +  G% 50  8  9 %5:#; 50      *3 U$6H%H 508   6('((*'*3DD U$6#,# 50 75033 6>E $"4%...3(&$G5  8  '(:& U-,- 50 75033 6>E $"4%...3(&$G5  8  8  2  %5(#: 50  !  (  3*( >   - 3((   L M   A( 3'33E)34((* '  &

   

+$,-,+.% /$.+$-/ >  (  3* *  C   3*'! (4 (( > 6  (5( 3*'! %.')4%..%5(: (>6(3 6  3'()  $.%503)(;( )3(0  8 ;  )3(  *  (( 3   5( ) (  GFG"# 50 @G  (4  *  >   (( )(*()3(*:))3(0

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

63&6  3((5 4*:3*)  )3(  4( '* 3  D 1 &  > 6 3  6?)(3  636(()*6)(5)  ( *:;  ((  3 *>; 

   

+$,-,+.% /$$+$-/ )3(0 660-- 1>(&:>( 4(( K) C*((>((3:()3( *((   *)  ()4 D 15)*);60$0$ &:) 6A*( ( 633(( (5* *6/) (0 ' A3(((33( *C*D 1 6('(3&  6 5(>6 *(( )3(3)>6('*3 ;C $"F$H,50( 0  ; 6*    )3(  *  ((  $HF,H. 50 74(8 GFG"#50@G75( ) (8'*36   (E

*)(* 5)*) A  *?; 55*0    (3(4 3 3*)3( $.%503)(0 #0  '   **)    3() )(  ))) )34 )*; $.% 50 5)*);  >(  ** *'33*(/'0( (4 *>)  HGF@,-50@G3E)3*' '** 3*(*>3*(( 4('*3D 1 $"F$H, 50 6  '    ' *((  )3(  >E  D 10

   

+$,-,+.% /$%+$-/   -+4  +,* -  * -+

  /  8 6;6A((  (*R,0  *(( >6 *)3( 6 * 3*(  5(A*  6('((* 3 *'*R G0 (>3* :(R @0 5)  3(   >6 3' 5)    3* E   *(  -. ? &  (5(( 3 3( )) *  *  (4 5* *   DCV(JC5>( @ @..,     ( A)3(0  *(  3 E 3:*0 )*)( (S 8 ( (> A)> *(( *(4((3  *(( >*R 48 A3 3 >)(5 ( () 3'( )    *((R 8 3  (:     3*0 D( )*)(  ( 3  ( **) *)**   8 48  8 (/   (45* * 33)(&>6( ' *('40)*)( )()!  3' >(  ?( (( >  *(( >*  6'33  >**A3* (*70$-%$.@$.H80    :55(&S    WX Y  *(S    1!  1    

   

+$,-,+.% /$-+$-/ *(/?(S  91   3(5) 3*E(5(*A3(((>6;655(5* * (3:55