opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/282/2005

Genf · 2005-03-31 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (4 Absätze)

E. 3  2* +4 $!  55555555555 *  +60/ ( # ! #*    #7 *, "  #" 821 % "  9 ": ( '#" ;55555555555 &  ##)' ( !#  7# # ! (:  .0 <*7  .11.4   (  *# # * "!   (' (#, 

&&    &&& ' &&  

& '   & 8 3":  & 94 .4  .6 7  .11. !"*, #7    %#  =    >, :7 '*  "( '*)  ? # # #!?* (' *%  7!# (*"  *%<(@ 7  !:@ < #  %# ()) (A :#  )# ( %# #  *"# !#   B#* @% #   #C#4   *(## *#* "   %@ "  !#

55555555555 ( (*"## ( % @   #* ( % @  (    ( DB" #A  7 #  ( :7 8 3":  D9 )  (@!#)*  <# A# ! !7# ( "! @# @% #  <# #   (  #E!F( ( ( 'A#* #* (# ( ( (! #4 '*  ?  #7# ! % @  "#)* "  "#    C G! # # (* %!" # *, ' #* ( % @  (    ( D ( /1 7   +2  .11.4 #  *G!   ! ? (A #7# ! % @   (# ( /1 7  .11.4 /4  +2   .6 G  .11. '*  *G!*,   ) ( **(# ! ( (*"## ( !   ) ( D4  !# 55555555555 # 55555555555 'E# A * !# "  (  ""!# ( + G # .11.  (@!#  "**(# "!* "  !<:  !#

55555555555  "* #)   # "!#!"*#!  *# #  "4  !# "   7* ( ':) ! (  %# '* 7 # ?  %! ( :  #C#  )'  '7 #   "# ( !   *   !# 4

24  /+  .11. $!  &55555555555 ( 7  ( ' "# ! ( %#  (  "!  ( !## !  (# !* '*   (*!# ( ' (#4   7* ( ! ""!#)  (  '*# # <#*  "! @# #  # !, ? ( #7# ! % @ 4   *@# 7* = %!,  #C# 7 #!? >4

E. 04 & # A " # ( '* !# ( #!? ( 

E. 7 3"* (# 0 ""*# # +P G@  8#4 + #4

# 0P

94

& #, '# ! ( '*# ! ( +P G@  "  ? <*(*  .O G7  .112

E. 8 +.0  2P+ ! (4 0 #  *<*94

  : (' A "!# <#  '""K# ") ' (#  # *#* !?G# 7# "!", "!(  ( #!? 7  #) A (!# !<< '* ) !<  ('   ""# ( *(  ""*,  (*#   ##)# ! #    ( !#4

 7 (  **#  !  G#* #  (*  !  !""! # ! (  & ( +P G # .112 !< *4

-.+/0-12 3 +.-+. 3

, *2  *,*   , ,

" 3-4   5  6   17 %8$  !9   4 

+4 *  ! ( +6 !#!? .112 7?4 " 4

.4  G##4 /4  #)  "!*( # @# #4 24 <!  "#  ( )' "7# <! ! !#  "*# C# (  (* ( /1 G! (:  !# < # ! " " !(* (*  ? <*(* (  &%Z H%!<) P P112    #!  A" 4  (*  "# C# "!!@*4 

*!  (! # X 9 () A##) (*  !  !# (*  !?#    # " (  (*  ! ##)*U ?9 A"! "!) !# <  #  "!7! (( ## # (*  !U 9 "!#   @# !  ( ! "*##4 & 

*!   !# # "  #!  **# *** ! ## 9 ?9 # 9  3(  ? <*(* (   "! " #  # :   !)'  (7 (* 7?4 

*!  ( ! # ! !  !E ( "7) !# G! #  )  (*  ! ##)* # '7!"" ( )   *#* A"*(*  !# 8#4 +/. +1P # +1M 94

 @<< : X

$ 3!   Y

 * (# X

!  ]   

 *# 3G # X ! $ 

 !"  !<! ( "*# C# # !# < * A "#   )', '<<  <*(* (  !  "  @<< 

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

    

    !"   !" 

        

#$%&'#$(() *#$+$#$((' *

*,*   , , % -.  " &%  $(('

  

" ///////////     !"# "

$ $ %

 &  ' #( ()  * # (!   !#

!#

0, *   1, , 1,, *   %### +,  # *

-.+/0-12 3 .-+. 3  2* +4 $!  55555555555 *  +60/ ( # ! #*    #7 *, "  #" 821 % "  9 ": ( '#" ;55555555555 &  ##)' ( !#  7# # ! (:  .0

, :7 '*  "( '*)  ? # # #!?* (' *%  7!# (*"  *% 4 04 & # A " # ( '* !# ( #!? (  7  !  !#! 

(   ) ( **(# !  "  (H37! "!  "# # 7  !"%#!!@4  !## ! ('!"%#!!@       2 G  .11. (#, )  !# 55555555555 !"%#!!@  7*)  4     !# 7 #

" # ( !# !   3":4   *

-.+/0-12 3 O-+. 3 +4  ! @7!   '!@ # ! G(   89  *#* !(< * #  # #* (:  + !R# .11/  ? #! (  !  !"!* ( 0 G@ (!#  "* (# #  7 3"* (# 0 ""*# # +P G@  8#4 + #4

# 0P

94

& #, '# ! ( '*# ! ( +P G@  "  ? <*(*  .O G7  .112 8

+/1  +1P9  (!  @7!   (!"#*  +/ <*7   ("! # ! # #!  @# "###  ? #! (  !  (  *@  , #!  G@ # #   ( '### ( '*# ! ( !7A G@ 4 .4 !<!*#, '#4 0P 4 + #    ? #! (  !  !K#  # ) ( !### ! "*7, '#4 0P (  ! <*(*   "#  @** ( (! # (  !  ( P !#!? .111 8 9 # 7,  ! <*(*  '3 (# ( .1  +6M+ 8

94 & !"*# "! G@ (  ('": #   *#? 4 /4   # #*  7 @  + G7  .11/ #K#  !(< # ! ( !? ("! # ! *@ (  (!  (  ! 4 &  " #*   "! # ( 7!) (! # S"") (! # C# #%*,   : ( "  " ! )  :@ "" ? !#   7 @  !# !T  < # G ()# (*# #  !# "!( # 8

+.O  2PO ! (4 + +.P  +/P ! (4 2? #  *<*94  7%  ) !  "!*( #, (*<# ( :@ # #!  !#   !7 (! # S"")  *7 (:  G! ( ! #*  7 @ 8

++O  6/ ! (4 P? ++.  /P1 ! (4 2U  $ +66M V /O "4 /+P ! (4 /?94 S# "!)!  "!*( #!( # ":  + G7  .11/ (7#  # ? #! !"*##  # : (S !  !# *@  "  !7 :@ ( "!*( !# (   # "  ("! # ! ( "!*( !# (  (<<*# !  "*  !(< * "   4 24  ) !  (* ( ! '#4 P1  "*7! #)  ! (! # C# (*"!* (  ## G!  7#  !# < # ! (  (*  ! G##, !4 '#4 +1P 

"*7! # "(#)' (*!@# !, '#4 P1 

 (* ( ! # ( #!  !  "!  (*  !  !""! # ! "!##   "## ! ('4  (*  ! (!# # ! *## #7  +P G # .112   !# < *  !  ( !#  +6 G # .112  ! ( +6 !#!? .112  *#* #G#*  #" #  # # (: ! 7?4 04 &  <!( ? ( * :7)  (*  !  # @  E# *#* (  (# ( +P G # .112   ###   *## ( < # G ()# (*# # !##, .11.  "*#  # @  A *,   : ( ("! # ! (   # ( ! !(!  ) (  

# ( !

-.+/0-12 3 M-+. 3 !(!  7 @ G)' /+ (*? .11.4  ("! # ! !# (: !  #* (    #4 P4   # @ "!#   (! # A "## ! (' (*!# ( ' (# ( .6 7  .11.  ) !  #!? !  (!# !<<  !#4 9 &! '#4 P 4 + 

 "## ! (' !# !*   (' (# "!< ! (' (# ! "!< ! # ( ( "!< !4 '*  !## (! #  # ## *( ""!" * ( * ! *## ( ' (# # '  # #!## ! "# # "? ( #7 ,   # ( ' (#,  ( #* G! : 8#4 +1 # #4 +P 

94    ! '#4 +M 4 + 

'*  (! #,  # (' 7 (#* '  (7 # 7 (, +1 W  !  "  # ('  (# # ! '#4 .2 4 + 

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

 !) 'A # (' ""!# ( , <<# # ' (# #  (!@ "K# "! ?  )'  "# " C#) < * ( "!?? (   "#    (! #, ( "## ! (*!# ( ' (# * (! # C#  * 8

++6  //O ! (4 + ++M  .M6 ! (4 +? #  *<*94   #* (*)# # )# !)S  ""# #  G@ #,   ( #%4  G@ ""*,  "!!  SA # (S ""!# (  #* (*)# (! #  ((  < (S %K# !# (  !# S  *# # "!??)  < # ! (** "!( K#  *## #7 8

+1O  +O/ +OO94

A # (  G "(   #* # (*)#  (S":  ! !(  ( %! # SA"*  (  7   < # ! (** *# # "!", #K  <<# ( @ ( ) S# "!( #  7 (  *## " # ( <J! @** <7! * "  #  !# 8

-.+/0-12 3 6-+. 3 +.0  2P+ ! (4 0 #  *<*94 ))  #:  7# "7# C# "!* X 3 "! 7!  # !*) !# (*)#  <# "# ( <<#)  !# <<# 7# "!( # # (* ( *#!"# 7#  # ()  S (# ""K# ! !   # 4 $C ( !*)  @ : S#3,3( A#!(  "7#  7#   !# C# ( !*) (*)# ( S (#U

3 " "!#)  !*) ! # "*7  ? ! !U  <# #  << # !  A "!# <#)   )# ! <R# !?G# 7# "!", "!(   !*)3, 84    #* ( (! # ( !? @# ! +6O/ "4 ++/ # ++2 # G "(  #*U & +661 "4 .+ ./ # .294

&!  G "( #  (!#  S#! #* ( ## 7 !  G@  (! 7# ! (*  < # ! "!7*) !)S  !# !7  (  * #* 8V ( ( Y 7 "!H%# 2 *(4  +6M2 "4 +/PU E@ (7Z#@%#"<@ . *(4 "4 .OM %4 094   (!  (  !   G@ <!(  (*  ! < ("! # ! !#  (  !   < #) <# (SC# *#?  (  : *<#? "" # !  " 7 ?? S#3,3() "*##  (@* ( 7 ? "*"!(*#4   << # (! ")S < # "  C# ! (** # !  %E"!#%: "! ?4  #!  **# ( < # *@* ! 7 @?  G@ (! #   *%*# # A)  " #  " "!?? 8

+.+  2O ! (4 . .1M ! (4 P? #  *<*94

 SA #3#3  "  (! # (  !   "  " ! ) S( ## ! !  G@ (7 # ## (  (!#  <7 ( S* 8 $ +66/ ! V 6.+ "4 +06 ! (4 /?94 & S( ## ! !  G@  <!(#   ""* # ! !   ( "7 <!  "  7# @# ! A)  (! 7# "!*( (S!<<  !# !7 ) #  < # "*##  (@* ( 7 ? "*"!(*# #) (S#  "!?#!   "! # " !(<  ## ""* # !  # "< (S( # (S# "7 8""* # ! #  "* ( "7U V   Z#@7<%  ( &!H 7 %@ "4 .+. ! 201U V[H-D\ Z3 #@7<% (Z#@%#"<@ ( ( . *(4 "4 /6 ! +++ # "4 ++O ! /.1U E@ (73 Z#@%#"<@ . *(4 "4 .O2U <4 

+..  2P6 ! (4 2 +..  ../ ! (4 / +.1 ? ..6 ! (4 .? ++6  /22 ! (4 / #  *<*94  #  : ( "!*(  7 ! "  (! # (SC# #( ! S#4 2 4 + #4 8

+.2  62 ! (4 2? +..  +P. ! (4 +(# SC#  #*94  ) !  7 "!?# (' ""!# *( ) # (*# # '#)  "! #  # @ A  # < # '!?G# (' *#(  !# *)  ""!#  <!(  ( A !"#)'  " *@# 

-.+/0-12 3 +1-+. 3 ! (*# !  " # A" * "  "! A *)'   # *#* *#?  "  !  ( ':)  ( "# ! ( !#A# *( # '""* # ! (   ## ! *( ! #   # < )  ! ! ( 'A"# ! # (R# !# 7*4

 (# '**# (*# # "!  7 "!?# '#  '! @  ( !E ( "7   (* @# ! ! ""!# ! ! A"#    ? # ?  ! !# 8

+.0  /0. ! (4 / +..  +P1 ! (4 + #  *<*94  G@ "#   !(  7 "!?# A ""!# # A"#  *#? ,  (( ( '3  (#  !@#") A3 ?!# #, ( *## !7 #)  ! ! !# * # !# 7*)  7   !# # " ( !#(# ! #)' ( !#  "# ( ##    ? 3<!(* ! ( (!# ( '!?G# 7 #* ( ""* # ! "!#* 8

! "? * ( ./  .11/     .PO-1. ! (4 24.94 ?9  '":  !# # )  #!? (  7  !)'  "*# !#  # ! (  #* # # (*)# 7  %!)'   ?,  #C# ! ( ' (# ( .6 7  .11.4  ? "  "# ! @## !   ""!# (  !#! D55555555555 #   < #)  !# 55555555555) ' 7  " : <!   2 G  .11.   # *)  #!? "*#* "!7 # C# (,  #E" ( !"   #C#4  7%  &

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

-.+/0-12 3 ++-+. 3 ! ! ( ## # 7  "!# ##)4

":  !(A ( %" 7   (*<  # ' " *#* "!( #4  !# 55555555555   # ( !7 A *  !#  .P G  .11/ #  !< *  "**(# !### !, 7!)'  'E 7 #  * ! !  7  ?  !" # !4 #  !#! 55555555555  A")* ( ! ""!# ( /1 7  .112)' * !  ( !"%#) !*# 7, ' (#  "!7 # C#   *7 (  )'  A # #  !  ( *<# ! (!# '! @  *# # "%E !!@) # *#@:, ' (#4  ! !(""!# ( / (*? .112   A")*)    (  #* #  (*@*# 7  #  #!? (  !## ! # ' (# '*# #) "! ?   # # " 7 ??4

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

+.0  2P+ ! (4 0 #  *<*94

  : (' A "!# <#  '""K# ") ' (#  # *#* !?G# 7# "!", "!(  ( #!? 7  #) A (!# !<< '* ) !<  ('   ""# ( *(  ""*,  (*#   ##)# ! #    ( !#4

 7 (  **#  !  G#* #  (*  !  !""! # ! (  & ( +P G # .112 !< *4

-.+/0-12 3 +.-+. 3

, *2  *,*   , ,

" 3-4   5  6   17 %8$  !9   4 

+4 *  ! ( +6 !#!? .112 7?4 " 4

.4  G##4 /4  #)  "!*( # @# #4 24 <!  "#  ( )' "7# <! ! !#  "*# C# (  (* ( /1 G! (:  !# < # ! " " !(* (*  ? <*(* (  &%Z H%!<) P P112    #!  A" 4  (*  "# C# "!!@*4 

*!  (! # X 9 () A##) (*  !  !# (*  !?#    # " (  (*  ! ##)*U ?9 A"! "!) !# <  #  "!7! (( ## # (*  !U 9 "!#   @# !  ( ! "*##4 & 

*!   !# # "  #!  **# *** ! ## 9 ?9 # 9  3(  ? <*(* (   "! " #  # :   !)'  (7 (* 7?4 

*!  ( ! # ! !  !E ( "7) !# G! #  )  (*  ! ##)* # '7!"" ( )   *#* A"*(*  !# 8#4 +/. +1P # +1M 94

 @<< : X

$ 3!   Y

 * (# X

!  ]   

 *# 3G # X ! $ 

 !"  !<! ( "*# C# # !# < * A "#   )', '<<  <*(* (  !  "  @<<