opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/206/2007

Genf · 2007-02-28 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (1 Absätze)

E. 23 $%%"%%:*3  .3

.3 %@''3 ?3 #'>&%"$%'8%'#'3 +3 G"%  &%'#   >P &:' G"%% %"% "'%  &%$' %%H'   $#  ?, @"% 9  "'#G#'#" &%9  %#* G$$%;(6T#M%6"G>#1!1,,+  =!&%:"#%"%'#9%%"#' &*#!"G"%$'E%'3J."#G$$%% %#*G$$%2F @# .,,0; Q=S  $"#%  %"% "#' ##>%  "#"! "'#G ' "B&%:'&"%'%#8'%%"%'""'#%S#"#' H'% %$  %#* G$$% &% :"# &"' " &% :"# $'%"#> E "#'#"  5%'3 +.  Q3  &%$' %%H' '  &#9  &"#"  %"%'!#:">$""B&%:!"#:'H'%@"#'I5:"#3  8%GG#9%   (B:#) A  %$#'<   #     %$'#%@%#'   6##&&  D   "&#"G"%&%$'%%H''"'#G#$E&%'#'(%$'%#'P ''I P$""#&%8%GG

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

 

   

       

      

         !""#$!"%%& '!"%&!"%%( '  ' ) )')   )  *+,  "- ./ "%%(

  !"###$!   !%&%$'$&%

((( (( %"%'

"'%

((      ( )  !#% "'*%#'+,!    #'#$

   

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

   

-../0-.,,1 ?-2, D (%$&'$":*'5H'%%$5'%&"#3"% '#% "&'  %&&"%' '%  8# &% @"%#% I 2,, L ' 5##'$ @"%#9%IJ,L!G#E$I203F@"%GG'#G&#"3 /3 '%$##".1":*%.,,+%'#:I%$##'#"%&&"%' '%:#:A (! #&%""$I5$8%5%$ &#"%"#'I5##'$+,@"%!%$I213J@"%!&%9:"#%&%# "&'8##'%$##%3 2,3 22@:#%.,,0!5%$G"%$"&&"#'#""'%$##""%'" $&%'  6M D  (3 '#' >5 5:#' "#  G'! "I&&%#"&#"%"#'I5##'$3 "' >"'#:#'$"#'#'IGG'%''"B8*%E#5 '>5%$#'$!:#'4''"B%#'#%''"#''#'*%E3

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

E&"$>!""%%#5&"B%!5%$$'#'G#''%:E ># 5''#' &#>5 :#' $'$ #G"%$! "%  " 88'! >5# "#'#''%:E''"B8#'#%3%#%! #%:$ >5%$$'#'"###$I7'$"#'%:#'>G#$'#'N8$I

   

-../0-.,,1 +-2, 5$&">G#'2J"%'>"6"%#%5$'#'&#"&'#*: :#G#3 "'%!&%$#$>%#9%'#:#'$"&$&%:' &%5%$$'#'5###'#89%IA2 3 :  #:% $$'!   # > 5" &":#' %#"*' E#8%  5%$>5"%:N'"&"#":*&%9D (!9 "% >5# 5$'#' & $'*# >  "'#'#"  %&&"%'  '%:# $'#' #'"$%*3 213 % '  .? @# .,,1! 5%$  %"% &%9  %#* '"  %"#"'%#'$##"%"&&"#'#"3 "'I>5#"#' "''$>55"#G'@'#G#'>">&#" "%"#'I5##'$3 "'#'>'%:#>5H'%":$&%9 D (&'&H'%>#G#$":*&#>!5&%'! :G"%'#"%$'#%'"%#%&"#&%'#5### ##>#89%&"%"&'5%96!#%$&"#'&I&'#'! 5'%&%'!#"#'#''%:E''"B8#'#%'#&#>#' :% E %"%  "%' >5#58##'5&"#&$#*''#: 'N6I"&#%>56"%#%I%3%%*""B! &%$'>#'%:#:#'H'%"#$%$"":*!&":#' &%$:"#% 5 "'#G :* &"% B ''% G# G#' &&%O'%  G' " $''"B"$89%3 2F3 %$&".F@#'.,,1!5#'#$&%#'$&"#'#"9"%> %"%'G##'&:"#%5'%%8'>E$@I#:">$ &%"$% 5"&&"#'#"3   &%$' > 5'#:#'$ E%$ &%9  D ($'#'":*&#>&G"%'#"5%$'$:$ '"E&$%##&"%''!&%'%:E":*'%83 2J3   %$&#>  ?2 "4' .,,1!  %"%'  #' 5#'$8%#'$  "#"&%#"%"%3 "'%!"''$>D ( #%#'G#'&%"&"#'#"'%:#3 2/3   &#>  .J &'*% .,,1! 5#'#$  E&#>$ >5 5:#' & "'>D (%#'"#&%"&"#'#"I%"%'!# *# >5# 5$'#' 88$ I # &%"&"%  '% &"' "%> 5"#"  &%$'%#''>%"%'5:#'&&'#5''%": &%"&"#'#"3 .,3  . "'"*% .,,1!  %#*"#>$''$%#'%I%"%'' 8%$I@8%3 .23 "%%H'./":*%.,,1; -?..1-.,,0=! %#*$ #&%'#'%"%'$$##"%"&&"#'#"2/@#' .,,03@8$>%"%':#'#G#G'#:'I""'%''%:#! #>5%#"%'9%'&"%#%5&"#>#5%#'&%$I

   

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

   

-../0-.,,1 F-2,

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

   

-../0-.,,1 J-2, &'#';%'3213.'3* =3 "$>!#G'''%> &"'%$&"E%#'9%5'%:#":*3 'I56"%#%'&"#!#G#'&&%'#"'#GE6'#G&%$: &%  $8#'% &%'''  "#$%% >5#  58#' & 5 '%:# %$&'$ ":*;G3 Q "&*#$/@#'.,,.! ?22-,2!"#3+=3 GG'! #5%678!%'!'%'%*'G:"%#%%$#%'#"& %*&"#*67%#%#'$""#>;G3%'32%3. =! 5%$ % '!  " 7'$! 5'%&%% '"'  >5" &' %#"*'E#8%#&"%"%'#%6783 #8#G#>5#"#'! $6$'!&'%6"%#%#G#'"%"'%:#*"6%## >G#'&%'#&"&'#"'#:3

G#!%"%'5@#G#':"#%5'%#%"''>"N8!  #''#" &%" " "% " $''  '$ ># &"%%#' I % '"% @'#G#%%G&"%#:%"'%:#''"B;%'3213.'3 =3

 GG'!  5' *"%$ I #:">%  #''#" &%" " "'#G # &%'''%G%&"%#''''#:#'$!'"'G"#E&#>%>"# #''#"&%"@'#G##'>5O''%E%'#"'%:#3%! G#:#'#E6#'"'G#'"%'>#''#"&%" &":#'&@'#G#%>5%"CN'I'%:#GG'$'%16,,'/6,,!E%$  %%"O' I 7'$  " "##3  '' %!  $$' "'#''#G 5 #''#"  678  I  &%"&% G'  5%$ @'#G#'  &#"%"#'I5##'$678;%'3?,32'3 =3 /3 ("5%'3?,3? !%$&#"'&%"&"%'#"I8%:#'$   G' '  &' E$% 1, @"% &% "'#G  &#"3 ("  @%#&%!  %$##'#" G'#: 5 "'%'  8# #'%$##% :#" 5"*#8'#"##%"8'"'''>5%GG'#G5'#:#'$ 8##'%$##%%$&'$":*5%'3?,32'3 " >5%$##'#"G'#:5%&&"%''%:#"%>5&"#>'#"' %$&'$":*5%'3?,32'3 ; 2//JR/&3+2"# ?=3 H #  %$##'#" G'#: 5 "'%'  8# #'%$##% 5' & $$%$#'E&'#:5%'3++32 !%8%5##'#" G#'&%@%#&%''#''#":%GG'#G5'#:#'$8# #'%$##% ' :  %$##'#" G'#: 5 %&&"%'  '%:#! # B  #  "#$%% > 5%$  '%":  '%:# &%  G'    '' #&"#'#"$8'>!G#'!"#G'8%:%$8#&%5%'3+0 3? 3

5&9!#5'&"''$>%"%'%$##$&%"&%##'#'#: "'%'  '%:# >#  ##' I " &"B%3  %"%'  %#' 9 "% E#&%G'5%'3++32#'3* >#$'#'%$5 '%&"#"#"&":#'E#8%>5"%:N'"#&"#3

   

-../0-.,,1 /-2,

##>5"5:#;"#3J=!&"''%:#&%9D  (%:H'#'%'9%":*>5#B#'#5$''%>"> %$%:I'$8%3"&"%''%"%'!>#%$##$"'%' '%:#:"#%%&'$$#%$##'#"&#>5"$""8$: GG' #$#' ' >#  #  '%   &%"&% ##'#'#: "& % "&;?, &'*% ' F "'"*% .,,+= I E "'%'  8# #'%$##%  5H'% %$ 5 '% &"#!  "'#' &  G' "B! #  G' 8%:5%'3+03? ;G3&%"8# Q "&*#$.+@# .,,?3 2.1-,.!"#3+! 2/JF22&32,J"#32=3

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

   

-../0-.,,1 2,-2,   '0  ' ) )')   )    123.3++ 4  533 3  67 8&"  9 23 $%%"%%:*3  .3

.3 %@''3 ?3 #'>&%"$%'8%'#'3 +3 G"%  &%'#   >P &:' G"%% %"% "'%  &%$' %%H'   $#  ?, @"% 9  "'#G#'#" &%9  %#* G$$%;(6T#M%6"G>#1!1,,+  =!&%:"#%"%'#9%%"#' &*#!"G"%$'E%'3J."#G$$%% %#*G$$%2F @# .,,0; Q=S  $"#%  %"% "#' ##>%  "#"! "'#G ' "B&%:'&"%'%#8'%%"%'""'#%S#"#' H'% %$  %#* G$$% &% :"# &"' " &% :"# $'%"#> E "#'#"  5%'3 +.  Q3  &%$' %%H' '  &#9  &"#"  %"%'!#:">$""B&%:!"#:'H'%@"#'I5:"#3  8%GG#9%   (B:#) A  %$#'<   #     %$'#%@%#'   6##&&  D   "&#"G"%&%$'%%H''"'#G#$E&%'#'(%$'%#'P ''I P$""#&%8%GG