opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/180/2004

Genf · 2004-03-24 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (1 Absätze)

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

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

            

      

          !"#$ %$$!  !&$ %$$'  ()(* *+*  (* +) ',  -. /  %'  %$$' 

 0 12222222222 ! "#$     %!%!!%&'%()!%% (%'*+*+,-.'  !  !  +33) *+*  4(*5)*6)) ( /01*+**.'*2 %!%3 

   

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

   

4*25,4+,,* 6@4*+6 +,7 +2F'% +,,-"  %!3(%;%=!=  !($ '%3(% 3&%(" 6%'%(%!3I%6 .$8J'%! !%3    > (  ! ("; !% ( (!  R9999999999 = (% !> +,,," 3 3!%!%%!3(! '%(" ((A,M7  "3!!(!3(  !"3!%!&& '3!3 % !;(3%%%!%&% (-%+,,* % =%F!%:%%!(%!% (3%%7 +*7 3  (3&33 !%: '%;I '%3! %!!G %(% 56 @J   "; ! !    $8 3!%!   '!  (3%% ( "  %="% '%!3!3(%&!%=3& ?  3 G%&% 3!%!   (%  %!%3 ( "3 +,,*7 !! ( %.  %: !% 3!%! ! (%!     ! ( (! 

9999999999 ! 99999999997 $% "  3:3 %! ?!%!7  * +) *7 %:3(3   !%&33 ((%!( %(@!>  +,,,I J!! 3'%& * F'% +,,2! T!(>  (%:%!%((%(" 6%'%(%!37(".(  !!:% 3&% (%%!%'%& F="2*(3> +,,+3& (   %%  =  F& (   % "  U:73&!(%%!%! %!%  !7A+7* J7 3! %!%&    3= ;%3 +,,+7(%%!%3& ! (. %!3( %! 7 +7 %&'% " &%!%F(%%% (++'> *0-*IJ3!3 (%:%3!%!%!3(.* P!+,,2 %>!(  %7 : 3! !( %!!!%!%= 

   

4*25,4+,,* 614*+6 !!!%!%. (" 6%'%(%!3!!I:7 !75@J7 3!( %>(3!%%3!>% F& ((".7 27 ! F!3!!%  ! : 3!;  !%@0 !A-(%:3(3  " 6'%%! '%'!( +,(3> *0-@I $J %>7 -7  %!%&  ! !%!    %! ( '%  = (%%!% (  %!3(&%  !>% %("!!%!  ( ! '% 7  !   (3 3(% !%!!  33! !%   (3! %  = ! ';  !   %>! ;%&  ( ) 3I R*+5+@*%(7-**5*2-%(7+**-2*-%(72 *,5  *5A %(7 *J7  !!!% ( 3(% ( :% =! ! %:3 %  ! ("  ! 3(%  =% ! (3! %!"!=%!%!%&%;% !!%!:%!">F!("3!( :%3 =   !  :(   ( ; ! ="%   3&!  %(3 !% %!; %3="%%!3!33!>%% %((% I.J=( %!%(!;!3(%%! % !:%=%("; !%!>%!%'3I R*++ *@,U$+,,,7*5-J7 !  =(; !% (3!(( 3( (%%! !%'!3!>% (3%%!  > ("> '!%  :(% ! ("%'!%&!% .! %% =" % % ( (%  ! =  ; ! >!%! %6:(3I R*+5252J7 ->7

"." ("> (%%!3"'%("3(%%(3(!=%  %!  %!3 3%( ( ! '% (  !  .  !&   %  :% %6% >!  . ( (!  R9999999999  '3 = "&& '!%("3!!(!3(  !3!%!%! '!3 % ! ! !%( '%( (%' 3(%:%(>  "; !%((! R9999999999=  3'.% !! (%!% =% %!3 3%(( ! '%(  ! 3 %( 33(!(3%%%!%&%7

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

   

4*25,4+,,* 6*,4*+6 %    %' ( =%:%!%  (% ("!%'%!3 !  ; !%!! ("%: !%:%>7 3:3    !!( (%3:(!!F  3(%'  ! I R*+-2+2 !%=$*0007*A+J7 > .!%( 3% ! ( :%! =    !!%! (   !3 ! G(%3 L   "%! ( !?G ;%%%  3&.  ! (3'!&3   =%     33 !%    ! ;  %3 !!!  (!%: ! '! L!  /3    L ! '%7 %  !;(%  &33 !%:3 %   I !%=$*00A7*107+0@J7 (=%   !! ( !!%!%= (%'! L!  3(%! (3( ( "> ( % !  ! :%( !%% I%%!!%%3G(% ?& 3 (  '% !%%!34!3& % ("! %!% ( 3F  ! !; ("!%J ! 3! (" 3'!% (  %%! ( '%  (" 3%!%7(3(!%&>;%(+5M % !!%!%=  !(!% !((%::3 !33!=%'!%:  ' ("!%'%!3 !%'I R*+@10%(75>46$+,,+71,%(7 ->J7 5>7

 ".   =%    '  %'%(%!3   ! '%! 3% *001&% (! 07+J7 !!("%!3 3%((! '%( 5,M '=  !'%! 3% "3'%!%% :3(3 (  (((%%% 7

%%((" ?&3(-2: !% :% !/!>33:%%3(" %!3! .> .'I(;3J>!!!(*,M 3!3 !I R >%3(*@%+,,251@4,+J7 !  %>:3(3 (  3(3 !!!(*5M   !%  !   !%%  (  !%%!3 3! &.  (  ! ! (

   

4*25,4+,,* 6**4*+6 "LG! !I R >%3(2,'> +,,*-++4,*J7  (3(!% (   (". !    (%'%% ( 3(!!% :%(" 3!%!(+5M7 (! T!! 3'3 & ((F % (!%3!>!!!(*5M:%( !%  ! ( %%!!% (  ! I?& (  !  %!3 > .' (%::%!3   '%!!%! %%7"( %=(3%%%!%&% ! 3 %!!(%! 3=!L! 37 57

  =%   "&& '!% ( "3!! ( !3 !3 %   +,,+    =   F % ( !! ( %> :3(3  (    F&  3%  3&%!3((3%%!!=3 .&&33 (" ."3!!(:%!;%!! !K(3%%%!%&%3!3 (I R*+1-@1%(7**+* 2@@%(7*>7**@+-A%(7*J7:%! '!3 % !!=% ! (%:%3 !! %!!% (%'!  ! :%  ">F! (" ' (3%%(%%! !%'I R**1+02%(7- R >%3(+5P! +,,220+4,2J7 

 ". %  !%( ( +,,+ . '% 3(& 3("%'%(%!3(  !(.!!(!:!%(" %!3 3%((! '%(+,M%%="::%%!%3" !( 3 %! (+2F'% +,,-7    !=%>!%! !%!&%(!  3!3 )#% &33 =%!%!%!!%((%!>%U: 3! !?% + @   :0 

*7 3    '>U  :0

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