opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/179/2006

Genf · 2006-02-21 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (6 Absätze)

E. 01 '"'2

31)453.55/

E. 6  1* 07  & ! "'" '& " 2 ) 8 ' 0)/-7   2,!2 !' 9& ! "'" '&  15 !8:  0)*)7  "" '! " 2 7 9&  00 8 ' 0);57  '8!   2"2, !!2  ..   0);17

.7 , !!2  .. !8:  0);1& <==' "!  < 6'8''"2 >'6 , ? @ < A  ! < 2 '8' B 055C ,'  0/ !8:  0);17

17  .5 D'" 0);*&   !2 ' B  ='& 7 97 %! <"  '&  =''"'!,"  <8'", 2"2 2":'7  2''!  . !"!:  0);*& <   8 2 B < 2 B, "'  0 D'" 0);*  " !,2"'  !:,! ! =' 7, "  !'2 "'! E <'"'"2 ,?   '6' 2"'" '!7

-7 !    2,"'!  !" " <,, "'F  7 "2  .5 ,":  .55-& <   !""2 E '" !" " "'!'" E ,?   '6' 2"'" !' 97  < 2  ' 8'" D' !2 E ! =' 8'" 2"2 !  05 !8:  0);*7 /7  0* !G" .55/& <     2''!  "'""'!,!  !""  # 7 .5$5/576 ! ,!" H, ""'! 8 2 B "! " B < 2,! ,2 '!  0 !G" .555 

E. 10 D'" .55/7   <!  " 2DB, 2'2 E< '   ! 22 <2"'",,!':     !I < 2 8'" !" 8 B <!:'F"'! 2F ! E "!" JF" ',! ""   '""'!, ! ! "2 '  :22='''  !'" K"  'F2 '2'"" B  '  !,"'! !,2""7  <, '  '=! 2 8!', ?" 2 B <==' "! , ! LF2 >'6, ? @ <  A  :! "  "!"'"2 !, "'"   !""7

47 < 2 <" !,,!2 B "" 2''!  .1 !G" .55/7   '  ='" E !' 9 8'" ! ! =' 7 E"  !' , ?  '7   "!"=!' H,'E2 E<  8'", E< 8'"  8 "' $  2"" !2 E< 8'" !  H =" B J F " <',! "", !:?  "27   ''E2,!  , E ,?   7  <2"'" D' '="2 "  ' 8'" D' 8 2 ,'!7 *7  2''!  !,,!'"'!  0; !"!:  .55/& <   !=' 2  2''! ''"'7   !'2 2 E  2F'F  < 2 2"'" F 8 " E  :! =!' ,!8'" K"  " +  !'"'! < ' <2"'", !2E", ,'7

31)453.55/ 6 13) 6;7 < 2  '" D"2 !   .4 !"!:  .55/7   !,2" "2  0- !8:  .55/&   2 2 E< " "" '"  ':  2   "'='"  ! 2', !8" E ! 2""  "2& ,  <2"'!  ! =' 7& <8'" ,KJ2  ,' ! !:'F"'! <8 "' < 7   ''E2  , E<,!8'", !'   8'     &  % 8' , !""'!   D& 2"" !2 E 6' !''" ,'  !:  2  '""'! ='' " ! 2""  "27

)7  / 2:  .55/& < 2  '' 8 2  !'  ,, 2'"'!    

& ! 2' " '"" ,',  'H & "2  .0 !8:  .55/7 6' =='  K"  !8' E <2"'"  "!" :! =!' E < 2 <8'", DF2 "' <! B <   !'  ! =','E ,?   '6' <8'" D' '="2 <'"2 K",! ! =" ' 8 2 ,'!7 < 2 8'" G    J F   H =" "  F 2  "',, !:?  "27   

, 2'2 E ,"'" " , ! E'  82 '=', ,!"2" '  ,'"  !'"'! <!" !' , ""'! E< M!'" " E' ='" " " !=' H '==2 "  8' ''" "'= " !'H E' F? "  !' +  :! =!' ,!8'" ? ! , K"  '  7    , ='"  E E < 2  " !8'"   '""'! =''?  " !', 2'  +   8!('", !2E", !" 6',! '" "'" .5$5/5 = 7  " "  '", '   !2E " ? !    F"'!   8' E!"''7

057  ! '  0. 2:  .55/& <  , '"2   !'!& 2"", 2'2 E <  <8'", !  ""2     "'""'!7 007  ':  2  ! !2  !, "'!, ! , "'& E' $" "  * =28 ' .5547 < 2  ''E2 E ! H6 ' <8'"  , ' ",, 8! !N"  7 " E<' <8'" ='" ,"2 E< '!  ! ''"7   H,'E2 E< <8'", 8! '  ,'!,! ! =',  E< 8'" 2DB  F  '=='"2 B !:"'  ' ,("  ,'! '"'   -55 = 7, !',! 7 ='H2  !"   '8! 7 %! H6 ' <8'" D' '="2 <'"2 K",!  ='7

$ 2 , '  ==' 2 E< <8'", ='" """'!  ='" E<' 2"'" ''E2   2''!  <  O " ', P,! 7 " O " !: P,! 7 " E  !"" 8 2 2"'" '==2 ",! J   H ="7   '8'" "!" D" B < ! "' =''? "7  8 "   " ' :'" ? !  D"'='27 < 2  =' !'F2 E ! 2""  "2 2"'" " ? 8' " E< 8'" G :','  '" 8"'! " K"  J!,'"'2 B  !:  , '&  E' 8'"  " =! "", " :2  H ='7

31)453.55/ 6 -3) 6 0.7 Q $'  "" '"'!& , "' !", '"2    !'! "    2"2 F 2 B DF 7  "* 07  !' F8!'  <! F'"'! D'''  >A  2"2 !'='2 "  '"'"2& ?  0 !G" .551&  ': "!    !'& !,!2  / DF& !" , 2'" "  8'6, 2'"& / ,,2" " 04 DF   > "7 0 "7

" /4

A7

%'" B <"'!  <2"'!  04 DF  &,  ': =22   .* D8' .55- > #

E. 015  .15 !'7 070+ 11/ !'7 07.+

# 0.)  - !'7 07.+

# 0.*  -4* !'7 0& 0.4  014 !'7 -: "  2=2 A7

 <,?&  2''!  "'""'!  2"2  , ? $" 2  8'F    & '  !  , ""'! !2 8" " , ?  0 D8' .5517

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

31)453.55/ 6 /3) 6 !'", "'" "'! ",! '  8K" "!"=!',  ',! " 2''8&  !" E , '', ,,': B  "'""'! " B  ' !   !" '   2F""'! "   D ',  "2 '  >' 9 % & !,7 '"7& !")   "7;.A7 ='&   E' !  , !2 &  !8 !'" <,,'E  2 8 ?  D!  ! " 2  8'F > # 00* )1 !'7 4:& 00.  145 !'7 -+ 

0)); 9 1*,7 104 !'7 1:A7

E. 017  <! & < 2  !2  0) !G" 0);*  '  ! =' 7  ='", 8' B <   "  '7  !' ("  ' E"  !', " &  =''"'!,"  <(='F '",7 < 2 < ,  '" D' '=! 2 < 7   '' B $28' !'  8'!"'!  ! !:'F"'! <!  ='"&  E<  !""  ",7 0-7  ?F  8J 8!' 'F! 2 "" !:'F"'!7  & !  : 'E Z !:'F"'! <'=!     JF"  '""'! Z& JE 2''!  <  ! "  8 "  " <'8'"'" <'  H, 2" B ! '2'"" "!" !'='"'!  '""'! ,"': <" N  ,, '!&  ''"'! !  F""'!  , ""'! !27

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

047  ': =22      !"" ' E<' (8'" 2F'F F 8    !I 6 , ?  2? < :22='''   "

% 6  "& ! :'   <(D!"" " !"  !"" 2"'" "2  K > 0)**&,7 --) +

31)453.55/ 6;3) 6  0);4&,744-A& 2"'" '2, , !J7    K !'2 2 E  ='" <8!',2 ! '&,", ?  = !'&  JF"  """ '" 8 B  '" < DF"  '8!  " <8!' '' !"'2 B, 8!'  " !,2"' ,! 2,! !"'"'"  2F'F F 8 > # !,:'2  0- 8 ' .551    ;135.A7

0*7  <,?& < 2 ,!8'" E  !,   E  !'  7 !"'"'"  282" B $28' ',! "" "  "  B ','E EE !'='"'!  ! !'" H, ""'!7  ='" , 8!'  ",!  H ="  !"" ':" '==2 "  8'", ' 2J,, 7  " 8 ' E$  8'" ,'! '"' ,! 7&  $ 8'", !,,!  '7    '" B " 2F !'2 2 E$' ('" :! =!' ! E $'"2 2  $", !=! 2 B  E'," K"  '!:" H'F2  "!", ! ,:  ' "   '""'! '"'E "   K ' !" > # 005  0;0A7  :! =!' !'"  ==" K"  '2 E $ 'J',!8'"  !"  8 " $""  B ! !:'F"'!  "'",  E$' 8'" ! 8'" 8!'  ='", 8  $"""'! E' E , ""'! 2"'" ' > "7 1 7 . +  015  -0-A7

 <" ? ! ,,!': <""  E<, ! ,:  ' ",2   '""'! '"'E "   K ' !" < '", !2  !'  ! =',",  'H6J'" &  8'!"'!  ! !:'F"'!  'F < & "  '" '' !"'2 B, 8!'  " !,2"'  !:,! '6' ! < ='" < 27  ' &  ='" E ,?   7 <'" D' '="2 <'"2 K",! ! =' " E<' <'" D' !" ':2 B ! " "' <",, "'"7  ': =22       ==" !'2 2 E < 2 !'" !'E "!" JF"   '""'!, ! K <', E '6' <, <'=  ! !'" B  " > 0);4&,7 44-A7

 ='" E< 8'" <!,   H =" " E< !== '" <',! "", !:?  "2  !"'"",  ' !", !,  B <,KJ <8' <   "" !'='"'!  '""'! 2"" !2 E 'H6J'"   !" 2!2 "   !' "  2''!  "'""'! " E," "",2 '! < 2  2JF2  !: H ! '  8 <   D"  , ""'! <'8''"27

0;7 <!''!  < 2 !"'", !2E"  2F'F F 8&  E' H" "!" :! =!'7 $  !'"'!,! !:"'  ' ='" '' 2="& ' " '"' $H'  '""'! =''?   $ 27  '  $!:'F"'!  :!   !  .5$5/5 = 7 ,"  !2E K"  ! 27

31)453.55/ 6)3) 6  - "*1  *! -*"  !- "-

 23/   4  5   67 +&("8   / 

07 2   !  8:7  /

.7  D""7

E. 17 '" E , !2  " F "'"7 -7 =!  , "'   E<,8" =!  !  !"  , 2"  K"   2'  15 D!  ?  !"'='"'!,,' !2  2  ': =22    & %J]'S J!=E' 4& 455-   &  " !' H,' 7  2' ," K" , !!F27  2!'  !'" @ A ''E H"" E 2''!  ! " 2'  !:"'  ' ",   2''! ""E2+ :A H,!,! E !"'= ' "',!8!'  "" "  2''!+ A,! "  'F"  !   ! , 2""7 %'  2!'   !"'",  " !' 22" 22 2 ! ""  A :A " A '6&  ': =22     ,! , "   "'?    !  E<' 8  2  ' 8:7  2!'   !  "'!  !   !( , 8& E'  !" D!'"& '' E  2''! ""E2 " <8!,,  E   2"2 H,2'2  ! " > "7 01.& 054 " 05; A7

 F =='? 

 '6!'  U

, 2'"

! ' ^   

 !,' !=!  , 2"  K" " !"'='2 H, "' '' E<B <==' =22     !',  F ==

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

    

       !"  

        

#$%&'#('') *#+,%#(''& *

! *! -*"  !- "- -.  +  (+ /0 (''&

  

  ! "

!" 

##

    $ %%    & '   (!)*+ ,!" -./& 0.00    01 '"'2

31)453.55/ 6 .3) 6  1* 07  & ! "'" '& " 2 ) 8 ' 0)/-7   2,!2 !' 9& ! "'" '&  15 !8:  0)*)7  "" '! " 2 7 9&  00 8 ' 0);57  '8!   2"2, !!2  ..   0);17

.7 , !!2  .. !8:  0);1&  '6 , ? @  '6, ? @  A  2"2 !'='2 "  '"'"2& ?  0 !G" .551&  ': "!    !'& !,!2  / DF& !" , 2'" "  8'6, 2'"& / ,,2" " 04 DF   > "7 0 "7

" /4

A7

%'" B  # 015  054A&    !' F8!'  !,"2&  01 =28 ' &  ',!'"'! " '"!'   F", """  ': "!    !'  '2F    B " !' DF "'"' & &    A E' !" "'8 B  !'    A7 % !,2",! DF  

# 015  .15 !'7 070+ 11/ !'7 07.+

# 0.)  - !'7 07.+

# 0.*  -4* !'7 0& 0.4  014 !'7 -: "  2=2 A7

  !   "7 1. , !D"A& "'= B  "'""'! , ""'! 'G" "!J2 " ,2'" "'!2 ! H, $ ',!'"'! E'   '", ,,': B , ""'! 2DB 8 2 8" $" 2  8'F   !' >## 0))0 ,7 .44 8A7  8J& ! ' 9 %  > %69!" & !")   "7;.A&     !I  E"'!   "'""'! ,! , ?  0 D8' .551&  !8 !'" " ,,': ? !  E$' " ""2   "'""'! , ? ! " 2  8'F " E :' K  "'""'!,! "  , ""'! ! 2 "2 ' " > K" !,:'2 %7  .4 !8:  .55-&  .35-A7  E"'! 

31)453.55/ 6 /3) 6 !'", "'" "'! ",! '  8K" "!"=!',  ',! " 2''8&  !" E , '', ,,': B  "'""'! " B  ' !   !" '   2F""'! "   D ',  "2 '  >' 9 % & !,7 '"7& !")   "7;.A7 ='&   E' !  , !2 &  !8 !'"  # 00* )1 !'7 4:& 00.  145 !'7 -+ 

0)); 9 1*,7 104 !'7 1:A7

17 2,!2   =!  " 2' ',!2,  !'& , 2" !  " 8:&  8 "   "7 /4  7 -7  '"'F,! "   E"'!  8!' '   A ',! E  J! "  = E',8", 2"   "  "7 .." 7 0, '? ,J A7  =" !" ,?  !  ?  " 222 !" !'" B  "  "7 ./ 7 0 " 1* 7 0, '? ,J  " .  %A7    "7 0 7 0    ! 2"'! 8 $ "7 .  A7   E' !  $!:'F"'!  "'" ! "& $ "7 ./ 7 0   ='" E ,    2F""'!  $ "7 -* 7 0  % E' 2"'" DE B ,,':

31)453.55/ 6 43) 6 !'" ' ""& !'", 8!' ! ! , !F'  $"  !'  !'"    !' >" ' 9 &  "'""'! , ""'! 'G" "!J2    & ' @  "' F22   !'"    !'&  .551&,7 0-) &, ,2'",7 04* A7

  # 0.)  005 !'7 070& 0.4  .1 !'7 -:& 0..  .0 !'7 1& 14; !'7 1& "   K" '"2A E !'" ,'  !'"'! $ !'2 "'! ! $ 28''!, !2    2''! 6 =!  ! ! 6, E , ""'!   !" 2"2 !2 >' 9 % & !,7 '"7& !" .    "7 ./+ J!  R &   '  %!S'8 'J F J"&   .551 T -.&,7 .*)+ F R#3 J '"' UV&

% 

:'"!8 'J F& '@ % % .551,7 15- 87 WB, !,!  $ "7)/  X+ Y F  RVR& "SF 

% =  ! F: 3  ! F S

F' '  %!S'8 'J F J"& '@ F"S Y: 

F' '  %!S'8 'J F J" W %X& %'"6 .551&,7 .5;+

# 015  10)A7    'F& '8! A "  """ 8'!"'!  8!' $! !  'F A !" ',": B  !,! "" !!'= ! B  2F'F F 87  ( 2F'F F 8 E  (" !'"   !=! , B  E'," '!:" K"  H'F2 $, ! ,:  ' "   '""'! '"'E "   K ' !" > # 005  0;0 !'7 1A7  8J& $'"2 2," '8!E  :! =!' ! E $" ! $!''! ="'=  !"'"" E$ 8'!"'! 2F?   $!:'F"'! $! !  'F > # 00.  051 !'7 .& 005  0;5 !'7 1+  .55. \ 1;,7 ./; !'7 .& .55. \ 0;,7 04. !'7 1& .550 \ 0;,7 04. !'7 1A7

047  ': =22      !"" ' E  0)**&,7 --) +

31)453.55/ 6;3) 6  0);4&,744-A& 2"'" '2, , !J7    K !'2 2 E  ='"

# !,:'2  0- 8 ' .551    ;135.A7

0*7   # 005  0;0A7  :! =!' !'"  ==" K"  '2 E $ 'J',!8'"  !"  8 " $""  B ! !:'F"'!  "'",  E$' 8'" ! 8'" 8!'  ='", 8  $"""'! E' E , ""'! 2"'" ' > "7 1 7 . +  015  -0-A7

   0);4&,7 44-A7

 ='" E  "7 01.& 054 " 05; A7

 F =='? 

 '6!'  U

, 2'"

! ' ^   

 !,' !=!  , 2"  K" " !"'='2 H, "' '' E<B <==' =22     !',  F ==