opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/163/2006

Genf · 2006-02-20 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (1 Absätze)

E. 24 A!  "# &  8B "$# A!  #  "%# K# &  &% & F. E &=  #A# " " !!&% &% 

D A%&% &   *+UV+A8 -  -..2      # H!"4  &%  "# K# "9%4  !%! &#? @ &8 H#!#8&%#&%D##"&&% ##8%M D@ H" " 8 !#A  #! "$ &!& ## # &%M @ "#  9#   &  "%##4 *  !%!  ## "  # %%!# %!%%  ## @ D@ # @ 3&  

DA%&%&""#!#=8B &$&%$D4!%!&!#!C & "$  8 # E#   8  &% ##8% # B$"" & 8%#%H"%&%#>#4,F/ ,.-#,.6@4  9AA?    W&    %&#?           

    012-0/..1 3,/0,/3 "A!&"%#K###A%H"#8B;BAAA%&% &#%"D8"9AA

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

            

     

       !"#$!%&&" !'$(!%&&$ ))  )* * *  )*   +  #  ',- %&&$    !"#$%#&&! '#&&(#)   # # *  **

 ***' **   * ' 

* +!###, -../     #!%

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

    012-0/..1 3F0,/3 #  99  "  D #% # $H4   ""# & /2 "#!D /..,   &   8 BH! 998 & !!D A%%##"A#!#!##"#%8$H4BH! B""##  H"# #; B&=! !#8 & !!D A%&##BC$#9!#8A$&BC!+&=!4 74 B#%%  8 $# &%"%  &!& & "## "= & B3 $&#%&#&/1!,555 %#%!"BAA#&B3 $&#%>3"=B @D%%A&B!&BD$#"A #G&9&2A%$/../1!/../4&!#& B%%#%%$%;,1I#%##HH%#%D$%4 64 &%&7E#/..F * ;B#%%&!#& "#%&9&,5I#&%#"&# % 9&26'...A4 &=,!/../4 #C%;B% &!#%"###;B#%9#%&,2'16.A4"&#;#H&,1I4 54 B%  " B#!%& &     A!% ""#  7 L# /..F  ###  &9% &B$&#%  8  #H & B###; B#%9#%4  $8#'!"D#%&'H#$#%#$#"#A#& !!DA%&#4,.4 *$!%&%9  * "%&%;H!8 D&"&#&/6E#/..F4*""#&/F"#!D/..F%#% !!8%;  * M   & !## A# !#8 # "C+8   !%& & *   # #  "#% & #$ H9D&/.I&###$#%4!N$&!"A %#%H&A9#"C+8&'%4,,4 /.E$/..2 * !&#%# "%#G +9#+"%&8 "H!!%&&'%4 !%&& ""#&#&1!/..24*#"&"# &#3"=4,/4  7 &%!D /..2   *   E#% '""#  &%# 8 &  #$#%%9=%&# %$##"#&+9"%;1O9 '% "# %   ! !C & " & F'7.. A4 >,F=!  @4 "=!"&9 &9%&'$&#%'%=$;,5I4 &'# "# %  #% &%8# #  #D "C+8 # '&#4 A A!%#H&'###;'#%9#%4,F4  # & 6 ! /..F     "%#% "   )   #E#% 4  A# $ 8' '# "  ! &'H  #$#% #$ #  %A=;'H!&*  &#

    012-0/..1 320,/3 A# %## &' "#% %& & /. I4  D%%A &' # #= & '3$&#%4H"$&%"%&!&"!#;'# &#  "D&%88'D#;E # %A=H&%#A#"#&&&## "%&4  #; '# &' # #=  D&!#;  !  N$&'H"#"+C8#"C+8A&&%#!%" &###"#%&#$#&94,24 %"&5!/..1 * #E#& ""#8  "D#% '%## " 99% " '!"## +9 "C+8 "%#%"'%4,14 ,, ! /..1   %# &  *  # %#% !!8%  #  8"#%&4,-4 " &$%9%&"##%%!#"##& #" ##8&D &"#&#3"=4     * ) ,4 9$B9#E&>@%#%!&A%###% &= ,L#/..F  D#& !"%&1E9  &#"%&##$3"%&# 1""%##,-E9>#4,#4 #1- @4 *#;B#&B%#&,-E9 " DA%&% /7E$/..2> ,F.,.-@ & 9$&"#% ,FA%$  &"###9#"!### D#&  & %9  ; # E9 ##    & B### & B%#&$HE94 /4 A!%!#; '#4 1- 4, #4  +4 1    D # & (##8&###"%$;B# 1-&"#9%%&&#&&6#D/... > @ 8 # #$;   A%&%  B3&# & /.!,56,> @4 *!"%#"E9&&B"=#%#D4

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

   # & !+% & #$%8D%&'#/6%/  #+=,55. "4153-/@4 $+  'D &' "# #$ " &  %#9=; '$&#%"#&&#;#4*%#$"#$ """%   &  ; !"&  #@  '3 $&#%'";%"&MR'"#%&#$R8%#'#"&; '$&#%> ,.7/,&4/M ,55,"4FFF&4FM,565"4F/1 &4/DM *4&,"#!D,556@4 A E9"#"A&!"!##$8'%A  '#! 3!K! "D&A"='&#  " %$#8 $#!###%&'A ;"A# &9%&$&#%> ,.- 6-&4/"467@4" !#= ##&""8 ""A&!# '%'D9#&##!## $ " !#  !H!!  "%E& D  # !K!  "H &'AA# !"## > ,.7 ,7@4 *  % '# "  "#% %& & #$ #H&'$&#%#&%#!%"%&#;!"&$ "%$; '# /6 % 2 & '&  '3&# & /.

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

,,5272&42M$  /...S2.-"42./4&4F  /..,S2,."47F4&4F@4  '   D =$ "&# 8 '3$&#%  # !"# &'# ###;  #% ; $  !D9 #  !"## +9 "C+8  " AH  "#% & #$ %& & #4 *'9# & 9 &#   !## A# &%# "  *  3;$"&#$!"#&&%"!#%9!K! # "#  " & #$ !"# & 9%AH  %#% &' #$ #!#"# !"!###'#,H0+4&"#  # &D# # "!### & !#  !!D A% &# #& 3 E9#&#4# &' A!% &  ""#&1!/..28'#$#%

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

    012-0/..1 3,,0,/3 

)  .  )* * *  )*  

 /01,1   2  311 1  45 '$%  6  ,1 

,4 %$D4 ,1

/4 E##4 F4 #8"%&#9##4 24 A!  "# &  8B "$# A!  #  "%# K# &  &% & F. E &=  #A# " " !!&% &% 

D A%&% &   *+UV+A8 -  -..2      # H!"4  &%  "# K# "9%4  !%! &#? @ &8 H#!#8&%#&%D##"&&% ##8%M D@ H" " 8 !#A  #! "$ &!& ## # &%M @ "#  9#   &  "%##4 *  !%!  ## "  # %%!# %!%%  ## @ D@ # @ 3&  

DA%&%&""#!#=8B &$&%$D4!%!&!#!C & "$  8 # E#   8  &% ##8% # B$"" & 8%#%H"%&%#>#4,F/ ,.-#,.6@4  9AA?    W&    %&#?           

    012-0/..1 3,/0,/3 "A!&"%#K###A%H"#8B;BAAA%&% &#%"D8"9AA