opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/1445/2007

Genf · 2007-12-19 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (1 Absätze)

E. 46 : !(!6 26  # ' #!=411@4&(!=411'6 /6 ?B:!#(? (!(#! ">!#!F #"? #6 .6  !G!#B?F"(C!" !#  &G.11>6B  #(6 @6 >!  (   %: (? >!    (# -   #  21 C 8  > (8  = ># # 7)$RS$>%@"@11/  ;"(? !8   (=">!#!F634 ># # =># # &' C 411. 7 *;M  !#!     %  " !>  !A (?(E  ! M 

-  #  = ># # ( ? (  ( ? #% F    G6 /4  *6  (# -   (8  (  "?%#!!!A (?" ?-CBG?6  E>>8      K 

)  (#      A    #5C9   TT  TT   

    0&1230411' 5&20&25 (>! (#->#F(%:B:>>># # (E>>

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

         

     

         !!"  #$ %&$'(')'(# $'  ) %(

*+, "  - .+,    !" !#$!  %&'" "(##(  )")   )))   **    ) )

) +,)"    $-./"  !#

    0&1230411' 540&25 ' /% &6 75(89:##;"#&   ( :5? #( # # 4&?411@"?>> #>21?41126 !5##A# 821?4112" !(#(5% B( C?411/6 46    &3 (!= 411@" :##  (## B :>>   ( DE# 75(89  ;  !   ( !(#! ># #7 *;7;6F( >!%#(" #  & # #" 8 & ! 41126 >" C%: 2& #!= 411." :## :?  B  (  (8"   =   :5!    E !(6 !( &C?411@":###!=##>  (!(#!(8"B$ 424>6(! C%:2&!411@" 432>6(! C 434>6(! & C2& #!=411@68&C?411'"!!   :#? B &@4 >6):E  =  " :    !!  !("((# B!( &C?411@" :E(  F #(F"E( :## &&G'@1>6411@ &4G1 6 411'" :E( :#( 2'G&.1>6411@ 2 6 411'6 /6 (## (    )"  )    )))" :##   #(  >!# ((   #   &3 #!=411@6 >E>B:   :? E ( :#(!#"5#!(=  ? (  & C 411.   : : #  :5 ? #6? ??" :(%E $#%  :## #  #?# ( (( B  ##   :( (H!>!?(##   ? 4.I6 .6    #? 411'" :    > ? % !(   #(H : !  :? # ( :#(  :##  & #? 411'" :##   #(  >!# #!   #  :    (   !  :((" 8  % :# #      ((   #   C

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

>" !P#?! > = (  "   #$#" B ?    ?!  ( !(#! ># #"   C> :F!  %   (  !(  E( :#(:E  FA( (" :  A  # ( ' #!=411@  B (!(#!># #6 .6 ;)G646& "% ! # $=)%!(  (#?F6 4 B 4    ? =##>  ( !(#!   #( 762=;(#F? #!762;6 ! (!(#!( B(  #( %F8 ? #!7626&;6

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

    0&1230411' 530&25 ( !(#!  (  B  >>#   ? !!! : ((=? #! :##76&.6&;6 =;##! ? #!##B:6.6& 6% :##  ? "    # >!#! F (((  :76.6;6 !!( ( ># #"  ( - (  !(  E $A($#% (  ( (! ? " DE#  !  @1 " % :F ( :?#?6 E #!#>!#!F (># # ?E6  (#>8 !F6&/&/= 5 )0 6 ;   E $A($#%  :#(  =##>  ("   # #?((#(!8 (># #:((% !! "((?= #!-!%F % :((%   !8 ># # 7)03/.0411." . ?!= 411.;6 '6 ;  C( %( #!E(  ! (!(#!"># #%"!( G#?  $ G   # (>  G#(  =##> (( GF!5!(  (#  B G G  G? #7 *(=# 44!411/" @&012" 626&M *(=#&3014"  #BC(  !8(

=># #%(C  #6  :F!(" CE#( =># #7 & ! (>"  ( (  >Q(#A!(!E #(?F#B  ()6 =># # ##%!(  DE 744 ;   >% #(F:?B#(%( :>" !(:% =E =F$E  !#E (  ( (#"  ( B !( (   ?#8(B!-?E#6C  # (FE((#(GA>!"  ( (%! (  >Q  A ( >  = DE 7)0'.10411/;6    ?$ >F# B .1 I  F G?# ? (=(#(AB$E%>"%#5!-!C %(# =>!7)0/@30411/;"B.1I#E! G #( A #E!  > B $E" ? #CB !! (!B 44$(!!" G# #(! GF ?F AEB  F$(

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

    0&1230411' 5&10&25 =;)G!( G(8FF!(C( #?%#5 " (%"!( (# :>=!AE :# >E$%":(! :F?#B&11I !$# ?6>% E >=!AE ( ? (:5? #:B#E ( #!6 A %:#(DE# /1"%: ( : F(# (> ?! E 7  ?# &1  C%: 411/ !! ?  B 8?;"  %: : ( ## E!( #E#  !   ?6    =   >Q 7 >># :((#;":( :>B$E:(%:# #   ! #   ( 7    % :#(F !(E#(> B( "?=;6 "( #%! ? %%$(C"B.1I" ? ?   ? #E" #?  !?! #(#>   (  $E"  %  :###?%#(!# ()6 ;  =  %G# G%-   " 411@" &"  ?# > " (  >!! FQ ?#!(#(#?"/:1& 6(!(/1$ (!6 !! #! ?B8?411@# /16 6&4(#(&11I G?#7/:1& 6F&40/1F/16 6@1(.1I G?#" =! &1I ?-(##(!(!! F :?##  $ ( ?>=!AE7>6

*(=#  6 6(6) #  &G.11>> ((#F F7626&6;"G! &2:' 6(  % ( -  B   E (  G#(  =##>  ("411@"!! ?- F#411'6;8%=?$E>> : #(  #(> !A  :# 411."  ( (  : # %:  ?#  (#  ?(= :-!? B( & C? 411@" :   :A : (  !(  E (  :#(%:B(  6 >"!( : # : (  % !"  : %:B (  & ! 411@ % :!# ( (    #E( :#(6 >#5 6

    0&1230411' 5&&0&25   = (! E  " :!#   !# B ? !# &G.11>6B  #(6

    0&1230411' 5&40&25  ) %/ ( %&$'(')'(# $'  ) %(

  0 12+

&6 #?=6  12

46 : !(!6 26  # ' #!=411@4&(!=411'6 /6 ?B:!#(? (!(#! ">!#!F #"? #6 .6  !G!#B?F"(C!" !#  &G.11>6B  #(6 @6 >!  (   %: (? >!    (# -   #  21 C 8  > (8  = ># # 7)$RS$>%@"@11/  ;"(? !8   (=">!#!F634 ># # =># # &' C 411. 7 *;M  !#!     %  " !>  !A (?(E  ! M 

-  #  = ># # ( ? (  ( ? #% F    G6 /4  *6  (# -   (8  (  "?%#!!!A (?" ?-CBG?6  E>>8      K 

)  (#      A    #5C9   TT  TT   

    0&1230411' 5&20&25 (>! (#->#F(%:B:>>># # (E>>