opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/1354/2007

Genf · 2007-11-28 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (1 Absätze)

E. 24 Q% ""%$%& %2-A$#233-4 14 #   C Q" $ ! ""  !$ "   % %$"4 <4 %  Q" $ C #  "  % "$ % /&;33 A4 C "" % %$!4 04 "$  "%/&333A4C>:%&" $4 94 A   !" %  =Q !#" A   "  !$" B" %  %$ % 13 @ %6  "A" !6 % D A$%$ 5)>TM>A=9933<  8!#% "6%%" !DA $ "H"4;2%A$%$ DA$%$%/- @ 2330 5 (8R  $  %  %" %=   "A " +%!#"!":"%"% %"R%" B" %$  D A$%$ ! # !"  ! # $"= H %" % &"4 <2  (4  !$" B" "  !6  ! % "#=$  +%!#%#"B"@"C&#4  :AA6    )+# F ?  !$%"        $"*@"7  >!! V  !A %!$"B"""A$H!"=QCQAAA$%$ %!:AA

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

 

          !"   

     

       #$%&'#())* +#$&%,#())* +  +  !+  ! !  !-./,  (0 1./ ())*    !"#$"%%  &$"%%'"  "

" ((     &)) *      %+,-  " $

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

    ./01,.233- * %&%! "4 /14 !$%/2E"2331& "%:$%&#%"$%/33I% 20   1/ "D 233/  = % /  1/  2331 !  %:$ %&#%"$%9;4/I%6/@2331$D%&"""= $$C03I4 / : "!A4 /-4)% %%& %!!"%20@#2330  !$$ = &$"" %$!#*HH $"" %$$ " =  !"" &#" ! >"$"!%#!+>"=!!$4 /;4  21 A$# 2330 &   !!$ C &$  D:" % %   % : "   % %$ %!% "" # $%!+>"! "!%#!+>"=!!$4 /,4 !!"%1A$#2339 $%%$!" "% !+>"%F%:"=$+% %%$!%C&H"" %! /,;0 5(4 /342 = !$$=%!""$ !" "%"" A  AJ" $:6 " &AA" " =  "D &$"" !

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

    ./01,.233- *9./-* >$!"=4H!$=%+!$"A":&$""!%&: "= $ " %$ "$ % " = &H!"  !#" ! !$"% =  + !"G  $"" $ C  """ %=  >$!"=4   @"$ =& % "%% "%13C03I"#"$C!" !&$""! @"A$4   #$ = &$ $"" :$  = !DD " %$%"$!&D%&"#"$!A%!!%H"=& #"$"$ =$""!AA"%==!!$"%"= & D%"H"@"G%!"%"D"":= A" %$A"4    =    D: >= #"  %   !"$ % "# $% " =& ! """ &H %&"#"$%!"$C!" !% "%% "C%"= !"%>:%" "$C/3N H  "="""#"$  !"  "#H !$D % ""  # " % "" $!$""A#%>!"""=!:$!"! C :H%$! "$:"#>" $>4 224 !!"%2;# D2339F $%)" !$"  $% "  %$$ = &$"" % "$ % &$ &$""  $$%!%$"%&"%!"""""%! 13@ 2330 %" % %$D" %#!+>"=!4  %=$ =  % = % &$ $"" %& !  " =  $=%:OD:O&$""!!%$" %%%&*#%"$4 214   !@" % %$ % 21 @# 233- &   A $ &$ =& "%"!! "%&#%"$%6/ 233-%6=&!#" H:%!" #%&!"$$%%"#"6% "#"$$:6% "%% "4) $">%%%  !%#$"D"H%&#%"$%1-I! """!  "%%"C"4@"$=&$""%"$&$"" $$%!  %$ " % !"" " = ""  $" !#" B" AH$  13@ 23304  !   %$$ = %  !A " #$ C &$>   %  %$!% C & " &$"" % ! %=$4 2 "= % &H!" %  $"" "%" !  =%$"=&!"$%"#$""%= "C +% %%$!%C& =&&% "! =& % " % % " %#" B" %  !  " "A $#=$ " !#"B"D "AH$D%A>"" "$!&H!" C # C 13 I4   D#$ =& &H""  "A % $#  % %$"!&$"%#%"$=#"$"$"% %$"!6&#$"$A"% H"= A""H%&#%"$$""% = """ $: "  >%! $H C  ! %& "#"$ !A4   %  $% """  A $  %:" %$@C  "  A" $"" %& "" !"*A"%&$!%"# %&E"2339C"%&>" %"$!$"$"" !6"!=&D%""""% &$! %" $""  "$4   " $ =& "#"$ !>+= " ":" !   D !$ %" " = # % !%  AA" % # " $!$""A % &$! &$"" " " ! !D4 "C%$!%"C&D%& !$$=& #" "'$  >$!"" =  !$"" :O $" "  !+!">%  DA$4 294 $!%;@233-&" $@"%%$" =  "  #"  : " !"D % &  C  !!$" %AA$" % 4   !  &" $A$$ C  "#" ""%%$4 2-4   $" % 2, @ 233-  "  !%"  !!" %  :: %  P &$>:!>!"A#%$!H "%&!D% &"6A$ !A4 !$"%=$=&$#"&$""! A#DA"#:"$:!>%&%$%&#"4

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

    ./01,.233- */-./-*  ! 3+ 2  +  !+  ! ! 

    4.

/4 $#D4  4

24 Q% ""%$%& %2-A$#233-4 14 #   C Q" $ ! ""  !$ "   % %$"4 :%&" $4 94 A   !" %  =Q !#" A   "  !$" B" %  %$ % 13 @ %6  "A" !6 % D A$%$ 5)>TM>A=9933 !! V  !A %!$"B"""A$H!"=QCQAAA$%$ %!:AA