opencaselaw.ch

ATAS/1297/2007

Genf · 2007-11-22 · Deutsch GE
Erwägungen (1 Absätze)

E. 26 ;""6 /6 8   !" %  BS !#" 8   "  !$" I" %  %$ % @3; %D  "8" !D % : 8$%$ E*9VC98B4433.  F!#% "D%%" !:8 $ "7"6A/%8$%$ :8$%$%2-; /330 E)F>  $  %  %" %B   "8 " +%!#"!"?"%"% %">%" I" %$  : 8$%$ ! # !"  ! # $"B 7 %" % &"6 ./ )6  !$" I" "  !D  ! % "#B$  +%!#%#"I";"=&#6   ?88D     ))  !$%"     T*  T  !8 %!$"I"""8$7!"BS=S888$%$ %!?88

Volltext (verifizierbarer Originaltext)

              

  

     

       ! "

!#$! $ %%

&' %()'* * * & '%* ( +,  -  !! .+,  ! $      !" # $" % %   &$"%%'"(#  "

" ))   & **    % +,-!"./0  " $

    1231/334 5/12.5 * /(

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

"!$"%?"%:$"?0 /33.6  $%+%BB"J%%:D""";"D #%$!" %"" "6*&+;""9+!""$"D%88 ""J: B&9+!"?+%$$ $#D+ !" "B6 -6 %"!!"/@H"/33.E!D2- F% B%?"#""$"$!$G%:D"%"+!5B$" $#" %! B  " = % $!% "$"8 % !$"" ?L 9+!""$:!$""?L=$!$""%+!%$ $#D6  $% " $B&!"$%"#$""""%!8%

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

    1231/334 5A12.5  $"% % &"D 8$  !8 %"  B % $ %$$ % &"D 8$ !8?96  "$$!9!"9 %"#!"$9+!!%$  $#D  "J$ "  9+!" "$  !"" $""  ""9$! ! "59+!"6   ?$ B &:$"$ % &$ " !  !""!B%% !E F&$D#=@@-6  $%$  #!"&?"%%:D" "8B%! "   "J " ? " 88" ?$ "  88" "9$!"B"!6"""&""" "!$;$!B %"!%" !!""%$#!!$ 5?!"9" %  : 8$ + !" "B +" %$;= $"$ " "  !:: "$"!9 "%"#"##6 $% " $B&:$"$%!"""%$%" "!9+B$#%"$"" !:: "=&?%%+!$%&88" !""%"!"6  #"J%%:D"B%&9+!?+$ $#D$"8= # "J "  "" " ! ! ! =  "  #"?  "B "%$"!!""B&"#"$ %9885#&$""!%""7?:"B&" I %? !!"""!"6 I  D" $B!$% #"?=$!$"""5%B""""#"$!8!B #? % "" "" " B  !#" $#" " "" ;  $"$ %&" %#%6  #9   " $ B &$ !" I"  %&""#"$"#%"%$B"%E!" !  " !!"F " = %$" %&8"?:"$ !""$"" !$$ B  % ! D" " "D %88 = $# %$B" "6  $% %$B"""#"$ !"%9$?58% 8" %   % !:  $?"$ %  !  " " % "J?+$ B%!""5"B&& !B%$! "!9+B "5%=%BB%C% D"5%!$ D"% 9 "D "$%!""5"#"$!9+B !""5#!"9" %+!$%&88"6 //6   % 20; /33-  "  #$ B  %7 7!" " 8 $ B&  !" ! 7? %  B& " = 7  $" % 9885#6  "" B &"#"$ %&!$" % 9 &" !  !7?:%!"% P88%!:D %"" "%#"?%"B&""#"$&7!"B!% "?!8=%%?6"B!"$$% %"#%"I"%$$ "!""%?$%&#%"$87$= 233M6

    1231/334 5,12.5 /@6 " = &" $   %B$ !  % /4; /33- B& ""  B";"%6

* &%(

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

    1231/334 52212.5 46 &!D :%$""$B%88$"!!" $%7 #$%%#?": "B"%&!!$"% !"$$%%"#%&$6  " $B !"$%"#%&$$""%3M%!8 B& !"  #9 7  "#"$ ! $?D  !"  "  ""!"E86!!"%@3H"/33.F6  &" B" =  ! !$$ " !$   B" %   !"$ $%%"# !$!"8#:" %$"#"$ B?%%!:"$!""E86!!"%/@H"/33.F6 !!"%&"%$%!""!8%&9J!"5*$;" #9"B% "%&$&#"; 7$%$@35.3M 5" ! B  :$"$ $""  8" 9%!" " B &!""%  ! "$""!$"6*:"""!!$") $%5 % &    =  !"$ "" % "# ""  " ?$ "" B &$ !" # %7 9!;!""B&"% I %!"%:"6 &"   %  %!"$ %  %88$" # B  : % $  %$7!":5%!9 "?B"%?B6

"    B    " #$ =   " =%$8%!&" $%%$"?B&$ !"%$ !7!8%9885#B$"" !#"6;?"&!% $%5"""6 " !%"B&!"7?%&$B&7= ! " ! " = ! % "  "#"$ %!"$ =  $"" % "$6   %B$B&""#"$%#"$#" # "$!$"$%9!" % 9?  "$ " %" %&6  "" %&7 !   "$!8%&!$"% 9% $% !$ "8 !"B$ !  !""6  %7 !8  :" !%" $? " 7 %   P    !$ %&$#"  "#"$ ! B  #? % "" "" " B  !#"$#" " "";$"$%&"%#%6#9 ;"B&"B&$!" $ 7"#"$"#%"!$$B&%#" !" % 9 $? " & !B%$! "!9+B" 5%=% BB%C% D""#"$!9+B !""6 " !%" "$ $#8   "7 %&!" B & !" ""% % "6   % % # B  %  "" !   %   "   "  B %   P  &"#"$

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

    1231/334 52@12.5  +E86 2,,2!6@@/%6@> #%"W"% :?"98#9?"9D):?2,,0!6/20F6;!% %D B "  !I9 " !! =  ! % &#%7?"B&$% ""%""%"""B6

"8 % " %$%"  %#" ! I" 88"$ % D 9$ "B " !"%& :%"%!" "  %  :" % %$"  = !" % %$ """B  # %&#% B !$"  7    # $ B 7?: % "#"$  !": #  !"$ % "# $% % &"$$6  %$%"%"!I"!$$" "B "  "B&7" % % B&  %& %!8"&$!" "" #!"$$%%"# 9$%"#B&#$"" $ B8$= +6&+!%!$%=% %$%"%""!9%8"""%$"   "" $  9%! &R?  $ % #  ""$   "$?%! %$;"7%&!"68":!"J" !$%=$#"?:% "%!#%&!!$"% 88" %  8"   # %&#%  !" " % & : % "%"68!"!$%=%$%"?: !$=/0M6&% ""%" "#:D# "%$%"!$$6 ";?!" "8!"":""!!$"=% &% ""E)2/4-0F6 A6 &!D#"%% !#B&"$$" /33."0/&,.486=B&"!:" I $ ?$&"""= "$%"#"$ !"$!$""#"0-&/0A86!E**/33.G .&0AA65! !.3961 6X.&--/65! !.24961 6X0-&/0A65F6 I   & !!B =  ""  $%" 7  %  ! ;!%"/0M:""%?$%&#%"$%2A,M88"! #%"=%!""%&5#%"$6,6 $?%7%$"B!$D%"";"$6  

    1231/334 52.12.5 %  0 (/  %()'* * * & '%* (

 1.

26 ;""6 /6 8   !" %  BS !#" 8   "  !$" I" %  %$ % @3; %D  "8" !D % : 8$%$ E*9VC98B4433.  F!#% "D%%" !:8 $ "7"6A/%8$%$ :8$%$%2-; /330 E)F>  $  %  %" %B   "8 " +%!#"!"?"%"% %">%" I" %$  : 8$%$ ! # !"  ! # $"B 7 %" % &"6 ./ )6  !$" I" "  !D  ! % "#B$  +%!#%#"I";"=&#6   ?88D     ))  !$%"     T*  T  !8 %!$"I"""8$7!"BS=S888$%$ %!?88